NPR's Philip Reeves slanted towards the Occupy Wall Street on Wednesday's All Things Considered as he played up the "huge outcry" over St. Paul Cathedral in London's dispute with the left-leaning movement, which has an encampment outside its doors. Reeves spotlighted a local official who "called St. Paul's a 'national laughing stock,'" and omitted sound bites from the opponents of the movement.
Host Guy Raz noted in his introduction to the correspondent's report how St. Paul's was a "national treasure" associated with Churchill's funeral and the wedding of Charles and Diana, and continued that it was now "the backdrop for another kind of drama: a protest camp modeled on the Occupy Wall Street movement. NPR's Philip Reeves says it's causing upheaval in the heart of British society."
After giving some background into why the demonstrators were camped outside the cathedral, Reeves stated that "the protestors' main targets are bankers and politicians, whom they blame for a capitalist system they say has gone badly wrong. Yet, their presence outside St. Paul's has also caused deep division within...the Church of England. Soon after they arrived, the clerics who run St. Paul's shut the cathedral for nearly a week, citing safety reasons....There was a huge outcry and words of disapproval, even from other churchmen." He then played a clip from Rev. Alan Green, who claimed that "in retrospect, the symbol of closing the doors- I think that was a real mistake."
The NPR correspondent continued that "the controversy grew even bigger when St. Paul's launched legal proceedings to remove the protest camp. Some clerics believe the church should, like Jesus, be on the side of the poor, and therefore, should support the protestors. A heated debate began in Britain about the church's role. The church's most senior cleric, the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, has now weighed in. He's positive about the protest." Reeves followed this with a sound bite of Williams's compliment of the "Occupy" movement.
Later in the report, the journalist related that "this row has damaged the standing of the cathedral and the clerics who run it. One local parliamentarian called St. Paul's a 'national laughing stock.'" Reeves concluded the segment by playing up the apparent resolve of one of the protesters outside St. Paul's:
REEVES: As for the protestors, their problems are not over. They secured another victory this week when the city of London authorities suspended their effort to evict them. But this could easily resume. That doesn't worry antiques dealer Adam Murray. He's been outside St. Paul's for all 19 days. He doesn't intend to give up now.
ADAM MURRAY: And if it snows and there's a blizzard and there's gale force winds or a typhoon or hurricane, I'm still going to stay. It's not going to put me off. It's the idea itself. It's what we stand up for.
The full transcript of Philip Reeves's report from Wednesday's All Things Considered:
NPR's Philip Reeves says it's causing upheaval in the heart of British society.
PHILIP REEVES: This is the 19th day of the protest here at St. Paul's Cathedral, one of the world's great landmarks. Tonight, London's going about its business. There are double-decker red buses passing by, black cabs waiting for passengers, and people thronging around the cathedral steps where, just a few yards from the front door, there's a cluster of scores of small, brightly-colored tents. This wasn't the original idea. When they first arrived, the protestors here were heading for the London Stock Exchange nearby. The police blocked their path, so they came here instead. Thus began a chain of events that had some very unexpected consequences.
The protestors' main targets are bankers and politicians, whom they blame for a capitalist system they say has gone badly wrong. Yet, their presence outside St. Paul's has also caused deep division within England's official church, the Church of England. Soon after they arrived, the clerics who run St. Paul's shut the cathedral for nearly a week, citing safety reasons. St. Paul's hasn't closed since Hitler's bombers blitzed London. There was a huge outcry and words of disapproval, even from other churchmen.
REVEREND ALAN GREEN: I mean, it's very easy for me to criticize from the outside. I'm very loathed to do that. But in retrospect, the symbol of closing the doors- I think that was a real mistake- closing for the week.
REEVES: That's the Reverend Alan Green, rector of a church close by St. Paul's. The controversy grew even bigger when St. Paul's launched legal proceedings to remove the protest camp. Some clerics believe the church should, like Jesus, be on the side of the poor, and therefore, should support the protestors. A heated debate began in Britain about the church's role. The church's most senior cleric, the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, has now weighed in. He's positive about the protest.
ROWAN WILLIAMS: It's triggered awareness of the unfinished business, really, in the financial sector- the unfinished business between government and banks, the whole sense of the need to press for something that will deliver a just and more rational system.
REEVES: This week, St. Paul's dropped its legal action against the protest camp, and the cathedral's dean resigned. He's the second senior figure at St. Paul's to quit over the protest.
This row has damaged the standing of the cathedral and the clerics who run it. One local parliamentarian called St. Paul's a 'national laughing stock.' But the Bishop of London, Richard Chartres, is confident it'll recover.
RICHARD CHARTRES: Christians are very used to near-death experiences. They're also used to resurrections. The cathedral has burnt down. Its symbol is the phoenix. I have absolutely no doubt that that will be the story this time, as well.
REEVES: As for the protestors, their problems are not over. They secured another victory this week when the city of London authorities suspended their effort to evict them. But this could easily resume. That doesn't worry antiques dealer Adam Murray. He's been outside St. Paul's for all 19 days. He doesn't intend to give up now.
ADAM MURRAY: And if it snows and there's a blizzard and there's gale force winds or a typhoon or hurricane, I'm still going to stay. It's not going to put me off. It's the idea itself. It's what we stand up for.
REEVES: Philip Reeves, NPR News, London.
