Monday evening’s PBS News Hour devoted its first 11 minutes of news -- two full segments -- to bashing Donald Trump’s long rally at Madison Square Garden in the heart of his hometown of New York City. White House reporter Laura Barron-Lopez actually led with criticism from his Democratic rival Kamala Harris, not news about the rally itself.
Laura Barron-Lopez: On her way to campaign in battleground Michigan today, Vice President Kamala Harris denounced recent rhetoric from former President Donald Trump and his allies.
Kamala Harris, Vice President of the United States: He is focused and actually fixated on his grievances, on himself and on dividing our country. And it is not in any way something that will strengthen the American family, the American worker.
Barron-Lopez: She was referring to a massive Trump rally at Madison Square Garden in New York yesterday, where a racist remark about Puerto Rico made headlines.
After running the offending clip by comedian Tony Hinchcliffe, the reporter noted “Trump's team tried to distance itself from the comment” but “did not distance itself from other remarks made by multiple Trump allies who hurled racist and sexist attacks at Vice President Harris."
A radical friend of the News Hour, New York University professor Ruth Ben-Ghiat, appeared in the following segment as the resident expert on what anchor Amna Nawaz called “The racist, sexist and vulgar remarks at Donald Trump's Madison Square Garden rally….”
Nawaz: So we are just days from Election Day. This was probably one of the ugliest collection of remarks from selected speakers that we have seen at a Trump rally. You study this kind of rhetoric. So what stood out to you about this type of language this close to Election Day?
Ben-Ghiat seemed to suggest that Madison Square Garden, where the Democratic National Convention, Ralph Nader, and thousands of musical acts have appeared over the years, was some kind of historically notorious Nazi hangout.
Ben-Ghiat: So this place in Madison Square Garden, and it was one of many occasions that the Trump campaign has chosen to allow comparisons to be made to the Nazis. So that was Madison Square Garden, which was the site of a rally by American Nazis in 1939, talking about polluting the blood, speaking of Americans as an enemy within. This is all straight from fascism. In fact, fascism -- the core of fascism in Italy and Germany were combatants who followed their leader to bring the war home and turned their force against their own people….
Nawaz: I want to underscore that parallel you're drawing there, because this is what many are talking about today, both the remarks from Trump about America being an occupied country, but also last night we heard from Trump loyalist Stephen Miller, who said America is for Americans and Americans only. That, of course, was also another parallel drawn to that 1939 Nazi rally at the old Madison Square Garden, which back then promised to -- quote -- "restore America to the true Americans."….
Ben-Ghiat then suggested Trump would establish concentration camps for American liberals.
Ben-Ghiat: ….And when the Nazis built Dachau in 1933 because they were running out of space in prisons -- they built this camp Dachau. And they didn't put Jews in it at first. It was for the political opposition, liberals, leftists. Then it had Jehovah's Witnesses, then LGBTQ people. All kinds of other people went in there, and then Jews were targeted as well by the regime….
That wasn’t even Ben-Ghiat’s first time making the insane comparison. In November 2023 she warned of Trump: “In 2025, he's got plans for mass deportations, mass imprisonments and giant camps.”
If the professor truly believes a re-elected Trump would ship liberals off into camps, she’s certainly brave for continuing to pop up on government-funded television calling him dangerous. But she doesn’t really believe it, of course.
Nawaz didn’t blink at Ben-Ghiat’s crazed comparison of a second Trump term to the Fourth Reich. If one really wanted to talk about modern-day Nazism, we could discuss why the pro-Hamas protesters that dominated college campuses earlier this year -- who agreed with Hitler on quite a few execrable matters -- were celebrated by PBS for months.
These biased segments were brought to you in part by BDO.
A transcript is available, click “Expand.”
PBS News Hour
10/28/24
7:08:06 p.m. (ET)
Amna Nawaz: The racist, sexist and vulgar remarks at Donald Trump's Madison Square Garden rally from the former president himself and his slate of speakers has drawn significant criticism the day after.
For more on the rhetoric and its impact, we're joined by Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a professor of history at New York University.
Ruth, welcome back to the "News Hour."
Ruth Ben-Ghiat, NYU History Professor: Thank you.
Amna Nawaz: So we are just days from Election Day. This was probably one of the ugliest collection of remarks from selected speakers that we have seen at a Trump rally. You study this kind of rhetoric. So what stood out to you about this type of language this close to Election Day?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat: So this place in Madison Square Garden, and it was one of many occasions that the Trump campaign has chosen to allow comparisons to be made to the Nazis. So that was Madison Square Garden, which was the site of a rally by American Nazis in 1939, talking about polluting the blood, speaking of Americans as an enemy within.
This is all straight from fascism. In fact, fascism — the core of fascism in Italy and Germany were combatants who followed their leader to bring the war home and turned their force against their own people. And when Donald Trump was talking about America as an occupied country and he was going to liberate it and also in the past talking about using the military on Americans, this comes out of fascism and also the tradition of military dictatorships like Pinochet in Chile.
So it's a purely authoritarian spectacle that we saw.
Amna Nawaz: I want to underscore that parallel you're drawing there, because this is what many are talking about today, both the remarks from Trump about America being an occupied country, but also last night we heard from Trump loyalist Stephen Miller, who said America is for Americans and Americans only.
That, of course, was also another parallel drawn to that 1939 Nazi rally at the old Madison Square Garden, which back then promised to — quote — "restore America to the true Americans."
Ruth, we have to point out, again, this is closing arguments time for the candidates. So why do you think this kind of rhetoric resonates with millions of people right now?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat: I think Trump has been conditioning Americans since 2015 to see violence as something justified in certain cases and even patriotic.
He's been conditioning them to see other Americans as enemies, as diseased, as dirty. And what we have to remember is that authoritarians might initially target one group, and he's been talking mostly about immigrants. But he's also calling the enemy within the political opposition.
And when the Nazis built Dachau in 1933 because they were running out of space in prisons — they built this camp Dachau. And they didn't put Jews in it at first. It was for the political opposition, liberals, leftists. Then it had Jehovah's Witnesses, then LGBTQ people. All kinds of other people went in there, and then Jews were targeted as well by the regime.
So when they're talking about deporting so many people in America, this is a massive amount of people, and thus you need an infrastructure of repression. You need camps. And the whole thing is a dystopia. And this is not what America is. But Donald Trump has been conditioning Americans to think that this is the way.
Amna Nawaz: We have seen, obviously, these remarks strongly condemned by Vice President Harris and Democrats.
But among Republicans, the response has sort of been a mixed bag. There's been some, like Senator Rick Scott, who's in a tight reelection race in Florida, who said in response to the comedian's racist remarks there about Puerto Ricans — quote — "This joke bombed for a reason."
And then we saw Florida Congressman Byron Donalds, who also spoke at the rally, who said this on CNBC this morning.
Rep. Byron Donalds (R-FL): This is the problem with most media today. They're too busy trying to fearmonger everything, instead of actually talking about the facts and the substance.
Amna Nawaz: So, Ruth, members of the Republican Party now also criticize Vice President Harris for calling former President Trump a fascist, saying that that is the dangerous rhetoric. Are those kind of remarks on the same level to you?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat: Not at all.
And this is part of an authoritarian projection mechanism. I call it the upside-down world of authoritarianism, where, ever since Mussolini, he was the first to call democrats the real tyrants and fascism was going to be freedom. Fascism was going to make Italy great again. That was a slogan, as was drain the swamp. Trump took that from Mussolini as well.
So this is pure projection to — and it's all — the endgame is to justify — to justify whatever they would like to do for retribution, locking up the political opposition by saying that they're the ones who are the tyrants, they're the ones who are repressive.
Amna Nawaz: Ruth, if members of his own party did condemn this kind of speech from Donald Trump, would it make a difference? What has history shown us?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat: You know, there's this concept of authoritarian bargains, where a party or elites, they could be religious elites, business elites, they sign on to protect the leader, and their job becomes to protect and support the leader.
And it's very rare once they sign on that they renege on this. And so you don't see much criticism. It's easier to blame the press or blame the political opposition. And so once they sign on, they find themselves having to be the party of more and more violence and more and more repression. And many of them realize only too late what they have gotten themselves into.
Amna Nawaz: That is Ruth Ben-Ghiat, professor of history at New York University. Ruth, thank you for your time. Appreciate it.
