This week marks the 40th anniversary of Philadelphia confronting the radical black group MOVE in an incendiary assault that killed 11 people, including five children, and destroyed a residential block. PBS News Weekend on Saturday marked the anniversary of with a dose of radical chic, omitting unflattering details about the bizarre urban enclave MOVE.
PBS spent six minutes and 40 seconds on this, even as they have ignored the Jake Tapper-Alex Thompson book on hiding Biden's decline. There were no ideological labels, unless you count MOVE touting themselves in a clip as "revolutionary."
Reporter Ali Rogin set the scene.
ROGIN: The complicated story of MOVE begins in the early 1970s. The organization followed the teachings of their founder, John Africa, who advocated a lifestyle rooted in nature. All members took Africa's last name and lived communally in West Philadelphia. They were known for staging disruptive demonstrations and frequently clashing with authorities, protesting everything from police brutality and war to pet stores and zoos.
Rogin didn’t delve into the genuine harms the group foisted both on its own children and the neighborhood, letting the son of two members describe it as an eccentric health cult.
MIKE AFRICA JR., MOVE Organization: We walked around naked a lot as children. The organization did not -- they believed in vitamin D from the sun. They believed in allowing your skin to be tougher and stronger.
Rogin injected a mild comment.
ROGIN: That way of life often put MOVE at odds with local police and their neighbors who accused them of creating unsanitary living conditions.
After demands from MOVE's neighbors, Philadelphia Mayor Frank Rizzo tried to evict the group and then in 1978 ordered an attack on MOVE headquarters, a confrontation in which an police officer was killed.
Yet Rogin put all the fault on the side of the police.
ROGIN: [MOVE documentary-maker] Tommy Oliver says those early confrontations, including that 1978 shootout, are critical to understanding what eventually happened.
TOMMY OLIVER: Seven years later, you had officers and members of the police force who wanted revenge.
ROGIN: In May of 1985, Philadelphia Mayor Wilson Goode ordered the organization to be removed once again from a home where they were living….Police would fire more than 10,000 rounds of ammunition into MOVE’s row house before eventually dropping a bomb on it….
A city commission later concluded that police actions that day were “unconscionable.” PBS never mentioned that the mayors in question here were both Democrats.
Rogin cited Mike Africa claiming “I`ve never heard of another case where a government has dropped a bomb on citizens in America.”
(The federal government’s invasion of a compound during the early Clinton administration resulted in a larger body count and with less excuse in Waco, Texas. Since guns and religion were involved, media reaction was sympathetic to the Clinton administration.)
A lot went unmentioned by Rogin: Nothing about Mumia Abu-Jamal, a MOVE member who was convicted of the 1981 murder of Philadelphia police officer Daniel Faulkner at a traffic stop involving Abu-Jamal’s younger brother.
The 1980’s archives of the Philadelphia Inquirer, an organ sympathetic to MOVE, reveals more details PBS skipped, involving MOVE children going hungry on raw vegetables while the adults ate full hot meals. A recent Inquirer editorial marking the anniversary noted that the rowhomes occupied by MOVE “were filthy and housed wild animals. Their kids often went unbathed and unclothed. MOVE members yelled and cursed into a bullhorn at all hours of the day and night, ranting against war, racism, and police brutality. Neighbors complained and lived in fear.”
Most striking was a retrospective in the far-left Nation that actually provided a more balanced story than did tax-funded PBS, which is congressionally obligated to provide balance. Hannah Epstein, an undergraduate student at Bryn Mawr, filled in some details PBS skipped (like holes for gun ports):
In the wake of Life Africa’s death and the imprisonment of nine of their members, MOVE became increasingly hostile toward the police. By the early 1980s, neighbors on Osage Avenue reported nearly round-the-clock bullhorn speeches, often laced with vulgar language disparaging city officials as well as anyone else MOVE saw as a part of the “system.” Nearby residents said the noise and disruption made daily life chronically unpleasant….Residents of Osage Avenue had, without success, asked the city government to intervene. But it was not until MOVE began to set up a wooden bunker, outfitted with holes for gun ports, that action was taken….
This whitewashed history of MOVE was brought to you in part by BNSF Railway.
A transcript is available, click “Expand.”
PBS News Weekend
5/17/25
7:14:42 p.m.
John Yang: This week marked the 40th anniversary of one of the worst tragedies in the history of Philadelphia. In May 1985, the city's police department dropped an improvised bomb on a residential home that housed the black revolutionary organization called MOVE. The bomb in the ensuing fire, killed 11 members of the group, including five children, and destroyed more than 60 nearby homes. Ali Rogin reports on why so many are still coming to grips with what happened.
Man: MOVE is a totally revolutionary organization.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): The complicated story of MOVE begins in the early 1970s. The organization followed the teachings of their founder, John Africa, who advocated a lifestyle rooted in nature. All members took Africa's last name and lived communally in West Philadelphia.
Man: We must fight back.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): They were known for staging disruptive demonstrations and frequently clashing with authorities, protesting everything from police brutality and war to pet stores and zoos.
Tommy Oliver, Director, "40 Years a Prisoner": MOVE is and was an organization that's very much committed to life and all of its forms and whatever that looks like.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): Tommy Oliver is the director of "40 Years a Prisoner," a 2020 HBO documentary that traces the group's origins.
Tommy Oliver: They're committed to eating naturally, to living naturally, to not being reliant on technology.
Mike Africa Jr., MOVE Organization: We walked around naked a lot as children. The organization did not. They believed in vitamin D from the sun. They believed in allowing your skin to be tougher and stronger.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): Mike Africa Jr. S parents were both members of MOVE.
Mike Africa: Yes, it was unorthodox. And yeah, some things were strange to some people, but for me, that was life.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): That way of life often put MOVE at odds with local police and their neighbors who accused them of creating unsanitary living conditions.
Tommy Oliver: Conditions them trying to live in the way that they wanted to live didn't sit well with a lot of people. So sometimes the neighbors, sometimes the city. And it escalated pretty significantly pretty quickly.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): In 1978, more than a year after the city issued an eviction notice, Philadelphia's then mayor, Frank Rizzo, ordered an attack on MOVE's home.
Frank Rizzo, Former Philadelphia mayor: They're going to go either easy or hard way. That can be standing up or laying down.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): The months long standoff culminated in a shootout. One police officer was killed and MOVE's home was demolished. While MOVE maintains that the officer died by friendly fire, nine of its members were convicted and sentenced to up to 100 years in prison, including Mike Africa Jr.'s parents.
Mike Africa: The mayor admitted that he believed my parents were innocent. He believed that my parents were not in prison for the charge that they were charged with.
Man: Police are inside MOVE headquarters in West Philadelphia conducting an intensive search for weapons.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): He says the media's portrayal of MOVE was often exaggerated. And he says the organization was misunderstood even among many African Americans.
Mike Africa: MOVE members are not the turn the other cheek type people. And a lot of people felt like pacifism was the answer. And MOVE members were not pacifistic. If a cop attacked them, they would fight back.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): Tommy Oliver says those early confrontations, including that 1978 shootout, are critical to understanding what eventually happened.
Tommy Oliver: Seven years later, you had officers and members of the police force who wanted revenge.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): In May of 1985, Philadelphia Mayor Wilson Good ordered the organization to be removed once again from a home where they were living.
Wilson Good, Former Philadelphia Mayor: What we have out there is war.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): And on May 13, local news stations like WCAU in Philadelphia covered the escalating crisis throughout the day. Police would fire more than 10,000 rounds of ammunition into MOVE's row house before eventually dropping a bomb on it. The city's police commissioner at the time, Gregore Sambor, defended his officers that evening.
Gregore Sambor, Police Commissioner: At no time did any police position fire in an offensive posture. It was purely in a defensive posture.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): Eleven MOVE members, including five children, were killed. While no city officials were criminally charged. A Philadelphia investigative commission later concluded that police actions were clearly excessive and, quote, unconscionable.
Mike Africa: I don't think I'll ever recover or heal from what happened.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): Mike Africa Jr. Who was six at the time of the bombing, is now working as the legacy director of MOVE. He's reunited with his parents, who were released from prison in 2018 but remain on parole.
Mike Africa: I've never heard of another case where a government has dropped a bomb on citizens in America. This is not something that you can repair back to normal. You have to find other ways to cope, and that's what I've been doing for the last 40 years.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): In 2020, Philadelphia's City Council formally apologized for what happened, as has former mayor Wilson Good. But Africa junior Says four decades later he'd like the city to create a permanent memorial to commemorate all that was lost that day.
Ali Rogin: In your opinion, why do you feel that so few Americans know about the events that took place 40 years ago?
Mike Africa: I think the city of Philadelphia does a really good job of limiting the amount of exposure to what happened. I also think that MOVE history is a very controversial history that brings up a lot of trauma for a lot of people. Black people were killed by law enforcement. And, you know, if you saw what happened to George Floyd, and at a certain point, you're tired of hearing about the people that were getting killed by these police officers.
Ali Rogin (voice-over): But that doesn't stop Mike Africa Jr. From his mission of making sure the history of MOVE and the tragic event that claimed 11 lives and forgotten. For PBS News Weekend, I'm Ali Rogin.
