NPR played up a pro-illegal immigration rally at an Alabama church with "strong ties to the civil rights movement" on Tuesday's Morning Edition. Correspondent Tanya Ott of affiliate WBHM trumpeted how "they could hardly pick a more historic place to hold the rally," and highlighted a an advocate for illegal immigrants who likened opponents to the devil.
Fill-in host Linda Wertheimer touted how "pressure is mounting against Alabama's immigration law, known as the toughest in the nation" in her introduction to the journalist's report, and used her "strong ties" phrase as she stated how 3,000 showed up for the rally at the church. Ott specified that the "historic place" which hosted the event is the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, "where, almost a half century ago, a bomb exploded, killing four young black girls."
The WBHM correspondent noted that the rally was the "kick-off for a national campaign to repeal HB 56" and hyped how the law "criminalizes almost every daily action of undocumented immigrants. They can't work; they can't rent an apartment; they can't be in Alabama." She described the mood at the rally as "victorious, but under the bravado, there's fear," and underlined this apparent fear by playing a sound bite from a ten-year-old girl who worried that her parents might be deported.
Ott then turned to Deacon Silverio Rubio, who "urges his congregants to stay in Alabama." The NPR correspondent included a clip from Rubio who directed some incendiary language at the supporters of HB 56: "I tell them don't leave; don't be cowards; you're not criminals. Just face the devil here. We have to ban together and repeal the law."
However, as the Birmingham News noted on Monday, some of the speakers at the rally went much further than Rubio. Roderick Royal, the president of Birmingham's city council, labeled Alabama Governor Robert Bentley (as well as the two stated legislators who introduced HB 56) a "reincarnated George Wallace," a reference to the former governor of the state who infamously stood in the schoolhouse door at the University of Alabama. Ott didn't point this out in her report.
After playing three straight sound bites from individual opponents of the Alabama law, the correspondent finally played a clip from Rep. Mo Brooks, an opponent of illegal immigration. However, she followed this with a sound bite from Alabama State Senator Gerald Dial, who supporter HB 56, but now claims that he "made some mistakes, and I'm going to try to correct those." Ott also acknowledged that repealing the law "won't sit well with Alabamians. A recent survey of likely voters found three-quarters say the law should be left as is or revised."
The full transcript of WBHM correspondent Tanya Ott's report on Tuesday's Morning Edition:
As Tanya Ott from member station WBHM in Birmingham reports, they heard from Democratic members of Congress, who vow to get the law repealed.
TANYA OTT: They could hardly pick a more historic place to hold the rally. The 16th Street Baptist Church, where, almost a half century ago, a bomb exploded, killing four young black girls. Tonight, though, the sanctuary explodes with cheers. (clip of audience chanting "Si, se puede!") It's the kick-off for a national campaign to repeal HB 56. The law criminalizes almost every daily action of undocumented immigrants. They can't work; they can't rent an apartment; they can't be in Alabama. The sound is victorious, but under the bravado, there's fear.
Ten-year-old Diane is here with her parents and younger brother. Diane was born in the U.S., but her parents are undocumented.
DIANE: When I see the police, I try- I want to cry because I'm scared, because I don't want my parents to go away.
OTT: Deacon Silverio Rubio of St. Theresa's Catholic Church says it's a legitimate concern, but he urges his congregants to stay in Alabama.
DEACON SILVERIO RUBIO: I tell them don't leave; don't be cowards; you're not criminals. Just face the devil here. We have to ban together and repeal the law.
OTT: There's movement on that front. Earlier in the day, ten Democratic members of Congress spent hours listening to immigrants talk about hardships under the law. They also heard from local government officials, who say they don't have the resources to enforce it. Illinois Democratic Congressman Luis Gutierrez is helping lead the effort to repeal HB 56.
REPRESENTATIVE LUIS GUTIERREZ: We don't need a hodgepodge of 50 different immigration policies in 50 states. We need an immigration policy that does justice and fairness to the rich history of immigrants here in the United States of America.
OTT: But Republicans in Congress, including Alabama's Mo Brooks, say the federal government hasn't done enough to stop illegal immigration.
REPRESENTATIVE MO BROOKS: If we had strong illegal alien laws on the federal government books, and those laws were enforced, the State of Alabama would not have to act.
OTT: Republicans say the law is necessary to protect jobs. They point to new data that shows an improved job picture since the law went into effect. But economists warn it could just be an uptick in seasonal hiring. Some Republican state lawmakers who voted for HB 56 concede there are problems with it. State Senator Gerald Dial says the bill came to lawmakers late in the session, near the end of a six hour filibuster, and they didn't have enough time to study it.
STATE SENATOR GERALD DIAL: And we were kind of caught in a box. We either vote for it or against it. If we voted against it, it looked like we were supporting illegal immigrants into our state. So we voted for it. I made some mistakes, and I'm going to try to correct those.
OTT: Dial insists, though, the changes he wants to make will not roll back restrictions on undocumented immigrants. One Democratic state lawmaker has drafted legislation to repeal the law, but there's evidence to suggest that won't sit well with Alabamians. A recent survey of likely voters found three-quarters say the law should be left as is or revised.
The legislature might not have the final say. A federal lawsuit against HB 56 is currently being considered by an appeals court. For NPR News, I'm Tanya Ott in Birmingham, Alabama.
