Regardless of whether a strike is called or a settlement is
reached, warned Chan and Greenhouse, the labor struggle over the
transit contract has highlighted one fact: Many workers feel they
lack dignity and respect on the job.
But on CNN, business reporters were wondering where the dignity of
and respect for the law factored into plans for the labor strike.
Cafferty opened the December 17 show explaining that the citys
Transit Workers Union had refused to go
to mediation with the city of New York, and, as a result, theres a
whole debate raging about whether 33,000 people should be able to
hold a city of 8.5 million people hostage over contracts that by law
they are not allowed to strike against.
Cafferty was referring to the
Taylor Law, which took effect in New York in 1967 and forbids strikes by most
public employees in the Empire State.
Caffertys co-host Susan Lisovicz added that transit workers start
at $52,000, close to $53,000-a-year while
rookie
police officers and probationary
firefighters earn about $25,000. The Timess
Greenhouse and Chan
similarly reported in a separate December 19 Times article that
transit workers have an average base salary of $47,000 and average
earnings of $55,000, including overtime.
But while the Times portrayed well-compensated transit workers as
ill-treated civil servants, no mention of the Taylor Law was made,
nor were the viewpoints of city administrators or millions of
potentially stranded New York commuters included for balance.
Chan and Greenhouse failed to report what Greenhouse wrote in a
separate Times article:
much of the contract dispute between transit union workers and the
city of New York centers on benefits to future employees in a
two-tier contract structure which saves labor costs over the
long-run without cutting benefits for current workers.
The two-tier contract structure was
designed by city administrators to lessen the heavy burden rising labor costs place
on the citys taxpayers.
Media imbalance on labor disputes is hardly a new phenomenon. The
Business & Media Institute has
previously documented how the media have skewed stories in favor
of unions.
Times Ignores Cost of Union Strike for Commuters, City
December 19th, 2005 2:00 PM
Font Size