PBS omnipresence Bill Moyers is winding up for another series of left-wing propaganda broadcasts on our taxpayer-supported PBS stations. On April 25, we're subjected to the film "Buying the War," which quite typically argues that the liberal media weren't liberal enough, that they were weak-kneed pawns for the Bush war machine. Moyers gave an interview to Eric Bates of Rolling Stone magazine, which posted some audio on its "Rock and Roll Daily" blog explaining how Moyers "gets ill talking about how the Big Red Hype Machine, i.e. Fox News and its conservative bedfellows, makes headlines by criticizing unbiased news reporters."
Moyers declares that one special presence in the new film is disgraced CBS anchor Dan Rather. He says the program begins with footage of Rather crying on the David Letterman show a week after 9/11 proclaiming he would go "wherever the president tells me to line up." But in this film, Rather and Moyers are denouncing a right-wing "slime machine." That's a rich characterization coming from someone who tried to use bogus National Guard documents to ruin President Bush's reputation. Here's how Moyers promised he would denounce conservatives from coast to coast:
For the first time in our history, we had this wall-to-wall ideological right-wing press that not only – the Fox News, the talk radio, the Weekly Standard – that not only mongered for war along with the administration, not only embraced the administration’s policies because they were quote, "conservative" including going to war, but also mounted a slime machine to discredit any journalist who dared to stand against the official view of reality. Rather himself says on my show, "They have a slime machine and we know it."
So that’s a new phenomenon that people don’t fully understand. How, if a journalist tried to tell the truth about the intelligence, the Hannitys and the O’Reillys and the Limbaughs and the Mike Savages would come down on them, slander them, discredit them, so good reporting lost its power to break through because of this avalanche of opposition and venom directed at them. What’s happening to the media, it’s all over the place, I mean, Bill O’Reilly’s in the media, Eric Bates [of Rolling Stone] is in the media, so am I. There are more media sources today than there ever was, as a result we’re losing our ability to, we’re losing the common knowledge that helps us act a society in response to certain crises.
This sounds a lot like the discussion Lesley Stahl had with Chris Matthews back in 2005 that has the flavor of "why can't everyone just let CBS run the country like they used to?" The old media whines that the new media showed up -- and argues laughably that the Old Media has much higher standards of evidence -- and brought way too much democracy to the public discussion in America.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center
















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
We have a slime machine? Wa
April 19, 2007 - 07:58 ET by Al CzervikWe have a slime machine? Was it created by the same people that came up with Karl Rove's Weather machine? I'm guessing the early versions of the slime machine were so big that they took up an entire room but the later versions are as small as an IPOD.
That way the "slime machine" can be distributed cheaply to the masses giving us the ability to slime anyone who disagrees with, say, global warming or gun control.
I sure hope that Haliburton was behind the production of the slime machine. I'd hate to see the proceeds from something as sinister as this go to a front company that sells carbon off-sets or something.
Can I buy a slime machine at Wal-Mart yet?
Bill Moyers has got to go!
April 19, 2007 - 07:59 ET by CTFire Bill Moyers!
Its time for Moyers to go, we can't have this obscenity on the Public airways. This hate speech is unacceptable and it is supported by our Tax dollars yet. The Public networks that plan to air this obscenity should be put on notice that the next time they hold one of their telethon begging campaigns that they will receive calls for Moyers firing in lieu of contributions.
There are more media sources
April 19, 2007 - 08:23 ET by dscottThere are more media sources today than there ever was, as a result we’re losing our ability to, we’re losing the common knowledge that helps us act a society in response to certain crises.
So to restate what Moyers said, we liberals are losing our grip over the news (propaganda) dissemination machine, because there are too many news outlets. As a result of this loss of power to control the news, the country (the great unwashed masses) can no longer be told what to believe and how to solve problems of our creation.
Yea, Bill I really feel sorry for you and empathize with your loss. NOT!
That liberals are so worried about this tells me we are heading in the right direction and we must not relax our efforts to thoroughly discredit the MSM by in fact redoubling our efforts to make sure all Americans and the World gets the news reported factually without error or editorialized so people can make up their own minds. "We report, You decide" Keep up the good work Fox News, drive that holly stake right through the MSM's heart.
There is a place for editorializing, it's called the opinion section and that section should be open to all perspectives including the Right and Left. You know what they say about opinions? They are like $%#$%%^$% and everyone has one.
“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
Meet the new boss - same as
April 19, 2007 - 08:31 ET by Dee BunkMeet the new boss - same as the old boss - in a democracy it's the people not the media. It's amazing he actually admits that they think collectively and sees nothing wrong with that.
So, Moyersaurus and Ratherdon
April 19, 2007 - 08:40 ET by GalvanicSo, Moyersaurus and Ratherdon pine for the days when three network news organizations all queued off the NY Times headline, and there were few significant alternatives to information that could challenge there reporting and editing. Their jobs were so easy then, and no one questioned their persepective. Boo-hoo.
How about a show where they analyze how the MSM "slime machine" attacks the skeptics in the Global Warming debate, equating them with Holocaust deniers. Ooops. My mistake . . . . Prince Albert Gore says the debate is over (I guess we missed it).
I wish we had a slime machine
April 19, 2007 - 08:46 ET by Gat New YorkI wish we had a slime machine so we could have countered the left wing 24/7 slime machine. Then Bush's approval numbers would have been a lot more favorable and we would not have lost the last election.
I would think their teaming u
April 19, 2007 - 08:56 ET by AlgerHissI would think their teaming up like this is a clear admission of what sensible people have been saying all along: These two are leftists and were associated with lefty outfits.
Bill and Dan, I thank you.
Rochester, Minnesota: A Fem_Leftist City!
Rather boring...
April 19, 2007 - 09:36 ET by goldenthroatExcuse me - but - are these comments coming from the same reliable, accurate, always fair and balanced, impartial, objective and seasoned reporter who slimed President Bush in 2004 by conjuring up false documents about the president's National Guard service in an attempt to keep him from being re-elected?
Never dance on an empty stomach unless it's a liberal.
Yeah. The same. Makes me
April 19, 2007 - 12:26 ET by Lord ElicaniYeah. The same. Makes me sick to know Dan "I'd Rather smear righties" comes from the same area I do.
Quo usque tandem abutere, Catilina, patientia nostra? Quam diu etiam furor iste tuus nos eludet?
Nota Bene: Those documents
April 19, 2007 - 12:28 ET by SygNota Bene: Those documents have never been proven to be false. They also have never been proven to be authentic. Why? Because the only guy that knows the truth is dead.
Of course they have Syg - eve
April 19, 2007 - 12:58 ET by Dee BunkOf course they have Syg - even the liberal media recognized that the type font was not available at that time. Wake up. Nothing can be proved to you. Except maybe Bush lied right? You are so entrenched in your politics that your reason is completely gone.
Having once been a yellow-dog
April 19, 2007 - 10:09 ET by ltcolusmcretHaving once been a yellow-dog Democrud the thing that pishes me off about the Repubs is that they are too soft. The Demodawgs and liberals know how to smear and do it very well. The Repubs don't do it well enough. You cannot debate Demoscum as their minds are made up.
Agree, Itcolusmcret
April 19, 2007 - 10:14 ET by RJI'm another crossover, Itcolusmcret, and I agree.
Today's Republicans think they have to be "statesmen", while Democrats understand that political wars are won down in the trenches....Tom deLay we miss ya, bud.
Tom deLay we miss ya, bud....
April 19, 2007 - 17:35 ET by bigtimerTom deLay we miss ya, bud.
...Boy Howdy...and how!
The House has never been the same...I am still furious the republicans went with that stepping aside if someone was indicted...
Of course the dem's didn't follow suit.
What Bill calls the "s
April 19, 2007 - 10:09 ET by Dave in TexasWhat Bill calls the "slime machine", I like to call "contrary viewpoints", "facts that the liberal MSM chose not to report", and "an assumption that the viewer knows how to think for themselves".
Bill Moyers is the high pries
April 19, 2007 - 10:13 ET by TEBill Moyers is the high priestess of the America hating, earth worshipping, tree hugging, militant feminist, fundamentalist leftist religioius cult. He's the perfect face of PBS.
English Grammar 101
April 19, 2007 - 10:33 ET by buckhiloLiked your blog, Tim. But it's "omnipresent" instead of "omnipresence" in your lead sentence. "Omnipresence" is a noun; "omnipresent" is the adjective you were looking for.
Ye olde school m'arm...
I disagree with your criticis
April 19, 2007 - 10:56 ET by Jack BauerI disagree with your criticism. Had Tim written
The omnipresence Bill Moyers -- you would have been correct, as that should be The omnipresent Bill Moyers.
However, imagine the noun had been "commentator" instead of "omnipresence" .. and Tim had written PBS commentator Bill Moyers...
That is correct usage isn't it?
I know you didn't start thi
April 19, 2007 - 11:00 ET by MightyMouthI know you didn't start this Jack, BUT... who gives a flip? :-)
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
MM -- on reflection, you are
April 19, 2007 - 13:35 ET by Jack BauerMM -- on reflection, you are right! That has to be my most pointless post ever.
A rarity from the likes of
April 19, 2007 - 13:39 ET by MightyMouthA rarity from the likes of you jack, and btw, I keep asking myself why I insisted on pointing it out! :-)
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Kind of like a dog chasing it
April 19, 2007 - 14:54 ET by dscottKind of like a dog chasing it's tail? You guys crack me up.
“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
No better example of the &quo
April 19, 2007 - 11:24 ET by iveseenitallNo better example of the "war" which is going on in this country today. The left-wing media is the enemy within.
NEVER, NEVER trust a liberal
Bill! Help, I'm drowning!
April 19, 2007 - 11:49 ET by Cool ArrowSo Dan Rather ain't getting any viewers on HDTV. Maybe Pravda Broadcasting System can help.
"Good evening, this is Dan Rather with Bill Moyers"
Now Bill, If Russia mounted a rear assault on Turkey, do you think Greece would help"?
Right, Riled One. All people
April 19, 2007 - 11:55 ET by iveseenitallRight, Riled One. All people have to do is some basic research concerning worl-wide communism to know from where these two and their ilk are coming. Thank God for the internet.
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
No, thank Al Gore for the Int
April 19, 2007 - 11:59 ET by dscottNo, thank Al Gore for the Internet, after all he created it, didn't he? <sarcasim on>
“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
I have a co-worker who proudl
April 19, 2007 - 12:01 ET by BeowulfI have a co-worker who proudly proclaims himself to be a Democrat. I have no problem with this at all. We actually agree on most issues, i.e. death penalty, guns, etc. One major point of contention, however, is Fox news. Just the mention of the channel generates the same vitriol, let alone the name Bill O'Reilly. He spouts the liberal party line about Fox being a right-wing propaganda machine. Of course, I immediately asked him to provide examples. And of course, he had none to offer.
How many times have the traditional MSM (ABC, CBS, NBC, NYT, etc.) been flat-out caught in misreporting or outright lies? How many times has Fox (once that I know of, concerning Obama's education - and it was corrected/retracted within days)?
The MSM is playing the same old game - repeat the party line often enough and people start believing it. This is what they did to Bush's approval rating, the war in Iraq, gun control, and the US economy. This is what they're doing to Cristianity, immigration and conservative information sources.
No... Get outta town... The
April 19, 2007 - 12:29 ET by Lord ElicaniNo... Get outta town... The MSM is liberal? How the heck did you do that detective work?
While we're on Rather... How about the get Jayson Blair involved with this? I'm sure he could "find" good stories to help this.
Quo usque tandem abutere, Catilina, patientia nostra? Quam diu etiam furor iste tuus nos eludet?
Moyers: How, if a journalist
April 19, 2007 - 13:30 ET by MidAmericaMoyers: How, if a journalist tried to tell the truth about the intelligence, the Hannitys and the O’Reillys and the Limbaughs and the Mike Savages would come down on them, slander them, discredit them,...........
Moyers reminds me of my father's comment way back when I was a kid. "There's two kinds of people in the world. People who agree with me and people who are wrong".
Moyers is just a media spoile
April 19, 2007 - 14:27 ET by ratso ferrariMoyers is just a media spoiled little nitwit. When he was a kid he wouldn't share the apple pie with his brother and sister. When he was a kid he took the baseball and bat home when his team was losing.Now he is all grown up and his world is being threatened again.I wish Tony Dow would pop him in the nose for the Beaver.
Moyers and Stahl complain b
April 19, 2007 - 14:53 ET by Right2thePointMoyers and Stahl complain because the Borg has been neutered!
A true journalist would praise the rise of alternative media since it allows all voices and opinions into the mix which is the supposed aim of liberal democracy by their guideposts.
Absolutely
April 19, 2007 - 18:05 ET by Cool ArrowSo you've noticed a dearth of true journalists. Your post is significant in your observation that alternative media rolls on despite the old guard clawing to hold the stage.
Good insight.
RatherMoyer
April 19, 2007 - 17:30 ET by gfrrman..uh-huh......"fake but accurate"....
"Eventually, Socialists run out of other peoples' money...." MARGARET THATCHER
The day that scumbag Bill Moy
April 20, 2007 - 10:26 ET by The Real TonyThe day that scumbag Bill Moyers drops dead will be a great day in America!!
Fight Terrorism at home - defeat a liberal!