CNN Reporter: Blacks Don’t Vote Republican Because of ‘Perception of Racism’

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

On Wednesday’s "Situation Room," reporter Bill Schneider, in a piece on minorities in America, very casually alleged that African Americans don’t vote for Republicans because of "the perception of racism."

He also claimed that blacks have no reason to distrust the federal government because, after all, that institution rescued them from slavery. (Apparently conservatives just don’t appreciate this point.) After noting the losses by several African American GOP candidates in 2006, Schneider made his point about racism:

Bill Schneider: "President Bush appointed two African-American secretaries of state. Republicans nominated three African-Americans for important statewide offices last year. None of them came close to carrying black voters, which suggests it's not just the perception of racism that drives most black voters away from the Republican Party. There's something else. Distrust of the federal government is a core issue for Republicans."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Ronald Reagan: "Government is not the solution to our problem. Government is the problem."

Schneider: "Most blacks do not share that resentment. Why should they? The federal government rescued blacks from slavery in the 1860s and from segregation in the 1960s. Of course, some blacks do resent over-reliance on the federal government. They're the minority who become Republicans."

Watts: "I think we have to look at new ways of dealing with poverty, new models in education, new models in health care. You know, I think we have to look at new models in, in retirement security.

Schneider: "African-Americans vote their interests, and most blacks see government spending, government regulation, and judicial activism, things most Republicans oppose, as very much in their interests. Wolf?"

Notice how the CNN correspondent casually promoted the idea that most people just assume the GOP is racist? And further, not supporting big government means that you somehow don’t appreciate the end of slavery? (And if one looks at history, emancipation was primarily accomplished through the blood and pain of a civil war, not a government bureaucrat.)

Finally, as if to make the point totally clear, Mr. Schneider ended the report with a decree, "African Americans vote their interests." Would the veteran reporter say the same things about evangelical Christians or Cuban Americans?

Mr. Schneider has a long history of schilling for liberals. In one report he called for the GOP to mimic the liberal Arnold Schwarzenegger. In another segment, he stated that the GOP lesson of the 2006 midterms should be to move left.

A transcript of the segment, which aired at 5:46pm on February 21, follows:

Wolf Blitzer: "‘Uncovering America,’ CNN goes in-depth to report on conflicts and controversies affecting minority groups, including African-Americans, Hispanic-Americans, Asian-Americans, gays, among others. Today, the power of the black vote. Our senior political analyst, Bill Schneider, joining us once again from Los Angeles with the story. Bill."

Bill Schneider: "Wolf, it's like an immutable law of American politics -- African-Americans vote Democratic in overwhelming numbers for more than 40 years. African-Americans are the Democratic Party's base. They vote for the Democrat when nobody else does, like 1972, when blacks voted more than 80 percent for George McGovern, and 1984, when blacks voted more than 90 percent for Walter Mondale.

J.C. Watts. (Former GOP Conference Chairman): "Most black people vote alike, but most black people don't think alike."

Schneider: "That's certainly true. Many African-American are evangelical Christians and embrace conservative social values, but they don't vote Republican. Recently, Republicans have been making a determined outreach to black voters. President Bush appointed two African-American secretaries of state. Republicans nominated three African-Americans for important statewide offices last year. None of them came close to carrying black voters, which suggests it's not just the perception of racism that drives most black voters away from the Republican Party. There's something else. Distrust of the federal government is a core issue for Republicans."

Ronald Reagan: "Government is not the solution to our problem. Government is the problem."

Schneider: "Most blacks do not share that resentment. Why should they? The federal government rescued blacks from slavery in the 1860s and from segregation in the 1960s. Of course, some blacks do resent over-reliance on the federal government. They're the minority who become Republicans."

Watts: "I think we have to look at new ways of dealing with poverty, new models in education, new models in health care. You know, I think we have to look at new models in, in retirement security.

Schneider: "African-Americans vote their interests, and most blacks see government spending, government regulation, and judicial activism, things most Republicans oppose, as very much in their interests. Wolf?"

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Weak, liberal, co-dependent,

Weak, liberal, co-dependent, guilt ridden CCCN reporting. Hurts everyone.

I think there is a great less

I think there is a great lesson deep in this report.  Black Americans have a high percentage of poverty in America....A high percentage of Black Americans vote Democratic because of the dependency on the Federal Government.  Now the lesson...(read quote)

"You cannot help men permanently by doing for them what they could and should do for themselves." - Evil Conservative

The issue of Blacks and the p

The issue of Blacks and the political system is not as simple as CNN would like to portray. Nor is all that complex either. It is really about exposure to that different to what you are used to. If your environment involves only other Blacks, your views will be somewhat insulated and narrow. Maybe a little diversity will do the trick. It's what is perscribed as the cure for the narrow mindedness of Whites. Blacks who vote for Republicans are not necessarily Republicans to the core, but are more likely evangelicals who disagree with abortion, the welfare state mentality that White liberals feed by waving more entitlements like carrots on a stick. Many see that with hardwork yoou can gave a better quality of life, and that living a responsible life and making sound judgments is the model to success.

Even the Black politicians and impersarios know this. While Obama, Jesse,  Al, Maxine, and M.E. Dyson rail on about the frailty of the Black community, almost all of them have Bachelor degrees at a minimum.... and ironically live very good lives. If they were to say "America is racist, but do as I do and yoou will be okay" it would help better than their current messages.

 I am Black, but I also vote for Republicans, as well as Democrats. For me, I vote the principle, not the party. I am one of the few people who vote who actually researches the candidates's records on different issues. And coming to my church to give a politial speech will ensure I will not vote for you. I like Republicans like W. Bush, Michael Steele, and Guliani. But I also like Democrats like Corey Booker, John Lewis, and Bill Richardson. So I fluctuate within the 10% range on either side of the political median.

And while Schneider likes to talk about the gvernment's benevolance for the "American Negro", it was the government who enslaved Blacks, it was the government that legalized apartheid in this country for Blacks, it was governments that ensured Blacks would never rise above the lower middle class for most of the 20th century due to sub-standard educuation and services, and it is still the government that feels it is equivilent, if not superior to the Black male as the head of the household...... even when the results state otherwise.

Mr. Schneider is either really disingenuous, or really naive and sheltered. In either case, he is really annoying.

For a treat on another day, I will tell all the story of how when I was in college, Wolf "super-sensitive to minorities" Blitzer let me spend an hour and a half trying to get his wife's Porshe on and off my tow truck...... and didn't even give me a tip.

I am white and I belong to th

I am white and I belong to the National Black Republican Association. They may not change things overnight, but at least it is a start.

Their web site has a mountain of information supporting the notion the Republican Party was and is their best friend. Why Americans with black skin reliably vote leftist by 80-90% is a puzzle.

You mentioned John Lewis. I think years ago, Lewis was gutsy and stood up to Democrats like the Klanners. It was dangerous for him to do this. But today, he is a downright Marxist and is loathsome. Conyers, Waters and Obama are loathsome as well.

I am guilty, as we all are to varying degrees, of going with the averages. If I were to see a group of 100 black Americans at a voting precinct, I would see 90 Marxists and 10 non-Marxists.

Rochester, Minnesota: A Fem_Leftist City!

GOP Is Not Racist

I just love how CNN promotes how the GOP is now racist because it doesn't court enough black voters while the Democrat party does a better job because they can be trusted with government. Look, the reason blacks vote overwhelmingly Democrat is quite simple. Democrats pander to blacks in this country. They say to black voters it's okay not to be responsible, father/mother children you can't afford, be poor because the tax payer will foot the bill, and tell them that the GOP will take away your government grab bag and will segregate your schools/communities again. If it wasn't for the GOP, blacks would still be segregated because Democrats (really Dixiecrats) thought segregation was in THEIR best interests. Dems are race baiters and they use this ploy with Native Americans a lot too. WE know you better and have your interest at heart. Those mean old Republicans will take away your social entitlements that the American public pays for and that you need even if we, in the same breath, are fueling that dependency. No, Dems think THEY understand the whole civil rights construct a whole lot more that Republicans. Give me a break. Blacks are a voting bloc, just like hispanics and Native Americans. Many in these voting blocs WANT to be pandered to, to be told it's okay to be permissive, to not take responsibility for your lives, to buy into Dem lies that racism will always exist and threaten your existence, that it's okay to be dependent on the federal government. No, it's not...it's unhealthy but it won't stop these people from feeding at the public trough.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

mjem, you make so much sens

mjem, you make so much sense, I don't even know where to begin! I'll start here: perhaps the reason Republicans don't court black voters is because they know it's useless. The MSM take, and the way they play it is this: Republicans hate blacks. If Republicans promote blacks within their party they only do it to hide the fact that they hate blacks. This has now become "conventional wisdom."

And you hit the nail on the head with the responsibility theme too. The Democrats encourage the attitude among blacks that if you can't succeed, it's because of racism. The Democrats, however, promise to make up for all their (blacks') failures by giving them stuff from the government....excuse me, ....the taxpayers' trough.

This is why many blacks, including their "leaders" don't want to hear someone saying the things Bill Cosby has been saying. Next I expect them to say he's not really black. Because you know, being black is not a skin color, it's a set of attitudes and beliefs that one subscribes to.

No racism in GOP

If CNN had any integrity, they'd launch a serious investigation into the claim that the GOP is racist.  If they were honest, they'd find that it is not.  They might find a few racist who call themselves Republicans, but they'd clearly be the exception, not the rule.  And they'd investigate why blacks are still so bad off after 40 years of policies and programs put in place by Democrats.  And they'd find those programs holding blacks back.  But those are huge, huge "ifs". 

For its part, the GOP needs to find people who can make it clear to blacks that conservatism works well for everyone willing to try it, really try it.  I'm an outsider, but it seems to me blacks could benefit from a Reganesque spokesperson who could find a way to connect with them without pandering.

How 'bout Trent Lott for th

How 'bout Trent Lott for the job?
JMR

How about Dubya himself? Cons

How about Dubya himself? Considering he rushed so quick to embrace the black voters when the NAACP asked him to speak at their gatherings. Or his quick response and compassion for the Katrina victims. Or his views on the death penalty when most people that die from the death penalty are Black. Yup, dubya loves blacks.

GOOD GAWD MOSTLY immoderate

The NAACP is a democrat arm - the enemy black or white- duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

Katrina wasbotched by Nagin and Blanco - both 24 to 48hours LATE - and denying federal access. The GREAT republican governor, Haley Barbour, of the neighboring state acted swiftly and cooperated giving access to federal relief immediately. Racism is CHOCOLATE CITY - and bush hate bigot BLANCO.

 Al Gore is and ran on 100 pro death penalty . Show me the white people Bush excused from execution,or shall I assume you were being sarcastic,or just a raving lunatic liberal ?

 Will you always go for Kayne West, as your "moderator" onyour opinion ?

 Wasn't it mr save AFRICA and the world himself who said something like " Clinton talked a lot - but BUSH HAS BEEN DELIVERING,IT'S AMAZING I REALLY CAN'T UNDERSTAND IT...."

 Yeah, it's called compassionate President,who DELIVERS, even to the "blackest specimens from the wilds" to quote Democrat Robert KKK Byrd.

Really, you were actually being sarcastic,right ? I mean you say you're mostly moderate...

ps - Wasn't it Bush who was going to give those hispanics a free ride in and bigtime anmesty  - even as they overran his prescious Texas ? Is he somehow an unequal opportunity bigot ?

( I'll admit this much - he doesn't seem to like carrottops )

Nope, wasn't being sarcastic

Nope, wasn't being sarcastic at all. And I am actually leaning more republican than moderate these days F.Y.I. I will also vote for another republican President. However, that doesn't mean I will forget how G.W. impacted the Republican's loss in the elections in 2006. If G.W. would have played his cards a little better, we WOULDN'T have Nancy Pelosi in her position today. I mean honestly, are you going to sit there and condemn a fellow Republican for questioning the political moves of our leader? Unlike you et. al., I am concerned with where the Republican party is headed, rather than worrying about sticking up for our errors. You mentioned G.W. and his "amnesty for illegals". Uh huh? That had nothing to do with compassion and was purely motivated by business leaders that need the cheap labor (which I don't have a problem with). Being a Republican does NOT mean I have to be closed-minded. Certainly our party can do better in the future in picking up more Black votes. That's all I ever wanted to get across.

Well, moderate, I disagree with your analysis of 2006.

Well, moderate, I disagree with your analysis of 2006.

Congressional elections are local.  Bush had not much to do with who got elected in 2006.

People voted on 'earmarks' and corruption and Foley.

That was about it.  Oh yeah, and macaca (whatever that means?).

So, that is my disagreement with you on your post.  I do agree with your points about open minds and attracting all people to the party.

ACA

...

Quoted from:  'Acaiguana Notes from the Bomb Shelter' (soon to be a movie at theaters near you)

Yeah, the Foley issue was dem

Yeah, the Foley issue was democratic dirty-tricks at its worst. I mean, how much closer could that story come out before elections? How long did they sit on it?

Listen, I would go to war for the President if he asked me too. I would support the President anytime he needed me too. I just think it is up to the Republican Party to strategically ELIMINATE any misconceptions minorities have about our party and I don't think G.W. has played the game as well as he could. If we can take the minority voters away from the democrats, they will be SCREWED! Then, the country will get better and better :-) Just think, no democrats, no B.S.

So in two cases it's racism, in another it's opportunistic racis

So in two cases case it's racism , in another it's opportunistic racism.

Amazing. Katrina - racism. Death penalty -racism. Africa slow the Aids - no mention. Amnesty - opportunistic cheap labor - abuse of people - racism.

Is that your analysis ? Sure seems to be. So, it's not our party either, figure that one out.

I think the reason is " people like you think Bush is a racist". There aren't facts to support that, and many that deny it, but Kayne and his crown of thorns said it best for you.

 I also think, the reason the election went the way it did is :

1. MSM and democrat lies in complete cohesion.

2. Angry republicans who fail(ed) to understand they never had a majority with the 60 senate votes needed for cloture issue.

3. By all counts it has nearly always gone so in a second term, and given the insane level of hatred for Bush, it should have been much worse than it was, and it was not bad at all.

So, really, it's the modern idiocy that the President does everything, all compiled together with regret, and the crybaby lookback whiney complaining trying to find a target to blame.

 I don't agree with you at all, especially on the "we could have done better with race" crap. The msm and the dems ( Kayne West) is all it takes for even people like you who claim to be centrist republican to declare Bush a racist.

 It's no use, and there is no doing better with people around who think like you do.

Al Gore ran on the death penalty,is he racist as well ? I guess EVERYONE who goes for it is racist, because of course, you say mostly blacks are executed.

 I find you devoid of logic. 

ps- How do you lean more republican than moderate ? Is moderate some party I'm unaware of ? Is moderate a democrat ?  You must have meant leaning more to the right than you usually do.

pss- I forgot to note Bush loves Arabs - especially the Saudi type - and is bestes friends with them. No racism there, either- according to the hate filled left.

Well let's just do what YOU w

Well let's just do what YOU want to then, ok? Let's talk about how GREAT things are :-) Everything is FANTASTIC! The Republican's should NEVER worry about attracting Black, Hispanic, or any other minority votes. Who needs em, right?

Look, it would be great to ha

Look, it would be great to have more minorities become Republicans (read conservatives).  But if this means the GOP leaning more to the left of center on issues to gain these minority votes, I say screw it!

It's my view, for the GOP to pick up more minority votes, our party will have to become more liberal.  This is an unacceptable trade!  BTW, why do we have to catagorize and hyphenate everyone?  Aren't we all Americans?

Sadly, in Old Europe people

Sadly, in Old Europe people actually believe that the GOP are all redneck racists. This is typical b/w thinking. The Dimmocrats do anything they can to keep people dependent on the government. Basically, it's nothing short of bribery by the Denocrats to secure votes: "Vote for us and we're gonna make sure you get your monthly allowance." You seriously believe the Dems have any interest to stop the poor's dependence on the government? it would erode their vote among blacks. But not only among some Blacks but among all destitute people. So the Dimmos interest is to keep the poor people poor. God forbid the ghettos disappeared one day and people stopped calling for Big Government! It would undo the Dimmos. So who are the racists here, Mr Schneider?

Picture a woman being abu

Picture a woman being abused by her husband - repeatedly. She goes to the shelter but then returns. The police help her out but she returns. The police are called in for a domestic dispute and they attempt to arrest the husband and the woman tries to intervene and attacks the police and tells them to leave her husband alone and stay out of their business.

Husband = democrat(ic) party

Wife = African American (Blacks, minorities, etc)

Police/Shelter = GOP

Once you are a victim it's very difficult to get out of the "victim" mentality and free yourself from it. Others can help all they want but it doesn't matter until the individual being victimized wants to escape from the abuse.

Is it just me, of did he just

Is it just me, of did he just say that blacks are in favor of goverment intervention and social services such as welfare? I mean, he dident say it out right, but the over tone seems to be that they are inclined that way. Just me?

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

both eric turner & bassndude

You're both walking the fine line right here, because a black man would call each of you racist for what you're saying.

Not ME; the black man. I'll clarify: The APPEARANCE of some racial pre-judgment (used to be called prejudice) is enough for rank and file African Americans to protest. Just see every interview where Al Sharpton or the righteously indignant Black muslim lawyers voice their opinions. They are never prepared to share any of the blame for racial tensions out there; it's 100% the white man's doing! And usually those bigots do not distinguish between white liberals and conservatives.

I truly believe the black underclass (leave out the achievers) is content to just see election day come and go; they don't turn out in numbers at all. We only see the voters percentages, not a head count. If we had the clout and political leadership today to actually bring out the black vote, more of them would leave their Democrat plantation. As things now stand, the ones who show up to vote are interested in some faction, big unions or the political hangers-on working for some demagogue. Until that turns our way, we generate nothing. All it takes is the old innuendo-- GOP is racist, and they stay home in droves. Just my opinion, don't quote me.

And where does the "perc

And where does the "perception of racism" come from? 

Republicans are no more racist than Democrats are, and probably much less.  The GOP was formed to oppose slavery, the Civil War was started by Democrats who had a temper-tantrum after a Republican won the presidential election. (Standard practice for DemocRATS)  After giving up on continued segregation, the Dems changed tactics and decided to exploit blacks for political power by trapping them in the dependency cycle - all the while accusing Republicans of racism.

Therefore, the "perception of racism" can't be based on reality.  It must be based on something else.  I'd say it's media bias, DemocRAT propaganda, brain-washing and lies, lies, lies...

The Left must persist with their lies, because if the truth ever became "common knowledge" they'd be sunk.

You stated one of my first th

You stated one of my first thoughts upon reading this, mattm. Any "perception of racism" for the Republican Party comes largely, if not entirely, from the MSM like Bill Schneider and CNN who purposely foster this disgusting lie. Since the Democrat Party has no substance the easy thing to do is label the GOP to be racist and themselves the party of "tolerance." Facts, of course, never matter (such as the fact of Bush appointing far more black people than The Great Stainmaker ever did). Heck, Sick Willie, a white man, was ludicrously called "the first black president" by some of his supporters! I suppose if Alan Keyes had been elected in 2000 the MSM would try to say his conservatism disqualifies him from legitimately being considered a black president!

And Mr. Schneider, which party does the former KKK leader Robert Byrd (who used 'white nigger' a few years ago) belong to? Which party has repeatedly voted him in office? And why would their be no "perception of racism" for this party? Could it be because liberal media pundits like you and CNN love people like Robert Byrd and give him a total pass forever no matter what he says, simply because he has a D next to his name in parenthesis?!

The MSM IS The Democrat Party.

Of course we're racist.  The

Of course we're racist.  The appointment of Colin Powell and Condoleeza Rice over the last six years to the most prestigious cabinet position is proof of that. 

Now, a geniune sign that we wouldn't be racist would be, say, if we continued to string along Jesse Jackson to secure the Black vote. 

don't be defensive

I always cringe at the conservative or Republican who immediately wants to distance himself from the old stereotype of racial injustice. It isn't any use to protest "we're not racists."

I maintain every American is entitled to IGNORE that charge; since it's hardly relevant. No one should shake in his boots about it. Not if we're men and women of good will. That's what I'd say to Bill Schneider. We are men and women of GOOD WILL, no matter what the left says or what YOU insinuate.

I recall vaguely when Lew Alcindor (Kareem) went around with a white girl-friend; ostensibly because she had proven herself "color-blind" etc., Just HOGWASH! He meant to say, we have a good relationship; what else? Nobody is "color-blind," that's BS! We're either men & women of good will, or we're just behind the times and bigoted. Please don't tell me that Bill Schneider's colorblind. He's no example for any American of good will, he's a damn muck-raker; and an apologist for the ultra left-wing in our government.

racist

Interesting that this comes from your Tumbler, since you are know to have called a few of us racist in the past.

it ought to be interesting to you

Chad from Boca;

I'm not surprised. All you've done over the last year is ignore what the subtext of my posts was, constantly --and squirm to distance yourselves from the charge.

But did you offer any proof that tumbler was wrong? No. You (for only one,) just kept trying to kill the messenger. A racist IS as a racist DOES. If you cry enough expletives at defenseless minorities and demean their humanity, you give a sorry impression; even if you're basically not guilty. (Let's not go there.)

Thanks kookball.

Thanks kookball.

Read the subtext.

Tumbler the name caller

What proof could I offer?!? None that would suffice, I think. Prove to me you stopped beating your wife.

Go ahead. I did not cry any expletives at defenseless minorities. NONE. If you have proof I did, bring it on old man.

What I learned to do was to ignore you, as others here have done. I learned to ignore such a lame, baseless charge. I notice you don't get a lot of responces these days.

I don't need to prove anything to you old boy. Good bye.

tumbler

Eugene - how come you don't use the broken english you used to use? Have you been taking english lesson lately?

I couldn't agree with you mor

I couldn't agree with you more on this! Well said. None of us are "colorblind". When I see a black person, I see a black person. When I see a white person, I see a white person. The only time I determine whether the person is worth a damn is how they "act" and whether they are decent people.

"Color-Blindness" is a stupid little myth the liberals like to condone. LAME

The ONLY reason Republican's

The ONLY reason Republican's are considered racist is because the Democrat's say we are. Other than that, Republican's and Democrat's are equally racist AND non-racist. Racism is a personal issue, not a party issue.