ABC Recognizes Survival of 21-Week Baby 'May Change What People Think About Life'

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

ABC's World News led Tuesday night with an unusual spin, one favorable to conservatives: the survival of a baby born in Florida last October just 21 weeks and six days after conception, the least time ever spent in the womb by an infant who has survived (AP article). Anchor Charles Gibson teased: “A tiny miracle that raises big questions in the debate over abortion." Setting up his top story, Gibson acknowledged the impact on the abortion debate: “The fact that she has survived and grown to more than four pounds, and is about to go home, is a miracle, yes, but a miracle that may have an effect on the debate over abortion. And it may change what people think about life.”

Reporter Dan Harris soon outlined how “anti-abortion activists” are using her: "For her parents, Amillia's story is a personal and emotional one. But for anti-abortion activists, Amillia is a national poster child. Today they promised to hold her up as an example in future debates over restricting abortion.” Leading into a soundbite from Tony Perkins of the Family Research Council, Harris noted that “only one state, North Carolina, explicitly prohibits aborting a fetus as the point at which Amillia was born.” Harris, however, countered Perkins by stressing how “bio-ethicists we spoke with today argue that Amillia is a miracle baby, and that it's unwise to change public policy based on miracles." (Transcript follows)

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Tuesday's NBC Nightly News didn't mention the case and the CBS Evening News, anchored by Russ Mitchell, aired a very short item read by Mitchell that was without any connection to the abortion debate..

The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video for the February 20 story on ABC's World News with Charles Gibson:

Charles Gibson, in opening teaser:

"Welcome to World News. Tonight, a baby born after just 21 weeks in the womb survives. A tiny miracle that raises big questions in the debate over abortion."

Gibson led his newscast:

"Good evening. We begin tonight with the birth of a baby -- a tiny baby. Amillia Taylor was born last October after just 21 weeks and 6 days in the womb. That, we believe, is a shorter period of gestation than any other infant that has ever survived. The fact that she has survived and grown to more than four pounds, and is about to go home, is a miracle, yes, but a miracle that may have an effect on the debate over abortion. And it may change what people think about life. ABC's Dan Harris joins me tonight. Dan?"

Dan Harris: "Charlie, good evening. Until now, the story of tiny Amillia Taylor has primarily been a medical and human interest story. But today it became a political story as well. When Amillia Taylor was born in October, she was roughly the length of a ball-point pen, her feet were smaller than a thumb, and she weighed less than 10 ounces. But she was clearly scrappy."

Dr. William Smalling, Baptist Children's Hospital in Kendall, Florida: "She told us early on from the start that she was a fighter and she wanted to be here."

Harris: "This is Amillia now. She weighs four pounds, and, despite the fact that she's had some respiratory and digestive problems, her doctor says Amillia's prognosis is excellent."

Sonja Taylor, mother of premature baby: "I guess I'm still in amazement. I really am, even looking at her now. Sometimes it's hard to imagine that she would even get this far."

Harris: "For her parents, Amillia's story is a personal and emotional one. But for anti-abortion activists, Amillia is a national poster child. Today they promised to hold her up as an example in future debates over restricting abortion. Only one state, North Carolina, explicitly prohibits aborting a fetus as the point at which Amillia was born; 12 states permit abortion at that point; 23 states leave it to a doctor to decide whether the fetus is viable; and in 14 states, there are no laws on the books that would prevent such an abortion."

Tony Perkins, Family Research Council: "As we see, with the advancement of medical technology, we have children surviving outside the womb younger and younger. And it really brings into focus how valuable and how precious this human life really is."

Harris: "Bio-ethicists we spoke with today argue that Amillia is a miracle baby, and that it's unwise to change public policy based on miracles."

Professor Arthur Caplan, University of Pennsylvania: "We don't have new treatments. There isn't anything to be done differently to try and save 21-week-old premature infants. And so, I think it would be wrong to just say, because this one made it, we ought to treat everyone when we don't have any new treatments."

Harris: "Amillia was scheduled to be released today from Baptist Children's Hospital in Florida. But her doctors decided to hold her for a few more days as a precaution, they say. And once she does go home, she will, Charlie, still be followed very closely by her doctors."

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

 So, according to the Profes

 So, according to the Professor, just because one made it doesn't mean a thing?  Wow, these people who worship at the altar of abortion never cease to amaze me.  On the other hand, what a wonderful story.  Her family is really witnessing a miracle but they seem to know that.  She is a beautiful little baby and I hope nothing but the best for her and her family.  She truly is a miracle.

...all babies are absolute mi

...all babies are absolute miracles - and about 40 million and counting have been sucked up by vacuums, ripped apart, and tossed in the trash since Roe V. Wade...

What an incredible boon for the lib's feminist movement - you go girls...

Truly a grand event, I'm very

Truly a grand event, I'm very happy for the child and the parents, and even more so for what this could mean for the future of abortion.
Abortion sickens me so much I normally can't even discuss it, I just hope this story is publicized and can help.

AtheistRep - That is so coo

AtheistRep - That is so cool that you are an atheist and still able to be against abortion. Liberals like to frame the issue as some kooky Christian religious belief when in fact any religion out there that I know of does not think abortion is right. It's not condoned in the Jewish, Muslim, Buddhists, or Hindu religions and wouldn't even be compatible with Spiritual Yoga.

If you think about it - it should be more appalling to Atheists than anyone else because the argument is always about when the soul enters the body. Since atheists don't really believe in a soul then the life should be a life without question when it starts growing. Most people know this in their guts, but they have been conditioned by people who want to control the population, limit the growth of minorities, or don't want to take responsibility for their actions.

I don't blame any individual for having an abortion - most of them are teenagers and immature people in their early 20's. I blame a society that makes it an accepted norm.

True

I once wrote an article (and there's even a site out there devoted to pro-life atheists) that atheists have more cause to be pro-life THAN religious folks. If you wholly believe Darwin, the fitness of a species is dependant upon that species' ability to reproduce. Thus, anything that hinders humanity's reproduction just hurts us all as a species. We'd never know if maybe, just maybe, the offspring just killed would have been the next step for our species or a trillion other hopeful possibilities.

Ironically, only religions have any basis for arguing that a parent has any sort of "life-right" over their children. True, honest atheists have only the basis that everything must be subserviant to creating and preserving the next generation.

There was a girl I knew that had to have an abortion, but it was that or she would die, and three women (2 family, 1 friend) who lost pregancies because of accidents (falling) or miscarriages/etc. Even then, they'll tell you it really sucks and is a sickening moment.

Challenger Grim - thanks fo

Challenger Grim - thanks for your input. It's good to know that there are more of you out there. The thing that makes me so mad about this issue is most of the people who are pro-choice only think it should be in the first three months and don't realize that because of the activists it isn't just that. Many of them also believe in things like parental notification for minors.

Somehow the radical nut job extremists have been able to make it so that babies who survive botched abortions can't even be cared for, the parent of an 11 year old can't advise and console their own child and someone can intentionally murder a womans baby(against her will) in the womb and not be charged with murder. It's so disgusting and the public just doesn't know. How Christians get portrayed as extremists on this one is beyond me.

Dee Bunk, you are far more to

Dee Bunk, you are far more tolerant then I am, you are right its mostly societies fault but the individuals in question still sicken me.

I can't accept someone dieing without a choice, I don't know how other atheists feel about abortion, I avoid the subject because for some unknowable reason it has such an impact on me, but I don't understand how anyone would be able to risk the lives of children for the comfort and convinience of an irresponsible woman.

If the pro-choicers were to s

If the pro-choicers were to see a baby in an 8 to 12 week (multiple times a week) sonogram they would change their stance, unless they were too brain washed to understand what the struggling life before them actually was.

The ultimate tipping point would be: she (and he) wanted that baby and lost it to natural causes. The Dr. say's: sorry we could not save the baby or your "last" tube but we managed to save your wife's life.

Yep, I think that senerio might change a few minds in the pro-choice camp. I know it did mine.

For the sake of the children, I hope more of this type thing <edit, Miracle> happens on a more frequent basis. God, Please Bless our children, amen.

"To bad Ignorance isn't painful..."

It doesn't change my view on

It doesn't change my view on it, but I hope it might help others to see what an horrendous and vomitous act that abortion is.

If the left had their way, the lovely Miss Amelia would be dead now and they feminazi's would be celebrating.  It's pathetic that those who are are pro-death on the left can't enjoy this story for what it is, because it damages their hateful and evil cause.

I can't believe that the MSM

I can't believe that the MSM actually used the term......miracle!!!

Miracles

Today's medical miracles frequently become tomorrow's standard practice.  What doctors are learning from this experience may well help other premies of this age years from now.

I think this suggests that any definition of life that allows abortion before a certain stage of gestation is arbitrary at best.  Because we can't draw a bright line defining when life begins, we should protect all humans from conception.  I can't "prove" my case either, but that's what I believe.

I fully expect Planned Parent

I fully expect Planned Parenthood to come out with a statement claiming that this was just a fluke, not a miracle. Anything to downplay the event and keep the murdering going full speed ahead with the efficiency of a production line.

There must be more to this.

There must be more to this. Babies are not resuscitated below 22 weeks and the abortion act permits terminations up to 24. One of these groups will claim Amilla deceived someone as to where she was in her pregnancy.

JDW

Wounded skier. Corrections have been causing time-outs so mistakes will be made.

New pro-adoption dems, what about replacing abortions?

Harris: &quot;Bio-ethicists w

Harris: "Bio-ethicists we spoke with today argue that Amillia is a miracle baby, and that it's unwise to change public policy based on miracles."

What set of qualifications does it take to become a "bio-ethicist" anyway?  I've always wondered.  To me, this is another one of those business card titles like Feng Shui consultant:  anyone can claim to be one.

What these self-proclaimed bio-ethicists will have to deal with is the fact that just as medical science is making it possible to spark human life outside a womb, it will also preserve at-risk human life begun inside the womb, raising the obvious challenge to the Roe v. Wade definitions of fetus and abortion.  

I'm guessing the line about t

I'm guessing the line about talking to 'bio-ethicists today' is a flat out lie.

The first question that is as

The first question that is asked of a woman in an abortion murder clinic is, "will it hurt?"  The answer, and this has been documented over and over by abortion murder clinic personnel is, "No."

The second question that is asked of a woman in an abortion murder clinic is, "is it a real baby?" The answer, again, has been documented over and over by abortion murder clinic personnel is, "No."

The correct answer to the first question is, "Yes, it will hurt physically now and psychologically for the rest of your life.

The correct answer to the second question is, "Yes, it is a real live human being that you have been given the honor and privilege to bring into this world.  Anything short of your best effort at this is shameful bordering on the criminal.  If you do not want the baby.  Then, please bring it to term and we will help you find a wonderful couple that will love and cherish this baby as if it was theirs"

Meanwhile, Planned Parenthood, the leaders in infanticide declared record income of nearly a billion dollars, record profits, record abortions murders, and the least referrals for adoption for 2004/5 the latest information available.  You can read about it here:  http://www.cwfa.org/articles/10965/CWA/life/index.htm

Geeze, they'd better be caref

Geeze, they'd better be careful publishing their profit figures, Hillary might want to take those profits from them.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

A so-called &quot;bio-ethicis

A so-called "bio-ethicist" is leftist code for: pro-abortion and pro-euthanasia.  Given that ABC's Dan Harris is a militant abortion advocate, it's not surprising that the "bio-ethicists" Harris "spoke with" would not object to killing this child or any other such child.

Amillia is still a fetus, silly

Excuse me, but according to the cult of lib***l dogma, if the lump of cells called Amillia was born at 21 weeks in October 24, 16 weeks ago. (total 35 weeks.)

That means "Amillia" is three weeks short of being a BABY.She is still a FETUS.

She only becomes a BABY after the full gestation peroid for a human being which is about 266 days or 38 weeks.

A fanatic is one who can't change his mind and won't change the subject.

Sir Winston Churchill

Each time viability is reduce

Each time viability is reduced (21 weeks now, maybe it will be 18 weeks in two years) the 9 members of the court will have to go back and decide when life begins. gods, all of them.

And don't change policy based on miracles; don't give the unborn the benifit of the doubt. Make the 22 week bastards stand up in court, or the ICU, and convince us they are not worth killing.

Memo to ABC: It doesn't change what we think of life.

Jack, not even then for those

Jack, not even then for those that believe in partial-birth abortion.

"To bad Ignorance isn't painful..."

I heard this story on NPR yes

I heard this story on NPR yesterday, and the woman doing the interview with the doctor who cared for this little one asked this question:Is it a concern for you that other parents in this situation will see this case and feel it will work for them?  Of course, I was not shocked that the NPR interviewer would ask this question because we all know where they stand. What shocked me was that the doctor said that it was a major concern for the doctors and was a question that they wrestled with! It shocked me to hear someone that is supposedly trying to save and preserve lives say that he was concerned that parents would be willing to do nearly anything to keep their children alive.

It is truly eye opening, and sad to see where this nation is heading to. But it is the natural progression in the culture of death. If it is okay to abort a full term baby, then it is equally okay to simply allow a child to die by withholding treatment, I suppose. God save us from our alleged 'enlightenment'!

My wife and I are about to ha

My wife and I are about to have our first child, and even before 22 weeks our "BABY" already seemed to have a personality of sorts, would move and flip around, respond differently to different types of music, or get scared and "jump" if there was a sudden noise.  It's very much alive and a REAL BABY, and responding to its environment.

I used to be a pro-choice conservative for years until I read Sean Hannity's book which cited the number of abortions performed in the U.S. since Roe v Wade.  The number made me want to vomit (over a million per year, and nearly 50 million to date??) which just goes to show that people are using abortion as their "birth control" and as an out from their own irresponsible behavior.  I had been under the impression that abortion was not very common, but that's just disgusting.  Imagine if the media tracked the number of babies killed due to abortion on a daily or weekly basis like they track the number of troops or civilians killed in Iraq on a daily basis?  Oh wait, they're just fetuses and not real live human beings.

Anyhow, we're about 32 weeks along now and just over a month away from being full-term.  I can't see how anybody could possibly live with themselves after having an abortion, considering how "real" the baby is even at only 20 weeks.  No wonder abortion is linked to psychological trauma and other disorders in women.  Good grief, use a condom or one of the zillions of other forms of protection.  Human life is precious, and this tiny little girl is living proof of that.  No it's not just a "fetus" or some inert matter, it's a real live human being in there!!

I've seen the light.

SP,Congrats on your first chi

SP,

Congrats on your first child!

I'm curious about your transition from pro-choice to pro-life.  Was it really just the sheer number of abortions that made you change your mind?  For me, it's always about the nature of the fetus that has made me pro-life.  Certainly one million is a horrendous number, but whether one or one million, the moral implications shouldn't be based on numbers, but whether the fetus is in fact human, or is, as the Left believe, just a mass of cells.  (Just a side note on the hypocrisy of the Left: have you ever heard a person on the Left excited to have a baby state they are having a "Fetus Shower"?  Me neither...)

Anyway, I'm just curious as to your thoughts on that.

Take care,
Dutch

Amillia is a miracle baby Th

Amillia is a miracle baby

They all are -that's the point.

Every year the medical community is able to push the "survival" limit further and further back. There will come a tme when 10 weeks in utero is sufficient. Then 5 weeks and on down. That's not a "miracle", that's science and medicine. The miracle is when egg meets sperm forming a new, unique, very human life.