Finally, Someone In The Establishment Press Calls Out Obama's 'Created and Saved' Jobs Baloney

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

(I know; it almost doesn't count, because it's in the lefty-despised Wall Street Journal Opinion section.)

As yours truly noted a month after the presidential election (at NewsBusters; at BizzyBlog), Barack Obama's handlers and his teleprompter began telling the president-elect to begin using variations on the term "create and/or save" in speeches about jobs and the economy within days of his electoral victory. During the campaign, I found no example of where Obama used any variation on that phrase; it was always "we will create X number of jobs."

Until now, no one in the press of note has paid any attention to this "clever" abandonment of logic and accountability. After all, by the new "create and/or save" non-logic, Dear Leader has "saved" over 130 million jobs since his inauguration -- even though, on a seasonally adjusted basis, almost 2.2 million Americans lost theirs from February through May:

BLSseasAdjJobChanges0107to0509

Finally, someone in the establishment media has done a serious call-out of Team Obama's risible ruse. Here are excerpts from William McGurn's hard-hitting column in today's Wall Street Journal:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The Media Fall for Phony 'Jobs' Claims
The Obama Numbers Are Pure Fiction.

..... "Saved or created" has become the signature phrase for Barack Obama as he describes what his stimulus is doing for American jobs. His latest invocation came yesterday, when the president declared that the stimulus had already saved or created at least 150,000 American jobs -- and announced he was ramping up some of the stimulus spending so he could "save or create" an additional 600,000 jobs this summer. These numbers come in the context of an earlier Obama promise that his recovery plan will "save or create three to four million jobs over the next two years."

..... "We would never have used a formula like 'save or create,'" he former Bush administration communications team member Tony Fratto) tells me. "To begin with, the number is pure fiction -- the administration has no way to measure how many jobs are actually being 'saved.' And if we had tried to use something this flimsy, the press would never have let us get away with it."

Of course, the inability to measure Mr. Obama's jobs formula is part of its attraction. Never mind that no one -- not the Labor Department, not the Treasury, not the Bureau of Labor Statistics -- actually measures "jobs saved." As the New York Times delicately reports, Mr. Obama's jobs claims are "based on macroeconomic estimates, not an actual counting of jobs." Nice work if you can get away with it.

And get away with it he has. However dubious it may be as an economic measure, as a political formula "save or create" allows the president to invoke numbers that convey an illusion of precision.

.... Now, something's wrong when the president invokes a formula that makes it impossible for him to be wrong and it goes largely unchallenged. It's true that almost any government spending will create some jobs and save others. But as Milton Friedman once pointed out, that doesn't tell you much: The government, after all, can create jobs by hiring people to dig holes and fill them in.

If the "saved or created" formula looks brilliant, it's only because Mr. Obama and his team are not being called on their claims. And don't expect much to change. So long as the news continues to repeat the administration's line that the stimulus has already "saved or created" 150,000 jobs over a time period when the U.S. economy suffered an overall job loss 10 times that number, the White House would be insane to give up a formula that allows them to spin job losses into jobs saved.

"You would think that any self-respecting White House press corps would show some of the same skepticism toward President Obama's jobs claims that they did toward President Bush's tax cuts," says Mr. Fratto. "But I'm still waiting."

So am I.

How much higher does the unemployment rate have to go before Team Obama's apparatchiks at the Associated Press, the New York Times, and elsewhere -- who, as noted, rightly would never have let the Bush administration get away with a similar move -- stop repeating the President's patently obvious "created and/or saved" nonsense without challenging it?

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Good news, but -

Well, maybe the WSJ is part of the "establishment press", but it's not like it's the liberal establishment press. If the NYT, WaPO, or one of the networks reported this, it would be a "man bites dog story"...

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

So what does Gibbels say?

I wonder how he will spin the jobs that move out of the country.  Hummer, IBM, Microsoft.  With a global economy, you can run your ships out of liberia, your software out of India etc.

He has saved acorn jobs

Beaureaucratic jobs

Census jobs

DHS jobs

Evejn green energy jobs are laying off big numbers.

Chrysler shut it's plants and have not reopened but the day they closed, he claimed he saved 30,000 jobs.  They were sent home.  How many car dealership jobs lost?   

Gibbels still has his job

Biden and Geithner still are twistin and spinnin'

WATCH DA SPENDNG!

 

OBAMA: WATCH THE SPENDING!

The
amazing J. Carter Obama must be kidding…”watch the spending”…that is
like me charging 80k on credit cards last week and then telling my wife
to “watch the spending”. This smiling confident walking ego is a piece
of work.
Who just spent a trillion? Who just forced 9 trillion in debt on us? Who just 4x the budget debt in his first budget?

This, as others are saying, is simply code for…..drum roll….many big
taxes from the Party of Taxes! Bet you didn’t see that coming. Okay,
voters for JCO did not see it coming but the thinkers (not the feelers,
the Oz Landers) have the common sense to realize the vote-buying is
over on our VISA. Now its coming out of your 2010 paycheck.

Its ALWAYS part of the democrat strategy to assume you dropped out in 7th grade.
That you missed the Jimmah Carter Misery Index Era.
That you think massive borrowing has no consequences.
That economic laws and history never matter.
That inflation is a myth.
That there is always a free lunch.

Here come the predicted taxes on top of 9.4% unemployment…ya like ya 401k balance this month?…SUCKAS.

Doug Schexnayder, Ph.D. (theconservativecrawfish)

Saved 130 million jobs?????

Sorry, gotta call Bull$h!t on that!

Without the "stimulus" there would be 130 MILLION more people unemployed?

That's about 40 % of the entire US population!!

How do they get away with stuff like this?

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows.  -Bart Simpson

 

Little by little I think

Little by little I think more in the print are going to start some kind of a reality check, I heard earlier on Hannity that even AP has some kind of a critical story about this subject.

I want to know when the press and the msm, are going to start questioning this insanity with the power of the Czars that O-Team is putting in everywhere...the likes of which we have never seen and NOT what this country was founded on...this is unlike anything we have never seen...even Byrd has been very upset and critical about this...they answer to NO ONE...except the Prez, they cannot be called before congress for any questioning, no over-sight whatsoever etc...when are people going to wake up?

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

I was listening to a female

I was listening to a female car dealer today that  said 3  of her dealerships  were closed due to the government, and is having to fire 170 employees, it was heartbreaking, she said she is not going to lose her biz with out a fight, so question is not only is obamma saving or creating, but  how many closings of private biz will he take credit for, me thinks a big fat zero,

The Empty Suit

is a master of the shell game...look over here while I move the ball there! Better get a Czar on this PRONTO before the public catches on.

Saving

I think Obama must have gotten together with my wife to figure this one out.  Every time she goes shopping she tells me how much money she saved! 

"I've sentenced boys younger then you to the gas chamber.  Didn't want to do it, but I felt I owed it to them."  Judge Smails 

Hey, Wait a minute

are we married to the same woman? 

"If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - General George Patton Jr

But don't worry....

In the first few months of his 'reign', Obama has destroyed the economy, destroyed several private businesses, and put over 1,000,000,000 Americans out of work and in the poorhouse.

But don't worry - because Obama says that he's 'saved' 100,000 jobs!  So you 900,000+ people who are being thrown out on the streets - you can sleep in your cardboard boxes securely - knowing that 100,000 of your jobs were 'saved' at the cost of over 900,000 other jobs!

Only with a government-controlled gang of media slaves could Obama get away with the whoppers he's been telling lately.

This is just like his budget promises.  We're over a trillion dollars in debt - but don't worry!  Obama is going to spend over TEN trillion dollars - that'll even things out!

Now Obama says he'll 'save' 600,000 jobs in a month or so.  Great - does that mean we'll be losing over 10 million MORE jobs?  Because any gains this stinking liar proclaims have thus far been offset by nearly ten times that number in LOSSES.

So does this mean that (even though 4,000+ US troops have died in the war on terror) that the Obama media will use the same math and say that Bush has SAVED over 400,000 US troops?  If 10,000 Iraqis have dies as a result of terrorist attacks and bombings, does that mean the Obama media belives that Bush has SAVED over a million Iraqi lives....?

Hey Obama - and your media slaves?  Can you say 'fuzzy math'??? 

All this from a HARVARD educated man!  Give him a dunce cap and sit him in the corner I say.  Or re-write the old children's story as 'The Emporer has No Brains'.

What about Climate Change?

This is the same logic used for global warming. When the numbers don't add up, change the term. Global warming is now climate change, which means the loonies can take credit for whatever. Just as long as no one says anything to catch them, they're always right.

How about same-sex marriage? Hi-jack the term.

Choice? Another term, used by liberals, to hide the real action, which is human-killing.

___________________________________ 

Liberals constantly demand that we accept a glaring falsehood as truth; Obama's elimination of the word "terror" will make terrorist acts less terrifying

Human Nature

"You would think that any self-respecting White House press corps would show some of the same skepticism toward President Obama's jobs claims that they did toward President Bush's tax cuts," says Mr. Fratto. "But I'm still waiting."

Mr. Fratto may have a long wait. The press corps and their bosses bought into the liberal game long ago. Now, with their credibility on the line, they are “owned” by the liberal establishment. They are former journalists who have relegated themselves to "tools" that are used to promulgate policy to the masses. Their objective; influence public opinion to support government initiatives aimed at establishing firm control over the people.The salvation of America against this propaganda machine and the power hungry government that wields it is by the public learning—realizing the truth. Some strive to inform themselves and learn to glean the truth from the myriad of lies surrounding it. Others learn from the harsh lessons one encounters in life. Others, sadly, will never learn.

 

"If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - General George Patton Jr

Obama

Does any honest person believe a word Barry is saying about the economy? The guy's a lying, political thug! Many American citizens know what is coming, yet many continue to refuse to say it. More suffering on the way before this is all over. Sad.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

isia... American citizens

isia...

American citizens afraid to say it is right....

One man who isn't is Voight....what a great patriot that man is.

Anyone catch him on BOR tonight...my words will mean nothing, but Voight was brilliant with BOR...too bad there wasn't more time in that segment...BOR needs to LEARN from people like Voight...instead of having his mouth and ego going at times.

Just my take on it.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart