AFP Criticizes Fox News for Obama-Critical Article -- Written by AP

Photo of Tom Blumer.

Maybe it was just too easy to assume the worst of the news network most others in the press love to hate. Or perhaps it was deliberate.

Whatever the reason, the Agence France-Presse (AFP) wire service's Wednesday story about reaction to Barack Obama's sort-of State of the Union Speech the previous evening spent four of its last five paragraphs pinning a report harshly critical of various claims in the speech on Fox News. 

True, Fox News's web site carried the story ("Fact Check: Obama's Words on Home Aid Ring Hollow"). But it was actually written by the Associated Press's Calvin Woodward and Jim Kuhnhenn. (Yes, the AP actually wrote an Obama-critical story. More on that in a bit.)

Here are the four paragraphs in question from the AFP report, which otherwise lavishes praise on Obama's speech and rips into Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal's GOP response performance:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The Fox News network however was critical of the president.

Obama "knows Americans are unhappy that the government could rescue people who bought mansions beyond their means.

"But his assurance Tuesday night that only the deserving will get help rang hollow," read an article on the network's website that disputed many of the president's assertions on economic growth.

Fox also pointed out a mistake: In the speech Obama refers to the United States as "the nation that invented the automobile."

But it was really the AP's report. It wasn't blatantly obvious, but the original source was right there at FoxNews.com:

FoxNewsAPobamaSpeechReport0209.jpg

One version of the article with the Woodward/Kuhnhenn's byline is here.

As to the AP article itself, the good news is that AP pair indeed spent over 1,200 words ripping into no fewer than eight assertions Obama made during his speech They related to housing aid, who invented the autmobile, oil imports, the credibility of government cost savings claims, how supposedly "gutting" regulations led to current economic mess, how his ideas are only proposals (not dictates, as they would appear to be from the tone of his speech, the nation's ability to double its production of "renewable" energy, and the claim (criticized in the past by yours truly at NewsBusters and at BizzyBlog) that his programs will "save or create 3.5 million jobs."

The bad news is that the Woodward/Kuhnhenn's AP report wasn't carried widely. A 1:00 PM ET Google News Search using the article's third sentence came back with 97 results -- certainly not big numbers, compared to the over 8,500 results that came back in a Google News search on "Obama speech" (not in quotes) for February 24-25. Further, it's not at all clear how many of those web results made into the print editions of subscribing newspapers included in those results.

I suppose we can speculate all day as to why AP's outlets largely ignored the pair's story. One possibility is that sugary-sweet odes to the speech offered up hours before Obama even uttered a word by the likes of AP's Jennifer Loven (noted yesterday at NewsBusters; at BizzyBlog) crowded out later, longer, and more sober items like the one from Woodward/Kuhnhenn.

Regardless, the end result is that AP will be able to say, "See, see, we criticized the president," in a story that, compared to others on the same topic, didn't gain much currency.

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

LIberals are the most cruel

Of all people you will ever meet.

Damned FoxNews....

They knew they were supposed to ignore that AP story like everybody else! They acknowledged receipt of the memo!

Hey, I got the wrong "CHANGE"!

Alan Keyes / Sarah Palin - 2012

We are the individuals

that Obama fears rising up. Don't forget that.

Since we are discussing FoxNews, Roger Ailes, Chairman and

CEO of FoxNews has announced today that Bill Sammon, who was FoxNews Washington Deputy Managing Editor, has been promoted to Vice President of News and Washington Managing Editor. 

I was surprised to discover that Bill Salmon is 6 feet 7 inches tall. Wikipedia states: "His nickname used by some, including President Bush, is "Big Stretch".

I enjoy listening to Bill Sammon's intelligent comments when he appears on many of the FoxNews programs. His selection will continue to strengthen FoxNews, hopefully at the expense of the other liberal networks.

----------------------------------------------------------

“The media is a disgrace.  You have forfeited any notion that you once had of respect” ~ Rush Limbaugh

Hey RF... This is great

Hey RF...

This is great news!

I love Sammom, I've been following him before Fox was a network...excellent choice indeed.

Thanks for this important tidbit of new as far as I am concerned.

Hi bt

I agree that Bill Sammon is an excellent choice. I hope FoxNews doesn't change. It's really the only reason I watch TV.

TVNewser is reporting that in the February ratings, FoxNews beat CNN and MSNBC combined in total viewers.

You might be interested in the links to articles I posted here.

Oh my gosh the worlds will collide

Oh my gosh, oh my gosh. Get my inhaler. I can't breath, I can't stand it. A non conservative news source (AP) criticized Obama. Oh my gosh the worlds will collide. We're all going to DIIIEEE!!! I don't want to die!!! I knew Obama would ruin eveything.
It's All Dirty Politics

Yes...

Yes, how dare anyone ever criticize Obama about anything ever, ever! After all, the media and Democrats were just so understanding and patient when they disagreed with George W. Bush! (Sarcasm alert)