In the "First Person Singular" interview in The Washington Post Magazine on Sunday, ABC and NPR news analyst Cokie Roberts expressed her female chauvinism loud and clear: "Men are just lesser beings." Strangely, her extreme take on the sexes came right after she proclaimed she was in the common-sense middle of political opinion:
I think that often where I am is just in the middle. The middle is often the common-sensical place to be. The notion that one side is right and one side is wrong is generally, as one finds in life, not the case. Women tend to be a lot more common-sensical than men are. In fact, when the Mark Sanford thing broke, I went tearing into my husband's office and said, "Okay, that's it. Women just are better. Men are just lesser beings." He couldn't argue at that point.
Her husband, former New York Times reporter Steve Roberts, might have noted that a woman was enabling Sanford to cheat on his wife. Or he could have matched Sanford with a female politician like Monica Conyers (wife of the House Judiciary Committee chairman), who just resigned from the Detroit City Council after pleading guilty to bribery charges.
This isn't a slip of the tongue. Cokie also said women are better in agreeing with Sonia Sotomayor. If a man said something this flat-out sexist, would he face suspension from his network duties? David Shuster might have been suspended for less for suggesting Chelsea Clinton was being "pimped out" by her mother's campaign.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
The notion that one side is
August 2, 2009 - 16:27 ET by MidAmericaThe notion that one side is right and one side is wrong is generally, as one finds in life, not the case.
hhhmmmm.... I think that is why there are more men managers than women. Sometimes in life it is necessary to make a decision and stick with it. If the decisions turn out poorly you take it like a man and face the consequences.
First...
August 2, 2009 - 16:34 ET by Army BratCan you possibly imagine the uproar if a well known male member of the MSM said that women were "lesser beings"? The mans career would be over to say the least. Bodyguards would probably be a necessity, at least for a while.
And...it's so typical of a liberal to say that there is no right or wrong. I think most of us know that's not true, and that this belief in shades of gray is dragging this country down, not building it up.
islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.
Well, yeah, actually...
August 2, 2009 - 16:42 ET by BKeyserNot MSM but the President of Harvard University (there's that name again...) said, among other disparaging things about women, that their lack of success in science and technology fields may be due to "the different availability of aptitude at the high end."
And you're partly right, his career at Harvard ended the next year. Fortunately though, we're all blessed that our Progressive in Chief appointed him his chief economics advisor...
And....she says "Okay,
August 2, 2009 - 17:27 ET by motherbeltAnd....she says
"Okay, that's it. Women just are better. Men are just lesser beings." He couldn't argue at that point.
Um...maybe he was just plain dumbfounded that you said that?
He "couldn't" argue that point??
August 2, 2009 - 22:34 ET by b4m4wyMy guess is that he DIDN'T want to argue that point. Do you actually think she would listen to him? Who names their child Cokie anyway?
Government's first duty is to protect the people, not run their lives.
Ronald Reagan
women are leeches on society.
August 2, 2009 - 22:50 ET by puredmashieif not for the vagina, they would not be allowed to live in men's homes.
swing hard in case you hit it.
pm... You'd better be
August 2, 2009 - 23:08 ET by bigtimerpm...
You'd better be joking or sarcastic or something along those lines.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
idiot misogynists
August 2, 2009 - 23:15 ET by Free StinkerNow the idiot misogynists (yes, I know that was redundant) are coming out of the woodwork.
FS... You got that right,
August 2, 2009 - 23:19 ET by bigtimerFS...
You got that right, and I'm patiently waiting for a response.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
BT
August 2, 2009 - 23:22 ET by Free StinkerI'm patiently waiting for a response.
Your patience is commendable, but I suspect a reply is not forthcoming.
FS... Obvious now isn't
August 2, 2009 - 23:33 ET by bigtimerFS...
Obvious now isn't it?
I try to remember all walks of life/opinions, what people may be going through in their own lifes, i.e. an ugly break-up or divorce etc etc...
But that was absolutely disgusting... I read it three times to be sure of what I was reading and wasn't taking it wrong... it won't be forgotten by me.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
See ya,
August 2, 2009 - 23:18 ET by general companyMy Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
MB, she could be a control
August 3, 2009 - 16:18 ET by ForeverOnTheRightMB, she could be a control freak and he's a wilber milktoast and it would be hell to pay if he said anything!
God Awful Woman
August 2, 2009 - 16:28 ET by OneCleverCookieThere should be no doubt among the masses that Kooky Roberts informs her husband when and where he may use his manhood, if you want to call it that.
Full disclosure:
August 2, 2009 - 16:28 ET by BKeyserI'm male, 43, divorced 15 years, and for all of my female friends here at NB, Mrs. Roberts is ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!
(quietly: dudes, this kookie roberts is a nut job)
I don't agree with her much but
August 2, 2009 - 16:36 ET by Delsawhen she gets it right, she gets it right! lol
Howdy Delsa... Are you
August 2, 2009 - 17:04 ET by bigtimerHowdy Delsa...
Are you saying you agree with Cokie...or were you just being sarcastic?
I'm just curious...I don't know how to take your post...know what I mean...I hope.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Hello Big
August 2, 2009 - 17:07 ET by DelsaI placed "lol" afterwards.
Personally, I think she's an idiot!
She's another WOW for NOW
Now you've got me laughing
August 2, 2009 - 17:11 ET by bigtimerNow you've got me laughing Delsa...another WOW for NOW!
I like that.
Okay, what does the acronym WOW stand for?
I'm looking forward to the answer. ;-)
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
WOW
August 2, 2009 - 17:17 ET by DelsaRhymes with NOW?
I'm not that clever.
Maybe our NBers will come up with something.
How about "Woman (or women)
August 2, 2009 - 17:21 ET by motherbeltHow about "Woman (or women) on the Warpath"?
I like that mb... We
August 2, 2009 - 17:55 ET by bigtimerI like that mb...
We could always throw in 'Wicked ol' Witches'.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Men are not lesser
August 2, 2009 - 17:10 ET by BlazerMen are not lesser being's but the right woman sure can have an uplifting effect on us and can aspire us to be better men, work harder and want to achieve more. Maybe that's what Cokie was trying to say.
I doubt it, but just maybe.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "
- Ben Kenobi on Liberals, and the MSM.
" The Cake is a lie."
I wouldn't bet on that
August 3, 2009 - 16:25 ET by ForeverOnTheRightI wouldn't bet on that Blazer.
Uplifting
August 4, 2009 - 04:32 ET by bolivarOk Blazer, was that a play on words or is there a hidden meaning in this.....I am a pig and I know that but, come on now.
I have no use for liberal thinking - it is just so......passe.
What a typical witchy thing
August 2, 2009 - 16:36 ET by bigtimerWhat a typical witchy thing to say...sexist indeed....and talk about elite arrogance.
Cokie always has been NOW gal in my opinion, and her lovely partner in life is a whimpering Uber wussy, he always has been...sure don't miss him as a regular on CNN anymore.
I hope I live to see the day when these critters and their opinions do not matter as much anymore.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Okay, that just rips it. It's time to bring this back:
August 2, 2009 - 16:51 ET by R D Helmhttp://www.jonolesh....
-Dave
Dave... Roaring with
August 2, 2009 - 16:53 ET by bigtimerDave...
Roaring with laughter here, Rush would be proud, as well as get a huge kick out of it.
I loved the Rio Linda reference too.
Hey, thanks for some laughter here this afternoon.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Despite all the lies about
August 2, 2009 - 16:44 ET by robert108Despite all the lies about "equality", Cokie's Freudian slip represents the core of feminist thought since the very beginning. She's just another arrogant leftie who mistakes her ideology for the truth.
Thank you Cokie,
August 2, 2009 - 16:48 ET by lsudolemiteevery day you people continue to show us how bigoted, haughty and spiteful the Left truly is.
Cokie....
August 2, 2009 - 16:49 ET by pantrymanWhat a one-sided dipshit...and crazier than a shit-house rat to boot.......
Flame on, cokie......
I'm still laugfhing over
August 2, 2009 - 16:52 ET by Delsa"dipshit"!
I didn't watch the show busy cleaning up after a pissed off renter but what did her male counterparts have to say?
Keeping in mind that evryone on the show is a "dipshit" and nothing will surprise me.
Let me get this straight...
August 2, 2009 - 16:55 ET by jdripperAll those years that Cokie was having an affair don't count I guess. Hummmmm
Jack
"If at age 20 you are a conservative then you have no heart. If at age 30 you are a liberal then you have no brains." Sir Winston Churchill
Cokie may want to dial
August 2, 2009 - 16:57 ET by BlazerCokie may want to dial down the Botox a bit or perhaps get her eyebrow lifts applied a little looser. I've noticed a big upswing in Botox dementia concerning elderly liberal women. Nancy Pelosi is living proof of that.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "
- Ben Kenobi on Liberals, and the MSM.
" The Cake is a lie."
Dave got me laughing and
August 2, 2009 - 16:59 ET by Delsadipshit kept me going!
I can't' watch these people anymore.
Used to look forward to Sunday programing.
NOT anymore!
reference
August 2, 2009 - 16:59 ET by nadadhimmiWhat Cokie was referring to with her hand gesture in the photo was actually the size of her favorite dildo, "Blackie". Yes, compared to "Blackie", men ARE "lesser beings".
Five,
August 2, 2009 - 18:45 ET by Dan Diego"Five, five dollar foot long" Maybe she's looking for a new gig.
"botox dementia"
August 2, 2009 - 17:01 ET by DelsaOMG I am running to empty my bladder!
"botox dementia"
August 2, 2009 - 17:01 ET by DelsaOMG I am running to empty my bladder!
Cokie's a . . .
August 2, 2009 - 17:01 ET by 1611LilacLadyIsaiah 5:20a Woe unto them who call evil good, and good evil. . . KJV
Her husband, former New
August 2, 2009 - 17:11 ET by fitzfongHer husband, former New York Times reporter Steve Roberts
Sounds more like former man Steve Roberts.
"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered." -George Best
Left wing radicals and agit
August 2, 2009 - 17:19 ET by celatorLeft wing radicals and agit props like Mzzzz Cokie see all phenomena through three basic lenses: stirring up the gender wars, acccusatory racism and man-made impending environmental catastrophe.
That's their entire world, their life encyclopedia and the explanation of everything.
Roberts, of course, proves the point.
No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.
It Takes 2 To Tango!
August 2, 2009 - 17:20 ET by Wildcatter1980Tim, if you had not mentioned this, I would have. Thanks for beating to the punch.
Ms Roberts should be made to apologize to all of us for such a ridiculous, callus, and insensitive not to mention stupid remark. She should be suspended from any political journalistic work for the next 4 years--in other words until after the 2012 presidential election year so that the good folks who make up the electorate will not accidentally hear her. However, I am not going to hold my breathe waiting for any of this to happen.
--
We already have term limits. They are called elections. We can & should vote out those who do not represent & serve us! - Me
A baker's dozen for Cokie ...
August 2, 2009 - 17:25 ET by metaphorsbwithuSo women are superior beings? And just who might Cokie choose to populate her short list of best-of-the-better and why?
Try this off-the-top-of-my head baker's dozen:
Michelle Obama
Hillary Clinton
Nancy Pelosi
Barabara Boxer
Maxine Waters
Dianne Feinstein
Janeane Garafolo
Carol Browner
Janet Napolitano
Kathleen Sebelius
Sonia Sotomayor
Katie Couric
Gwen Ifil
Superior beings? Cream of the crop?
I don't know about you, but this makes me shudder just thinking about it.
metaphorsbwithu
Andreeea Mitchell...on and on it could go.
August 2, 2009 - 17:42 ET by bigtimerShudder indeed.
Of course Cokie thinks these enemies within are all the cat's meow.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Yes, BT, what a roug-ettes' gallery indeed!
August 2, 2009 - 18:21 ET by metaphorsbwithuCokie's mother Lindy was a strong woman herself, running and winning her husband Hale's congressional seat after he was killed in a plane crash, but gracious and classy, heads and shoulders apart from the women Cokie seems to admire.
I'd love to know what Lindy really thinks of the current crop of female role-models, although I feel even at 93 she might have too much tact to be totally honest.
Of course she too is a hardcore Democrat so who knows?
metaphorsbwithu
Evenin' meta... I knew
August 2, 2009 - 18:32 ET by bigtimerEvenin' meta...
I knew about her mom, her dad and all, wasn't one of her sisters also involved in politics too?
I should google it...may later if you don't know.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
BT - on Cokie's sister Barbara
August 2, 2009 - 18:54 ET by metaphorsbwithuYes, BT - Cokie's sister Barbara was heavily involved in politics, was once the mayor of the Bourough of Princeton, until she succumbed to cancer many years ago.
I live in the district where Hale and Lindy Boggs served. It's the 2nd Congressional District where disgraced congressman "Dollar Bill" Jefferson served for so long and where the first Vietnamese-American, Joseph Cao (pronounced GOW), was just elected.
metaphorsbwithu
meta... Hey thank you so
August 2, 2009 - 19:08 ET by bigtimermeta...
Hey thank you so much.
Cancer runs in their family too eh?
I like what I've seen of Cao...what do you think?
I've also been past disgusted with the non-coverage in the msm regarding Cold Cash Jefferson, we all know if this was a repub the msm would have been all over this story long ago, and wouldn't have let up, especially once the trial started.
No bias/hypocrisy here...
Yeah...and pigs fly too.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Yes, BT, the Jefferson
August 2, 2009 - 22:12 ET by metaphorsbwithuYes, BT, the Jefferson matter has been very frustrating. Jefferson was actually re-elected in 2006 after his indictment but was beaten in a surprise by Cao last year, mainly because of low minority turnout.
Cao is a mixed bag. He is not a true conservative and is under pressure from the black community to deliver on his promises of improved health care and medical facilities for the poor, etc.,
I have communicated regularly on matters like the stimulus, cap-in-trade (like Sen. Landrieu he seems to believe this global warming nonsense but is fearful of the costs to the oil industry and people in general), health care, etc., and he has been fairly good about voting with the Republicans. However, he makes me very nervous because he wants to deliver money and projects for his district and I can see him being coerced by promises from Pelosi to take care of him in exchange for his support of the disastrous legislation she wants to pass.
It remains to be seen whether he has the courage to stand against the Democrats on principle or bow down and accept a few cosmetic changes in the bills (in exchange for a few "bones" thrown at his constituents).
On a good note, he does seem to be actually reading the health care bill which he wasn't able to do with those previous massive pork barrel bills passed by the Democrats.
metaphorsbwithu
Hey meta... Thanks for
August 2, 2009 - 22:28 ET by bigtimerHey meta...
Thanks for filling me in on a lot of the going on's in La. from your perspective....really appreciate it.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
I think we've discovered.....
August 2, 2009 - 17:44 ET by pantrymansomething here.....
You know how the Cialis commercials warn of an erection lasting more than 4 hours??
I think we've discovered the cure here....just run videos of this list in front of the effected subject, and watch it disappear...perhaps forever.....
This list...the cure for the 5-day erection.... and the cinderella liberty.
Heck, you wouldn't
August 2, 2009 - 17:48 ET by BlazerHeck, you wouldn't even need to run video's. Just show the affected individual a picture of Helen Thomas and it will fall right off.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "
- Ben Kenobi on Liberals, and the MSM.
" The Cake is a lie."
That's terrible!
August 2, 2009 - 18:24 ET by metaphorsbwithuThat's terrible! :-D
metaphorsbwithu
You left out
August 2, 2009 - 18:06 ET by UpNorthJennifer Granholm
Debbie Stabenow.
Loved the No Ma'am reference upthread.
Al Bundy for President!!
My apologies meta, I
August 2, 2009 - 18:09 ET by Radical1979My apologies meta, I reacted to the article without reading previous. I bow to your (I assume) y chromosome. See, all women aren't stupid, some of us can admit when we made a mistake.
Move on Cokie
August 2, 2009 - 17:46 ET by jdlybrandPenis envy is sooooo 60's.
"What a revoltin' development this is!"
Chester Riley
Yes Dear
August 2, 2009 - 17:47 ET by slickwillie2001Makes me kind of feel sorry for Mr. Roberts. I think maybe the words 'yes dear' is about all he says to her.
sw... So do I. Doubling
August 2, 2009 - 17:53 ET by bigtimersw...
So do I.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
No comment
August 2, 2009 - 17:58 ET by Joe CamelWe low life's are not allowed to say anything..So I shant.
Liberal Arrogance and Feminazi Double Standard
August 2, 2009 - 18:04 ET by Mr. TerryCokie,Cokie, Cokie! Your slip is showing. Your elitist senitments are offensive indeed.
With all of your moral sermonizing you give out I think that this kind of statement deflates your moral balloon. You have no room to talk and you relienquish your supposed moral high ground.
I have one simple statement for you from all of the inferior race of beings, Shut up!
re women are better than
August 2, 2009 - 18:07 ET by Radical1979re women are better than men
Nancy Pelosi
Barbara Boxer
Hilary Clinton
Michelle Obama
Sorry Cokie, neither sex has the eliminated the stupid gene yet.
Great minds think alike ...
August 2, 2009 - 18:59 ET by metaphorsbwithu... is the usual saying.
No problem Rad, I don't always read all the comments either. Anyway, I'm sure the same idea occured to the majority of us here.
No single group has a monopoly on stupidity, but some groups do seem to celebrate it. ;-)
metaphorsbwithu
Oh, what a lucky husband he
August 2, 2009 - 18:31 ET by KevroyOh, what a lucky husband he is...
Thank you!
August 2, 2009 - 18:51 ET by Roger the ShrubberThis shrubber never passes an opportunity to post this on a Cokie Roberts thread...
Damn, Rog.
August 3, 2009 - 21:38 ET by R D HelmThe resemblance there is a little too close for comfort. :-O
-Dave
You don't think she was just
August 2, 2009 - 19:05 ET by balboaYou don't think she was just being hyperbolic for effect? I don't think this is an actual policy position she was voicing.
But please, keep piling dirt on that molehill...
Geez Bal
August 2, 2009 - 19:18 ET by jdlybrandHyperbolic? How about Freudian?
"What a revoltin' development this is!"
Chester Riley
I don't think something so
August 2, 2009 - 19:22 ET by balboaI don't think something so overt would be written by Roberts. It's obvious her comment was intentionally over the top. It doesn't reveal some inner truth beneath the surface.
Okay,
August 2, 2009 - 19:29 ET by jdlybrandI have some ocean front property for sale in Tennessee. You interested?
"What a revoltin' development this is!"
Chester Riley
You really shouldn't be
August 2, 2009 - 20:25 ET by bretzysdudeYou really shouldn't be typing.
Be rational. For once. She
August 2, 2009 - 20:40 ET by balboaBe rational. For once. She thought this guy was an idiot for cheating, said something she didn't really mean as an over-arching philosophy for a the entire population.
I know you think the worst of anyone left of, well, you, but be rational. Think.
You stop being naive. It's a
August 2, 2009 - 21:20 ET by dvdaughtryYou stop being naive. It's a mindset.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0Ftq9N4fzo
(forgive the link, my hyperlink is not working)
You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?
You're connecting Sally
August 2, 2009 - 22:20 ET by balboaYou're connecting Sally Field's Emmy speech to a column by Cokie Roberts? WOW.
I'd rather be naive about such a trivial point than overly nuts.
It's not a hard concept to
August 2, 2009 - 22:28 ET by dvdaughtryIt's not a hard concept to grasp, you just have to think a little.
I'll help you: draw a line from the dot with the small one next to it to the small dot with the small 2 next to it. Continue in chronological order until the picture is complete!
It's a mindset where women, mommies, etc are somewhat superior.
You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?
Or...
August 3, 2009 - 00:07 ET by Army BratWho you gonna believe? My interpretation of her statement, or your lyin' eyes and ears?
islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.
AB... Bulls-Eye! Doublin
August 3, 2009 - 00:20 ET by bigtimerAB...
Bulls-Eye!
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
after deep consideration-----
August 2, 2009 - 19:12 ET by misterbillGarofalo Cokie Roberts and her eunuch.
Cokie's thinking is highly suspect.
August 2, 2009 - 20:23 ET by Ted ClarkeI wonder how far Cokie Roberts' line of reasoning takes her. She bundles a bunch of anecdotal examples as a way of supporting her claim that "men are just lesser beings".
To be intellectually honest and consistent, would she make similarly harsh, broad-stroke claims about other demographic groups that have less-than-impressive stats? Following her line of reasoning, she would have to conclude that "------- are also lesser beings." Right?
that's right up there
August 2, 2009 - 21:14 ET by WesenWow, that's right up there with a friend who said "women are just p**** pockets".
What about Spitzer?
August 2, 2009 - 21:47 ET by zachlindShe “went tearing into my husband’s office” and complained about Mark Sanford? What about Eliot Spitzer? What did she do when his news broke? With her political background and coming from a family of Democrats I suspect it’s ok as long as you pay for it. Remember Cokie Roberts is from Louisiana and the Hale and Lindy Boggs gang, generally considered the next political dynasty after the Huey Long mob. Given the scope of the Kingfish’s aggressive ethics and wealth redistribution methods it’s not a stretch to assume some of those divine gifts rubbed off on the Bogg’s clan. Also, you might have noticed, Ms. Roberts is getting a little long in the tooth; she’s turning 66 this year.
Hey Cookie, from 2000-2005
August 2, 2009 - 22:55 ET by Lancasters Saved UsHey Cookie, from 2000-2005 Women in Israel accounted for 1.9% of the patents issued. You Go Girl. Someone has to dream up the new Toys (Advanced weaponry they will need to survive).
Come on now. I think we all
August 3, 2009 - 03:04 ET by FranksamCome on now. I think we all know that Cokie is right. just look at the history of civilizations founded and governed by women. We'd all be starving to death in the dark were it not for the technology in food and energy production developed by the girls (oops, my bad), I meant womyns.
I love my wife, and I've told her more than once how much I appreciate the things she does for me that I can't do. In turn, she knows that I am so much better at starting the snowblower at 5 AM. Lesser being? I don't think so.
I'm sorry for her husband. I guess the cat has his tongue.
I never did figure out what
August 3, 2009 - 04:54 ET by RR GOPI never did figure out what this woman's job, worth to humanity, claim to fame...whatever...actually is? Just seen her for years running her mouth and nothing she ever said seemed all that important.
Also, I really can't stand supposedly mature people that have cutesy names: "Cokie" Roberts, "Scooter" Libby, Tom "Cruise"...at some point in one's life you'd think the embarrassment factor would kick in.
One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).
Long ago, I submitted to the
August 3, 2009 - 07:48 ET by SickofLibsLong ago, I submitted to the massively superior intellects of Joan Walsh, Katrina venden Heuvel and the Coker.
ps: Coker, the porcupine look went out in the 80s after Annie Lenox went underground. And guys were never really that into it in the first place. Black bras are still good though, just not you, K?
Re superior intellects
August 3, 2009 - 08:46 ET by slickwillie2001I've seen Naomi Wolfe surface in the last week or so, on Fox News. She is as crazy as ever, and as big as Kirstie Allie was.