Air Force One Flyover: Blogosphere and Talk Radio Go Where MSM Fears to Tread


 National ReviewWhat is remarkable about the mainstream media coverage of the Air Force One flyover scandal in New York is how incurious they remain. NewsBusters managing editor, Ken Shepherd, has already pointed out how the Washington Post has labeled a mere 54-word apology as "profuse."

Currently the MSM seems to accept the explanation that it was was an obscure official in the White House who caused Air Force One to fly low over New York. Here is more from the same "profuse apology" Washington Post article:

The FAA did not return calls fo comment, and the Air Force referred calls to the White House. But White House spokesman Robert Gibbs, when questioned about the matter at his daily afternoon briefing, said he was unaware of the photo mission.

Finally, in the early evening, Louis Caldera, director of the White House Military Office, who said he approved the mission last week, shouldered the blame.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

"I take responsibility for that decision," Caldera said in a statement. "While federal authorities took the proper steps to notify state and local authorities in New York and New Jersey, it's clear that the mission created confusion and disruption. I apologize and take responsibility for any distress that flight caused."

Yes, it was all the fault of Louis Caldera! This obscure White House official got on the phone and ordered Air Force One to buzz Manhattan on his own without telling anybody higher up in the White House. Plus he took responsibility for it all not just once but TWICE in the same paragraph! Case closed! 

That now seems to be the attitude of the mainstream media to this incident. Unknown Louis took responsibility for the flyover so no need to investigate further. 

And why were officials in New York unaware of the impending Air Force One flyover? According to Fernanda Santos of the New York Times, it was the fault of yet another obscure official who forgot about an e-mail:

On Monday, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg was fuming. On Tuesday, he was forgiving, characterizing the actions of a low-level manager who failed to notify him or his superiors of a planned flyover exercise in Lower Manhattan as merely a mistake.

Perhaps it was because the mayor had already punished the manager, Marc Mugnos, with a letter of reprimand (and, presumably, a tongue-lashing). Perhaps it was because of all the apologies the city had received – from Mr. Mugnos, most likely, and also from the White House. (President Obama has ordered a review of the matter.)

The guy just didn’t do it. He read the thing and just didn’t do it,” Mayor Bloomberg told reporters during a news conference at City Hall, referring to Mr. Mugnos’ inaction after receiving an e-mail last Thursday from the Federal Aviation Administration, notifying him of the plans for a flyover by F-16s and a backup to Air Force One. (The New York Police Department also received the same e-mail.)

Towards the end of the article Santos, after a long, tortured, explanation of why Unknown Marc would receive such an important e-mail, triumphantly concludes:

Mystery solved. 

Woo! Hoo! It's all clear now as to why New York City officialdom was unprepared for the Air Force One photo-op buzzing of lower Manhattan. It was all the fault of one Marc Mugnos and the forgotten e-mail. Time now to move along and, oh, forget about actually interviewing Unknown Marc:

Mr. Mugnos could not be reached for comment. Mr. Bloomberg said that his was an error in judgment, that he has been reprimanded and that “we’ve all learned something” from the situation. “Now,” the mayor added, “it’s time to make sure our procedures are better and to get on with other things.”

In stark contrast to the purposeful incuriosity of the MSM, are the blogosphere and talk radio. The Virginian blog asks who wanted those photo-ops of Air Force One:

We know who has taken the fall, Louis Caldera, the Director of the White House Military Office. But lots of questions remain. And in today’s political climate, “taking the fall” means being the one who says he’s sorry. The days of falling on one’s sword, even metaphorically, are long gone for Democrats.

Who wanted new pictures of Air Force One against the New York skyline? Why was there a demand for secrecy? And, of course, the big question: who thought that low flying jumbo jets over Manhattan would pass un-noticed by the people who watched their friends die just eight years ago?

The first question: who wanted the pictures is likely someone in the Obama political image camp. Caldera is political appointee (who is not particularly popular even with Obama supporters) in a post that is traditionally held by a military officer. We either have to believe that he woke up one morning and decided that the pictures of Air Force One in the archives were out of date, or … more likely … someone in charge of the Obama image machine decided that images of Air Force one next to the Statue of Liberty would be useful in the future and tasked Caldera to do it.

The second question – the demand for secrecy – is a puzzle. You can’t run a 747 up and down the Hudson River without anyone noticing. Only months ago someone landed a commercial airliner in the river. It’s one of the most densely populated parts of the world. Were they afraid that if they told New Yorkers that they would be able to see Air Forced One fly by someone would take a shot at it?

I think that I have the answer to question number 3, why the people who ordered this had no idea of the reaction. The people who populate the Obama administration really don’t believe in 9/11. They may have read about it, They may know intellectually that it happened. But they view it the same way we may view a lightning strike that hits an isolated golfer: a billion-in-one shot that “just happened.” That’s why the Obama team is renaming the attacks of 9/11 as “man-caused disasters” putting it on the same moral plane as an auto wreck. That’s why the Obama team is not really concerned about revealing what we do to interrogate prisoners with vital information. They don’t believe we haven anything to worry about. Unlike the people who evacuated their buildings during the fly-bys and who ran for their lives, believing that they were under another attack. For Team Obama, it’s always 9/10.

UPDATE: A few other thoughts:

Who was doing the photography? In the pictures I saw the Air force jet trailing Air Force One was not in a position to take good pictures. Was there a photo plane? If so, where was it? Would it have not been much cheaper to photo-shop an image of Air Force One next to the Statue of Liberty and get the same effect? Were there any passengers on Air Force One during this flight? Was this a joy ride that bombed?

If you were listening to Rush Limbaugh yesterday, then you heard him discuss this Air Force One flyover at length and bringing up issues that would make the MSM very nervous about investigating:

This thing in New York yesterday with the flyover, Air Force One getting some pictures, flying past the Statue of Liberty, buzzing Ground Zero at a thousand feet, did you see the videotapes?  People scramming from their office buildings, running through the streets like the blob had been turned loose in their office building.  Then they went and they asked Gibbs about it, (paraphrasing) "How am I supposed to know where Air Force One is?"  Obama was reported to be furious.  Chuck Schumer, why, this is outrageous, these photo-ops, and they blamed the Bush FAA for doing all this.  I'll guarantee you, if this incident had happened with George Bush we would not know the name of the military officer who ordered this, who's been forced to fall on the sword, this guy Caldera.  

Let me tell you the truth about this.  The whole Obama administration is a photo-op; but, folks -- this is only common sense -- Obama cannot credibly say he didn't know that this was happening.  There are two Boeing 747s that suffice as Air Force One, and every time Obama goes someplace, both of them fly.  These travel schedules are worked out days, weeks in advance.  It takes a major movement to get Air Force One in the air on a presidential trip.  So, they had to go through the schedule, and they had to say we want to do the photo-op. Now, maybe not to Obama personally, but he had to be told at some point, "You can't travel on Monday, the 27th.  Are you traveling on the 27th, are we going to go anywhere on the 27th?"  It might go through Rahm Emanuel, but eventually somebody is going to go to Obama, and he's going to say, "Why?"  "Well, that's the day we scheduled a photo-op up there. We're going to get new pictures of Air Force One flying by the Statue of Liberty."  Just like our guy Victor from Boca Raton called, Obama doesn't know, he doesn't know any of these things are happening, he's just totally unaware, he's furious.  I'll guarantee you, if Bush were president when this had happened, only Bush would have made the decision, we wouldn't have heard of this Caldera guy or anybody else in the FAA or the White House office of military planning. (interruption)  Yeah, of course they wanted to keep it quiet.  Their notion of security is crazy.  

Limbaugh discusses this at even greater length, including sound bites of various officials involved, which can can read in this transcript.

The sad fact is that even the World Socialist Web Site is more skeptical about the official version of the Air Force Flyover than the MSM is.

(Photo Credit: Photoshop picture from National Review)

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

After this little incident...

....I'd like to see a poll of NYCers' opinions on the use of enhanced interrogation techniques as well as how well they think BHO is making America loved again by the rest of the world.

It seem to me that by their reaction they obviously think there are still plenty of bad guys out there who want to kill them.

Theory and Practice

We are now getting into the difference between theory and practice of New York Liberalism

Frankly I am surprised New Yorkers did not bow down in awe at the appearance of the wings of their new "lord".

The only dots NYC libs are

The only dots NYC libs are capable of connecting are the ones that result in pulling the voting lever for the democrat.

NYC Jewish voters would vote for a Guantanamo detainee if he claimed to a democrat.

It really amazes me

Obama, and Democrats in general, do their best to marginalize Israel and pave the way for its iradication plus back abortion yet a good portion of both the Jewish and Catholic communities back these hacks.

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain

Unsophisticated Urban Liberals

New Yorker's are quintessential "unsophisticated urban liberals". They judge by labels not substance.

That's why they pay inflated prices for designer clothing.

That's why New Yorkers wouldn't think of giving Sarah Palin a fair hearing.

  

 

designer clothing...

...and $950,000 for a studio apartment in a converted meat warehouse.

 Where are members of

 Where are members of congress calling for congressional hearings? I think America should know "who knew what and when"; who all were the passengers on Air Force One, what did their farts smell like? What did the Air Force One Chef serve to then as they flew over Ney York scaring the hell out of everyone? and what did his farts smell like? Where is Monisha, Tomisha, Monique, LaTisha... ready to sue everyone for breaking a finger nail while holling "bootie" out of the sky scraper, and Jessie Jackson trying to get them MILLIONs for Post tramatic stress disorder and racisum? 

I am a respectable redneck, bigoted, racist, gay bashing homophobe,democrat slamming, liberal trashing, ACLU cussing, gun toting, Muslim hating, SUV driving - gas guzzling, cigarette smoking by the No Smoking sign, beer drinking, meat eating, resource wasting, free internet porno watching, God fearing Christian...employed full time and single!

I want names!

Who thinks it is ok to raise my taxes so that they can do photo opps of Air Force 1? WHO???? This is tyranny. Unacceptable.

  -Reject ALL incumbents in 2010-

The disturbing aspect of

The disturbing aspect of this whole story is how buzzing lower Manhattan happened in the first place. Common sense to most that this is just bad taste and judging by 911 calls and video of the actions of pure panic on the ground. Gives you a clear snapshot of how out of touch this administration really is. Then to have the # of officials in this administration clearly denying having anything to do with it or knowing why this happened in the first place. Simply....scary folks..

The MSM

If this were done during the Bush Administration the MSM would be going ballistic. But since it's the Barry Administration they ignore it.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

The MSM

The MSM has become tediously predictable - If it's a lib, no D to identify party, words like 'misspoke' instead of 'lie' or 'misled'.  On and on it goes, where it stops ....

The evidence begins to mount

  • They ask to cover religious symbols for a photo-op (sorry, speech ... ah, what's the difference?).
  • He bows to a foreign king. 
  • They give a gift of unworkable DVDs.
  • They have a plane flying near buildings in Manhattan.

Remarkably tone deaf, aren't they? But they're such a smooth, professional White House operation, aren't they?

 

The Real Reason Should Be Obvious

Does anyone actually believe the "Photo Op" nonsense?

Anyone with a decent computer could make a fantastic photo of Air Force One flying over the Statue of Liberty.  So what's the real reason for the fly over?

Think Obama's Air Force One as the Clinton Lincoln Bedroom.  You can photoshop the image all day long, but in order to get the experience of taking Air Force One and flying over the Statue of Liberty and lower Manhattan, you actually have to be in the jet doing the flying over!

When we see the flight manifest, we will know the real reason for the fly over.

(Yes, yes, yes........I know that it's not technically Air Force One unless the President is on board.)

Was thinking the same thing

Probably Soros.

If one of the military (you know, the people Obama is cr@pping on) detail responsible for the upkeep of those planes had a set, there would be a mysterious copy of the manifest show up in Glen Beck's inbox.

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain

Re Passengers

I'm also very suspicious as to who was on the plane. We've been told unofficially that it was an Air Force-only flight, but I don't believe it. There has to be more to this.

Joy Ride

It was a joy ride. In fact, the entire Barry Administration is one big joy ride so far. They're spending our money with reckless abandon while they travel around the world dissing America. $380,000 for this llittle jaunt --- Chicken feed.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

That accompanying graphic is

That accompanying graphic is absolutely hilarious!

White House Explanation

This new "transparency" is great!  Robert Gibbs, chief spokesman for the President is unaware of the details surrounding this incident.  You have got to be kidding.  How in the hell can the vast majority of the American People be satisfied with the job that Obama and his crew of "marketeers" are doing?  It's becoming apparent that we as an electorate are being taken for fools.  Just because fools elected this guy, the rest of us have to suffer.

Re Gibbs

During one of the WH press conferences that covered this, the bumbling Gibbs actually suggested that some of the reporters "call the White House" for more information on the flight. I have to wonder how long reporters are going to treat this guy with any level of respect.

Too bad someone like Tapper

Too bad someone like Tapper didn't say "Hey Gibbsy. You ARE the Whitehouse!"

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain

The sock puppet has a hole in it

I would posit that a great number of the electorate aren't paying attention to the White House pressers. Unless Fox gets going on something like this, it's pretty much overlooked. Gibbs knows perfectly well what the truth is. It's his job to obfuscate. But he's not very good at it. If Obama is so smart, why does he have such a doofus for a press secretary?

Civilization is the progress toward a society of privacy. The savage's whole existence is public, ruled by the laws of the tribe. Civilization is the process of setting man free from men. - Ayn Rand

Schumer, as usual, blamed the FAA

 

http://www.youtube.c...

 

Does he owe them an apology? 

It's hard to believe ...

It's hard to believe that the president wouldn't know the status of one of his 2 aircraft. You AF aircraft scheduler out there speak up. As a maintenance training NCO in the Air Force, I had to schedule aircraft for maintenance training. When we scheduled an active AF asset to be down for training, the Wing Commander knew that one of his assets would not be available.

So here's the question. Don't you think that Obama ("the one", "the messiah", "the savior"), being C-I-C, would know when one of his only 2 aircraft would not be available? What is he had to suddenly go some place? Don't you think he would know the "status" of his only 2 aircraft? For Obama to say that he didn't know about the flight to NY is, huh, ah, a lie.

Just another example of Obama's arrogance. And what about cutting the $100 million out of the administrations budgets. This flight cost "We the People" more than $300k. Ah, so much for reducing the administration's budgets.   

Obama is not an honorable man, pure and simple.

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

Chief of Staff

I really think this is the sort of thing that a Presidents Chief of Staff would be on top of.  The President doesn't have to know this sort of detail stuff on the exact location of his two jets and all the helicopters.  But his Chief of Staff needs to know this sort of thing all the time.

I'm not so sure

Think about it.

The White House has a zillion contingency plans for everything from a tea bag being tossed over the fence, to illegal penetration of the DC airspace by a kite.

Sooo.....if the "normal" contingency plans for the day are not the same as on every other normal day.....say, for instance, that one of the President's planes is unavailable (IIRC, AF1 serves as KNEECAP, the flying command center during an emergency) that day....it most certainly would be mentioned in the President's Daily Brief.   White House security has plans for every possible scenario, and as much as BHO probably doesn't like it (remember him whining about how "confining" the White House was).....he damned sure has to know about them to do his job.

The notion that The One "found out like everyone else" is so much whitewash. 

 

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

Plausable

I'm not saying Obama didn't know.  What I'm saying is, at the very least, Ron Emanuel had to know.

Agreed.

 

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

~In all fairness

It seems perfectly plausible to me that the fact that one of his 'personal' planes was being used in a photo op that day would have been included in his daily briefing. I think it would not naturally have occurred to him to ask the specifics. It doesn't mean he was completely unaware, though, so his reaction is still a CYA moment.

 

 

That high-pitched scream you hear is the troll under my heel. 

True That!

I posted a reply but it's way below here.  So happy I'm now over the 30 years from my initial enlistment date.

You and me ...

You and me both, Sarge. The only way we would have to show up now is if the bad guys were crossing our beaches (or to take on the domastic terrorists). I which case I would be more than happy to take up arms again.

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

$380,000 for just THIS one. Others were planned...

with a number of national landmarks to be used as backdrops.

Typical government waste and stupidity - that's where these trillions are going (they know how to spend it better than you), while Barry does the faux-empathy thing, telling us he understands how tough it is out there.

The guy is a charlatan through and through.

Doesn't this prove what we all know?

Ordinary people on the ground notice what's happening before the DC officials do.

Obama, Gibbs, and the White House didn't know at first that a fighter jet and a jumbo jet flew, dangerously low, over NYC.

The people in NY and NJ knew, right away.

Centralized governments are out of touch.

didn't Obama say "the Buck

didn't Obama say "the Buck stops with me" and "if you got a problem come talk to me"

has anyone "talked" to him yet? 

Close

Truman:  The Buck Stops Here.

Obama:  The Buick Stops Here.

And after the "stimulus" plan proves to be a dismal failure

Obama:  All your bucks stop here!

King~

Brilliant!^_^

We have friends who work for GM in Michigan (pretty much awaiting their fate each and every day), and they sure wish Obama hadn't gotten into the car business -- not helping

The American public: What's a Buick?

The American public:  What's a Buick?

How Many More Times is NOBama

going to keep denying he knows anything about a serious issue?

In other words - he's LYING - again!  And many folks don't seem to give a damn about it. 

  • They don't care about the hundreds of thousands of OUR tax dollars spent for this little joy-ride.
  • They don't care about the carbon footprint Obama KEEPS making. 
  • They don't care that this administration could give a rats A$$ if the people of NYC were scrambling from their offices/buildings, making frantic phone calls to 911 (Hmm, doesn't THAT cost time and money?), running for their lives in sheer panic.
  • They don't care that Obama has no respect for the victims and family members of 9/11 OR the American public.

Anyone with 1/2 a brain would have figured that NYers would be terrified at the sight of these aircraft and the fact the Obama takes NO responsibility for this event is unconscionable.

For ONCE, this A-hole needs to take the heat for his decisions and actions, but I don't see that happening any time soon.  

ConcernedOne

Part of the fun of the joy-ride

Part of the fun of the joy-ride is watching the hoi polloi scramble as you buzz lower Manhattan.

"Yes, Lovee.  Those are some of the people that handle our brokerage accounts.  Pass the foie gras please."

Two comments on this one

First- I want to know where Pelosi was during this time frame!!! Don't put it past her [office] to demand use of the AF1 so she can fly up to Maine and work on Snow and Collins...

And Second (and the only serious comment...maybe...)- My real concern is the way things keep "disappearing" whenever something critical of Obama is aired. The CNBC Tea Party guy- makes an emotional declaration, gets some extended press about it, then blamo, he's "quieted" [my word]. Where's Daschle? Anyone seen or heard of him recently? How's ole' Nancy Killefer doing? My point here is not that these people should get non-stop, never-ending coverage, but how quickly its dismissed as unimportant or otherwise. Its almost as if anything anti-Obama is "dealt-with" before much damage can be done...

Love the pic J.P.

 
The White House could have saved a lot of money and ill feelings if they only borrowed your pic.

“It does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless minority keen to set brush fires in people's minds”

Samuel Adams

Come on folks

we all know the truth.   That was NOT a photo op, it was a pay-back to someone who we'll never know, and with Obama's knowledge.  Get real! 

I heard it said on "Quinn

I heard it said on "Quinn and Rose" this a.m. that it was likely a complimentary victory lap for some Saudi royalty. Pretty edgy, eh?

Civilization is the progress toward a society of privacy. The savage's whole existence is public, ruled by the laws of the tribe. Civilization is the process of setting man free from men. - Ayn Rand

Saudi royalty indeed

It was probably Bin Laden.

"B Hussein, my brother. After all the $ I put into your campaign I would like a small favor. I would like to fly the same route my glorious martyrs flew on September 11th. But of course <chuckle chuckle> without the same end result."

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain

This is the latest in a

This is the latest in a number of bumbling SNAFU's from the Obama administration and I think it proves a theory I have come up with: Obama's people are deathly afraid to tell him he is wrong. You cannot tell me someone, SOMEONE, in his White House did not realize how this fly-by would scare the wits out of all those NYers. I think Obama reacts so poorly to being told 'That's not a good idea." no one says it, EVER. Hence, the apologies, and the "I wasn't aware of that." as an escape clause for Obama.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

SentryDan -- True That!

For 20 of my 22 years in the USAF (Uncle Sam's Air Follies) I was a "commode post" (compost?) controller.  (actually it's the command post, but it's usually a windowless "block-house" secure bunker so we only know what we are told)

I coordinated on "Photo-Op" missions and let me tell you, those were HIGH PROFILE, and everyone knew, (and I mean everyone from the aircraft "wiper" that washed the plane to the Wing "King" to the Numbered Air Force Commander, and sometimes, depending on the airframe, the Major Command Commander.)

With the VC 25?  Not only  the AMC Commander, Gen. Arthur J. Lichte knew what was going on out of Andrews AFB (an AMC asset) but  Gen. Norton A. Schwartz  Air Force Chief of Staff, and Michael B. Donley (Secretary of the Air Force) knew as well.  So did the FAA and maybe even Mayor Bloomberg, he just didn't know that a VC-25 is usually called "Air Force One."

The "Honorable" former Secretary of the Army, Calderia should not be totally hung out to draw fire.  But it shows (sorry Army) that former Army JAG corps Captains SHOULD NOT be put in positions that they are neither qualified for or knowledgable of all the procedures ALREADY INPLACE.

I cannot "confirm or deny" rumors,  but I'm sure some "insignificant" military member attempted to "follow the checklist" and was over-ruled for political expedency or secrecy.

 

nice photoshoppin!

whomever does your blog pics should apply for the next photo op job ;)   Tell them you'll give it up for half price at $150K.

I love to help the helpless but I'm not gonna help the clueless   ~Dennis Miller

Attention all military members

I am retired from the USAF. This flyover shows many things, but I believe the biggest thing is that the White House staff do not know or care what people think of them other than the Obamessiah is perfect. I don't have any problem with the flyover itself. The problem is that, like so many other things, they are clueless about how the "little" people will view the grand standing that they do. And then when they are caught with their pants down, the CYA spin team goes from zero to the speed of heat.

That said, I would all active duty military members (and those who know active duty members) that when you retire, you get a "thank you" letter from the President. The good news is that it can be from any living President!!! If you want Clinton, Bush41, Bush43, or even Jimmeh, they can sign it. Doesn't have to be the current temporary occupant of 1600. P-) 

MSM

 As usual the MSM won't ask the basic questions.

Why wasn't this done on a Sunday morning when nobody would have even noticed?  Did it have to be on a Monday morning?

Why wasn't the public told?  The POTUS wasn't on the plane so what does it matter who knew? 

Remind me of another prez

Obama is like Clinton in terms of being told he is wrong.  When Clinton had his way he was the nicest person in the world, but tell him he was wrong or accuse him of something and he became a red faced S.O.B.  Narcissistic personality to the extreme.

"For a people who are free, and who mean to remain so, a well-organized and armed militia is their best security."

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

 

 The Snake oil salesman doesn't know where his planes are?

 

Too Rich and the libs beleive HIM

 

 

 

 

" The Future Is X Rated"