ClimateGate Scientists Cited in Report to White House and Congress

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

Scientists involved in the growing ClimateGate scandal were cited in an October climate change report prepared for the White House and Congress.

Titled "Our Changing Planet," the 172-page document was created by The U.S. Global Change Research Program along with the Subcommittee on Global Change Research, and was submitted as a supplement to President Obama's fiscal 2010 budget.

As such, its contents not only impact future and current legislation involving global warming, but also how tax dollars are spent to research and address it.

The report began with an introduction by White House science czar John Holdren, a man directly involved in ClimateGate (h/t Right Pundits via NB reader George):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Members of Congress:

We herewith transmit a copy of Our Changing Planet: The U.S. Climate Change Science Program for Fiscal Year 2010. The report describes the activities and plans of the U.S. Global Change Research Program (USGCRP) established under the Global Change Research Act of 1990. The USGCRP coordinates and integrates scientific research on climate and global change supported by 13 participating departments and agencies of the U.S. government. [...]

The document describes a range of activities including examples of the USGCRP's contribution to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, as well as progress in understanding Earth system components of the global climate system, how these components interact, and the processes and forces bringing about changes to the Earth system. [...]
USGCRP is committed to its mission to facilitate the creation and application of knowledge of the Earth's global environment though research, observations, decision support, and communication. We thank the participating agencies for their close cooperation, and we look forward to working with Congress in the continued development of this important program.

Respectfully,

Dr. John P. Holdren,
Director, Office of Science and Technology Policy
Assistant to the President for Science and Technology

The subsequent chapters addressed a number of topics involving climate, and concluded with "Chapter References and Endnotes" where the following names appeared:

  • Phil Jones, Director of the British Climate Research Unit
  • Gavin Schmidt, NASA climatologist and climate modeler
  • Michael Mann, Penn State professor and author of the Hockey Stick graph
  • Benjamin Santer, Lawrence Livermore Lab climate modeler
  • Raymond Bradley, professor at University of Massachusetts, Amherst
  • Kevin Trenberth, head of the Climate Analysis Section at the National Center for Atmospheric Research
  • Peter Stott, climate scientist at the UK Met office
  • Tom Wigley, climate scientist at the University Corporation for Atmospheric Research

To be sure, that papers by these scientists would be cited in such a report is by no means shocking. They have been preparing high-profile documents about global warming for years including for the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

In reality, it would have been shocking if this report DIDN'T include them.

However, what is disturbing is that America's news media haven't cross-referenced this high-profile report with all the names in the e-mail messages obtained from the computers of the University of East Anglia, and reported to the American people just how connected to the United States government these people are.

Or would that be too much like journalism?

Before you answer, consider how the press would be all over this report if the scandal involved policies advocated by leading Republicans that were not supported by the media, and the man in the White House was also a Republican.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Inhofe is going to be all

Inhofe is going to be all over this...I know he already is, but this will add more fuel to the fire.

'Planetary Emergency' comes to mind.

We gain power in '10 their will be hell to pay in my opinion, high past time there was.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

OUCH

I fell into a burning ring of fire I went down, down, down and the flames went higher And it burns, burns, burns, the ring of fire The ring of fire

Dr. Phil Jones - November 2009

I thought

I thought that was the "day after eating habaneros" song. =-)

  MSM - shaping all the perceptions you need to believe, then confirming it with a poll.

Different---

ring, different kind of fire.

MD

"There is no distinctly American criminal class - except Congress."

Mark Twain (1835-1910)

can we officially call global climate change warming

can we officially call global climate change warming *science fiction*

lunaticcringeradio

lunatic... You

lunatic...

You betcha!

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

can we officially classify the religion of gb/cc a cult

can we officially say the religion of global warming/climate change is downgraded to a cult. i am trying so hard to be offensive and denegrading to the progressives that thought they could scare the world into socialism with this boogeyman story. 

lunaticcringeradio

it graduated from hoax to ..

Full blown outright fraud.

Fear is a lawmakers best friend.

Laws and policies are easily made when there is a “fear” that needs to be taken care of. Fear is a lawmakers best friend.

http://politicallore.com/blog/?p=576

It is a shame that this

It is a shame that this house of cards is falling at this time. This is a long holiday weekend. Nobody around like Rush, Sean, and Levine to really pick up the ball on this and run. We all know that the MSM is not going to do one darn thing about it. I know the story has been around for a week or so but this is the first link to the WH. It will be overshadowed next Monday when the Senate returns and the debate on Obamacare begins. Want t o bet on what the MSM will concentrate on.  

Semper suprene nitens 

There is no point dwelling on all the foolish mistakes we have made in our lives. For one thing, it can be very time-consuming. Dr. Thomas Sowell

 

Rick

Rick,

Let not your heart be troubled!

You really don't think we're going to allow something like a holiday weekend to interfere with getting the truth out or making sure it's fully covered come Monday?

That's what the warmers and the media are expecting. Not going to happen.

This is a HUGE scandal that forever changes the global warming debate. Have you noticed that we haven't had any comments from our resident trolls on this subject? What does that tell you?

Ding, dong, AGW is dead! ns

Now, now...

Now, now, Neil... do I detect a hint of gloating?

Make that "well deserved" gloating.

On your comment about what the MSM would be doing if this was a Republican issue with a Republican president...

How about a little closer to home... what would the MSM be doing if some hacker found a cache of emails proving the "AGW Deniers" were conspiring to falsify data and more to prove their cause.  Can we say "Pulitzer" (instead of jail time) for the hacker?

Beauxdog

"Listening to you, I get the music. Gazing at you, I get the heat. Following you, I climb the mountains. I get excitement at your feet." Tommy - The Who (or is it the MSM?)

bd

bd,

Gloating? Nah. This is an embarrassment for our nation. That I'm the right side of the disgrace doesn't make it any less embarrassing.

Well, it does a little, but it's still pathetic and points to many problems in our government, media, and educational facilities. 

Not something to smile about. 

Shame on all these people for making this happen, especially our elected officials. ns

Noel, they will prop it up

Noel, they will prop it up and put sunglasses on it, and drive it around the country like Bernie.

The Ministry of Information will insist that "there's no there, there" and that the story doesn't have legs (which, of course, they will see to).  Next anyone who alludes to it will be called part of a "fringe" element.  Thus begins the discrediting of the critics. They they will attack the hacker, find out that he hasn't paid his child support for five years, and claim that that makes him non credible.  

Mother and Noel

Noel I am willing to bet the talking head shows on Sunday will not mention this. With the exception of Fox they will all be discussng Obamacare or the need for another porkulus. Don't you get a preview of who is on with the talking heads and the subjects? Again being a holiday weekend will they not have a lot of guest hosts?

Mother you are right they are in some way going to attack the messenger. That is there MO isn't it?

Semper suprene nitens 

There is no point dwelling on all the foolish mistakes we have made in our lives. For one thing, it can be very time-consuming. Dr. Thomas Sowell

 

rick... Plus you wanna

rick...

Plus you wanna bet they will also be talking about the couple that crashed the WH Dinner/lack of security blah blah blah as well.

...they will do anything they can to avoid it.

It will take power with the congress-critters to bring much attention to this....I do hope Inhofe is on Fox...I haven't checked the line-ups.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

Resident AGW trolls?

Have you noticed that we haven't had any comments from our resident trolls on this subject? What does that tell you?

It tells me that the majority of our most informed resident AGW supporters--Giles Winterbourne, Tokyo Tom, meteor79, etc.--were either banned or stopped commenting a long time ago.

Jer

oh, that's right Jer

Because all I remember is three or four people who ever came on NB to preach AGW. The stonewalling silence from all of our lefties means nothing.....

Unless you plan to assert that this post counts as a lefty reply to the topic.

What IS the topic? 

What IS the topic?  AGW?  Climategate?  The fact that both the liberal and conservative media have thus far failed to thoroughly cross-check names?  The tedious and obligatory "if this had been a Republican" argument?  The practice and propriety of embarrassing candor appearing in email exchanges among scientists?

I'll await further details.  If it is clearly inexcusable and duplicitous conduct, undermines the AGW "cause", and/or proves damaging to the current administration, I have no problem in acknowledging same.  I've done so in other areas in the past.  But,  I've never professed to be anything other than an "agnostic" when it comes to AGW.  The point of my previous post was to merely note that a fair number of qualified "believers" are no longer around to provide more informed commentary.

Jer 

Still in denial Jer?

The tedious and obligatory "if this had been a Republican" argument?

"Argument?"  What's to argue?  I believe NB has offered ample data on that subject to declare a concensus....and without any need (or desire) to "trick" the data.  Or were you just being argumentative?

→ acumen

I think in libspeak "tedious and obligatory" must mean "embarrassingly appropriate"

Just tryin' to help you out there, Jer!

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Thanks, that's what I was

Thanks, that's what I was trying to say. :-)

Jer

Why don't you wait until something smacks you in the skull.

I'll await further details.  If it is clearly inexcusable and duplicitous conduct.. 

  What further details are you waiting for exactly? Another set of emails and documents?

  They can't account for where the CO2 is going.

  They can't guage how much SO2 is being produced.

  They failed to see the decadal warming of the last 10 years even though the models and dire predictions are 22 years old.

  They can't fully account for the sun, they will never be able to fully predict the sun's actions.

  They discard evidence that does not go their way (tree rings after 1960 vs actual recorded temperatures)

  They keep evidence that can't be trusted. (tree rings before 1960)

  They won't release evidence for peer review.

  They destroy evidence rather than release it. (missing mag tapes)

  They collude to keep opposing views out of peer reviewed journals.

  When they do release evidence, and it is used by others, the resultant graphs are completely different. (New Zealand of late)

  They refuse to see that CO2 is a trailing indicator not leading.

But yea. You keep waiting for some more details there O.J. jurur #4. Maybe someting will turn up to finally convince you.   

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

I was waiting for YOU,

I was waiting for YOU, JWF...

that's basically the same as being "smacked in the skull".  :-)

Good the see you.  Hope you had a nice Thanksgiving.

Jer

You left out throatwobbler

You left out throatwobbler and that other fellow whose handle escapes me.

Did it ever occur to you these fellows might have been intellectually defeated?  Those banned were in large part because at some point their arguments collapsed into ad hominem profanities.  That is telltale of intellectual defeat.

Was it professortruth oe

Was it professortruth oe drtruth or something like that.

"You lie!"  Rep. Joe Wilson R-(SC)

Jer , What you may have missed...

And the trolls of yesteryear skipped...

Is that most of the 61 MB was DATA...sample

That pal, is the most damning information..more DATA on the way.

Rick you also assume that

Rick you also assume that everything has been released.  I'm thinking that there are still a few more shoes to drop on this whole issue much like the ACORN issue.

MSM

Most people watch Foxnews and read blogs so even if the MSM ignores the GW fiasco, it's only a minority that won't be informed.

 

I want my global warming tax green back, back...

Isn't there a law against defrauding the federal government? There needs to be a federial investigation on this. Think of the millions of US tax dollars already spent on this hoax.

Skip, It's in the many Billions..

79 Billion

Nova also says these government expenditures have “created a powerful
alliance of self-serving vested interests” drawn by the prospect of
lucrative profits soon to be garnered from carbon trading. The result:
the establishment of a near-monopsony that is distorting climate science in favor of climate alarmism.

State controlled health care music

Problem is...

it was our Federal Tax Dollars that created and supported the hoax from the beginning.  After all the quest is control, not climate. 

You can't sue yourself for defrauding yourself.

You can always hope your fellow citizens are smart enough to vote them out of office.

Beauxdog

"Listening to you, I get the music. Gazing at you, I get the heat. Following you, I climb the mountains. I get excitement at your feet." Tommy - The Who (or is it the MSM?)

I'll take installments...

Give me a 30% tax break over the next 50 years.

otta be a law...

SkipperMLM,

Since GangGreen (Obama and all his Commie, socialist, Progressive, Liberal, NEA gang) have been following Saul Alinsky's playbooks, which promote any means are justified to reach the end goal, they have no valid Scholtz-syndrome defense ("I know nu'ting!")

Obama certainly has had the SAME information you and I have been so easily 'gleening' from the internet. If he chooses to keep the blinders on, then he is acting improperly, for anyone in the office of the President of the USA. Acting improperly = the Misdemeanor, in "High Crimes and Misdemeanors" (referred to in Impeachment procedings, per the US Constitution.)

So, House of Representatives, it seems charges are in order AND Senate, once the House DOES IT'S DUTY, it'll be time for you to take the next step, which YOUR DUTY! And Congress will not do its duty, it will fall upon the States, then upon WE the PEOPLE to do OUR DUTY to defend the Constitution of the United States of America.

That's one direction things can go.

"Do Different"

Take a look at the University of East Anglia motto:

 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia

This may provide some explanation...perhaps after this, they should change it!

motto

Yeah, Like: "Remember Climategate: Always do the due."
OR: "Due, or do not."

OR: "SpongeBob is our mentor."

hubby was watchig local news here

They ended the broadcast with a plug for 11pm when they would show viewers even more ways to go green because we all had to work to save the planet. Nothing about ClimateGate, no question about whether we really need to save the planet.

Time for me to send them a friendly little email.

Be sure to add links to

Be sure to add links to where they can take their lazy journalist asses and look up the facts. Good job!

policies

if policies advocated by leading Republicans where involved

We now return to your containing 24hr coverage going on day 8. Most of the scientist involved have all been relieved and are in custody waiting formal charges and their court dates. This has destroyed any chance of anything that the GOP wants done do get done. We will stay on this story until all involved have been strip of all responsibility's. This fraud that involves no only billions but trillions have now been stop.

12 days of global warming

I posted this on the OT but this seems a better place to post. It is from the guys at Minnesotans for Global Warming

Semper suprene nitens 

There is no point dwelling on all the foolish mistakes we have made in our lives. For one thing, it can be very time-consuming. Dr. Thomas Sowell

 

Hey rick... I apologize,

Hey rick... I apologize, that's what I get for not clicking the link first, I thought it was this one, it's recent, has to do with this hidden info that has come to light...same group as well....got yours saved.

Have you seen it yet?

 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEiLgbBGKVk

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

Hide the decline!

bigtimer,

Thank you for posting that link!

There was dancing in our home!!!

Love it!

Hide the decline!

bigtimer,

Thank you for posting that link!

There was dancing in our home!!!

Love it!

js... You're welcome,

js...

You're welcome, glad you and others enjoyed it as much as I did, along with some of my pals.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

Hide the decline

has been running on replay in my mind all week... :)

But I don't mind, I love the song and video.

Thanks again Noel

I have been waiting for my 3 local rags to print something about the climategate scandel. Not one printed word until today. Todays Baton Rouge Morning Advocate ran a column by Eugene Robinson. He gives some info but then spins the entire column pleading that the emails are irrelevant to the threat of global warming. They ran only one article on Mary Landrieus bribe, and 3 stories on the party crashers. No more paper for me, no more alphabet tv, and NB in small doses on Dr's orders. Thanks for keeping me informed.

The big story seems to be

The big story seems to be the party crashes everywhere. One other thing I just thought about to overshadow this next week. The messiah makes his Afganistan speech next week from West Point. It is a shame it is coming from there because of the 3 words on Gen. MacAurthor's statue-Duty, Honor, Country. Something he knows nothing about. But we'll leave that until next Tuesday. 

Semper suprene nitens 

There is no point dwelling on all the foolish mistakes we have made in our lives. For one thing, it can be very time-consuming. Dr. Thomas Sowell

 

We are on the right side

We are on the right side folks, the truth is on our side..

Glenn Beck a few months ago said we should expect miracles...first ACORN scandal broke, which like David and Goliath, Goliath got a nice pebble on the head.  But this is a bigger giant than Goliath, and so we have the second stone...this story.

We still need to fight the good fight for sure, but its nice to know the Lord is on our side.

I have written my Senators

I have written my Senators and Congressman to ask if the evidence of climate change fraud will cause them them to vote NO on any cap and trade legislation. Probably pissing in the wind but if enough of us write, they get the picture... sometimes.

Please excuse old ladies

I am not techi and lost memory is mine, not my computer. But,  I found something of interest. Please excuse me, I was unable to drag the site to NB.

I found a blog   THEHINZSIGHTREPORT by David Hinz.

He was interested in the climategate thingy so contacted the United Nations. Spokesperson  says about 400 million per year since 2001 has been sent to the UN from developed nations to be spent on poor nations to fight climate change. However, a recent finding showed 2.7 billion is missing. A financial review was still unable to account for the money.

Perhaps Senator Inhofe could add to his investigation, how much of that 2.7 billion belonged to the US and when did it go missing. In politics, timing is everthing.

cajun2, I think this is

cajun2,

I think this is probably the same story that I commented on earlier this morning.

Wow dbo

You're fast. I just found this last night then took me all day to find it again so I could show proof to my husband. He makes me verify everything I tell him. Next time I need a quick reference, you will be my source. Thanks.

sorry but it's the entire 400 million that's missing

that's the second facet of the fraud that is called climate change, ooooohhh all the money that is going to go and help impoverished countries. the truth of the matter is the money is going to line the pockets of warlords in impoverished countries for them to arm their armies to commit genocides in their borders. 400 million buys a lot of cheap machetes to hack up people in sudan. if anything global warming wealth redistribution is funding the murder of a lot of dark skined people. but that's not racist, because it's highly enlightened and educated progressives that are suckers enough to believe science fiction writings instead of walking outside and saying "damn it's a bit chilly you know"and they don't have the moral or intellectual integrity to admit they are wrong. but they are oh so educated, ask them, they'll tell you themselves. meanwhile they want everyones wealth to be pooled into goverment(to assuage their guilt of success and existence) and supposedly scattered around to the needy. you'd think after all these years of big governments doing that, there would be some dramatic astounding success stories about how government helped people, hhhhhhmmmmm i'm trying to remember some. detroit, nope, chicago, east la, south atlanta, new orleans, nah nothing. progressives will tell you those are americas failures because of capitalism getting in the way. more fraud.

lunaticcringeradio

lunatic

I agree with you on another item. This black president wants to be a global leader. He gave 100million to Indonesia.Why?  Why is he not worried about the thousands of blacks starving and being butchered in Somalia,Sudan, and Ruwanda? He is soooo interested in global warming, ending the war in Afganistan, being appeaser and enabler to Iran, and is applauded by the fringe media. And right, they cant see the plight of blacks in this country is because of these so called progressives who are nothing but elitist snobs.

I was a social worker for 30 yrs and saw first hand the damage done to blacks in this country with this "entitlement" mentality, affirmative action , and lowered expectations in education. Liberals think they are mandated to help those in need due to "social justice" as their mantra. But I saw the harm done and it will take a strong black voice to change it and it will take generations.

If anyone else speaks of a change from "victim" to "empowered", they will be called racist. Some are trying, like Star Parker and Thomas Sowell. But what we need is not This Guy. He doesnt see himself helping blacks but rather stepping on their backs to climb to the peak of his world agenda. And I dont care what people call me, this man is not an African-American and he sure isn't American. 

Victicrates (thx ZoNation!)

For those who wish to see the kindness of the Liberals & Progressives, go visit http://blackgenocide.org

There is a silent "in" in the mantra of the Slavery Party (dems... I do wish the BlueDogs would leave that party, because I feel somewhat bad in not being able to separate them in my statements; somewhat, but not totally so...) anyway, the placement of the silent "in" is placed like this: "social INjustice".

The elitist Liberals and Progressives are the most racist creatures to slither the earth - ever! They educate their current an future voter base, teaching dependence upon the trough and amplify the effect by using fear of loss, if Conservatives come into power...

Big Siphon

How big is the siphon that is going to divert funds into the pockets of UN functionaries and their families and friends? Remember the Oil-for-Food scandal? I'm still waiting to see someone go to jail for that!!

A Find Cast of Characters

A couple of other significant names from climategate that also went into "creating the science" in this report.

Jonathan Overpeck- -His name appears on a mere 232 of the leaked e-mails and has been lead author of several IPCC reports. He is the person that said "We have to find a way to get rid of the Medieval Warm Period" back in the 1990's, just before Michael Mann miraculously got rid of the MWP to create his bogus hockey stick. For the record, in these leaked e-mails he says that he has no recollection saying this or that he might have been quoted out of context.

Tom Karl- Karl is the co-chair of this USGCRP document and was invovlved in 65 e-mails (I believe always as a recipient). Karl is a long time alarmist and pig at the trough courtesy of hard working Americans. He is the director of NOAA (the agency that puts thermometers beside air conditioner vents and BBQ's and claims this does not matter) and has been lead author of several IPCC reports. How unscrupulous is Karl? He presented himself for years as a Doctor despite the fact that his highest academic achievement is a Masters in Meteorology. At one time his own web site at NOAA listed him as Dr. Tom Karl, Phd. He was given an honorary doctorate in 2002 (not even in science). Karl has changed his title since he was called out on the indiscretion. Roger Pielke Sr. has documented numerous times how Karl out and out lies and excludes peer reviewed scientists that do not agree with his views. Pielke's latest documentation was just yesterday.

One name that is mentioned above but people are probably not familiar with is Ben Santer. He so classy that in one of the e-mails he threatened to "beat the crap" out of Patrick Michaels who is a Senior Fellow at the CEI and Cato Institute. Santer was aslo caught making unauthorized changes to IPCC SAR in 1995.

Climategate Foretold...

“• What is the current scientific consensus on the conclusions reached by Drs. Mann, Bradley and Hughes? [Referring to the hockey stick propagated in UN IPCC 2001 by Michael Mann.]Ans: Based on the literature we have reviewed, there is no overarching consensus on MBH98/99.   As analyzed in our social network, there is a tightly knit group of individuals who passionately believe in their thesis. However, our perception is that this group has a self-reinforcing feedback mechanism and, moreover, the work has been sufficiently politicized that they can hardly reassess their public positions without losing credibility.”  AD HOC COMMITTEE REPORT ON THE ‘HOCKEY  STICK’ GLOBAL CLIMATE RECONSTRUCTION, also known as The Wegman report was authored by Edward J. Wegman, George Mason University, David W. Scott, Rice University, and Yasmin H. Said, The Johns Hopkins University with the contributions of John T. Rigsby, III, Naval Surface Warfare Center, and Denise M. Reeves, MITRE Corporation.

"Our Changing Planet"... 

"Our Changing Planet"...  Is that kind of like "Your Changing Body"?

If Edison were to invent the light bulb today, the head- lines would read, '200,000 candle makers lose their jobs.'

It's a shame...

that the filename wasn't HARRY_REID_ME instead.

hoax to fraud to.....

yes, the AGW hoax, preached on by the likes of Al Gore, is a fraud, but perhaps now, due to the fact that the US federal government has accepted this fraud as gospel, without opportunity for debate or opposition, before made into multiple laws, restrictions and taxes, can now be shown as COMPLICIT-- unindicted co-conspirators!

dirty dozen

Some sceintists have their name left out.  So sad.  The dirty dozen will have a surge in publications.  Of course the dirty dozen peer reviews and endorses esach of the other members.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.