WOR radio's Steve Malzberg likely had no idea the hornets nest he was walking into Monday when he decided to discuss race relations with Fox News's Geraldo Rivera.
Regardless of the tension on display or the uncomfortable conclusion, what transpired perfectly demonstrated how far we as a nation are from ending racism.
At first, Rivera seemed rather reasonable when he called CNN's Rick Sanchez a jerk for his comment a few months ago that Hispanics working for Fox News are all sellouts.
But when the discussion turned to the confirmation of Justice Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court, and whether her comments concerning a wise Latina woman making better decisions than a white man could be perceived as racist and sexist, Rivera got quite defensive and eventually hung up on his host (15-minute audio available here, rough transcript below the fold):
GERALDO RIVERA (After Malzberg asked him about what CNN's Rick Sanchez had said about Hispanics on Fox News all being sellouts): I think he’s a jerk. And, you know, there aren’t enough, there aren’t, you know, that many Hispanics at Fox News Channel for him not to have included me in his blast. I, you know, I didn’t respond at the time because Rick Sanchez is such a loser and, you know, nobody watches his show. And so, it’s a typical ploy of the under-viewed to, you know, make a spectacle…It’s certainly a lazy, sloppy, self-promoting, you know, transparent attempt to attract attention on the back of someone else.Good answer. But things became far less cordial when Malzberg brought up Sotomayor:
STEVE MALZBERG: To me, Sonia Sotomayor is a blatant sexist and racist. And just because she’s Hispanic…
RIVERA: I think that’s outrageous that you say that. I mean, you base that on her speech at a college in the year 2000? Have you read her decisions? I mean, that is, this is the most eminently qualified, new jurist on the high court ever…She grew up in the same building as my Aunt Anna and my Uncle (?).
Wow. She grew up in the same building as his aunt and uncle, and that means she's not a racist and/or sexist?
Moments later, when Malzberg pointed out that Sotomayor gave practically the same speech numerous times over several years, Rivera got agitated:
It is exactly that attitude that is the reason the Republican Party will never again have the presidency.
Republicans will NEVER win the White House again? Ever? Wow! Why, Geraldo?
Because here is the most, here is the best among us, someone who has overcome enormous obstacles. A single-parent home, her Dad died when she was eight-years old, she’s in the East Bronx, her mother’s working two jobs, her mother a veteran of the Army, an Army nurse working two jobs. Puts her brother through school, her brother becomes a doctor, she becomes this eminently qualified lawyer whose decisions are flawless.
Hmmm. So that not only means she's not racist and/or sexist, but also makes her qualified to be on the Supreme Court?
When Malzberg questioned this reasoning, Rivera predictably went after Justice Clarence Thomas:
Who do you like on the Supreme Court? Do you like Clarence Thomas? Is he your guy?...Have you ever heard Clarence Thomas utter one word on that high court?...I mean, what was his record like? What was his? Have you examined his record?
Malzberg tried to bring it back to Sotomayor saying, “I said to you she was a racist and a sexist.” Rivera wasn't having any of it:
I think that’s absolutely slanderous, Steve. It’s lazy, it’s anti-intellectual. She hasn’t done a racist thing in her life.
Malzberg followed with a great question: “Have you ever said that you are better than a white male because of your ethnicity and sex or better than a white female? Have you ever said that Geraldo?” That seemed to really fluster Rivera:
I don’t, in terms of the statements you make before college kids, I’ve done a hundred college speeches, and I’m sure if you parsed every…she hasn’t said it over and over again. You’re distorting her record, and you are, you’re being anti-intellectual, and you certainly have never read her decisions…What is open to debate is your characterization of her as a racist. You sound like Glenn Beck calling the President a racist. I mean, you don’t throw those words around, they mean something.
From there, the discussion devolved further, with Rivera eventually hanging up in disgust, leaving Malzberg to finish the segment by himself:
Into the great abyss, Geraldo hangs up. Very nice. I guess when you can’t argue the point, and all you can do is say, “You’re lazy, that’s intellectually lazy,” or whatever. Imagine, I called Sonia Sotomayor a racist for saying that she’s better than a white man because she’s Latina, and she’s a woman, and I just asked Geraldo if that was racist, and he hung up. Very disappointed in Geraldo. I thought he could handle himself better than that.
Actually, I'm not surprised, for the segment demonstrated perfectly what was at the heart of the Sotomayor confirmation process, and the dirty secret about racism: it is indeed very difficult for people -- even journalists -- to separate their own background and experience from their views on the world thereby making it tough for most to be completely impartial.
Rivera during this interview couldn't separate himself from his upbringing to honestly answer the questions being thrown at him, and most people can't.
But folks that are sitting on a court -- especially the highest court in the land -- have to be able to do that, or they're not qualified for the position.
As an attorney himself, Rivera should know this, but clearly his own background and experience are clouding his judgement.
In the end, we will never conquer racism in this nation until we eliminate all ethnic classifications, and just consider ourselves Americans.
On a personal note, Steve Malzberg's father passed away Monday night. Please say a prayer for him, his family, and his friends.
—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Why doesn't Geraldo just go over to CNN or MSNBC?
September 15, 2009 - 10:53 ET by MightyMouthPlease!!!
"The bureaucracy is growing to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy"
Geraldo was there
September 15, 2009 - 11:05 ET by allanf.. he just did not fit in.
Geraldo is not a doctrinaire liberal. He is conservative when it comes to law and order issues -- although he is wrong about Gitmo.
He also had the guts to go to Afghanistan and cover it for Fox and then cover the Iraqi invasion for Fox. That's something beyond the capabilities of most liberal reporters. CNN had two foreign anti-American leftists, Nick Robrtson and Ben Wedemeyer coving Afghanistan.
I'd rather listen to Geraldo, who is at least sincere than a liberal like Ellis Hennigan.
didn't jerry rivers
September 15, 2009 - 11:55 ET by larry on LIget his rump uninbeded ,in second iraq invasion,for drawing the coming attact plans in the sand. it's jmo, but this loose cannon hasn't 'earned his pay' since his willowbrook expose.
Yes He Did
September 15, 2009 - 12:17 ET by allanfI believe he was escorted out of Iraq!!!!!
MightyMouth, I second the motion!
September 15, 2009 - 11:03 ET by goldenthroatWhat a freakin' jackass! Geraldo has worn out his welcome at FNC and has proven himself as one of the most inept "journalist" in cable news. When he makes comments like:
"It is exactly that attitude that is the reason the Republican Party will never again have the presidency..."
...it just solidifies and confirms his stupidity!
Check your messages, GR - CNN and MSNBC may have left you one - you can't hold a candle to other commentators at FNC. Guys like Bill O'Reilly have morons like you for lunch everyday! Please - leave FNC - and don't let the door hit you on your sorry butt on the way out.
"Inferior people should not be employed." - Firesign Theatre
growing list
September 15, 2009 - 11:16 ET by jon_torlinJerry Rivers is among a growing list of people on FNC that I am choosing not to watch anymore. Shep Smith's another one, prefer watching his substitutes when he's not there, BOR, can't stand more than a minute or two of him so I watch his subs as well, Williams on Chris Wallace's show who's getting too wishy washy for my taste(along with a couple of others).
Only time I do watch Rivera on purpose is during a storm, tropical or hurricane where he goes out there, seemingly to put himself in harm's way for one reason or another, usually the results are a bit silly. Him getting swept off his feet when a wave came in while the fire fighters were still on theirs was funny as hell.
-Jon
Gerald is a
September 15, 2009 - 11:42 ET by kgGerald is a racist.
"DumbAssity of Dope"
Geraldo
September 15, 2009 - 20:39 ET by Sergeant ROCKYes.. yes he is.
"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason
I'm with you on this
September 15, 2009 - 22:00 ET by Tugboat PhilI can't take Gerry or Shep any more. Even if one is on another show, I just mute while they're talking.
And just for the record I don't think he's a racist. D-bag yes, racist no.
Gun Control - The theory that a woman found dead in an alley, raped and strangled with her own pantyhose, is somehow morally superior to a woman explaining to police how her attacker got that fatal bullet wound.
Jerry Rivers?
September 15, 2009 - 10:56 ET by Willis_Leon_JohnsonJesse Jackson, Al Shaprton, geraldo rivera, no difference.
Just another race baiting whore that gets ratings from the poorly educated masses held prisoner by pubic education/INDOCTRINATION and forced poverty.
http://gjresult.com
Typical...
September 15, 2009 - 10:56 ET by Fuzzlenutterarrogance, ingnorance, and just plain buffoonery from "The Spitter"...
It's one of those things
September 15, 2009 - 10:59 ET by 10ksnookerThat Americans are picking up on, they get called a racist a bigot all the time and then the Senate votes to confirm a certified racial bigot for the Supreme Court.
Al Capone's Vault, the Remix
September 15, 2009 - 11:05 ET by SickofLibs"And so, it’s a typical ploy of the under-viewed to, you know, make a spectacle…It’s certainly a lazy, sloppy, self-promoting, you know, transparent attempt to attract attention on the back of someone else."
Hey, that's Rivera's career in a nutshell!
SickofLibs, How can we forget...
September 15, 2009 - 11:18 ET by goldenthroatWhen Gerry River was on the news/talk show holding one of the orginal ticket stubs from Woodstock - then - he ends up pulling it apart, instantly sending its value right into the dumper!
No matter where he goes or what he touches, he is a disaster waiting to happen!
"Inferior people should not be employed." - Firesign Theatre
golden: yeah, that was a classic
September 15, 2009 - 11:24 ET by SickofLibsAnother 'greatest hit' when he was embedded in Iraq and scratched into the sand, on camera, the current US positions.
He was lucky to have avoided a 'friendly fire' incident.
no matter how educated one gets-
September 15, 2009 - 11:08 ET by JIMMY1660if you are not of color-any critical statement of someone of color-you are a racist. its funny, no matter how successful someone of color can get, a stumble and its the racist rest of the world who did it to me. Rivera is one of those.
i as a white man in America-when i stumble-i stumbled. fall down and get back up, dust off, back in the saddle. who do i get to blame. Me!!
the word racist is getting old and tired. this is not 1864.
how did Thurgood Marshall make it to the high court?
Highly educated men and women say things they later have to retract, why?if you said it, i know what you meant, today and a year from now. i said when i said it, i will not retract it.
BHO- THE PROGRESSIVE PIRATE
Rivera is just ego
September 15, 2009 - 11:16 ET by richb313Rivera is just an ego wearing a suit. He always thinks that everyone is also out to get him. Paranoid and a large ego this has got to be clinical. Any time anyone gets over defensive it is an indication that there is more there than meets the eye. Thou doth protest too much come to mind every time I hear these rants.
Rivera...
September 15, 2009 - 11:27 ET by Georgia GirlHe appears to approach the news in much the same way he did his talk show -- with over-the-top sensationalism. He truly reminds me of a used cars salesman (no offense to car sales folks because I know that's a stereoptype). But he's got that fast-talking, pushy type of hype.
One of the things that bugs me the most about him is that he interrupts people all the time & tries to put words in the mouths of his guests -- and it seems pretty transparent that it's an effort to further the sensationalistic spin. Sometimes he is okay. But sometimes he really makes me cringe...it can be embarrassing to the concept of journalism. Most of the time, I think somebody needs to tell him: "Tone it down!" ^_^
Racial conversation
September 15, 2009 - 11:34 ET by KC MulvilleFirst, condolences and prayers to Malzberg.
I'm going to pick a fight here, Noel. I strongly disagree with your statement: "In the end, we will never concur [conquer] racism in this nation until we eliminate all ethnic classifications, and just consider ourselves Americans."
I don't want to have to surrender The Chieftains for Eminem, OK? Why should I exchange James Joyce for Danielle Steele, just because idiots like Geraldo are offended so easily? I'm an American just fine, thank you very much, and I don't need to abandon my ethnic heritage to avoid hurting the feelings of the over-sensitive.
What has made America great
September 15, 2009 - 11:59 ET by Hunter12What has made America great in the past is our united identity as Americans and the melting pot that created that identity. KC, I'm going to go out on a limb and make a guess that you and yours don't speak Gaelic at home and family functions. All the stories I grew up with were about immigrants coming here, making the struggle to learn the language, establish their niche, and live the American dream. When we hear stories of honor killings due to the embrace of Sharia law, see transplanted enclaves of Mexican culture inside our major cities (and not so major anymore), have multi-language ballots for local election, and so forth, I think we are starting to see people who want the advantages our Irish, German, African, Polish, and other ethnic grandparents fought and died to establish with none of the work. I don't think we can survive as a nation made up of migrated citizens of foreign lands, retaining all the original culture, ways, and language. I do agree with you and love the benefits of our diverse national heritage, but I agree with Noel that some of the roots of today's problems stem from an unwillingness to think of ourselves as one nation. When you travel outside the country or talk to visiting foreigners, do you identify youself as Irish, or do you say, "I'm an American, but my ancestors came from Ireland."?
"An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last." - Sir Winston Churchill
Let's wrestle on this one:
September 15, 2009 - 13:15 ET by KC Mulville"I agree with Noel that some of the roots of today's problems stem from an unwillingness to think of ourselves as one nation."
Yes, I specifically deny that. To me, that's at the heart of the American experiment. We were never intended to be a new ethnic group. In our system, individuals pursue their own interests, and government is only the referee. The result is a free society. We're more like an open market, and less like a corporation.
We are unified, but it's a chosen unity, not a natural one. It comes from what we choose. France is France because it's full of Frenchmen, and their Frenchness comes because they share the same blood and culture. They're French because they were born French. Not so with Americans. You don't have to be born American to be American.
September 15, 2009 - 11:44 ET by jessieHEven the best news orgs. have their dumbasses. Geraldo proves that. He is biased. Corruption is everywhere, even in the supreme court.
Geraldo has a history of
September 15, 2009 - 12:01 ET by Chris NormanGeraldo has a history of this - remember his treatment of Michelle Malkin? I think he's mentally unstable.
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
what kind of ratings does Jerry Rivers get?
September 15, 2009 - 14:01 ET by carolina09because I can't bear to see him or listen to him and always switch channels if he appears.
Geraldo and racism
September 15, 2009 - 15:34 ET by djm159Geraldo is an issues pimp. Racism didn't bother him that much when he was the Jerry Springer of the race debate having a low-life group like the Klan on evey other day because it brought him ratings an cash, it did nothing for race relations except accentuate a group that is impotent and feed off it for cash. When he was embedded with the troops covering his butt he was 100% war - as soon as the camera was on and he was back in NYC he was the left-wing radical anti-war pimp we all know him to be. Geraldo will be on whatever side of an issue brings him the most cash at the moment. Like Geraldo's buddy Al Sharpton and Tawana Brawley. Geraldo was fine defending the lying Sharpton about what happened, or didn't happen to the lying, money grubbing racist who blamed the police for all sorts of dastardly deeds. How much time did Brawley do in jail for her lies and Sharptons defense of her? None. Geraldo was on the stripper's side in the Duke "rape" case, that too was a lie and no one apologized including Geraldo.
Geraldo
September 15, 2009 - 15:42 ET by grumpyoldbThe problem is twofold. 1. Geraldo is an idiot. 2. Sotamayor IS a racist.
Geraldo: "... she
September 15, 2009 - 15:58 ET by stratmanThat's a whopper!
Has Jerry examined Sotomayer's record? Obviously not. What a blowhard.
Maybe Mr. Rivers can regale us with Sotomayer's flawless judgements as judged by SCOTUS.
I'm sensing Geri is a bit ethnically motivated here.
For The Race Everything, right? (La RAZA)
Al Capone's Vault
September 15, 2009 - 19:36 ET by Radar_OneI still remember being quite young and staying up for about 3 hours watching the "Al Capone" vault special....I was about 5 or so...and I was hoping there'd be guns or gold or something REALLY COOL...
3 hours later I was introduced to "Gerry Rivers" and a couple empty Gin bottles...
Barack Obama= Half Honkey...ALL Donkey
Radar~
September 15, 2009 - 20:39 ET by Georgia GirlCracks me up ... I remember bits and pieces of that. What year was that?
Hurricane Season and other fantasies
September 18, 2009 - 02:10 ET by GloriaJean...... isn't it the time of year Geraldo is usually hanging onto a palm tree in the eye of a hurricane..?... Last year during Ike I was cheering for the palm tree to sacrifice it's life, uproot itself and take this wanker out to sea...... It's true. He hung onto that damned tree and acted like a drama queen all night long...... *snooze*
BIG Fox fan here, but if Geraldo magically disappeared I wouldn't be at all sorry. Does THAT make me a racist? Or just somebody that can't handle a wanker?
good morning Gloria
September 18, 2009 - 02:31 ET by cocodrieWe are taking up a collection to buy Geraldo a pirogue to paddle out to the middle of the next hurricane so he can report in a vivid and intellectual manner on how calm the eye is.
Jesus Loves You so much He died for you
Coco~LOL
September 18, 2009 - 08:13 ET by Georgia GirlHow very generous! ;)