Camille Paglia Defends Rush's 'Barack the Magic Negro' Parody

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

When I first heard "Barack the Magic Negro" shortly after the March 2007 publication of the Ehrenstein article (which was partly inspired by a term used by director Spike Lee), I found it very daring and funny.

So wrote Camille Paglia in her weekly must-read column at Salon Wednesday.

Also on her plate was why talk radio is dominated by conservatives, and how "something very ugly has surfaced in contemporary American liberalism...[T]here are some real fruitcakes out there, and some of them are writing for major magazines."

Wow. Better strap yourself in tightly, for here are the truly delicious highlights (h/t Hot Air via Thomas Stewart):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

When I first heard "Barack the Magic Negro" shortly after the March 2007 publication of the Ehrenstein article (which was partly inspired by a term used by director Spike Lee), I found it very daring and funny. It was timely and had the shock of the new -- exactly like Lenny Bruce's violation of conventional proprieties. But Rush kept playing it and playing it well beyond its shelf date, and after a while it felt gratuitous and dismayingly oblivious to racial realities and sensitivities in the U.S. Although I'm a longtime fan of Rush's show, I started turning the radio off when this skit came on.

So, it was funny, but overplayed in Paglia's view. Fair enough. Yet, she clearly favors conservative talk radio over the left-leaning alternative:

The most rewarding aspect of talk radio for me is the callers, whose voices are heard nowhere else in the culture -- the feisty, super-organized home-schooling moms, the gruffly stoical transcontinental truckers, and the fiercely independent and self-reliant small-business owners, outraged by Washington's tilt toward bailing out corrupt, top-heavy corporations.

However, the popularity of conservative radio shows is a round-the-clock phenomenon. There are flamboyant evening hosts as well as night replays of the major daytime shows, extending well past midnight to dawn. Clearly, conservative hosts have an instinctive rapport with AM radio, which I have been arguing for years is a populist medium (an idea that finally seems to have taken wing in its invocation by other commentators).

Salon reader Cecil W. Powell writes: "The failure of talkers on liberal radio is in large part due to an absolute inability to poke fun at themselves." How true! Liberal hosts like to snap and snip and chortle snidely, but they are weighed down by a complacent superiority complex, a paralyzing sanctimony. They mistake irony for wit. The conservative hosts love to rant and stomp and bring down the house. They're doing breakneck vaudeville while liberal hosts are primly stirring their non-caffeine green tea.

As for the state of liberalism?

Yes, something very ugly has surfaced in contemporary American liberalism, as evidenced by the irrational and sometimes infantile abuse directed toward anyone who strays from a strict party line. Liberalism, like second-wave feminism, seems to have become a new religion for those who profess contempt for religion. It has been reduced to an elitist set of rhetorical formulas, which posit the working class as passive, mindless victims in desperate need of salvation by the state. Individual rights and free expression, which used to be liberal values, are being gradually subsumed to worship of government power.

The problems on the American left were already manifest by the late 1960s, as college-educated liberals began to lose contact with the working class for whom they claimed to speak. (A superb 1990 documentary, "Berkeley in the Sixties," chronicles the arguments and misjudgments about tactics that alienated the national electorate and led to the election of Richard Nixon.) For the past 25 years, liberalism has gradually sunk into a soft, soggy, white upper-middle-class style that I often find preposterous and repellent. The nut cases on the right are on the uneducated fringe, but on the left they sport Ivy League degrees. I'm not kidding -- there are some real fruitcakes out there, and some of them are writing for major magazines. It's a comfortable, urban, messianic liberalism befogged by psychiatric pharmaceuticals. Conservatives these days are more geared to facts than emotions, and as individuals they seem to have a more ethical, perhaps sports-based sense of fair play. 

Finally, Paglia noticed something that has been a major sticking point with conservatives since last week's G-20 summit:

Obama's staffing problems are blatant -- from that bleating boy of a treasury secretary to what appears to be a total vacuum where a chief of protocol should be. There has been one needless gaffe after another -- from the president's tacky appearance on a late-night comedy show to the kitsch gifts given to the British prime minister, followed by the sweater-clad first lady's over-familiarity with the queen and culminating in the jaw-dropping spectacle of a president of the United States bowing to the king of Saudi Arabia. Why was protest about the latter indignity confined to conservatives? The silence of the major media was a disgrace.

Good question, Camille, especially given the attention former President George W. Bush got for holding the same King's hand almost exactly two years prior.

Go figure.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Camille Paglia hits it exactly right

Great read. Camille Paglia hits it exactly right frequently. Do you think any on the left ever listen to her? Or they consider her to be one of those off of the reservation?
TSF Protests!

I want to know....what is the point?

I was listening to Rush one day talk about how his parodies and comments are for a reason. They aren't to be funny or offensive. They have a point. Well, I'd like to know what the point of "Barack the Magic Negro" is? Is it okay to call him a 'negro' because the guy who wrote it is black? Or 'Banking Queen', making 'fun' of Barney Frank? What does 'queen' reference?

What 'point' is there, Rush? Really. I want to know. Because, to me and to alot of people, it's offensive. And is Rush an equal opportunity offender? Does he play songs that parody the other side? What about 'tap, tap, tap' Larry Craig? Was there a funny song about him?

Good evening Jen

The main point is the hypocrisy of the left.

Nothing is said when Present Hussein Obama is called "The magic negre" by one of his own race but all hell breaks loose when Rush uses it in a parody.

Nothing is said of Bawney Fwank"s homosexual prostitution ring based in his own apartment and Larry Craig gets arrested for tapping his foot in a restroom.

If you want to hear a song about Larry Craig go to a liberal site. In case you didn't know Rush is a conservative. If Rush offends you maybe you should listen to Ed Schultz.

Jesus Loves You so much He died for you

"Nothing is said of Bawney

"Nothing is said of Bawney Fwank"s homosexual prostitution ring based in his own apartment and Larry Craig gets arrested for tapping his foot in a restroom."

I was only 12, so I didn't hear much about Barney Frank's problems. But, he was reprimanded by the House. He wasn't charged and claimed it was  a dude he had a relationship with that ran it in his house. So, to say, 'nothing is said' is inaccurate. Plus, it was almost 20 years ago. What would be hypocritical is if Barney was against homosexuality and voted for measures to stop gay marriage, ended up in some homosexual scandal. So, I still don't know the point Rush was trying to make by the 'queen' reference.

"Nothing is said when Present Hussein Obama is called "The magic negre" by one of his own race but all hell breaks loose when Rush uses it in a parody."

You're right about that. I find it equally offensive.

 

  

I get it Jen

Bawney Fwank gets a pass because he's a liberal. Larry Craig is gyilty without a rrial because he is a republican.

More hypocrisy.

Jesus Loves You so much He died for you

You're a liberal so you have no sense of humor.

Liberals are so serious because they think they are so smart. But that's not the case. They're just glib.

Lighten up. Obama's taking us all to the same place so try to find some humor in it.

Yeah, libs have no sense of

Yeah, libs have no sense of humor...as opposed to righties who never get outraged about Family Guy, South Park, The Daily Show, The Colbert Report...

bal: Or your idiotic

bal:

Or your idiotic postings...

<sarc>

Oh, I forgot!  You're NOT a troll!  You're SO much loved here!

</sarc>

Grow a thicker skin

Good grief.

-Dave

This coup has gone on long enough. The time to put it down is NOW.

Jen7 is a new American

Jen,

Your question "Is it okay to call him a 'negro' because the guy who wrote it is black?"  says everything we need to know about you.

You are not happy about what the second guy did, not the first guy.  You should have asked: "Is it okay for the first black guy to call him a 'negro'?"

Or, are you saying it is okay for black guys to call each other 'negro' but not white guys to repeat that same term?

Which is it?

Barney Frank is Chairman of

Barney Frank is Chairman of the House Banking Committee.  He is one of those most instrumental in causing the recent Subprime mortgage crisis and consequent financial collapse.   Barnet Frank is also and in-your-face homosexual, hence, Rush calls him the "Banking Queen".

In earlier times, Frank was censured by the House for abuse of power.  Specifically, Frank's boyfriend and employee, Steven Gobie, was operating a male prostitution ring out of Frank's DC townhouse.  An assortment of this establishment's patrons received parking tickets while illegally parked in front of Frank's townhouse.  Barney Frank misused the authority of his office to have these tickets fixed at the request of Mr. Gobie.  When this activity was exposed, Frank denied any knowledge of Gobie's wrongdoing and fired him.   My take:  If he knew nothing of this why was he fixing the tickets?

--->  Barney Frank is a lying, cheating lowlife.

JEN 7 -- SORRY YOU'RE OFFENDED BY RUSH. BOO FREAKIN HOO.

 

Were you equally offended by the media calling Sarah Palin 'Caribou Barbie'?  How about calling GWBush 'Hitler'? VPCheney 'Darth Vader'? Condie Rice 'Aunt Jemima'? 

You ask if Rush is an equal opportunity offender. Spoken like a true liberal. Why does he have to be? Uh, it's called free speech. (:-p)

 

"Were you equally offended

"Were you equally offended by the media calling Sarah Palin 'Caribou Barbie'?  How about calling GWBush 'Hitler'? VPCheney 'Darth Vader'? Condie Rice 'Aunt Jemima'?"

Yes. All except for Darth Vader.

"You ask if Rush is an equal opportunity offender. Spoken like a true liberal. Why does he have to be? Uh, it's called free speech. (:-p)"

Of course he doesn't have to be. That's what makes him a hack. ;) There are consequences to free speech, though.

Consequences?

There are consequences to free speech, though.

Yeah. 20 million listeners.

→ Jen7

Well, I'd like to know what the point of "Barack the Magic Negro" is? - Jen7

I can only submit you seem not to have read the original column that inspired the song.

In reading it, you might come to an understanding, but you really wouldn't  "like to know what the point of "Barack the Magic Negro" is", would you?

Your question is rhetorical, not an attempt to gain any insight.


LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Cool Arrow

After reading all about it, I'd still like to know the point of it? David Erhnstein was talking about the term 'magic negro' in films and how that perception was attached to Obama. I don't agree with it, but I understood his point. What was the point of the parody? To make fun of Al Sharpton?

 

 

As you may presently yourself be fully made aware of, my grammar sucks.
Family Guy

Parody

Parody is a verb as well as a noun.

→ Yes, Jen7

The song is about the sour grapes Sharpton and Jackson must be feeling during the time that Joe Biden was noticing Obama was "clean and articulate"

Sharpton made note of the slight to Biden with "I did take a bath, Joe"

That's exactly what the song is about.  It is a parody of Al Sharpton and the notion that the brass ring passed him by because Democrats thought both Sharpton and Jackson were too black.

But, as the liberal columnist intimates, here comes Barack Obama!  Finally, the "Magic Negro"


LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

"That's exactly what the

"That's exactly what the song is about.  It is a parody of Al Sharpton and the notion that the brass ring passed him by because Democrats thought both Sharpton and Jackson were too black."

Democrats thought they were 'too black'? I don't understand? Where does that come from? 

 

 

As you may presently yourself be fully made aware of, my grammar sucks.
Family Guy

That was exactly the point.

That was exactly the point. He was "clean and articulate." Conservatives did not say that, liberals did. Some liberal said the race struggle could press on because Barack didn't have any "slave blood." Liberals throw Oreos at Michael Steele. Liberals made fun of Condoleeza Rice being Aunt Jemima, and I have heard several references to Black conservatives as being "house slaves." You see, liberals seem to think that Blacks can only be Democrats, and if they aren't, they're "selling out their race."

  MSM - shaping all the perceptions you need to believe, then confirming it with a poll.

→ pbanks

I kinda' get the feeling Jen7 already knows this stuff.


LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Pbanks7

"That was exactly the point. He was "clean and articulate." Conservatives did not say that, liberals did."

Joe Biden said it. One. Not plural.

"Some liberal said the race struggle could press on because Barack didn't have any "slave blood.""

On TV? Was it a Senator? Or a pundit? A blogger? Who?

"Liberals throw Oreos at Michael Steele."

Got proof of that? From what I have researched, they are unfounded claims.  

"Liberals made fun of Condoleeza Rice being Aunt Jemima, and I have heard several references to Black conservatives as being "house slaves.""

Again, was it a Senator? A pundit on TV? A blogger?

"You see, liberals seem to think that Blacks can only be Democrats, and if they aren't, they're "selling out their race.""

Which liberals? 

 

As you may presently yourself be fully made aware of, my grammar sucks.
Family Guy

Soooooo.... Ruch Limbaugh is

Soooooo.... Ruch Limbaugh is a Senator? Please be clear.

BD

No, but he's in the same category as a pundit...he's a mouth-piece for the republican party.

 

As you may presently yourself be fully made aware of, my grammar sucks.
Family Guy

I dispute that.  He

I dispute that.  He actually has castigated Republicans when they have not been conservative ENOUGH.  THerefore he has not been the classic "mouthpiece".  In fact he has NOT been such.

"I dispute that.  He

"I dispute that.  He actually has castigated Republicans when they have not been conservative ENOUGH.  THerefore he has not been the classic "mouthpiece".  In fact he has NOT been such."

 

Oooooh, what an insult. Please, BD. He may 'say' that, but he barely criticizes them for what they have done that last 8 years. And when you have Senators and the RNC apologizing to him for attacking him...he is a mouth-piece for them.

 

As you may presently yourself be fully made aware of, my grammar sucks.
Family Guy

→ Jen7

Oooooh, what an insult. 

Aren't you noting an insult that wasn't offered?

How is a disagreement necessarily an insult?


LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

What insult? Regarding

What insult?

Regarding his castigation of the wayward Republicans, the nature of his criticism was targeted to the persons who most offended.  For instance, the three RINO Senators drew particular ire, in my opinion rightly.

Therefore, is Rush a mouthpiece for me?

You really do not

You really do not understand the nature of the joke involving Sharpton?

Background:

Al Sharpton is a race hustler who has made his living since the 1960's by using the megaphone to agitate a small section of a community into regular bouts of outrage based purely on race.  He has also attempted to parley this outrage into a grater political future using the same tactics.

Along comes the notional "Magic Negro" which in an instant eliminates his political future as well as put the lie to his lifetime of agitation.  THe song is sung from his perspective through the megaphone he uses for his agitation.

Personnally, I think it is a scream.

And, although she received

And, although she received several answers to her question - POOF! - Jen7 is gone...

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

Jen

Obviously, the "queen" reference is to frank being queer. 

But, perhaps if you read the lyrics in their entirety, you will get the point being made: 

Banking Queen

Oooooooo

Oooooooooo

 

You can
build.

You can
buy.

Any house your heart
desires.

Oo zero
down.

 Financing.

 I am
the banking queen.

 

Friday night and your
cash is low.

I know a place that
you can go.

Oh, get your house
and use it.

 Go
ahead abuse it.

 You can
do anything.

 

Go out and have a
fling.

 I am
the banking queen.

Old and sweet didn’t
do a thing.

 Banking
queen.

 Don’t
complain or you’ll hear me scream oh yeah.

 

You can
build.

You can
buy.

Any house your heart
desires.

Oo zero
down.

Financing.

 I am
the banking queen.

 

Told the bankers hey
you guys.

Make the loans or
it’s your behind.

My friends at Fannie
sure need it.

Do it my way or beat
it

Why are the stocks
crashing?

 

That doesn’t mean a
thing.

I’m still the banking
queen.

Never spanked for a
single thing. 

Banking
queen.

Don’t complain or
you’ll hear me scream oh yeah.

 

You can
build.

You can
buy.

Any house your heart
desires.

Oo, zero
down

 Financing

I am the banking
queen.

 Oooooooo

 I am
the banking queen.

Oooooooo

 

"This
liberal would be all about socialize -- uh, uh, would be about
basically taking over and the government running all of your companies."-Maxine Waters 2008

"Obviously, the "queen"

"Obviously, the "queen" reference is to frank being queer."

He's making fun of him for being 'queer', right?   Or rather, a 'banking queer'?

 

 

As you may presently yourself be fully made aware of, my grammar sucks.
Family Guy

Actually, the years he

Actually, the years he spent as an activist in that community innoculates Rush from criticism that he is unduly using that status against him.

Liberal rules being used against the liberals.  SOOO KOOL.

Re Sharpton

In her full article she also acknowledges that the song is a parody of Al Sharpton's bullhorn career as well, something largely lost on the old media. As for overplaying the song, Rush tends to play it when Al Sharpton is in the news as a lead-in to that segment, so its use is appropriate.

On the question of why conservative talk radio is successful and liberal is not, she misses the obvious point, that the target audience for liberal commercial talk radio is busy watching liberal NPR talk radio.

that the target audience

that the target audience for liberal commercial talk radio is busy watching liberal NPR talk radio

I think that those people will be watching teh radio also. 

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

She missed one point.

One of the reasons Rush played it so often was because it was making news. Then since it was in the news, Rush gave us a "Magic Negro Update."

Liberals were complaining that Rush was being racist toward Obama. They didn't get that it was a skewering of Sharpton in particular, and liberals in general.

  MSM - shaping all the perceptions you need to believe, then confirming it with a poll.

Recommended Reading

This is a must read!

I knew you'd post this

Great stuff....and a real treat at the very end, a total skewering burlesque of Titanic's "Rose" character. 

 

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

Once again, Paglia is spot-on

"Individual rights and free expression, which used to be liberal values, are being gradually subsumed to worship of government power." - Prof. Camille Paglia

There's a quotable quote from a self-described liberal feminist  who is never afraid to speak honestly.  That's why she's been excommunicated by The Left.  Like her contemporaries Christina Hoff Sommers and Tammy Bruce, Paglia deconstructs the myths and rhetoric of The Left, and reveals its ugly side.  These courageous women are not afraid to expose the hypocrisy and anti-American behavior of the Left.

 

I thought someone besides

I thought someone besides Rush created the song.

paul shanklin (sp?), but

paul shanklin (sp?), but rush played it

Yes, it was done by Paul

Yes, it was done by Paul Shanklin at Rush's request.  Paul does all of Rush's parodies, which are always very good.

Republicans believe every day is the 4th of July.  Democrats believe every day is April 15th ~ Ronald Reagan

Camille

She's the only liberal I can relate to as a conservative because like me she can picks and chooses what she believes in and is critical of the opposite side of the political spectrum and her own. Thank you Paglia.

Does anyone . . .

...have the lyrics???

I'd love to see them . .

 

 

Isaiah 5:20a Woe unto them who call evil good, and good evil. . .  KJV

Lyrics to Barack the Magic Negro

PAUL SHANKLIN (Al Sharpton impersonator):

Barack the Magic Negro lives in D.C.

The L.A. Times, they called him that

'Cause he's not authentic like me.

Yeah, the guy from the L.A. paper

Said he makes guilty whites feel good

They'll vote for him, and not for me

'Cause he's not from the hood.

Listen to the rest here.

-Dave

This coup has gone on long enough. The time to put it down is NOW.

Jen7

Jen7:

I am a conservative, and my views come from that perspective.  I believe individual rights are more important than common good. 

In America, you have the right to free speech. You do not have the right to not be offended.

By the way, do some easy research. This specific phrase, used in language directly pointed at Barack Hussein Obama, was first uttered by this guy:

David Ehrenstein (born February 18, 1947, in New York City) is an American critic who focuses primarily on issues of homosexuality in cinema. His father was a secular Jew with Polish ancestors, and his mother was of African American and white Irish descent.

Apparently Rush thought the language was funny, and that the irony was even better coming from an 'American Critic' who himself is 50% black.

You point your finger at Rush Limbaugh, but why not at David Ehrenstein? Is it possible that you have an underlying motive? Is it possible that you will ignore a liberal saying this phrase, but can't ignore the opportunity to be an enormous hypocrite by getting upset when a conservative says the exact same phrase?

You are so biased, your opinions don't count.  Next time, identify yourself as a liberal so that we can understand where you are biases truly are.

As those of us who listen to Rush Limbaugh know, Rush is a fan

of Camille Paglia. Even when Rush believed she was in the tank for Barack Obama, this is what he said about her:

"By the way, I was wounded to the heart today, or last night, because as you all know, I have the deepest admiration -- the most profound respect and love -- for Camille Paglia.  I think Camille Paglia is absolutely brilliant in what she does, but she in the tank for Obama. And she has a little paragraph in her latest column that takes to task conservative talk radio, which she has been listening to and has very much enjoyed it for 20 years. Twenty years?  I'm the only one doing it for 20 years!  She doesn't mention any names, but she says we're just going off the deep end here with these criticisms of Obama that he can't speak without a prompter, that he's really not that bright, that we've called him a Marxist.  I've never called him a Marxist; maybe some other people have. (interruption) Snerdley said, "Why haven't you called him a Marxist?  We've been waiting."  I haven't called him a Marxist.  I haven't gone into this Muslim business.  But anyway, it's clear that she included me in some of this, and she's such a brilliant lady, but you listen to this bite."

----------------------------------------------

"Barack Obama's demeanor belies the fact that he is who he is. You would never think he's an extremist unless you took seriously who his mentors were." ~ Rush Limbaugh

It's Parody

Rush doesn't call anyone a negro, any more than a rap radio station DJ is responsible for all the words in the songs he plays. The song is also a parody. If I simply recount what Senator Robert Byrd said about white n*****s, does that make me a racist? The parody suggests that Al Sharpton is referring to the Bamster as the magic negro, and the term magic negro wrt to Obammy started in an LA Times column written by a black journalist.

The song also incorporates other things Sharpton said himself about the Bamster, when in the parody he says Obammy is not 'authentically black'.

Paglia makes some good

Paglia makes some good points about the foibles of liberalism.  She also notes that Rush's "Magic Negro" parody was used well beyond its shelf life and in so doing became gratuitous and insensitive.  Paglia is right about that, too.

Jer