AP: US 'A Nation That Enshrined Slavery in its Constitution'

Photo of Mike Bates.
  • Bookmark and Share

NewsBusters associate editor Noel Sheppard did a fine job of analyzing today's Associated Press story "Poll: Racial misgivings of whites an Obama issue."  I found this passage from the AP story particularly provocative:

Such numbers are a harsh dose of reality in a campaign for the history books. Obama, the first black candidate with a serious shot at the presidency, accepted the Democratic nomination on the 45th anniversary of Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I Have a Dream" speech, a seminal moment for a nation that enshrined slavery in its Constitution.

Did the United States, as the piece contends, enshrine slavery in its Constitution?

According to the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, "enshrine" means "to enclose in or as if in a shrine" or "to preserve or cherish as sacred."  Over at thesaurus.com, synonyms for the word are "cherish, consecrate, idolize, sanctify."

In a 2002 Heritage Foundation article, Dr. Matthew Spaulding writes:

John Adams opposed slavery his entire life as a "foul contagion in the human character" and "an evil of colossal magnitude." James Madison called it "the most oppressive dominion ever exercised by man over man."

In 1987, former aide to President Johnson, Jack Valenti penned a commentary for The New York Times.  His purpose was to challenge comments on the Constitution made by Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall, a man placed on the court by Valenti's boss.  Writing about the Constitutional Convention, Valenti noted:

Nevertheless, white-haired old George Mason of Virginia was openly and passionately abolitionist. He wanted all slaves freed. Gouverneur Morris of Pennsylvania, stumping heavily on his wooden leg, vented his anger. His words rang through the hall. ''The curse of heaven on the states where it [ slavery ] prevailed,'' he thundered.

That doesn't sound as though slavery were cherished or santified by at least some of the Founding Fathers.  Rather, it was acknowledged as an evil, an issue that needed to be avoided to ensure the building of a nation.

As Valenti observed:

By first building a nation, the Founders, though they did not know it at the time, conspired to form a general public spirit that 70 years later imploded. When the debris had been cleared, there was no more slavery. A metastasis - ancient, mean, ugly -had finally, providentially, been cut from the heart of the country.

And the document that had tolerated the omission in the first place was the life-giving sustenance for a political and social contract that had endured. Survival of an idea, a governing process, is not an inconsiderable triumph.

Frederick Douglass, in an 1852 speech, intoned:

Fellow-citizens! there is no matter in respect to which, the people of the North have allowed themselves to be so ruinously imposed upon, as that of the pro-slavery character of the Constitution. In that instrument I hold there is neither warrant, license, nor sanction of the hateful thing; but, interpreted as it ought to be interpreted, the Constitution is a GLORIOUS LIBERTY DOCUMENT. Read its preamble, consider its purposes. Is slavery among them? Is it at the gateway? or is it in the temple? It is neither.

And later he told his audience:

Now, take the constitution according to its plain reading, and I defy the presentation of a single pro-slavery clause in it. On the other hand it will be found to contain principles and purposes, entirely hostile to the existence of slavery.

The point of all this is that, contrary to the AP article, our Constitution did not enshrine slavery.  The practice was in no way cherished or sanctified.  Acknowledging that it was reluctantly tolerated so that the nation could be formed is closer to the truth.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Mike

Mike,

I really hated that line, too. Sadly, these folks at AP probably have no idea the historical issues our Founding Fathers had to deal with in order to reach agreement on our Constitution. To suggest this document "enshrined" slavery is a slur on those involved its crafting as well as those who died for its advancement.

What a shame, really.  ns

Noel, historical issues

Sadly, these folks at AP probably have no idea the historical issues our Founding Fathers had to deal with in order to reach agreement on our Constitution.

And they're passing on their jaded views to readers.

Mike

Mike,

Well, as I'm sure you know, slavery almost prevented the ratification of the Declaration of Independence. The original document drafted by Jefferson outlawed it, but the southern coalition, led by Rutledge of South Carolina, refused to sign if that clause wasn't scratched out.

This created HUGE arguments with the folks in the North, especially Adams, Jefferson, and Franklin. In the end, the North had to yield in order for our nation to be born.

Do you think they made a good decision? Oddly, I think many liberals don't.  ns

Good decision, Noel

Do you think they made a good decision? Oddly, I think many liberals don't.

Anything that puts the Founding Fathers (or is that Persons?) in a negative light is OK with some libs.

Jefferson??

NS, Jefferson was definitely NOT a Northerner having been born and raised in Virginia . . . also, as a slave-owner all of his life (inheriting part of his father's estate and slaves when he was only 14), he was apparently not too anti-slavery - yes, he did free them all upon his death.  Not saying he was a bad guy, but history should be remembered correctly.

CP

CP,

Yes, Jefferson was from Virginia, and it was considered a southern state. However, if you recall your history, Virginia was the first state to offer a resolution on independence. Furthermore, the Virginia delegation INCLUDING Jefferson supported the slavery clause.

As I recall, when Jefferson's slaves were brought up in Philadelphia, he vowed to release them once he returned to Virginia.  ns

Jefferson

He must have been a Democrat then, since he waited until he died to release them!!  LOL (I know he was one of the founders of the Democratic-Republican Party!)

CP

CP,

Well, apparently Jefferson acquired his slaves with loans. He vowed to release his slaves once he was debt-free -- which he never was. :-)  ns

NS

I think he inherited most of his original slaves from his father and the rest were their children, but he did die with major unpaid debt . . . more proof that he was a dem!!

not just the media

The public schools are helping to push these lies.

"I've now been in 57 states -- I think one left to go." ~ Barrack Hussein Obama ~

"You cannot go to a 7-11 or a Dunkin' Donuts unless you have a slight Indian accent.... I'm not joking." ~ Sen. Joe Biden

Thank you Mike...that line

Thank you Mike...that line infuriated me also...of course it was all done intentionally. 

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Oh, no, BT, thank you

...of course it was all done intentionally. 

It's hard to know what they have in their minds.  Or hearts.

I'm surprised that the AP

I'm surprised that the AP did not blame Bush or Palin for slavery:)

I would say that this hit piece is more fanning of racial issues in this country but it would be more like the AP is taking all the control rods out of the reactor hoping for a meltdown. Mike good job!

 

Mike

AP should be AB of R, or ABR...

Associated Baiters of Race.

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

I believe AP has scheduled

I believe AP has scheduled that story for the early morning news on Sept 29. Watch for it.

The major media report only half the news. Why are they surprised they have only half the potential audience?

Sarah did it, jc

I'm surprised that the AP did not blame Bush or Palin for slavery:)

Or, since we're going back in time, maybe Ronald Reagan.

Thanks for the kind words.

I'm surprised that the AP

I'm surprised that the AP did not blame Bush or Palin for slavery:) 

Well Whoopi-do did suggest that they will be bringing it back

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

The Race Card

I love it when these clowns try to pull the race card on me.

There was a black kid registering people to vote locally (In Las Vegas) and given that I used to live in California, but I now live in a battle ground state I decided that McCain really needs my vote here as opposed to there. I registered as a Libertarian.

The kid had the cajones to ask me  "So you gonna vote for Obama?" Maybe he saw my long salt and pepper hair, noted that perhaps I was Hispanic, and just assumed that he had the right to ask such a thing.

"Nope" I answered with even bigger cajones. "I'm voting for McCain"

Well, this young snot nose of a kid tries to get me to change my vote.  I listend to a couple of his comments, none of which were good enough to remember, then I said:

"Look my friend. I'm Mexican and I have a question for you.What has Obama done to win the Mexican vote? I'll tell you.

Nothing.

Forget aboput not chosing Hillary. That was just stupid. He could have put Bill Richardson on the ticket. He's from a battle ground state. He has experience and he's a Mexican guy with credibility.

But no, your candidate went out and put the whitest white guy he could find on ticket instead."

The kid starts chasing me to my car still trying to convince me to vote for hope, change and Marxism.

He says "Well I really don't see this as an issue of race, but of change."

 Oh really? Race doesn't have anything to do with it? Well what a surprise! How refreshing.

 Now my fellow bloggers you and I both know that kid is glowering over voters and trying to guilt them into voting for Obama, or at least into feeling darn guilty about being white and not voting for Obama.

It's great to be Mexican in this situation because I get to watch these types pull the race card, then try to stuff it back in their wallets when I pull it on them.

It was true that race really has nothing to do with the issues of this campaign, nor should it have anything to do with who is better prepared to lead this country. The problem is that the kid doesn't really believe what he said to me at the end of his attmept to bully me into voting for Obama.

My choice is easy. McCain is the most prepared candidate the Republicans have nominated since Ronald Reagan.

Obama is the least prepared presidential candidate in history.

So I guess that makes me a racist.

 

MexNobama

THANK YOU, for you are an inspiration!...

So true, Obama is the least prepared presidential candidate in history.

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

Face time, MexNo

Well, this young snot nose of a kid tries to get me to change my vote. 

Just following The One's urging his supporters to get into people's faces.

Speeches have certainly lost their charm...

Since the days around the civil war.  Those guys knew how to do it right.

I was thinking about that line the AP used, and I couldn't think of a single line which "enshrined" slavery in the constution.

Enshrinement, Saint

I couldn't think of a single line which "enshrined" slavery in the constution.

I don't believe the word "slavery" (or "slave" for that matter) appears in the Constitution.

So Far...

There's nothing really that talks about the legal status of slavery. There's references to slaves, but that's in the context of the 3/5 compromise, which again would be beyond most if not all journalists.

 

Thank God for the online, searchable, annotated US Constution.  If I can find it, surely they could have?

SZ... "If I can find it,

SZ...

"If I can find it, surely they could have?"

Don't bet on it. Remember, if it's not on wiki then a liberal will be lost!  

Democrats Energy Plan - Breaking News

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Not on wiki

. . . if it's not on wiki then a liberal will be lost!  

And then they'll have to make something up.

Isn't that the same thing?

Isn't that the same thing? Wiki and making crap up?

Democrats Energy Plan - Breaking News 

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Same thing

Isn't that the same thing? Wiki and making crap up?

On Wiki you don't need a journalism degree to advertise your ignorance.  

Actually, I hope the AP and

Actually, I hope the AP and the rest of the MSM do more of these pieces.  There is nothing like obnoxious annoying, whining guilt trippers to tick off the public to make them vote for anyone but Obama.  The MSM storyline is if you're white you have to prove you're not racist by voting for Obama. That should really tick off the voters.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

Wishin' and hopin'

Actually, I hope the AP and the rest of the MSM do more of these pieces.

I think your wish will be fulfilled.

Offical democrat declaration of enslavement 2008

Democrat
platform "For decades, Americans have been told to
act for ourselves, by ourselves, on our own. Democrats reject this recipe for
division and failure."

 

2008 Democratic platform

 

 

The founding father fought for individual rights, "life, liberty and pursuit of happiness"

2008 Democratic platform

Contrary to what they tell us, not a lot new in this year's edition.

Yeah, Right ....Sure....you got it.....WRONG

Who is putting out this BS ?  Journalists ?  Assholes Personified ?

 

The Republican Revolution will not be Televised

The easy way to dis-arm

The easy way to dis-arm Obama's race baiters is... tell them you won't vote for Obama because you disagree with the policies of his white half. 

Liberals Hate-Filled Life

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Obama and race

. . . tell them you won't vote for Obama because you disagree with the policies of his white half. 

Perhaps he should use "Ebony and Ivory" as a campaign song.  He's always identified as the black or African-American, but white is equally accurate.

BAMBI'S SONG - Ebony & Ivory

Ebony and Ivory
For Obama it's not quite
Harmony....

With Reverend Wright
We saw Ivory
Under
That bus
So quickly....

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

Bambi's Song

I'll give it a 98 because I can dance to it and like the words.

Thanks Michael! - shy PS:

Thanks Michael!

- shy

PS: and, um, the 2-point deduction?... because?? :p

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

Deduction

If you were as old as some of us, MrShy, you'd know that 98 was the max rating on American Bandstand.

Aaaah....

THAT was the reference. Okay, okay.

Oh, I remember the '70's and that show plenty as a kid, but probably didn't watch it enough.

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

The AP article may have

The AP article may have unintended meaning. If slavery were indeed "enshrined", then this country has made decent progress. If the words "reluctantly tolerated" were used in the article instead, progress, not so good.

where does it say anything about slaves in the constitution...

where does it say anything about slaves in the constitution? most mentions simply limit governments ability to abolish it, and other limit  "other persons" from voting equally or at all... including women, who were also their husband's property...

can someone point out where it says "hey we dig slavery it's kool..."

Kool

can someone point out where it says "hey we dig slavery it's kool..."

Nah, it was the fist bumps after they signed it that gave it away.

Replies to my 1st post

For Mr Shy:

We are all Americans, and at the same time we are from the cultures of our ancestors.

We can be proud of our ancestors and proud of America at the same time.

 I am too proud of this country to allow ti slip into the hands of Obama without a fight.

 For Michael Bates who replied:

 "Just following The One's urging his supporters to get into people's faces."

 Well, that is why I point out that Hitler was a community organizer too!

We have to get right back in their faces my friend! 

Totalitarians like to use fear to control their enemies, but we live in the United States. I am not going to be silenced by the fear that someone will think I am not voting for Obama because he's Black. 

There are a number of Black candidates (Powel and Rice come to mind off the top of my head) that I would not hesitate to vote into the White House were they to run. Oh, but they don't count because they aren't liberal blacks. They're "Uncle Toms".

..and I guess that makes me a "Tio Juan Valdez".

 Yeah if you want real racism and real sexism look no further than the democratic leadership of 2008. Just ask Governor Palin.

The left can name call and threaten but we still live in a society wherein free speech is protected. I will not be intimidated by guilt as to slavery in America's past. 

This election is about conditions now. Wealthy Black people abound and that is a great thing. They should prosper. A Black man was nominated by his party because the American People look past race. That is a great thing as well.

Obama is tied with McCain and perhaps will lose because people are looking past race and instead at the qualifications of the candidate. That is a great thing, but not so great for Barry-O! 

He can use race to console himself should he lose the election but it will be his poor performance at debates and thin record that finishes him off, not the color of his skin.

»→ Mexnobama

My ancestors left Germany somewhere around 1857.  It's not important to me why they left, just that they left.

I owe Germany nothing.  Germany took one uncle I never met, at Normandy. 

Cortez, Pizarro, Hitler, I have nothing in common with these disgraceful butchers.

"Us white folk will take care of you" - Barbara Walters

How ironic that the Dems

How ironic that the Dems including Obama want the US to be more like Europe.  The very place from where most of American's forebears voted with their feet to LEAVE. They didn't like the implications of a Nanny State back then, no one likes being continually told what to do except if they don't want to take responsibility.  Hey Democrats, if you want to be like Europeans then go to Europe.  We are American's because we DON'T want to be Europeans.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

A few bad people started the

A few bad people started the slave trade and only the richest ever had slaves.  Are we supposed to trash the U.S. indefinitely for these mistakes of a few people?  Even 200 years ago a majority of people were opposed to the nasty slave trade because after-all, we did end it didn't we?  Slavery was never enshrined into the Constitution.  Also, most of the people in this country today are not from colonial roots; we are immigrants.  Throwing slavery out there only fuels racial divide :(

For Cool Arrow

I'm glad that you love this country, but Hitler isn't the only thing Germany ever produced.

Ever heard of Goethe, Hegel, Beethoven?

Nothing to be ashamed of there.

As for Cortez etc... I've been hearing about how horrible the Spanish were for years. Ever consider how it was so easy for Cortez with 500 men to overtake the Aztec empire? There was an entire country of people who were sick and tired of being Aztec Sacrifice fodder. They helped Cortez.

He didn't do it with Small Pox infested blankets alone.  

There is plenty of barbaric behavior in the history of nearly every culture on Earth. The point is what are we doing about it now?

America, even with its faults, is trying to do something about it.

Roll over, Beethoven

Ever heard of Goethe, Hegel, Beethoven?

I've heard of Beethoven.  That was really some cute doggie.

»→ Mexnobama

That was easy.

Bringing out the good old ethnic pride usually is.  My point is that I claim neither pride nor shame for Germany.  I am American.

BTW, is there really documented evidence of the smallpox blankets.  I keep hearing the story with various different conquering groups as the culprits.

I've even heard it about America, but is it documented, or just a good story? 

"Us white folk will take care of you" - Barbara Walters

I don't know if it was intentional......

but the American Indian (Mandan tribe) were practically wiped out due to smallpox according to my early reading.

I guess AP is worried that

I guess AP is worried that Oh baa baa ma is losing some of the 90% plus black vote.

No O, NO!!!

The black vote, Eileen

I guess AP is worried that Oh baa baa ma is losing some of the 90% plus black vote.

Don't think they have anything to worry about.  Not that that level of support has anything to do with race or anything.  They've carefully examined the candidates' positions, immersed themselves with policy alternatives, studied the issues, made a thoughtful evaluation. . . .

MM... Last week I got

MM...

Last week I got into a short conversation with an elderly black guy at my wifes doctors office. We were both outside taking a smoke break while waiting on our spouses. Somehow the conversation got around to Obama (not by me). After this gentleman made the comment..."Obama is the only choice to save this country" I asked him what Obama's plan was to fix things and this is what he said... and I quote "he will bring back good ideas to our country". He confused me so much I couldn't say a word. Do you have any clue whatsoever, what he was talking about? I know I don't. Don't worry if you can't answer that, I will totally understand.

Democrats Energy Plan - Breaking News

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Good ideas, Clear

Maybe he's referring to those good ideas like the Great Society, New Deal, New Frontier. . . .

Don't forget new taxes.

Don't forget new taxes. It's sad that so many people these days forget the meaning of "logic"! Sigh...

Democrats Energy Plan - Breaking News 

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

New and improved taxes

How'd I forget that?  Thanks!

That's one old dog

Michael Bates says:

 "I've heard of Beethoven.  That was really some cute doggie."

That's a pretty old joke dude. 

I think it was the last thing Beethoven heard before he went deaf.

I had an uncle Beto. (short for Humberto) Whenever I would say Beethoven in the course of coversation my dad  would reply "you mean 'Beto Ven'?" (which means "come here Beto") Evidently this was what they did for laughs in rural Mexico during the depression. 

Anyway your fine for using such a hairy old joke in a serious public forum should be that you have give one Beethoven symphony a fair listen within the next 72 hours.

You'll love it.

Please don't come back with the "what's brown and sits on a piano bench" one. There are ladies reading this stuff!  

Old joke

That's a pretty old joke dude.

What else would you expect from a pretty old dude?

Can't pay the fine you levied.  My 8-track's broken again.

MMBates

You need an 8-track -to- CD-R converter, if there is one. :p

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

Slavery is not an American invention

To hear libs tell it, you'd think that America invented slavery.  Slavery has been practiced around the world throughout history, and every race has been enslaved at one time.  It wasn't invented to oppress blacks.  America is also one of the first nations to get rid of slavery.  Of course we've had our racial problems, but we've also made a lot more progress than some would have you believe.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

viking75...

Right! In other words:

This is a great nation. Period.

 

NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun

 

»→ Unlike Kenya

All Kenya did was capture and traffic in the slave trade.

Excuse me while I upchuckle. 

"Us white folk will take care of you" - Barbara Walters

nkv......spot on......but, they...

either ignore, or just wont talk about slavery that still exists today.  Places like the Sudan, and other sub Sahara regions.  This was never an exclusive american thing.  As I have told people who have debated me on the issue of slavery, when I tell them it is still going on, all I get is blank stares.  I tell them to do a little research and get back to me.....of course the lemmings never do...and just keep spouting that stupid line of how evil america is.  Boneheads!!!! 

"If a man does his best, what else is there"?

General George S. Patton Jr.

hypocricy, of course

Here's what ticked me off. Over 1000 words on the subject, picking apart white voters thoughts, motivations, rationales, etc.. and this one line "On the other side of the racial question, the Illinois Democrat is drawing almost unanimous support from blacks''

Could someone explain to me why it is OK for blacks to vote straight down the color line, but if a white does it, it is unfair and prejudiced?

It's almost like they are setting up Barry's impending failure, and they plan to point the finger at deep-seated racial biases of whites, all the while applauding the deep-seated racial biases (call it loyalty, of course) of blacks.

I am sick of it! Feel free to look into my heart and my brain. There is no racism there. I just think that Obama is a treasonous idiot, who will sell the US out. I wouldn't vote for him for dogcatcher, no matter what color he was.

 

"I've now been in 57 states -- I think one left to go." ~ Barrack Hussein Obama ~

"You cannot go to a 7-11 or a Dunkin' Donuts unless you have a slight Indian accent.... I'm not joking." ~ Sen. Joe Biden

Voting based on color, Mazzi

My favorite writer recently noted:

Not that that level of (black) support (for Obama) has anything to do with race or anything.  They've carefully examined the candidates' positions, immersed themselves with policy alternatives, studied the issues, made a thoughtful evaluation. . . .

Trotsky and the Communists like compulsory labor

From the link below in regards to Trotsky and the Communists.

 

"One would expect that the mere suggestion of compulsory labor, let alone its actual imposition, would have branded Lenin and Trotsky as demonic traitors to anyone who purported to care about the plight of workers. Ominously, it did not; Party intellectuals proclaimed the wonders of the new system. "Compulsory labour under capitalism, wrote Bukharin, was quite the reverse of compulsory labour under the dictatorship of the proletariat: the first was 'the enslavement of the working class,' the second the 'self- organization of the working class'."

  

http://www.gmu.edu/departments/economics/bcaplan/museum/his1g.htm

 

 

Great link Carl.

Many also do not know that we (Americans, that is) have been fightin the commies since around that time.

http://polarbears.si...

http://net.lib.byu.e...

I just find it rather sad that the battle now takes place within our borders.

 

If you make people think they're thinking, they'll love youBut if you really make them think, they'll hate you.

Don Marquis 1878-1937

Great links too. I knew

Great links too. I knew about the Americans had been involved in conflicts in Russia after WW1.  Didn't know about the MIAs or POWs though.

 Check out this quote from the below link about WW2.

 

"But Soviet archival documents -- from an earlier era after World War II -- reveal that Americans were detained, and even perished, in the vast Soviet GULAG. To find out additional information about Americans liberated from German prison camps by the Red Army and then interned in Soviet camps, the U.S./Russian Joint Commission on POW/MIAs was formed early in 1992. Library of Congress officials, among others, have been authorized to research Russian archival materials on the subject in Moscow"

 

http://www.ibiblio.org/expo/soviet.exhibit/wartime.html

 

 

 

I had heard

sumthin about the US POWS in Russia during War II from this;

http://www.telegraph...

http://www.imdb.com/...

But, thanks for the great link, I did not know about the commission that was formed in 1992. I'll read some more about it later today. Thanks again. 

If you make people think they're thinking, they'll love youBut if you really make them think, they'll hate you.

Don Marquis 1878-1937

http://www.cnn.com/2... Here

http://www.cnn.com/2...

Here is another link to checkout.

I thought about it and I am going to comment.

  The insanity that these people spew when it comes to the history of slavery and this country has to end now.

  Slavery was a divisive issue before the founding of this country, at the founding of this country, and to paraphrase some guy I wish I knew his name, for four score and seven years.

  It nearly tore this country apart at its founding, several times thereafter, and finally did tear it apart, and again I quote, after four score and seven years.

  Yes, there has been uneven progress after the civil war, but there was been great progress by people living and dead. And yes, there is more work to do, but that is no reason to distort and lie about what has been and what is.

  I am a product of the post civil rights movement. It has been pounded into my brain and the brain of all Americans not to be a racist or a bigot or to discriminate. And it has been successful. I am not a racist. No one I know is a racist.

  So stop with the insidious lies. Every culture on the planet has faced the issue of slavery. Some a little later than others. Some still face the issue today. Yes, slavery is still alive today on parts of planet earth.

  This country has nothing to apologize for when it comes to the issue of slavery.

Well said J.

I regret to inform you that it is useless to reason with the insane. By insane, I mean anyone that thinks the United States of America owes anyone alive today an apology with regards to slavery. 

I agree 100% with your comment, I just feel that given the indoctrination that some in this country have undergone, we will be confronted with these lies for the foreseeable future. All we can do is what you have called for; Demand an end to the insane statements and tell the truth of the matter.  

 

If you make people think they're thinking, they'll love youBut if you really make them think, they'll hate you.

Don Marquis 1878-1937

JWF

"... and to paraphrase some guy I wish I knew his name, for four score and seven years.

This you gotta know. Two things happen when you get older -first, your memory fades and then second, something else really important happens but I forget what it is.

Just because it was

Just because it was "allowed" under the Constitution that doesn't mean it was "enshrined".

Did the US Government ever even own one slave?

Fish Wrap

The only documents I have ever read that "enshrined" slavery into their charter are found in the Declaration of Succession by the southern states. Which were all Democrats. Dare we mention the Qur'an or the slave trade thriving in Africa today?

»→ Succession

Secession? 

"Read my lips. I would not be anybody's Vice President" - Joe Biden 08/07

Constitution and slavery

 I believe it is correct that - If those in the American Constitutional Convention who tried to abolish slavery had not compromised, the South would never have joined, the South would have likely joined with France,  an enemy of England, and formed their own New France.  A few years later, 1812, England by itself  invaded and attacked the United States, killing Americans and burning our public buildings.  Add the South to that, and there would be no "American Experiment" in Liberty and Justice for All.  The Constitution was written in such a way that liberty could be, and has been, expanded to include women, black Americans, and Native Americans.  The process continues to this day.

And about Jefferson owning slaves

 And, Oh, yes, THAT.  -- Some of the Founders had slaves, mostly they inherited them.  So what if they had freed them then and there?  They would have been captured and re-enslaved by others who likely would have treated them worse.  You could not BE a free black person there.  Otherwise where would they go anyway?  They had an existence that was unchangeable.  Jefferson was said to treat his slaves well. (A slave is a person who can't quit his job and has no other home.)  He had a part black common law wife, whom he apparently loved.  But it was against the law to marry her.  No one then lived in the atmosphere of Liberty which they so desperately bought for us. 

Shadow of Power

Maybe these AP guys just read Steve Martini's novel Shadow of Power. This was a fiction book with references to how slavery was supposedly written into the Constitution.