CNN Highlights Ephron's Racist/Sexist Theory About White Male Voters

Photo of Matthew Balan.
By Matthew Balan | April 22, 2008 - 20:47 ET

NewsBusters.org - Media Research CenterCNN's Carol Costello focused on Nora Ephron's Huffington Post rant against white male voters in Pennsylvania during a report on Tuesday's "The Situation Room." "Ephron uses provocative language to make a point. She says, 'let's not kid ourselves. Try as we might, white men will still decide who gets to be president.'" While Costello used results from previous primaries to cast doubt on Ephron's theory, she and CNN chose to highlight Ephron's words and found voters who apparently agreed with it.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Host Wolf Blitzer introduced the report, which aired at the bottom of the 5 pm Eastern hour, and described Ephron's "controversial opinions," as he put it, as "pretty intriguing stuff." After playing a clip from a Democratic debate that included the then-candidate John Edwards, Costello described Ephron as "[t]he woman famous for making movies like 'Sleepless in Seattle'" and excerpted some of the Huffington Post article. "Pennsylvania's primary is 'an election about whether the people of Pennsylvania hate blacks more than they hate women. And when I say people, I mean white men.' In other words, if Hillary Clinton can win the white male vote in Pennsylvania, where white male politicians overwhelmingly hold office, she will win the primary, because, as Ephron puts it, 'she can attract more racist white male voters than Obama can.'"

Costello then played two sound bites of Pennsylvania white males who apparently agreed with Ephron.

COSTELLO: A number of voters we spoke with today buy Ephron's argument.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: No question, absolutely. It will be the white men that determine who is going to be the president.

BEN WINTERS, VOTER: It's sort of a paradoxical result, considering this is the first time we have an opportunity to elect a woman or a African-American, that white men should sort of hold the power. That feels icky to say. But I guess it's true, technically. They will cast the deciding vote.

Both of the men interviewed agreed that the white male vote is going to be crucial, but it isn't clear from the sound bites if they agreed with the racist/sexist component of Ephron's theory.

Costello then highlighted the fact that "[i]f you look at how this year's primaries have been won, he who takes the white male vote rules. Clinton won Ohio, taking 58% of the white male vote. Obama won Wisconsin, taking 63% of the white male vote." But, as Costello pointed out, this detail "may not matter two hoots in a general election."

The report concluded with possible scenarios for Democratic victory in the fall election.

ROGER SIMON, POLITICO: No Democratic candidate for president since Lyndon Johnson has won the white vote. Jimmy Carter; Bill Clinton, twice; have always lost the white vote. The trick for a Democratic candidate is to get enough of the white vote and an overwhelming black vote.

COSTELLO (on-camera): Or you could look at it this way -- the winning candidate will have to get enough of the white vote and an overwhelming female vote and that makes both Democratic candidates a possible winner in the general election. Nothing is easy to figure out in this election, Wolf.

BLITZER: You're right, Carol. Thank you.

Interestingly enough, Democratic strategist and CNN regular Paul Begala slammed Ephron's theory only a few minutes later on "The Situation Room" during a panel discussion.

BLITZER: Paul, what do you make of these exit poll numbers that we've just received? 92% of African-American voters going for Obama in Pennsylvania.

PAUL BEGALA: Right. And I think this is what -- I'm a huge Nora Ephron fan, I've never met her, but I love her movies, she's a great writer, but she's a pretty crummy political analyst, okay? 92% -- if Bill's exit polls are right, and who knows? But if that's true, they're voting for Barack Obama. They're not voting against Hillary Clinton. It's not to say that African-Americans are racist against white people. They have a terrific, remarkable candidate that they can be for. So it is with Hillary Clinton, particularly in the Democratic primary, right?. If this was -- if they were torn between their sexism and their racism, they'd stay home, because that's the only choice they got is the African-American or the woman. There's just nothing in the data that suggests, at least in the Democratic party, that this is hurting them. You know, more and more people are registering, more participating, which is good.

The full transcript of Carol Costello's segment from Tuesday's "The Situation Room:"

WOLF BLITZER: A female author has some controversial opinions on tonight's Pennsylvania primary -- Nora Ephron thinks the race will turn on white men, and whether they are racist or sexist. CNN's Carol Costello talked to her today. She's watching this story for us -- pretty intriguing stuff, Carol. What did she say?

CAROL COSTELLO: Well, to put it mildly, Wolf, Ephron uses provocative language to make a point. She says, 'let's not kid ourselves. Try as we might, white men will still decide who gets to be president.'

COSTELLO (voice-over): For some, Pennsylvania's primary will make one thing crystal clear, despite denials from Democrats, present and past --

JOHN EDWARDS, FORMER DEMOCRATIC PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: ...And the only thing I would say, and I think it has nothing to do with race and gender. Let me be real clear about that. It's amazing now being the white male --

BARACK OBAMA: ...Feeling all defensive about it. John, it's all right, man.

(LAUGHS)

EDWARDS: ...is that this is different.

NewsBusters.org - Media Research CenterCOSTELLO: But Edwards was wrong according to Nora Ephron. The woman famous for making movies like 'Sleepless in Seattle' writes in 'The Huffington Post' -- Pennsylvania's primary is an election about 'whether the people of Pennsylvania hate blacks more than they hate women. And when I say people, I mean white men.' In other words, if Hillary Clinton can win the white male vote in Pennsylvania, where white male politicians overwhelmingly hold office, she will win the primary, because, as Ephron puts it, 'she can attract more racist white male voters than Obama can.' And she thinks that may persuade those undecided superdelegates that only Clinton can win in the general election against a white man, John McCain. A number of voters we spoke with today buy Ephron's argument.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: No question, absolutely. It will be the white men that determine who is going to be the president.

BEN WINTERS, VOTER: It's sort of a paradoxical result, considering this is the first time we have an opportunity to elect a woman or a African-American, that white men should sort of hold the power. That feels icky to say. But I guess it's true, technically. They will cast the deciding vote.

COSTELLO: But is it true? If you look at how this year's primaries have been won, he who takes the white male vote rules. Clinton won Ohio, taking 58% of the white male vote. Obama won Wisconsin, taking 63% of the white male vote. But guess what? It may not matter two hoots in a general election.

ROGER SIMON, POLITICO: No Democratic candidate for president since Lyndon Johnson has won the white vote. Jimmy Carter; Bill Clinton, twice; have always lost the white vote. The trick for a Democratic candidate is to get enough of the white vote and an overwhelming black vote.

COSTELLO (on-camera): Or you could look at it this way -- the winning candidate will have to get enough of the white vote and an overwhelming female vote and that makes both Democratic candidates a possible winner in the general election. Nothing is easy to figure out in this election, Wolf.

BLITZER: You're right, Carol. Thank you.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Oh, Please

BEN WINTERS, VOTER "that white men should sort of hold the power. That feels icky to say."

Where do they find these people...if this guy is white, shouldn't this be under the "Man-bashing ads...".

Have You Ever Noticed

Modern liberals come at things from an essentially negative perspective most of the time. For example, according to Ephron, the issue in PA is about who white men hate least, as opposed to who white men like the most.

What is about the modern liberal brain that automatically moves to the negative side of any issue? Is it biochemical? Is is learned behaviour? Is is just a symptom of the mental disturbance we call modern liberalism?

I think research must be done.


"All that is necessary for the trimuph of evil is that good men do nothing."

- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)

www.conservativeboot...

There you have it folks

A liberal insults conservatives "provacative and worthy of a serious discussion.

 Ann Coulter insults Liberals, "hate speech", " a pox on humanity and the GOP".  "Should never be allowed to speak publicly".   Let's ask our viewers to email in how much a hate-monger she really is.

 Bill Bennet "Bigot" "Hater of Black"  We'll play a snippet of his radio show taken out of context and you can email in to our show how much of a bigot you think he is.

Never mind what Coulter or bennet is trying to say, why bother.  As Ephron says they hate blacks and women. 

I heard or read something

I heard or read something about this a couple of weeks ago, and the reason given was that they already knew the breakdown of a lot of other demographics...women, blacks, the under 25 crowd, elderly...but the only segment not accounted for was white men (funny how they got ignored until the last minute, huh?) So now, of course, that is the one demographic that they are clueless on.

And of course, it wouldn't do to talk about who they like the most; of course it has to be cast in terms of who they hate least.

More put people on the defensive: if you vote for Obama it's Why do you hate women? For Hillary it's "are you a racist?"

Because of course, white men ONLY vote on their hatred and bigotry. <sarc>

mb...  "Because of

mb...

 "Because of course, white men ONLY vote on their hatred and bigotry."

Especially white Democrat men!

"Abstain from McCain"

No Clear

I think it must be all white men...you know how they are, don't you?

DDM... I see hatred and

DDM...

I see hatred and bigotry come almost exclusively from lefties.

In other forums I have been called many names for pointing out that I have never met a Conservative that was a racist.  

"Abstain from McCain"

I should

have made my point more apparent Clear...I was speaking from their (the lefts) point of view...they seem to think all white men are stupid and evil.

Understood! I should have

Understood!

I should have known better. 

"Abstain from McCain"

Thank God for white men!

she says, 'let's not kid ourselves. Try as we might, white men will still decide who gets to be president.'" 

Thank God for that.  If not, we would have Snoop Doggy Doo as President.  Or Hitlery or Balack Osama! 

Help... Can anyone tell

Help...

Can anyone tell me why Snoop Dogg get's paid millions of dollars? Seriously, he has zero talent, so what gives? 

"Abstain from McCain"

Apparently his fans either

Apparently his fans either think he has, or don't care that he doesn't.

Remember PT Barnum: a sucker born every minute. And the other guy who said no one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American people.

But to be fair, I can't understand why sports stars get paid the way they do either.

No talent = Rap stars

Clear, no talent pretty much sums up the entire rap (and a lot of current music). It also covers most of the Hollywood crowd IMHO.

I have also wondered how Ted Turner is a billionaire. I'm pretty sure he has hired someone to tell him to inhale/exhale.

What's delicious is that

Ms Ephron is basing her assertion on how white democrats are voting in the primaries. The men are either racist or sexist. No allowance for chosing a candidate based on policy. What's even better is that with this same logic she's painting the democratic blacks who vote for Obama racist and the democratic women who vote for Clinton sexist!

Hey, white males are a

Hey, white males are a minority in this country, where are my special privileges?  I'm the victim here, &&$%#$%^$%&^, I demand legal status as a "protected class" and the quotas that go with it.  I don't like the way you MSM types are talking about me, since I'm the victim, I get to decide what is and isn't hate speech.  You Costello have offended me and I demand a public apology otherwise I am suing.  <sarcasm>

 Lord Sidious / Darth Vader 2008  Long Live the Empire!  Come to the Dark Side, it is your Destiny.

Nora Ephron: Clueless In Washington

I just posted this latest missive on my little blog -- plus added bonus sexy photo of the longfaced Nora... www.hollycrud.com

Ace political analyst, and Oscar nominated screenwriter, Nora Ephron is a tolerant liberal. As such she’s very comfortable at making trite generalizations based on her stereotyping of a whole class of people.

"Pennsylvania's primary is 'an election about whether the people of Pennsylvania hate blacks more than they hate women. And when I say people, I mean white men.' Nora Ephron, Huffington Post, 22 April 2008.

Now I don’t want to get into a whole should people who look like Secretariat really be making gratuitous insults against others.

That’s a generalization, but you decide.

Nora is famous for writing a few movies in which the number of leading black faces can be counted on the fingers of a handless man. That is: ZERO.

When White Harry Met Pale Sally... Blackless in Seattle... You've Got White Male... Bewhited

But that’s not even my main point. You notice Nora’s impeccable circular logic that so befits a liberal. The “when did you stop beating your wife?” question.

No matter which candidate the white male Democrat votes for, it is irrelevant. If it is Obama, then they are a misogynist. If it’s Clinton, then they are a racist. Heads you lose, tails you lose again white scumbag!

So being a white male means you can’t win. Except if you marry Nora. Like Carl Bernstein of Deep Throat fame, Nora’s second white husband.

Lecturing us recently about the whole Spitzer/hooker scandal, the effortlessly superior liberal Nora droned...

"Prostitution is a victimless crime..."

Back in 1986, Clueless in Washington (that would be Nora) had no idea her hubby was having an “affair” right under her nose with one of her best friends! That would be an also married British politician slash media whore. She was/is Margaret Jay – who also looked like a horse.

Ephron was pregnant with her second son, Max at the time. So traumatized was she when she found out what the whole of trendy Washington knew, Ephron delivered her baby son – sorry, I mean fetus son, prematurely as a result.

Maybe if she had two daughters she wouldn't be so cavalier about women selling their bodies for money as, oddly enough, news of HER husbands infidelity caused her so much emotional distress, her baby was born early.

Sure Nora... no victims here. Let's all move on.

Maybe that’s why she now has it in for racist and/or sexist white men. Apparently they are the bedrock of the Democrat Party! Who knew.

Vote 4 change. Vote 4 anything. See Jack & Mr Shy's first campaign ad for the ONLY viable 3rd party candidate.

Yeah..I break the conventional mold...

As a white male, well endowed, educated, veteran, athletic, articulate, etc., I appreciate the ability to herd sheep into a corner and take advantage of them.

Need a context to distort?  Start with that, liberals.

I didn't inherit any power.  I created it.  Very liberating. 

 

New Cable News Network Announced...

This just came off the wire:

A new cable news network will be launched this fall that will focus on plight of minorties in America. The network will be called HOW which stands for Hatin' On Whitey. Anchors will be exclusively minority and wear authetic street clothing while on-air to reflect their personalities. FUBU and Sean John have been announced corporate sponsors. You'll see baggy, low-riding jeans, bandanas and dangling gold chains accessorizing the talent. Additionally, anchors will talk in authentic street slang while reading the news. Words like Jit, Brah, Biiatch will be common place as will phrases like "cracker punk ass bitch."

Amazing.