It is NBC Green Week, after all, so who can blame Andrea Mitchell for recycling two dilapidated defenses of the Rev. Jeremiah Wright?
Mitchell's heart didn't seem wholly in it, but like a burned-out public defender going through the motions, Andrea apparently felt constrained to mount some kind of defense of Rev. Jeremiah Wright's controversial remarks. And so she trotted out two hoary chestnuts:
- that's the way it's done in African-American churches, and
- media critics say he was "taken out of context."
View video here.
Andrea is occupying the Mika Brzezinski Chair of Political Science on this week's Morning Joe. The show's first segment today focused on Rev. Wright's re-emergence, first in an interview with Bill Moyers to be aired tonight and of which snippets have been made available, and then in planned appearances before the National Press Club and the NAACP.
In one clip that was played, Rev. Wright implied to Moyer that America has "blood on its hands." The panel agreed that none of this can be helpful for Barack Obama. But Andrea did her best to limit the damage.
ANDREA MITCHELL: Well, I think, this comes out of a whole issue of the African-American church. The way preaching, the way preachers build a crescendo and then have it come down. And that's what he was also saying, and that's what a lot of people, critics of the way we all have handled this story say, that, taken out of context any one line or two from these long sermons sounds much more explosive than it really is. But if you look at the words, the words say what they say.
JOE SCARBOROUGH: I've been to a lot of churches. And I get kicked out of every church I go to, so I have experience across--
MITCHELL [jocularly]: That explains a lot.
SCARBOROUGH: Across a lot of denominations, and I've just never heard anybody say "God damn the USA" or the US KK--and OK, maybe that, maybe that is the way the African-American church works, we've had several pastors on here from the African-American church say that's insulting, to suggest that of them. But if that is the way the African-American church works, that's a problem for any African-American candidate.
Perhaps not for any African-American candidate, but certainly for one who sat in Rev. Wright's pews for 20 years, calls him his "spiritual guide," and continued to donate tens of thousands of dollars to his church despite his rhetoric.
Possibly abashed to directly adopt it, Mitchell resorted to the technique of putting her "taken out of context" claim in the mouths of others. Perhaps in a later segment Andrea will explain the proper context in which we should understand Rev. Wright's claim, for example, that the US government introduced AIDS as an instrument of genocide against African-Americans.
Note: see Matt Sheffield's item of this morning for some of that crucial "context." And last month, appearing on Morning Joe, Time editor Rick Stengel spoke of "the incredible ignorance of white Americans about what goes on in black churches."

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
These people need to find a
April 25, 2008 - 07:09 ET by motherbeltThese people need to find a new phrase, instead of constantly misusing "out of context." I think what they want to say is "misinterpreted." (most of the tim it' not misinterpretation either, but at least that can be argued). Generally, the "context" that they say was removed just reinforces the point, in plain English, rather than refuting it.
So you say all these terrible things that America has done and then say "G-D America!" Does the context around "G-D America!" mitigate it? No, it reinforces it.
It's like saying that Michelle Obama's "first time proud" comment was taken "out of context." Or her "America is downright mean!" No, the context around those comments make it clear what she meant, which is exactly the way they were interpreted.
Providing the "context" the way they use it, is supposed to explain why what they said wasn't terrible, not provide more proof that it was.
Looking at it that way, Rev. Wright's supporters should be thankful that he was taken out of context. The G-D America is just a snippet. The whole thing, in context, as provided by Matthew Sheffield in the posting below, is even worse.
How stupid does Mitchell,
April 25, 2008 - 07:11 ET by ThisnThatHow stupid does Mitchell, Obama, and the rest of the MSM think we are? America does not consist of the Liberal Elite, and we don't spend a lot of time going thru the mental gyrations necessary to explain away what we heard from Obama's reverend.
Notice that Mitchell and the rest of the MSM are now trying to explain this as "very brief, one-off statement" out of a "long, long sermon" -- again, to help guide us during our mental gyrations? This will be picked up and emphased by the rest of the MSM.
It ain't gonna work. Not in middle America. As John Kerry says, if we were all that stupid, we would be in Irak, and it's obvious we are not all in Irac.
___________________________________
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber
black church = racist
April 25, 2008 - 07:18 ET by pearlblack church = racist
If some talking head on TV says the phrase "black church" and doesn't realize how racist that is, just mark them down as a leftist.
There is no way you can
April 25, 2008 - 07:32 ET by taterThere is no way you can take what he said out of context. He has hate in his heart for this country from what he said and there is no way around it. You don't get a free pass because you have a (D) by your name.
"They need to have a course in college called common sense and everyone should take it. Problem is there isn't too many people that could pass or teach it." -my grandfather
A Defense of Mitchell
April 25, 2008 - 07:45 ET by allanfMitchell is hardly an apologist for Reverend Wright. Perhaps it is because she is a Hillary supporter.
In a March 27th 2008 report on NBC’s Today Show , Andrea Mitchell became the first network correspondent to reveal that Obama’s Church published the Hamas leader’s diatribe (sent under separate cover). Mitchell also found numerous other anti-Israeli writings published by Obama’s Church. Mitchell also found another instance where Wright had referred to Italian’s as “garlic noses”.
I'll give Mitchell credit
April 25, 2008 - 07:49 ET by Mark FinkelsteinI'll give Mitchell credit for the work you describe, but view the video and tell me if Mitchell wasn't, if somewhat half-heartedly, mounting a defense of Wright this morning.
Andrea: His remarks were
April 25, 2008 - 07:57 ET by motherbeltImaginary conversation:
Andrea: His remarks were taken out of context.
Me: OK, Andrea, what was the context?
Andrea: Well, he was talking about blacks not having equal protection
under the law, and putting blacks in inferior schools, and giving them
drugs and then putting them in prison...locking them into positions of
hopelessness....that's why he said "G-D America!"
Me: And that "context" makes it better?
Andrea: Well......
PS Mark, the video link goes to a still shot.
Motherbelt
April 25, 2008 - 07:58 ET by Mica the MagnificentShort and sweet.
That about sums it up.
Right, and that 18-year-old
April 25, 2008 - 08:50 ET by motherbeltRight, and that 18-year-old who used his senile, 84-year-old grandmother in a "gangsta" video says it was all a misunderstanding...it was a joke!
I know this veers off a little, but it's the same principle. Click on the video to see his mother say "That's his grandmother. He doesn't abuse her....He loves her!! <GAG>
Today Show
April 25, 2008 - 07:57 ET by allanfI watched Andrea's piece live on the Today Show this morning. I was struck by how her voice over obliterated Reverand Wright's "God damn America" phrase. Her defense of Wright seemed unenthusiastic to me.
NBC has all but officially endorsed Obama. NBC's "journalistic standards" (and Mitchell's desire for air time) require Mitchell to "defend" Wright.
It is ironic. Mitchell now knows a lonely Republicans feel in a news room.
Guilt by association?
April 25, 2008 - 08:33 ET by JustaPatriotThose who fail to learn from History, are destined to repeat it.......
No justa - he's guilty for his own actions
April 25, 2008 - 10:08 ET by Dee Bunkof following this man, letting his children be influenced by him and not condemning is comments earlier. Knowingly following a hot headed racist who tries to foster hate for white people in his church is not good judgment whether you actually agree with it or not.
My guess is that Obama doesn't agree with it but joined the Church purely to pander and capitalize on their hate of white people. That doesn't make him any better. If anything, it makes him worse.
Thirty five years as a
April 25, 2008 - 11:28 ET by JustaPatriotThirty five years as a pastor, twenty years or so as Obama’s pastor; one, two or three sermons a week. How many statements from within his sermons have been brought up? I know of one statement being repeated of “the chickens have come home to roost”. My understanding is this was a quote from Ambassador Peck on Fox news soon after 9/11 not Rev. Wright.
As far as condemnation goes I’m sure there were quite a few negative “words” spoken about our governments role or lack there of during the Terry Shiavo case from the pulpits.
It' s a shame that we can't debate the issues of our times instead of reverting to who is the more patriotic.
We all are patriotic Americans.
Those who fail to learn from History, are destined to repeat it.......
No justa - No one who says "God Damn America" is a patriot
April 25, 2008 - 11:37 ET by Dee BunkUnless they live in Iran. And neither is someone who defends those who do.
Fallwell was throughly slammed by the press for saying that God brought this on because of our moral failings and he deserved it. No politician would get a pass if Fallwell were his personal pastor.
Church's can disagree with public policy without damning America.
"My understanding is this
April 25, 2008 - 12:49 ET by ckc1227"My understanding is this was a quote from Ambassador Peck on Fox news soon after 9/11 not Rev. Wright."
Yeah, a quote that Wright agreed with. That's why he felt the need to share it with the members of his racist, hate-preaching church.
"We all are patriotic Americans."
No, we aren't all patriotic Americans. That's why the Reverand Wright stuff doesn't bother you: You're too naive to understand why it matters. Or maybe you're just too left to care.
We should abort all black babies for crime to go down
April 25, 2008 - 09:55 ET by Dee Bunkwas taken out of context. The media never gave Bill Bennett this type of publicity to explain the context that completely changed the meaning to be the opposite of what the sound bite conveyed. The statement sounded horrific when you didn't know that he was saying that type of statement is dangerously flawed. It's like if someone says - I hate it when ignorant people say "black people are lazy" and then you cut out everything but "black people are lazy" and attribute that to the person.
Rev Wright's full transcript, doesn't change any of the meaning. The parts shown on the news were consistent with his whole theme of America is the wrong and bad country and we deserve to be attacked. You don't read the whole thing and think - oh he meant that he loves America and it's the greatest country and he condemns people who say "God damn America". He said and meant the horrible things and the full transcript shows that.
That's right Dee...Mitchell
April 25, 2008 - 11:28 ET by motherbeltThat's right Dee...Mitchell should have let it go. The context doesn't mitigate anything; if anything, it exacerbates it.
Obama's chickens have come home to roost
April 25, 2008 - 11:12 ET by CapitalismRulesI have a strange feeling that Obama would be pounding this into McCain's face, or Hillary for that matter if the shoe were on the other foot.
"And so she trotted out two
April 25, 2008 - 12:56 ET by ckc1227"And so she trotted out two hoary chestnuts:
I really don't get this defense at all. I mean, is it supposed to make white Americans feel better knowing that racist, hate speech is occuring in black churches all across the country instead of being isolated to just a few?
Not that I believe it is done this way as a general rule in black churches, mind you, just pointing out how foolish this defense is.
Echo and Amen
April 26, 2008 - 04:19 ET by ToddonCapeCodI am just scratching my head over this lame "taken out of context" remark so many on the Left are throwing out in defense of Wright.
How in God's green earth can the words "God d*** America" be taken out of context? What is redemptive about those words?
Makes no sense, and this is my whole complaint with the Left's defense of Barack Obama and his ilk: they just think they can throw out some lame statement and think that will pacify everyone.