On Monday’s CBS Early Show, co-host Julie Chen introduced a segment on China hosting the Olympics: "Well, the Olympic games are more than a chance for the world's athletes to excel, they also give the host nation an opportunity to shine. For China and it's 1.3 billion people, the Beijing games are feeding a groundswell of pride." Chen then went to correspondent Barry Petersen who declared: "From designer clothes to new cars, China is getting rich. Democracies once bragged that theirs was the only way to economic success. China is doing it the communist way."
Petersen began his report by observing: "Well, China wants to throw a successful Olympics party and so far they're doing just fine. With plenty of enthusiasm spreading from Beijing pretty much around the world." Of course that ignored the heavy pollution in Beijing, constant protests, President Bush’s criticism of China’s human rights record, and the fatal stabbing of the father-in-law of a U.S. coach. Petersen went on to describe how: "Beijing has the welcome banners out to a half million visitors. More foreigners at one time than the country has seen since the Mongol invasion a thousand years ago." So Olympic visitors are like barbarian hordes?
One such foreign visitor was an American tourist who remarked: "I think the thing that really struck me more than anything is just how vast the city is, you know. Our big cities, New York and L.A. and Atlanta, you know, they pale in comparison." It was at that point that Petersen spoke of the Chinese gaining economic prosperity "the Communist way." A clip was also played of one Chinese citizen explaining: "The younger generation are being channeled. Their energy has been channeled into making money, getting rich."
Petersen did make brief mention of Chinese government repression: "Rich, but not free. Religious activist Qua Wei Chi told us last week the police warned him to remain quiet or he might disappear. Sunday, on his way to the church that President Bush attended, he was arrested." However, Petersen followed that one sentence by going on to tout poll numbers suggesting that the Chinese people are happier than Americans: "And here are some numbers that are not about gold medals. An American polling company asked Americans and Chinese what they thought about the direction of their country. About 23% of Americans said they were satisfied, but an astonishing 86% of Chinese said they're happy with where their country is going. Julie." Chen replied: "Wow, that's quite a number." The same poll was cited by Matt Lauer on NBC’s August 5 Today.
Chen concluded the segment by bragging about how well CBS was covering the games: "Well, we take pride in the great job our team is doing covering the games. And to read their own accounts of their experiences, visit our website at earlyshow.cbsnews.com."
Here is the full transcript of the segment:
8:07AM SEGMENT:
JULIE CHEN: Well, the Olympic games are more than a chance for the world's athletes to excel, they also give the host nation an opportunity to shine. For China and it's 1.3 billion people, the Beijing games are feeding a groundswell of pride. CBS News correspondent Barry Petersen is in Beijing with the story. Good morning to you, Barry.
BARRY PETERSEN: Good morning, Julie. Well, China wants to throw a successful Olympics party and so far they're doing just fine. With plenty of enthusiasm spreading from Beijing pretty much around the world. The wow factor started with that $100 million opening ceremony. And Beijing has the welcome banners out to a half million visitors. More foreigners at one time than the country has seen since the Mongol invasion a thousand years ago. And $40 billion spent on Beijing is impressing first-time American visitors.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN: I think the thing that really struck me more than anything is just how vast the city is, you know. Our big cities, New York and L.A. and Atlanta, you know, they pale in comparison.
PETERSEN: From designer clothes to new cars, China is getting rich. Democracies once bragged that theirs was the only way to economic success. China is doing it the communist way.
[No Audio, Footage of Tiananmen Square protests]
Petersen: Today, the ambitions of most students are not about changing their country, but changing their lives.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN: The younger generation are being channeled. Their energy has been channeled into making money, getting rich.
PETERSEN: Rich, but not free. Religious activist Qua Wei Chi told us last week the police warned him to remain quiet or he might disappear. Sunday, on his way to the church that President Bush attended, he was arrested. As for the games, China has one ambition, win more gold than its athletic and super power arch rival, the United States. And here are some numbers that are not about gold medals. An American polling company asked Americans and Chinese what they thought about the direction of their country. About 23% of Americans said they were satisfied, but an astonishing 86% of Chinese said they're happy with where their country is going. Julie.
CHEN: Wow, that's quite a number. Barry Petersen in Beijing for us. Thanks, Barry. Well, we take pride in the great job our team is doing covering the games. And to read their own accounts of their experiences, visit our website at earlyshow.cbsnews.com.
—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Commrade Chen?
August 11, 2008 - 14:05 ET by AgentAmericanTalk about propaganda piece! Goebbels, though not a communist, would shed a tear for Commrade Chen!
Drill ANWAR
only 86% ??
August 11, 2008 - 14:17 ET by SouthJersey1953"...an astonishing 86% of Chinese said they're happy with where their country is going."
The other 14% have been placed in slave labor camps for speaking poorly about their country.
It's all up from here!
August 11, 2008 - 14:18 ET by SickofLibsYeah, Chen, communism and totalitarian regimes are just fabulous, if you consider an average family income of $6000/yr 'prosperous'.
86% are happy where their country is going? And why wouldn't they be happy considering most of the population didn't have a pot to piss in 10 years ago?
Not surprised
August 12, 2008 - 08:05 ET by pbanks7I'd be happy too. Many Chinese, for the first time in their lives, have actual discretionary spending money.
When I consider the deficit spending problems, tax increases, foreign policy issues, the price of gas and all the other fiscal problems that are caused by government, then blamed on free enterprise, I'm not so happy with the direction our country is going.
MSM - shaping all the perceptions you need to believe, then confirming it with a poll.
"The communist way..."
August 11, 2008 - 14:31 ET by trak65I'm no CommSimp, but I have to agree with the gist of Barry Peterson's summary: China is in fact allowing a lot of economic freedom while still being pretty stingy about political freedom. China is staying communist and prospering economically in many ways vis-a-vis other communist regimes, past and present.
The poll sounds very sketchy...but, if true, it probably shows how much the media's message can shape public opinion.
what a joke
August 11, 2008 - 16:16 ET by TruthMongerthis is such a lame attempt at communist vindication
the more China adds capitalism, the more prosperous they become
or is that too subtle for these educated observers?
subtle like a freight train
as if the fall of the USSR wasn't enough, China's capitalistic success must be as humiliating as hell to the university commie crowd
Journalism is the opium of the liberals
Since more "economic
August 11, 2008 - 16:40 ET by ahusserSince more "economic freedom" is actually "capitalism" then the regime is now no more than a one party dictatorship that espouses capitalism. They can call themselves "communists" as they wish but communism as an economic system in China seems to be dead or dying. I have no idea what the tax structure is and how much the newly rich capitalists have to pay but I am sure the party profits from this prosperity.
Captalism and Communism are economic systems not political systems. We just associate capitalism with Democracy (an open society) and certain "left-wing" dictatorships (closed society) with communism
just let her live
August 11, 2008 - 14:42 ET by gopstevejust let her live there...
be a "journalist" there and bash the country
see how far she gets and realizes the usa isn't really all that bad...
if she isn't jailed
Yes, good point Steve...
August 11, 2008 - 14:49 ET by trak65And I am looking forward to her follow-up story on all the dissatisfied Americans hiding out in ocean containers to sneak into China!
Chen then went to
August 11, 2008 - 14:40 ET by MidAmericaChen then went to correspondent Barry Petersen who declared: "From designer clothes to new cars, China is getting rich. Democracies once bragged that theirs was the only way to economic success. China is doing it the communist way."
Don't know this guys educational background but that was a really ignorant statement. China was a basket case trying to do it the communist way. It wasn't till they instituted market reforms that their economy took off. And secondly it is also because they have an almost inexhaustable low wage labor pool that they have become the worlds manufacturing center.
This is a major reason why
August 11, 2008 - 14:58 ET by deerjerkydaveThis is a major reason why I don't watch this tabloid trash. I don't want analysis from somebody who obviously has no understanding of history.
Let me give CBS a little history lesson: communism leads to bankruptcy. After the USSR collapsed due to bankruptcy, China got a little smart and realized that economic communism doesn't lead to prosperity. So they loosened their belts and opened up their econonmy to CAPITALISM. I remember hearing that Fidel Castro was not too happy when China did this.
The result has been multiple decades now of economic prosperity in China. Sure they still have a lot of controls, and corruption is a major problem, and they still have political communism which practices censorship heavily, has a one party state, and eliminates basic rights like freedom of religion and speech. You know, the kinds of things the libs want in this country.
Th communist way? Only in your dreams
August 11, 2008 - 15:17 ET by CobraManSomeone needs to remind this twit that capitalism and free market "reform" is NOT "the communist way." A centrally controlled manufacture, supply, and distribution market system is "the communist way," and that what China had under Mao when TENS of MILLIONS died of starvation and the greatest majority of their population lived in worse conditions than the poorest of our poor lived during the Great Depression. Just how "prosperous" was that? I sure hope WE never get that prosperous!
first of all, it's not Communism
August 11, 2008 - 15:17 ET by wizardjrFirt of all it's a fascist oligarchy not communism. Does anyone out there actually read Marx, even the Cliff Notes version, before making such idiotic statements?
The closest they had was Chairman Mao. He was a charismatic dictator using Marxist bafflegarb to steal everything for his gang of "leaders". He led them towards redistributionist economic ideals and State owned everything. He had a quasi-socialist model. The funny thing about redistributionists, it never seems to apply to the top tier. They still get limosines and mansions.
After killing all the educated people in the country he and his successors cratered the economy (as expected) with their idiotic brand of "Communism". So why did they change? There was not enough tax income to support a huge (and I mean huge) military. The only way to do that is to build the economy. The only way to do that is through some variant of Capitalism. There is nothing "Communist" about Shanghai. Even the rice farmers got into the act. They have been granted land title to their little patches and all the profit is their to earn (with appropriate taxes to the oligarchy of course).
Once again the MSM shows its ignorance and its love affair with "Communism". There isn't a dictator they can't adore. There isn't a failed philosophy they can't hold high.
Communism does not include
August 11, 2008 - 15:18 ET by robert108Communism does not include the concept of economic growth, so all their claimed growth comes from abandoning communist economic beliefs. Ultimately, they will have to free their people, or collapse. They are simply creating the illusion of growth by exploiting their working class. This is the ironic truth behind the lies of Karl Marx. The free enterprise system enriches the working class.
They're importing
August 11, 2008 - 15:52 ET by mattmThey're importing capitalism, but the government controls its distribution among the people. Kinda like what the Democrats want.
BTW 86% of Chinese are happy??? Could that be due to the fact that the unhappy ones are in jail, or dead? Or is it because they're afraid to tell the truth? Or is it because compared to the historical squalor they've lived under, they are doing great?
I don't think the guy that killed Todd Bachman was very happy... (funny, I don't remember foreign nationals getting murdered in America when the olympics were here)...
the bomb in Atlanta
August 11, 2008 - 16:07 ET by wizardjrRemember Richard Jewell and the Altanta bomb attempt?
Richard Jewell was falsely
August 11, 2008 - 16:32 ET by mattmRichard Jewell was falsely accused, but I forgot that someone was actually killed as a result...
Who did plant the bomb? An uhappy American - like Ted Kaczinski (the Left-wing unabomber) or some Islamic terrorist? Did they ever find out?
Still, no one person was specifically targeted. The news claimed the China murder was random and not directed at Americans, but the nutcase who committed the crime certainly didn't attack an asian person...
(Sorry, I just don't like commie regimes....although I have nothing against the chinese people - they invented spaghetti, after all)
Re: the Atlanta Olympic Bombing...
August 11, 2008 - 21:39 ET by on-the-rockswas attributed to Eric Robert Rudolph, whom the Feds captured in the NC mountains after his hiding out there for more than a year.
He was also blamed for bombing an abortion clinic in Birmingham, AL, an abortion clinic in Sandy Springs, GA, and a gay bar in midtown Atlanta.
I don't recall his legal status right now. I don't think he has said much about the "why" of the Olympic bombing. An Albany, GA woman died in the bombing and a Turkish news reporter died of a heart attack running to cover the story.
on-the-rocks
August 11, 2008 - 21:53 ET by JerIt's a little misleading to use the terms "attributed" and "blamed". He has confessed to the crimes, and his guilt has been clearly established. His legal status is "incarcerated...behind bars". One can't appeal from an admission of guilt to avoid trial.
Jer
I believe Kaczynski railed
August 11, 2008 - 21:56 ET by JerI believe Kaczynski railed against both the Left and the Right in his manifesto.
Jer
China is getting Rich!
August 11, 2008 - 16:19 ET by winston smithYes Barry. Wonderful, isn't it? Just ignore all the slave labor, child labor, illegal imports/exports, the fact that China is responsible for about 70% of the world's pollution. Yessiree, capitalism works well in China alright! Oh, and I'm sure the sale of missle techonolgy to the ChiComs courtesy of the Clintons and the sale of missles and WMDs to rogue states doesn't hurt them either. If the US were guilty of a fraction of the violations that China commits, people like Peterson would be belly-aching for reform.
Propaganda
August 11, 2008 - 17:17 ET by usbeefIt's such a coinicidence that the olympics end up in Red China this year right on the height of America's possible election of our first communist president Barack Hussein Nobama. Now the media can use Red China's economic growth to spread "See communism isn't all that bad" propaganda. Because eventually Obama is going to have to come out of stealth communist mode and lay his agenda out for everyone to clearly see if he is elected.
That may seem like a stretch but with a communist one step away from the White House and communists already in the house and senate in the likes of Pelosi and Reid, no amount of extreme propaganda would surprise me anymore.
"Push back the liberal hordes!!" - Mark Levin
If China is wealthy, it is only because of the US
August 11, 2008 - 18:39 ET by jefflebowskiThe US has allowed China to increase its wealth. If we were to rescind "most favored nation" trading status and cut off their money supply, how wealthy would they be? Our "leaders" have allowed billions to flow into China under unfair trade practices and we will one day pay for that. I would prefer we start treating China and Russia like the enemies they are and stop pretending that they want democracy.
Jeff Lebowski
www.angrywhitedude.c...
Do these idiots think
August 11, 2008 - 19:34 ET by GregEDo these idiots think anything about the fact that a fascist oligarchy, or a communist government, or anything similar, must suppress free thought and expression to continue to exist? Do they have any clue why the Chinese government blocks certain internet access and won't even let their people run searches for certain words that might lead them to read about freedom, Democracy, etc etc?
Oh yes, the Chinese people are just so happy that they can't speak their mind openly. If anyone thinks that people who can't do something so simple as that, are happy, their a nutjob.
At least Newsbusters isn't
August 12, 2008 - 10:15 ET by DarkCurrentAt least Newsbusters isn't banned or blocked in China Frankly few people here seem discontented. As long as the free market reforms of the last 2 decades continue to increase people's material well-being at a rapid pace, I don't think the average Zhou on the street cares a lot about politics. Certainly Americans wouldn't be at all happy if they were reduced to the standard of living of the average person in China, but that's not the point. Relative to where they've been, they are doing much better economically and even have more civil liberties as well.
Of course, US "news" organizations attributing the fact of strong economic growth and increasing prosperity to socialism or communism is ridiculous. It has in fact been due to the government pragmatically allowing the re-introduction of capitalism and the inherent entrepreneurial spirit in Chinese culture.
Well let's see how
August 11, 2008 - 20:19 ET by bws53Well let's see how prosperous things get when a shellfish invasion takes over their continent too.