Is there something in the tea over there, or do British movie critics imagine commentary on American politics is actually part of their job description?
Two years ago I noted how at least two British reviewers, James Christopher and Leo Lewis, panned "Spider-Man 3." Christopher lamented the "Sunday School morality" and "the inevitable flash of the American flag" while Lewis labeled as "disappointing... the inability of the director, Sam Raimi, to end the romp without a fleeting shot of the American flag."
Today, Times Online reviewer Debra Craine decided to timidly go where other hacks have gone before. From the penultimate paragraph from Craine's April 21 review of the upcoming "Star Trek" prequel (h/t separate e-mail tips from NB readers Jake Mathon and Charles Lovell):
The movie looks gorgeous. Gone is the gloom of the last Star Trek film, Nemesis (2002), which seemed cast in the depressing shadow of George Bush’s post-9/11 America. The prequel, though conceived before the rise of Barack Obama, taps into the optimism of his presidency.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Star Trek
April 21, 2009 - 13:23 ET by BeanManI admit that Star Trek, the original series and the first few movies were my favorites. I was a fan of the original series way back. My favorite movie was The Wrath of Kahn. It showed the fortitude of the crew and harkend to the fact that they didn't just use muscle and fire power, they used their heads and out-thought Kahn.
These are things that Obama cannot do. He went to Harvard but is no intellectual. He cannot learn from his mistakes because he doesn't believe he has ever made any. Kirk, on the other hand, continually realized his mistakes and learned from them which is why he became such a great starship captain.
There is no comparison between the crew of the Starship Enterprise and the current Administration. The former stands for courage, strength, and accountability, the latter for blaming everything on someone else.
Obama needs to realize that even if he were three months old when the Bay of Pigs happened, now that he is president, it rests squarely on his shoulders as does everything else any president has ever tried and succeeded or tried and failed before him.
Since government is coercion, politics is largely the exercise of deception regarding the intended use of coercion - George Orwell
To be fair, the comments
April 21, 2009 - 13:55 ET by moderncommentaries83To be fair, the comments that were there when I read this review earlier today took the reviewer to task for politicizing the film.
Aut viam inveniam aut faciam
I'll wait for the DVD of "Star Trek 90210"
April 21, 2009 - 14:08 ET by UndercoverConservative<GEEK> but even as of the previews, when they show the building of the Entrprise with carbon arc welders...did no one read the source material? Is it more important to "reimagine" old properties instead of new ones? I'm lookin' at you, "Battlestar Galactica"! Seeing a pampered Kirk running cars off of cliffs only dampened my enthusiasm further. <\GEEK>
WWW.GS2AC.COM. 2nd Amendment Grass Roots Action in the Bay Area, CA. We're not all "Breakfast Cereal" folks here! :)
Wow!
April 21, 2009 - 14:19 ET by happyuscitizenWhat A Galactically Stupid review!!!
What has "journalism" come to? They must be getting talking points for the Garofelo Institute for Galactically Incompetent.
"I'm just a big fat hairy American Winning Machine!" - Ricky Bobby
Wow!
April 21, 2009 - 14:27 ET by happyuscitizenWhat has "journalism" come to? They must be getting talking points for the Garofelo Institute for Galactically Incompetent.
"Gone is the gloom"? You would swear these Lefties had just been released from the Gulag after having rubbed elbows with the likes of Sakharov & Soljenitsin for the last eight years. Pull your head out Craine then you might see the light.
"conceived before the rise of Barack Obama,
taps into the optimism of his presidency", yeah well the Germans were as optomistic at the rise of Hitler because he promised Hope & Change as well
*rolls eyes*
April 21, 2009 - 14:29 ET by katainkenthow can a person who reviews films blatantly ignore how long it takes for a film to get 'into the can'. Silly reviewer.... get a political blog if you want to slobber on politicians.
I love to help the helpless but I'm not gonna help the clueless ~Dennis Miller
When the musical
April 21, 2009 - 15:30 ET by Chris NormanWhen the musical "Annie" first debuted way back in the seventies, I read somewhere that the creator of it was quoted as saying when he first started writing it, he meant it as an "antidote" to the "bleakness" of the Nixon/Ford years, but once Jimmy Carter was elected, he meant it as a "salute" to the new "hope" and "optimism" that Carter was bringing. A few years later, after we all knew that Carter was a disaster, I thought about that producer's pompous claim and wondered if Little Orphan Annie was somewhere crying her little blank eyes out...
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
hmm
April 21, 2009 - 15:40 ET by RowaneI'll wait for a few more reviews before making up my mind but, if more like this come out I think I'll pass on this flick.
a small reminder
April 22, 2009 - 16:03 ET by jazzact13Don't let one idiot (who wasn't even involved in making the movie) spoil it for you. Here's something that was on NB a few days ago, about the cast themselves.
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2009/04/13/star-trek-cast-visits-soldiers-kuwait-media-couldnt-care-less
"Thoroughly worldly people never understand even the world; they rely altogether on a few cynical maxims which are not true."
Chesterton, Orthodoxy
Another potential problem
April 21, 2009 - 15:49 ET by bioteachedIf the last Star Trek movie was released in 2002, most likely the production began in 2001. This means that the movie was not "cast in the depressing shadow of George bush's post-9/11 America." Instead it was cast in the pre-9/11 America. If Ms. caine can make the assumption of the last sentence, then my assumption is equally correct.
Didn't Willy Nelson write a song about that?
April 21, 2009 - 16:04 ET by kgObama on my miiiind
Obama on my mind
"DumbAssity of Dope"
All liberal claptrap
April 21, 2009 - 18:42 ET by slickwillie2001Star Trek and Star Wars and most science fiction is generally bogged down with liberal political correctness. Always world government, money doesn't exist, no corporations or if there are they are evil, etc. Star Trek has that thing (?) that's a perfect mirror of our United Nations, like they ever did any good. Don't even get me started on BSG.
An Idiot, This Reviewer Is...
April 21, 2009 - 23:09 ET by The7SticksFist of all, the last Star Trek movie took about four years to make when it was released in 2002, so how can it be a post-9/11 movie if it was being written during the last years of the Clinton administration? I heard that among Star Trek fans, it was pretty lousy anyway, so no love was really lost. Love was only lost with the Enterprise series ("Way to tarnish the franchise, Bakula!".)
I'm still going to see the new Star Trek anyway, especially after that story about the cast and crew meeting with our soldiers in Iraq. I was just salivating over that new Starship Enterprise they showed off in the commercials.
Incidentally, I saw Spider-Man 3 on DVD, and the main problem I had with it was that there were too many villians he had to fight, thereby diluting the whole narrative of the movie.
The article reads, "The
April 22, 2009 - 05:42 ET by HockeyKidThe article reads, "The prequel, though conceived before the rise of Barack Obama, taps into the optimism of his presidency."
So this mental midget actually says, right in the article, the equivalent of, "This isn't a valid conclusion, but I'm making it anyway."
Why not just write, "I realize that movies are entertainment conceived and written well in advance of this year's political events, leaving no room for the injection of political commentary. But I'm going to inject Duh One into my review anyway, because he just gives me goosebumps!"? At least that would be honest, if not exactly journalism.
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me