CBS Spins Setback for Obama on Health Into 'Warning from the President'

Photo of Brent Baker.

A night after CBS and NBC skipped the assessment from the chief of the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) that the Senate and House health plans won't meet President Obama's pledge to not increase deficit spending, the two networks caught up only when Obama, reacting to “anxiety” even from Democrats, addressed the setback to his quest late Friday. CBS anchor Katie Couric spun the bad news for Obama into “a warning” from him about the ominous fate which awaits Americans if he does not succeed.

“Also tonight, a warning from the President,” she teased Friday's CBS Evening News before a clip of Obama with a very suspect claim: “If we don't get health care reform done now, then no one's health insurance is going to be secure.” Couric introduced the story by portraying Obama as the hero trying to reach a noble goal: “President Obama today continued his hard sell for health care reform, but he also had to do a little doctoring, treating a case of sticker shock over the latest proposals for insuring nearly every American.” Chip Reid related that “with anxiety surging over the cost of health care reform, the President today sought to reassure the public and nervous members of Congress” a day after the CBO director “sent shock waves through Capitol Hill.”

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Over on NBC, anchor Brian Williams at least accurately painted Obama as on the defensive with a “hastily-scheduled” public appearance after 4 PM EDT on a Friday: “One day after the Congressional Budget Office said a Democratic health care reform plan would actually cost money instead of saving it, President Obama put together a hastily-scheduled appearance at the White House for a pep talk.” Kelley O'Donnell explained “signs of trouble for his health care overhaul” led him to deliver “that quick speech with a stern and unwavering message for Congress.”

My Thursday night NB item, “Only ABC Cites 'Devastating' CBO Judgment & 50%+ Tax Rates to Pay for Health Care,” recounted:

“Congress's chief budget analyst delivered a devastating assessment yesterday of the health care proposals drafted by congressional Democrats,” the Washington Post reported Friday, but of the broadcast network evening newscasts on Thursday only ABC's World News related how, as Jake Tapper put it, “the President's case was dealt a blow today” when CBO Director Douglas Elmendorf warned the health plans will require massive additional spending....

(On Friday night, ABC didn't mention health care or Obama's late in the day pronouncement.)

The story on the Friday, July 17 CBS Evening News:

KATIE COURIC: In Washington, President Obama today continued his hard sell for health care reform, but he also had to do a little doctoring, treating a case of sticker shock over the latest proposals for insuring nearly every American. Here's our chief White House correspondent, Chip Reid.

CHIP REID: With anxiety surging over the cost of health care reform, the President today sought to reassure the public and nervous members of Congress.

OBAMA: Health insurance reform cannot add to our deficit over the next decade and I mean it.

REID: His statement comes one day after a congressional budget director sent shock waves through Capitol Hill with testimony that the bills now working their way through Congress would send spending on health care soaring.

DOUGLAS ELMENDORF, CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE: The legislation significantly expands the federal responsibility for health care costs.

REID: That's exactly the opposite of what the President has repeatedly promised, that health care reform will bend the long-term cost curve downward. A promise he repeated today.

OBAMA: The bill I sign will also include my commitment and the commitment of Congress to slow the growth of health care costs over the long run.

REID: But Republicans say the budget director's prediction that the cost curve will go up means the Democrats' plan will break the bank. Many Democrats are worried, too. About three dozen first-term House Democrats today voiced their concerns about cost in a meeting with chief of staff Rahm Emanuel, a meeting the President dropped by. Members in the meeting say President seemed open to suggestions but was adamant about passing it this year.

OBAMA: If we don't get health care reform done now, then no one's health insurance is going to be secure.

REID: In another effort to try to keep control of the health care debate, the White House announced today that the President will hold a prime time news conference next Wednesday. Katie?

From the NBC Nightly News, following the lead story on Obama addressing the NAACP:

BRIAN WILLIAMS: Some of the intensity of last night carried over today to the President's push for health care. One day after the Congressional Budget Office said a Democratic health care reform plan would actually cost money instead of saving it, President Obama put together a hastily scheduled appearance at the White House for a pep talk. On Capitol Hill. Correspondent Kelly O'Donnell with us tonight for more on this. Kelly, good evening.

KELLY O'DONNELL: Good evening, Brian. Clearly the President wanted to get in the last word of the week after he could see there was new resistance and signs of trouble for his health care overhaul, so he added that quick speech with a stern and unwavering message for Congress. Now the issues are basically cost and time. It really set off alarm bells when the Congressional Budget Office said that the plans would increase spending, not reduce it. And today, key Democrats and Republicans -- moderates the President needs -- made a direct appeal to the White House asking for more time to resolve these differences. But as you'll hear, the President's answer was a definite no.

PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Those who are betting against this happening this year are badly mistaken. We are going to get this done. We will reform health care. It will happen this year. I'm absolutely convinced of that.

O'DONNELL: And Brian what happens here next week will be critical in this debate because the differences are still so wide. The President did soften a bit acknowledging this is tough work, but he is not yet ready to budge on some of the issues that Congress thinks are most important right now. Brian?

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Pathological liars, the whole lot of 'em...

 I'm sorry, but I cannot believe a word, not a single ever-loving word, that
comes out of the mouths of Obama, Biden, Pelosi, Ried, Frank, Dodd, Kerry, Kennedy, et al.  NOT.A.SINGLE.WORD...

Nor do I, Fuzzle...

Nor do I.

sheesh

“If we don't get health care reform done now, then no one's health insurance is going to be secure.”

What the sam hill is that supposed to mean, you got a plan B to run them out of town!!!

It does sound a bit like a

It does sound a bit like a threat, doesn't it? 

The reality is it's just the opposite. Passing the reform he wants guarantees no one's insurance is secure.

Yeah, it's a threat that

Yeah, it's a threat that sounds a lot like "I'll hold my breath until I turn blue", or "It's my ball and I'll just go home with it unless you play by my rules."

Your rules suck air, POTUS, please do hold your breath.

Maybe....

The Jug-earred Village Idiot  plans on dismissing all of the CEOs of all the health insurance companies for non-performance and incompetence just like he did with the CEO of GM.  He'll offer a nice serverance package, and they will all go quietly.

 Then he can infuse the insurance companies with yes-men (and yes-women) and suck-wad drones loyal to him, and he now has control over health care without a vote from Congress?

Ya know, I just can't find the words to describe just how much I despise this man!!

This is why....

This is why Couric has slipped into the realm of irrelevance.    

Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

TH... You hit the nail on

TH...

You hit the nail on the head.

Not just her either.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

And she's looking more

And she's looking more masculine with each passing day. 

Where are the cries of "fear

Where are the cries of "fear mongering" that we heard throughout the Bush years from the media and their left wing friends?

Questions For The President's News Conference

1.  It's apparent the American public is not behind your plan.  They either don't understand what you're doing; don't believe what you're saying; and lastly, don't think you and your administration know what you're doing.  So, what's your response to a skeptical electorate.

 2. All things considered, what the hell is the rush?  Why are you insisting this be done by the end of August - where are you going?

 3. Tell us specifically, every group, in goverment and out of goverment, exempted from this planned overhaul, starting with you and your administration.  Will you and your family and your administration participate in the new plan, or are you exempt.

 Assuming he answers the three questions, there will be no need for a 4th question, it'll be over and out by then.

If they don't get it done,

If they don't get it done, Obama will just appoint a Health Care Czar to head a Health Care Committeee and it will all be done by decree, the Congress be damned. Because Obama "knows" that this is much too important to let a little thing like "the people" stand in the way of it.

Because "the people" don't know what's good for them.


 

mb... I wouldn't doubt

mb...

I wouldn't doubt this may be tried, but if he did do this, even plenty on his side of the aisle in congress would be up in arms ...along with the 'r' side of the aisle.

Well, I think that's what would happen...sure could be wrong, wouldn't be the first time...or last.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

I'm not so confident BT

It's worked well for him so far, hardly a peep and he has the banks, auto industry, and now working on health care.

If you control the countrys' wealth and health you've pretty much got it all.

It may be time for a major sea change, sooner rather than later!

IT... LOL...like I said,

IT...

LOL...like I said, I could be wrong.

One thing about it, we shall see just what happens.

A major sea change indeed. ...somethings got to give, one way or another.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

It may be time for a major

It may be time for a major sea change, sooner rather than later!

Indeed!

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2295284/posts

BT...

I don't think even he could get away with that. He is (finally) getting folks angry & making some of Congress and the Senate evaluate what is going on & push back (probably because they are in fear for their jobs, but fine by me if that is what it takes)...if Obama starts to completely overide all the checks on his power, I do think that is when forces beyond his control (military) come say: "Okay, dude...time for you to be walked out of the White House."

And if he can just start making up his own rules, this is no longer America. America is then gone. I pray it does not get that bad!

"Sick" and Tired

This whole "heathcare" issue is making me "sick". I'm sick and tired of this inexperienced manchild, Chicago punk and his adolescent friends in the media and his administration telling me and all decent, mature Americans how to live our lives and spend our money. The Constitution, the 10th Amendment in particular, specifically states that the federal government has no right to do this. Get the hell out of the states' business, you fools. A hero?? Courageous?? Give me a break. Got along quite well without you before I met you, Barry et.al. Will do very well after you are gone. America doesn't need you fools. Cut the crap! Leave us alone!

P.S. Read the short story "The Family That Dwelt Apart" by E. B. White. It says it all.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

This isn't a warning from a

This isn't a warning from a courageous President, this is a threat from a garden variety, brass knuckled Chicago union thug.  Like all bullies, he needs to be confronted directly and punched right in the mouth (rhetorically speaking).

"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered."  -George Best

check this out

http://hotair.com/headlines/?p=46082

Now this yanks my chain, there are thousands of people that can;t get private health insurance because of pre exsisting conditions.

There you go--spoiling my afternoon

"The goal is to reduce everyone’s consumption of health care and to ensure that people have the same health-care experience, regardless of ability to pay."

 Why do I get the feeling that Fidel Castro is sitting out on his veranda right now, with a glass of rum and a huge cigar--laughing his ass off.

"If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - General George Patton Jr

Small business

Here's the plan. This will put smalll business out of business. Then we will have only big business. Then the government will take over the big businesses ( a la GM ). It's socialism, fascism, communism rolled into one! DUH!

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

Not a Solution

Keith Hennessey, a former member of President George W. Bush's cabinet, pointed out last week that even the Bamster's Obamacare will strand about 8 million of the uninsured because they will get fined, yet not be able to afford to purchase health insurance for what the fines cost them.

Does the House Really Want to Raise Taxes on Eight Million Uninsured People: http://keithhennessey.com

The Bamster's plan doesn't come close to covering the mythical 47 million uninsured, yet spends us into oblivion. Why is there no rational measure of success with all these plans? Maybe because the objective is socialism and not insurance coverage?

slick--

"Keith Hennessey, a former member of President George W. Bush's cabinet, pointed out last week that even the Bamster's Obamacare will strand about 8 million of the uninsured because they will get fined, yet not be able to afford to purchase health insurance for what the fines cost them."

What reasons would they be fined for?

Re fines

Under the plan in Congress, individuals that do not have health insurance would be fined via their income tax forms, 2.5% of their income. The Bamster gets around his commitment to not raise taxes on the middle class by calling this a 'fine' rather than a tax.

This is intended to force young people that think they don't need insurance into a plan. The article points out however that some folks will not be able to get insured for 2.5% of their income, so they will remain uninsured and the 'fine' will in effect become a tax on them. 

  One way to stop this

  One way to stop this healthcare fiasco once and for all is to insist that members of congress and their families will be under the same plan and have no more access to healthcare than ordinary Americans.

George Carlin

"OK Sherriff; we're gonna f**k you now...

But we're gonna f**k you slow!"

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

Katie, Katie, Katie

These MSM folks seem to believe it's not their healthcare that's going to be affected by Obama's disaster of a program. How come they haven't figured this out?  Apparently they just don't ask enough questions about this stuff. 

They'll have their chance, on Wednesday night, to ask questions.  Anyone want to be it will be more of "Where's Michelle shopping for clothes these days?" instead of "THe CBO says health care could bust the budget.  Do  you really want to rush this through and get another Cap and Trade/Stimulus Bill that wasn't well thought out and no one read?"

Election 2008-God's way of showing us that elections count.  

Don't have a link, may have

Don't have a link, may have read it here, can't remember, but michelle is working on opening schools in the middle east to teach them english and the american way so they won't hate us and want to blow us up, how about a question on that!! Its a good one since teachers here are being layed off by the hundreds in florida. Charlie red coat took 15 billion in stimulas money, but everyone  from council to cops are getting layed off anyway. But they can build a new baseball stadium that we don't need for millions, and will only employ 10% of florida residents, so they ship in 90% more from out of state?? where is the logic in that? maddness I tell ya

Hey! Barry Obama! Listen

Hey! Barry Obama! Listen up.

We are going to say this again to you. Scoop the bat snot out of your ears this time. Stop having press conferences and listen to us, for a change.

Americans are NOT afraid of reform. We do it all the time.  You may have heard of the War of Independence. Happened back in the 18th century. It was in all the papers at the time. That was reform.

But we know the difference between efffective reform  versus the violent destruction of something that works pretty good but needs a little fixing in the right places. Like our health care system.

Do you not get the distinction?

When your car needs gas, do you blow the car up, or do you put some gas in it? When your roof has a little leak, do you bulldoze the house flat, or do you fix the leak?

Wake up, Barry. We ain't buying your health care rationing program. 

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

o-Dumb-uh

I have noted that many elected officials, both Democrats and Republicans, called upon America to unite behind Obama.
Well, I want to make it clear to all who will listen that I AM NOT uniting behind Obama!

I will respect the Office which he holds, and I will acknowledge his abilities as an orator and wordsmith and pray for him, BUT that is it.

I have begun today to see what I can do to make sure that He is a one-term President!
Why am I doing this?

It is because I do not share Obama's vision or Value system for America;
I do not share his Abortion beliefs;
I do not share his radical Marxist's concept of re-distributing wealth;
I do not share his stated views on raising taxes on those who make $150,000+ (the ceiling has been changed three times since August);

I do not share his view that America is Arrogant;
I do not share his view that America is not a Christian Nation;
I do not share his view that the military should be reduced by 25%;
I do not share his view of amnesty and giving more to illegal's than American Citizens who need help;
I do not share his views on homosexuality and his definition of marriage;
I do not share his views that Radical Islam is our friend and Israel is our enemy who should give up any land;
I do not share his spiritual beliefs (at least the ones he has made public);
I do not share his beliefs on how to re-work the healthcare system in America;
I do not share his Strategic views of the Middle East, and certainly do not share his plan to sit down with terrorist regimes such as Iran.

Bottom line, my America is vastly different from Obama's, and I have a higher obligation to my Country and my God to do what is Right!

For eight (8) years, the Liberals in our Society, led by numerous entertainers who would have no platform and no real credibility but for their celebrity status, have attacked President Bush, his family, and his spiritual beliefs!
They have not moved toward the center in their beliefs and their philosophies, and they never came together nor compromised their personal beliefs for the betterment of our Country! They have portrayed my America as a land where everything is tolerated except being intolerant!

They have been a vocal and irreverent minority for years; they have mocked and attacked the very core values so important to the founding and growth of our Country!

They have made every effort to remove the name of God or Jesus Christ from our Society! They have challenged capital punishment, the right to bear firearms, and the most basic principles of our criminal code; they have attacked one of the most fundamental of all Freedoms, the right of free speech!
Unite behind Obama? Never!

I am sure many of you who read this think that I am going overboard, but I refuse to retreat one more inch in favor of those whom I believe are the embodiment of Evil!

PRESIDENT BUSH made many mistakes during his Presidency, and I am not sure how history will judge him.
However, I believe that he weighed his decisions in light of the long established Judeo-Christian principles of our Founding Fathers!!!

Majority rules in America , and I will honor the concept; however, I will fight with all of my power to be a voice in opposition to Obama and "his goals for America ."

I am going to be a thorn in the side of those who, if left unchecked, will destroy our Country!! Any more compromise is more defeat!

I pray that the results of this election will wake up many who have sat on the sidelines and allowed the Socialist-Marxist anti-God crowd to slowly change so much of what has been good in America !

"Error of Opinion may be tolerated where Reason is left free to combat it." (Thomas Jefferson)
God bless you and God bless our Country!!! (Please, please, please. Pass this on if you agree.)

Thanks for your time, be safe. "In God We Trust"

'If we ever forget that we're one nation under God, then we will be a nation gone under.'
- Ronald Reagan

I

Remember, only two defining forces have ever offered to die for you, Jesus Christ and the American Soldier

kilrod

I must say, that is one of the most profound posts I've ever read. For what it's worth; you made my day!

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

Kilrod...

How dare you, sir?  Assuming that the majority or the readers will feel you went overboard is comlete and utter garbage!

I agree with everything else you said. ;-)

Well written, sir! 

Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

kilrod... Amen to all of

kilrod...

Amen to all of that!

I'm with ya all the way.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

kilrod what a great post! 

kilrod what a great post!  I agree, I cannot get behind someone whose fundamental beliefs are so opposite of my own.  I believe President Bush's mistakes, whatever they might have been, came from a man who truly desired the best for his country.  I think Obama is acting in what he considers the best interests of the global population.  That is not his job and will sink our country as he lowers our country to others.

Kilrod..Excellent! One the

Kilrod..Excellent! One the best posts I've read on here.

By pointing to Obama's pronouncements,  you illustrate one of this churlish trickster's most used takeover techniques: to falsely describe the current situation we find ourselves in order order to create a sense of crisis in the hearts of the American people.

It is the media's most sacred obligation to expose lying politicians like Obama. They have resoundly failed.

The Founders noted the importance of having an educated and informed citizenry to make sure scoundrels like Obama never get elected.That's the point of having a free, truthful and vigorous press: to let us know what is really going on.

Obama is exactly the kind of political tyrant the US Constitution was meant to protect us from.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

The arrogance...

...of BHO is absolutely stunning....who the hell is he "warning"....I heard a threat.....and he's the only threat that I'm aware of to our health system....I hate to think I'm actually wishing part of my life away.....but the mid-term elections can't get here soon enough so the independents that were duped by this dope can act on their buyers remorse......

 

God Bless America!  The one I live in...Not the one obama wants to establish.

 

not... I'm with ya

not...

I'm with ya here...

I just hope and pray the ACORN thievery that is going on big time behind the scenes with the tax-payers funding them and sister groups, let alone all the usual tactics they have used for generations that the Independents along with the rest on the right side of the aisle can overcome them...we have to win...I don't even like to think what will happen to us if we don't regarding all the destruction O and his crew will do to this nation...they are doing a great job as it is so far.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

You got it!  We've got

You got it!  We've got chicken little for a president constantly telling us the sky is falling.  LET IT FALL ALREADY! 

I bet we can survive without this health care bill.  I just don't think we will with everything he's already done.

Call/Fax Monday

From Dick Morris: Seeing his popularity draining away rapidly, President Obama has cynically decided to ram through the complex health care legislation in two weeks, without debate or amendment. He is going to give up the attempt to win sixty votes in the Senate and will use the budget reconciliation procedure - which is only used for budget bills - to push it through with fifty votes...

http://www.dickmorri... or fax Monday morning...

Max Baucus / (202) 224-2651(Office) (202) 224-9412 (Fax)

Jon Tester / Phone: (202) 224-2644 Fax: (202) 224-8594

Byron Dorgan Phone: (202) 224-2644 Fax: (202) 224-8594

Kent Conrad Phone: (202) 224-2043 Fax: (202) 224-7776

South Dakota-Tim Johnson Phone (202) 224-5842 Fax: 202-228-5765

Nebraska-Ben Nelson Fax: Phone: 202-224-6551

Fax: 202-228-0012

Arkansas-Mark Pryor Phone: (202) 224-2353. Fax: (202) 228-0908

Blanche Lincoln Phone: 202-224-4843 Fax: 202-228-1371

Louisiana-Mary Landrieu Phone: 202-224-5824

Fax: 202-224-9735

North Carolina-Kay Hagan Phone: 202-224-6342. Fax: 202-228-2563

Indiana-Evan Bayh Phone: 202-224-5623 Fax: 202-228-1377

Connecticut-Joe Lieberman Phone: 202-224-4041. Fax: 202-224-9750

Maine -Olympia Snow Phone: 202-224-5344. Toll Free: 800-432-1599. Fax: 202-224-1946

Susan Collins Phone: 207-945-0417. Fax: 207-990-4604

survivor... Glad you have

survivor...

Glad you have the numbers here for others.

I will be calling when this hits the floor...and we see how and who are leaning towards what before the votes.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

obama ...

**This post's content has been deleted and the user banned ~ Management**

trhug--

Hinkley is still alive, but I don't think it's wise to wish assasination on anyone...especially on a public message board.

This post should be deleted

This post should be deleted and trhug should be banned.

WOW!

Kilrod's post needs to be read to Congress.