Less than a week after likening conservative blogger Michelle Malkin to a “mashed-up bag of meat” on his Countdown show, MSNBC host Keith Olbermann on Monday called out former President George H.W. Bush for daring to call him and fellow MSNBC host Rachel Maddow “sick puppies,” as Olbermann described Bush’s words from a recent interview as a “weird term."
As he characterized Bush as being hypocritical for making the comment while denouncing the incivility in American politics, Olbermann accused Bush of helping to create the climate of incivility himself in 1988 with the Willie Horton ad, although the ad Olbermann was referring to which showed a photograph of Horton – and which Olbermann displayed images of – was produced by an independent group, the National Security Political Action Committee. The Bush campaign never used Horton’s image, but instead ran the “Revolving Door” ad attacking Michael Dukakis’s support for a prison furlough program.
MSNBC political analyst Richard Wolffe, formerly of Newsweek, came aboard to discuss the issue, and, as he seemed oblivious to Olbermann's history of name-calling and over-the-top attacks on conservatives -- such as indirectly calling Ann Coulter and Bill O'Reilly "dogs," making a crude joke comparing Sarah Palin to a pitbull, and even calling former President George W. Bush a "fascist" -- Wolffe defended Olbermann's history of attacking former President George W. Bush. Wolffe: "But it`s neither sick nor puppy‑like to point out that invading the wrong country, leading to unnecessary thousands of deaths isn`t actually just name-calling."
After contrasting Bush 43's governing style with that of his father, Wolffe soon continued: "His son took a wholly different path and created a whole ocean full of sick puppies."
After Olbermann again linked Bush 41 to the Willie Horton ad, Wolffe ended up tying in the recent "tea party" protesters:
OLBERMANN: Would you agree that there`s no overstatement in this, that it was -- when he ran for President the first time to succeed Mr. Reagan, he was the one who turned -- he with Mr. Ailes, he with the ad for Willie Horton -- these are the men who turned the corner on to the street about which the potholes therein he’s complaining about?
WOLFFE: Well, Karl Rove didn`t come out of nothing, you know. Roger Ailes begat Lee Atwater, who begat Karl Rove and so on and so forth, and we end up with tea parties.
AUDIO CLIP OF FORMER PRESIDENT GEORGE H.W. BUSH, IN OPENNG TEASER: Keith Olbermann and Rachel Maddow, I mean, here are a couple of sick puppies.KEITH OLBERMANN, IN OPENING TEASER: In the middle of a plea for less name‑calling in politics, President George H.W. Bush calls us names, including “horrible” and “obscene.” Rachel is obscene? Rachel isn`t obscene to inanimate objects....
OLBERMANN, BEFORE COMMERCIAL BREAK AT 8:25 P.M.: Speaking of “when conservatives attack,” George H.W. Bush rips into me and Rachel. Or at least he shot outwards. But what does it say that he did so while complaining about the loss of civility towards presidents and in our political dialogue, and given that he was the one who sent that snowball rolling down the hill?...
OLBERMANN: It`s a kind of political version of the famous cynical observation from Morty the Mortician in the movie Chinatown, “middle of a drought and the water commissioner drowns.” It`s normally not effective to complain about coarsened, below the belt dialogue, when the person voicing that complaint either abetted or launched that very kind of discourse. Nor is it particularly effective to assail name-calling by calling somebody names. In our third story on the Countdown, that is what former President George H.W. Bush did when he chose to describe me and my colleague Rachel Maddow as "sick puppies." And it`s even more unfortunate given the context. The former President making the marks on the eve of hosting President Barack Obama, who went to Texas A&M to laud Mr. Bush for his support of volunteerism and public service.
President Bush had said that President Obama, quote, "is entitled to civil treatment and intellectual honesty when it comes to critics." But in an interview with CBS Radio News, he had more to say about the tone of national discourse. Here it comes:
GEORGE H.W. BUSH AUDIO: I don`t like it. I think the cables have a lot to do with it. I’m thinking back to when I was President, we got tons of criticism, but it didn`t seem, day in and day out, quite as personal as some of these talk show people. And it`s not just the right. There are plenty of people on the left. If you want me to name a couple of names, I`ll be glad to do that for you.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Go ahead.
BUSH: Keith Olbermann and Rachel Maddow. I mean, here are a couple of sick puppies. And the way they treat my son and treat anybody that`s opposed to their point-of-view is just horrible.
OLBERMANN: The former President also said his son had been treated obscenely. It`s hard to imagine anybody more civil, less obscene that my colleague and friend Ms. Maddow. And, as I said when I called in to her show on Friday night, it`s easy to understand how the father of any President might have a blind spot when it comes to how his son was doing. But consider the pre‑W. days. In 1988, the first President Bush employed Roger Ailes as a political consultant, basically in charge of the media message. In so doing, Mr. Bush became the father of the process that took us to the place we are now. They were the men who ran the notoriously offensive, race‑baiting Willie Horton ad, when Bush was running for President in 1988 against the Democratic nominee, Michael Dukakis.
And there was the scam on Dan Rather, when then-candidate Bush pretended to be ambushed by then-anchor Rather in an interview for the CBS Evening News. It was all pre‑arranged by Mr. Bush and Mr. Ailes.
So the narrative arc goes, right on through the actual egregious non‑news from Roger Ailes` Fox News. Aides of President Obama this weekend expanding on comments by White House Communications Director Anita Dunn that Fox News basically acts as a wing of the Republican party.
RAHM EMANUEL, WHITE HOUSE CHIEF OF STAFF: It`s not so much a conflict with Fox News. But unlike, I suppose, the way to look at it – and the way the President looks at it and we look at it, is it`s not a news organization so much as it has a perspective. And that`s a different take.
DAVID AXELROD, OBAMA ADVISOR: The only argument Anita was making is that they`re not really a news station. If you watch even – it`s not just their commentators, but a lot of their news programming. It`s really not news. It`s pushing a point-of-view. And the bigger thing is that other news organizations, like yours, ought not to treat them that way. And we`re not going to treat them that way. We`re going to appear on their shows. We`re going to participate, but understanding that they represent a point-of-view.
OLBERMANN: Let`s bring in MSNBC political analyst Richard Wolffe, also senior strategist at Public Strategies and author of Renegade: The Making of A President. Richard, good to see you.
RICHARD WOLFFE, MSNBC POLITICAL ANALYST: Good to be with you.
OLBERMANN: Sick puppies.
WOLFFE: Yes.
OLBERMANN: I`m glad, since Rachel and I have been both battling these respiratory things, I`m glad he’s concerned for our health. But do you decry name-calling by name-calling?
WOLFFE: Yes. Well, of course, we’ve all been called something worse than sick puppies in the last hour or two. But beyond the irony, let`s just take a step back here because, yes, it`s understandable, he’s defensive about his son. But it`s neither sick nor puppy‑like to point out that invading the wrong country, leading to unnecessary thousands of deaths isn`t actually just name-calling.
I mean, there is something substantive there about what his son did as President. And in his more reflective moments -- and I think we can all agree that the 41st President of the United States is generally a reflective person -- he should look at his own record in the Gulf War, the first Gulf War, and wonder why, not just because there were no cables in the same way -- I guess he’s not meaning underwater cables. But it wasn`t just the public discourse that led him not to face the same kind of criticism. It`s that he operated differently as President. His son took a wholly different path and created a whole ocean full of sick puppies.
OLBERMANN: Would you agree that there`s no overstatement in this, that it was -- when he ran for President the first time to succeed Mr. Reagan, he was the one who turned -- he with Mr. Ailes, he with the ad for Willie Horton -- these are the men who turned the corner on to the street about which the potholes therein he’s complaining about?
WOLFFE: Well, Karl Rove didn`t come out of nothing, you know. Roger Ailes begat Lee Atwater, who begat Karl Rove and so on and so forth, and we end up with tea parties. Yes, the discourse in politics changed. It coincided with all sorts of changes in the media. But the ads that they cut, the kind of campaigns that they established led directly to 2002 and 2004. And, you know, has it become meaner and tougher? You bet. But the politics of national security, as it was played out, was established by this group of characters. And they came out, sadly, of his own administration.
OLBERMANN: And you can hit those low points. I mean, the next one that significant, I suppose, was the campaign against Max Cleland.
WOLFFE: Right.
OLERMANN: And that’s, you know, these are the stars that shine in this dark night that President Bush is complaining about, and calling us this weird term. Explain the White House, this White House versus Fox News, the rebound effect here. A lot of them seem unhappy about that network, very unhappy. And the quote ‑‑ buried in that Rahm Emanuel quote was the way the president sees it. He’s not just saying that they sit around and Rahm Emanuel is throwing things at the screen. It`s not just him?
WOLFFE: No, it`s not just him. And it hasn`t been just him for some time. Look, this isn`t ‑‑ they’ve come to the understanding that this isn`t just about commercialism. There is something deeply twisted about what`s going on over there. And, yes, the people can dismiss this conversation as some kind of commercial rivalry.
But let`s look at how this video has just popped up about Anita Dunn and her graduation ceremony of her own son. You know, this video, which was not available for public record, happened to pop up on the Glenn Beck Show, and it`s the same school where Chris Wallace spoke the year before because his kids also went there. Was that just a coincidence, or is Fox determined to take this to another level? That`s not about news. It`s about personal attacks. Look, they may enjoy it for all sorts of commercial reasons.
OLBERMANN: Yeah.
WOLFFE: But it goes way beyond the commercial aspect here. There is an unholy jihad going on.
OLBERMANN: Is it politically smart to invest that much in this, out of the administration and the people who work in that building there and the other one over here? Or is it, did they just feel like they had enough? I`m not making any undo comparisons, but when I started down this path six years ago, it was because I had enough. I didn`t know if anybody would, if I might be laughed at for pointing these things out, or there would be financial gain in it or not. As it turned out, there was. It was there say, hey, this is crap. Is that where they’ve come to?
WOLFFE: I think there are two things. First of all, yes, they`ve had enough. But they also realize that they cannot reason with Fox anymore. And if you cannot make the argument, if you think the argument is not getting through because of some other ulterior motive, or because there`s just not rational thinking going on, then you don`t have many choices. And that`s where they`re at.
OLBERMANN: Richard Wolffe, MSNBC political analyst, and, of Public Strategies as well, good to see you again.
WOLFFE: Thank you, Keith.
—Brad Wilmouth is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Wrong Phrase
October 21, 2009 - 12:18 ET by legacyrepublicanNo, 41 used the wrong phrase. He should have called you the "worst sick puppy of the year."
Then, maybe, you would see what a really sick puppy you are!
I think it's a ...
October 21, 2009 - 13:14 ET by Thinking.ManHow about we rename this nutjob Oberpoodle, describes a key member of the Pocket Poodle Media perfectly.
Dont expect any kind of inegrity from anyone on the left, they don't understand the concept, and I am starting to believe their brains are just not wired for normal behavior
Sick Puppy?
October 21, 2009 - 13:29 ET by GeneralAlHow about calling these morons Raving Buzzards? They wait to jump on someone whom they designate as "Dying" too consumed their flesh. With the Enabler-Tele-Prez-Comrade-Apologist in chief giving the go ahead, these idiots have been on a search and destroy mission! The only thing they forgot was those of us who have been libeled and malaligned have begun lauching a surge which is working! thats why the slanted polls are beginning to be published!
Keith "I can see a sick puppy from my bathtub" Olbermann
October 21, 2009 - 12:28 ET by CO2Maker... is fretting about what GHWB said about him and Rachel Madcow, and he's sharing his fret with a guy named Wolffe?
Didn't an irony alarm not go off on the set?
ANY TIME I hear the words "Sick Puppy" This pops up...
October 21, 2009 - 12:56 ET by upcountrywaterSick Puppy by
Carl Hiaasen
Yes we are living the fiction now.
Richard "Hack" Wolffe
October 21, 2009 - 12:58 ET by tim413Wolffe is very familiar with Olberf--ka-s's history of name calling. Have you noticed how so many commentators ask ridiculously long questions? Chris Matthews appears to be the worst. The only way these coversations can flow is if these regular guest hacks have the questions and answers ahead of time.
Stop federal judges from foisting their notions of "fairness" on the States. Amend the 14th Amendment! - tim413
Length matters
October 21, 2009 - 13:08 ET by CO2MakerThe longest, most prolix, most tendentious questions come from the mouth of late night wunderkind Charlie Rose.
Richard "Hack" Wolffe
October 21, 2009 - 12:58 ET by tim413Wolffe is very familiar with Olberf--ka-s's history of name calling. Have you noticed how so many commentators ask ridiculously long questions? Chris Matthews appears to be the worst. The only way these coversations can flow is if these regular guest hacks have the questions and answers ahead of time.
Stop federal judges from foisting their notions of "fairness" on the States. Amend the 14th Amendment! - tim413
"...these are the men who
October 21, 2009 - 13:01 ET by HockeyKid"...these are the men who turned the corner on to the street about which the potholes therein he’s complaining about?"
There is a phrase that describes a person who, as in this example, fails miserably while trying to construct thoughts that sound highly educated.
That phrase is "pompous ass", and KO exemplifies it on a daily basis.
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me
Keith's thought bubbles
October 21, 2009 - 13:12 ET by CO2MakerKeith "I can see Roger Ailes from my bathtub" Olbermann's thought bubbles rise from his bath water and burst through the surface of his consciousness, and he utters them.
That was.....
October 21, 2009 - 17:10 ET by pantryman...really well written, CO2 !
My vision is just a tad different....I see Keith's thought bubbles rising through his bath water, and him trying to bite them before they get to the top.
The operational definition of a genuine frump.
I'm white and friggin-A straight proud of it !
Bubbles---
October 21, 2009 - 18:12 ET by matthewdeanKeith Olberman farts in his bathtub, then bites the resultant bubbles.
And that, boys and girls, is the sum total of his productivity level for the day.
MD
"I may not agree with what your bumper sticker says, but I will defend to the death your right to stick it." (Unknown)
Olbermann, the 'sick puppy' hypocrite
October 21, 2009 - 13:05 ET by Gary HallReally Keith - you don't understand why former President George H. W. Bush had a few chioce words for you? Really?
Got a mirror, Keith?
What Keith should really think is 'weird' is that the former president decided not to call Keith what he really is; but then, the former president is a very decent man - unlike the current host of the Olbermann show.
(;~/ gary
OMG it makes me sick to
October 21, 2009 - 14:43 ET by Radical1979OMG it makes me sick to watch.
".... they cannot reason
October 21, 2009 - 13:08 ET by mattm".... they cannot reason with Fox anymore." When did reason come into the mix? Lord, what a bunch of psychos!
They cannot reason with Fox anymore???
October 21, 2009 - 13:30 ET by Thinking.ManThe leftist term reason should be translated by American Citizens (vs. Tennants, aka the left) as "dictate"
Anytime you see that phrase "You just can't be reasoned with" from the left just replace the form of dictate that would properly complete that sentence.
This little slip points to the fact that they think anyone not in the PPM (Pocket Poodle Media) needs to have a conversion experience to PPM status "Have you SEEN THE LIGHT?"
They have just "Given up" on excercising the demon of "Free" out of the Fox Free Press.
That thought alone is just astounding, the B-Daddy adminstration clearly sees the press as a state funded (it's coming) tool and is angry they cannot control the last TV news station that is telling the truth vs. the B-Daddy hype.
This is all going somewhere, and I would expect they are angling for some kind of finanance reform violation as whacky as that seems.
???
October 21, 2009 - 13:45 ET by charlietexasWhy would Bush 41 insult puppies the way he did?? Queef Olbermannnn is a sick piece of puppy poo........
The term is fitting since Olbee is a lap dog
October 21, 2009 - 14:47 ET by bfrankfor the BO Administration. Beck brillantly illustrated this on his Oct 20th show. He also prodded fun at Matty while holding this cute puppy and claimed it whispered 'Let's play Hardball'.
http://www.mediaite....
Decry name-calling by name calling?
October 21, 2009 - 15:11 ET by Trix RabbitQueef spends his entire time of verbal masturbation criticizing those he deems as the "worst person". Who the $%#* gave him the right to denounce anyone?
But Bush was right. Uberdork is like a very tiny and frightened hypersensitive, pop-eyed chihuahua who will yap at anything just for the sake of being heard.
For the MSM: In your pomp and all your glory, you're a poorer man than me. As you lick the boots of death born out of fear.
Ian Anderson "Wind up"
Sick Puppy?
October 21, 2009 - 15:29 ET by ricklailHe should have used the term I heard when I got off the bus at the receiption station at Fort Jackson-Crap (didn't want to type the real word) maggot.
Semper suprene nitens
OBAMACARE: If it ain't good enough for my Congressman then it ain't good enough for me.
The originator of the Willie Horton ad . . .
October 21, 2009 - 19:46 ET by Galvanic. . . was not George H.W. Bush, but a racist Democratic opponent of Governor Dukakis: Prince Albert Gore.
Galvanic...
October 21, 2009 - 19:51 ET by JerTo my knowledge, Gore never ran an ad about Willie Horton, or one mentioning his name in any manner whatsoever.
Jer
More word games from the Jertroll.
October 21, 2009 - 20:45 ET by JWFSlate researched this. Why the word games. Why not just state the truth?
http://www.slate.com...
Sincerely,
a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.
JWF... Good find...Slate
October 21, 2009 - 20:57 ET by bigtimerJWF...
Good find...Slate no less...hehe
Now wait for the lawyerly response from Jer.
'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart
This isn't a lawyerly response, bt...
October 21, 2009 - 21:23 ET by JerThis isn't a lawyerly response, bt...
It's a very reasonable request. Read the entire Slate article. It proves exactly what I posted.
Jer
Thanks for the link, JWF
October 21, 2009 - 21:27 ET by JerThanks for the link, JWF troll extraordinaire..
You have just proved the accuracy of my recollection.
Would you now care to revise your accusation? Or leave your lie intact?
Jer
Where is the lie?
October 21, 2009 - 22:42 ET by JWFYou knew the truth. You have admitted to knowing the truth. Yet you failed to debunk galvanic. Instead you play word games. It took me researching to post the actual story here on this page, not you. Me.
Galvanic claimed Gore was
October 21, 2009 - 22:50 ET by JerGalvanic claimed Gore was the originator of the Willie Horton ad. That was misleading at best. Flat-out wrong at worst.
This isn't the first time this issue has come up, JWF, nor the first time I've commented on it. I've acknowledged that Gore introduced the general subject of weekend furloughs in the primary with Dukakis. But Gore unlike the Republicans later on never mentioned Horton and didn't originate any Wille Horton ad.
You're own link confirms my version, not Galvanic's.
Jer
Did I ask you that?
October 21, 2009 - 23:04 ET by JWFI said "Where was the lie"? Is this more word games? The Slate link cleared up the entire issue. Did I ask for a recap of the Slate link?
Again. Where did I lie?
Monkeys flying out of Gore's butt.
October 21, 2009 - 23:40 ET by JWFTo my knowledge, Gore never ran an ad about Willie Horton, or one mentioning his name in any manner whatsoever.
To the best of my knowledge, monkeys never flew out of Gore's butt.
Technically, both of us are making factual statements. They do nothing to clear the air. You knew the truth. This isn't the first time this issue has come up, JWF, nor the first time I've commented on it. And yet you failed to debunk Galvanic. That was misleading at best. Flat-out wrong at worst.
I say again. Where did I lie?
Sick puppy?
October 21, 2009 - 20:09 ET by MightyMouthThat is way too kind! Olbermann is a retarted puppy! Sick doesn't even come close! Olbermann makes the Pet Rock look like a Nobel Peace Prize Winner! No wait...that doesn't work anymore either... he is just retarted!
"The bureaucracy is growing to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy"
misnomer
October 21, 2009 - 20:24 ET by cajun2I agree that "sick puppy" was inaccurate.
"Patin's Duck" is more like it.
Cajun for a malformed duck with an ass on both ends. And he dont give a quack.
Mashed up bag of meat
October 21, 2009 - 21:13 ET by Worriedor sick puppy.
I'd say sick puppy is much worse.
Is Olbergagme for real?
What a loser.
Anyone that has to proclaim on the air "I'm not gay"
October 21, 2009 - 21:37 ET by MightyMouthIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"The bureaucracy is growing to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy"
Bush 41 "incivility"?
October 21, 2009 - 23:41 ET by nkviking75Bush 41 created the climate of incivility? The man who seemed to put up no resistance to the lies of Bill and Hillary in 1992? If he'd have been "incivil" to Bubba, the Clintons would have had to slink back to Arkansas and lived as a footnote in American history. I wish George H.W. Bush would have come out swinging in his reelection campaign.
“Always love your country — but never trust your government!" -- Bob Novak (1931-2009)
Perfectly predictable
October 22, 2009 - 00:38 ET by general companyThey slime good men every day. What choice do they have? You cant be an effective slime machine, unless you have proper indignation
My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
I love it!
October 22, 2009 - 08:17 ET by MightyMouthAnn Coulter tears Keith a new one!
"The bureaucracy is growing to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy"
Someone should tell
October 22, 2009 - 08:45 ET by Laffing at libs and leftiesOverbite what they do with uncurable sick puppies....
___________________________
"A communist is someone who reads Marx. An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx." Ronald Reagan
Olbermann
October 22, 2009 - 08:56 ET by jessieHOlbermann isn't a sick puppy, he's a boot licking freak.
Sick Puppy.
October 22, 2009 - 10:02 ET by blazermaniacI can't believe that George H.W. Bush would call Olberdork a sick puppy. How dare Mr. Bush say that about Olberdork. To compare Olberdork to millions of animals is a terrible insult. Bush should apologize to every dog in the world for comparing them to Olberdork. Puppies are much better than Olberdork!