Best of 2006? Other WashPost Critics Mock Haggard, Tout Communist Brits

Photo of Tim Graham.

There were more guess-what-I'm-liberal picks of the Washington Post arts writers in Friday's Weekend section, so since it's a slow Sunday morning, here's the others. The movie critics listed their favorite actors of the year. Ann Hornaday closed out her list with this flippant pick:

5. Ted Haggard in "Jesus Camp." In this documentary, the evangelical preacher leers at a camera operator and says, "I know what you did last night." Well, it turned out what he had done last night was score some crystal meth and get together with a male prostitute. Meanwhile, this prevaricator and moral hypocrite had thousands of followers convinced he was a straight and sober man of God. Well played, sir!

Liberals loved "Jesus Camp," made by two liberals who enjoyed showing people a set of frightening evangelical theocrats in training. Hornaday touted that film, but clearly hated "The Passion of the Christ," and its "troubling" literal approach, as if the Gospel writers were eyewitnesses. She preferred the knocking-boots Jesus of "The Last Temptation of Christ." (So if Haggard had honestly went about the sex and drugs and preached that message, she would have liked him much better, apparently.) See Bozell. She lauded how Last Temptation's "lyricism and meaning and spiritual heft have grown with time....The film is one of the most provocative, haunting and devout meditations on spiritual sacrifice and commitment ever made.”

Then it's back to the music critics. Catherine Lewis's list had two liberal/radical picks:

3. Josh Ritter, "Girl in the War." No one really needs another opinion about the war, but Ritter finds a way to make his chilling take relevant in this song, framed as a conversation between Peter and Paul.

4. Billy Bragg reissues. There's much to rediscover among these eight albums, reissued with bonus tracks and live footage. Bragg's feisty political rants and working-class struggles still seem fresh after two decades, and it's easy to get lost in his exuberant bellow, "There is power in a union!"

Josh Ritter is also on the top-ten list of the aforementioned J. Freedom du Lac. The lyrics to this tune do have a "chilling take" at best, which is that God is utterly powerless before the wars of the world and can't do anything to stop them. At worst, Ritter makes God into a fool: "But now talking to God is Laurel begging Hardy for a gun."

Then there's Billy Bragg, who is not merely a "feisty" ranter but another communist. In 1990, he put out a record with the title "The Internationale," which included that song, which is not really an anthem of "working-class struggles," but the official theme song of the Community Party of the Soviet Union, a theme song for Soviet domination. This is the kind of pick that just makes you laugh. It's "still fresh after two decades" to rehash Soviet Union anthems? It recalls all the jokes we used to make in the 1980s when the Washington Post building and the Soviet embassy were on the same block of 16th Street, and we joked about there must be tunnels underneath joining the two.

Mark Jenkins went local, praising a group called The Evens, a spinoff of the old radical D.C. band Fugazi. "This folk-punk duo's (Ian MacKaye and Amy Farina) rougher-edged second album serves eviction notices to certain unnamed "liars," vowing that "Washington is our city!" The Washington City Paper, the local alternative rag, elaborates on the politics of The Evens:

On "Dinner With the President," about a fantasy invitation to the White House, MacKaye is rendered speechless. He sets up the scenario: "If I went I know what I’d like to do." But Farina has to finish his thought: "Stand up and scream while the food is served."

It probably wouldn’t do much good, and the Evens know it. So much of what motivated voters in the midterm election was apparent the last time the Evens released a record, a point made on the soulful "Cut From the Cloth." "How do people sleep amidst the slaughter?" MacKaye asks. "Why would they vote in favor of their own defeat?"

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Liberals

Ignorant, liberal tripe. Just goes to show you what sane people are up against. We need much more conservative media to counteract these immature fools. Come on Fox, they don't deserve "fair and balanced"; they need to be exposed for what they are.Tell it like it is in the new year.

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Haggard is the greater shame...

Ted Haggard is the greater shame than Hornaday. I have little interest and absolutely NO respect for Hornaday's theology or interpretation of things spiritual however, if Hornaday is the heathen and Haggard the Christian, how much more accountable and warranting reproach is Haggard. Even to this day Haggard doesn't have the integrity or conscience to come clean regarding the entire scope of offenses, lies, theft, deception and moral hypocrisy to the 30 million (his number) conservative evangelicals he duped for years.

If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal.

Guy, I was not really coming

Guy, I was not really coming to Haggard's defense with this note, merely underlining one liberal's glee at underlining his hypocrisy, and I do agree that his burden is greater before God. My main point was to underline that Ann Hornaday sees orthodox Christianity as "troubling" at best.

Tim, thanks

Tim, thanks for the comment and I should have been more clear regarding the target of my post which was general and not specifically toward you. What you said about Hornaday was and is understood by me and I concur with the distastefulness of the liberal glee.

If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal.

I assume Hornaday isn't hopin

I assume Hornaday isn't hoping and praying for a man who fell (who hasn't) and that he recovers well so he can teach the divine message of salvation... I pray for him and her.

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

I really should pay more atte

I really should pay more attention to polls - I could have sworn going into this weekend the polls in the news had Hillary forth yet come sunday morning news she is on top - even in the polls predicting who will be on top at end of 2007.  If that isn't well spent money from the Mr. Clinton seduction of the press I don't know what is.  She doesn't have such a war chest because of her husband's record and name recognition - could it be?  I thought that money machine was supposed to have been term limited so that the press and politician would have to go back to the people, and learn and listen and work to understand without being spoonfed by a past term limited president and those so close to him they have no other chance of getting back into White House without him.   Where has your money come from Hillary?  Please don't play the village idiot about this.   To consider Hillary is to consider trusting a candidate more than ever with finer distinctions in right and wrong use of constitutional power.   Will she be scrutinized accordingly - Such is too much to ask of most politicians let alone a spouse whose husband went through impeachment hearings.  Are you sure behind all your advisors you are not just about vengence Hillary?

I believe the clinton machine

I believe the clinton machine uses the constitution in new ways and slides up against it ever so carefully so as to enjoy a kind of plausible denialibility--I remember bill and his minions using a phony fear that impeachment threatened our consitution although why was never made clear.  Bringing charges of impeachment for perjury seemed to be exactly in line with the consitution.  

I do not have the capacity to foresee how another clinton cabal (should they be successful) will use and misuse our foundation, but I strongly suspect they will.  It's the agenda of their supporters first and the country second.  That will never change.   

Liberalism is a convenient lie.