Talk Show Host Suggests CBS Evening News Go Conservative

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

Many people might not be familiar with Denver, Colorado’s most popular radio talk show host Mike Rosen. Regardless, he wrote an op-ed in Friday’s Rocky Mountain News which was an open letter to CBS president Sean McManus (hat tip to TVNewser, emphasis mine throughout):

Unfortunately, CBS News has been mired in last place behind NBC and ABC in recent years. Your response has been to hire Katie Couric to "perk up" your evening newscast. That was a mistake. Although she scored some good ratings numbers during her first week, this was likely a flash-in-the-pan reaction to a big promotional campaign and viewer curiosity. In the November sweeps, she's settled into a "distant third," as Variety recently phrased it.

Fascinated? Well, here was the marvelous payoff pitch:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

But all is not lost. When you finally give up on Couric, I have a rescue plan if you're willing to take a chance. Really, what have you got to lose?

Here it is: go conservative. Not right wing, mind you. Just mainstream conservative. Couric's nightly audience is about 7 million. There are at least 20 million (that's the size of Rush Limbaugh's radio audience) American grown-ups who are sick and tired of the pervasive liberal bias that dominates the so-called "old" mass media. They'd also like a little more substance.

Rosen continued:

Rather was liberal, Brokaw was liberal, Jennings was liberal. Brian Williams and Charles Gibson, your current competition on ABC and NBC, are liberal. And Katie's liberal. So break the mold. Let Williams and Gibson split the liberal audience and you'll have the conservative audience all to yourself, including millions of new viewers who long ago gave up on network news. It's called product differentiation. Yes, the Fox News Channel skews conservative, but they're on cable and Brit Hume's Special Report has only 2 million viewers, which is pretty good for a cable channel. Just ask CNN and MSNBC.

As a matter of fact, Fox would be a good model for you. I know this is hard for inbred liberals to understand, but Fox's news is more fair and balanced than yours. They skew right of center less than you, ABC and NBC skew left of center. You could probably have gotten Hume for a lot less than you paid Couric, and he'd have been much better. OK, he's not as perky, but he has gravitas.

This guy sounds like an NBer, doesn’t he? He continued:

Change your agenda. Don't obsess on bad news. When you criticize institutions and public figures, don't just attack from the left. Say some good things about business and capitalism, and some critical things about labor unions. Try being more skeptical of environmental activists and global warming hype. Make fun of Cindy Sheehan and Michael Moore the way you do of conservatives.

This will mean, of course, that you'll have to turn your newsroom upside down. Change the culture. Inject some conservative blood. You could call it diversity. Reacting to Richard Nixon's re-election in 1972, The New Yorker's film critic Pauline Kael ironically declared that she couldn't believe he won, since no one she knew voted for him. There's a message there. Get some editors with a different viewpoint, who travel in broader intellectual circles. You know those young people behind the scenes who help produce shows and write copy? They don't all have to be rubber-stamped, idealistic, "progressive" journalism school graduates who want to change the world. Hire a few interns from The Weekly Standard. Get a White House reporter who doesn't hate George W. Bush.

Rosen fabulously concluded:

You get the idea. It could propel CBS to the top of the nightly news ratings. And it might just be good for America, too.

Spectucular job, Mike. I couldn’t agree with you more fervently!

*****Update: A NewsBusters reader wrote an article on this subject a couple of weeks before the elections --

NBC isn't really a good buy, but CBS IS worth going in debt for. CNN was once upon a time...the main source for news on Cable and Dish. Add Foxnews to the choices viewers could make, and look where they went. The majority doesn't have Cable or Dish though, and so we must buy CBS, because I can make it the most watched, and once I have done that...the other 2 won't be able to afford utter bias anymore.

So some Angels get together and talk Viacom out of CBS, and I'm given control of turning it around. The first order of business at the Conservatives Broadcasting Salvation network...Letterman gets tossed out the backdoor on His backside. And I'd bring in Ann Coulter, because Her polarizing personality draws viewers and we can poke fun at Liberals who won't come on her show.

Couric will be placed on the trading block, and NBC could get Her back for their show Friday Night Lights...which I would let Sherwood Baptist direct after the acquisition. Friday Night Lights, taking points from the group of writers and actors that created Facing the Giants would be wonderful for the youth of America.

I would also be willing to trade all of my CSI shows for Fox's 24. Cold case, two and a half men, Ghost Whisperer, and Rockstar supernova would also be on the trading block. The focus would be sports at first, I'd either be working on a deal for more Nascar, MLB, NFL, PGA, or NBA.

Sunday would have TD Jakes, and Will Graham. Along with a special program, in which we'd travel to a different church each week. None of this would appear in time slots that might keep people from going to their church, we'd put news shows in Church time slots. Face the Nation would be there, but Chris Mathews would not. Mychael Massie and Star Parker would co-host Face the Nation.

Michelle Malkin would host Nightly News, but Rush would have His own 20 minute segment...as we'd extend our evening news to an hour. Another 30 minute program called "Newsbusters" would follow the Nightly News...based entirely on the website Newsbusters.com and they'd focus on the Broadcast, Cable/Dish, and Print media lies and distortions of the day. This would get me to 8 p.m.

I'm not above ripping off shows from other networks either, I'd just add a twist to them. Like extreme home makeover...would now be handed to Church groups. Anyone wanting/needing a home makeover would watch the show and await a code word to be flashed at the bottom of the screen, then they'd write their info and the code word and mail it in. If a Church in their area, or a group of Churches were signed on to build, and the family was found to be in need...then we'd dispatch a camera crew to them. I'd run this show 3 nights a week at 8 p.m.

The best part would be my Friday Night Live, which would take NBC's "Crazy Christians" and turn it upside down. We'd mock pop culture, slam the latest Hollywood film failures, and blast elected liberals. We might even get really stupid and create 2 other shows based on the making and operation of Friday Night Live. NBC has really done that now...

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

That and a dollar will buy yo

That and a dollar will buy you a cup of coffee.

Unless and until there is wholesale immediate rejection of the MSM by the public, there won't be any change.  Without that, It's going to take about 40 more years of wandering before I think (IMHO) that MSM would start to skew towards even the middle ground.

--Hokiecon

not at a Starbucks. ;)-

not at a Starbucks. ;)-

It could propel CBS to the to

It could propel CBS to the top of the nightly news ratings. And it might just be good for America, too.

It not only could...it WOULD! Period!

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

Noel,Well, I'd watch.  To te

Noel,

Well, I'd watch.  To tell the truth, I'm getting kind of tired of Fox.

I loved the bit about "diversity" in new news room....do you think they'd then have to cheer for the (R) candidates on election night?

This has about as much chance of happening as hell freezing over, but it is a nice thought.  And from a business perspective, it's a winner.  Guess we'll just have to see how low Katie's ratings sink. 

Joyeux Noel, Noel.

Fox is as unwatchable as Kati

Fox is as unwatchable as Katie is.

I wouldn't go that far but Fo

I wouldn't go that far but Fox has become yawning lately.  I mean last night half the coverage was about blowhard Rosie and donnyboy Trump's quarrel.  It's getting where you have to watch 3-4 dumbass stories before they get around to something worth listening to.  

Sad to say, but that is not a

Sad to say, but that is not a Fox News thing: that is an American media thing.  The Outside World is a fertile ground for news stories that I, for one, would be interested in, but the media in the United States would much rather cover the "O'Donnell - Trump" wars.  Fox News is no exception.

Who would have thought that all media would strive to become Entertainment Tonight?

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

This has about as much chance

This has about as much chance of happening as hell freezing over, but it is a nice thought.  -   Well even that won't happen, what with global warming and all, but if it were to happen, you can find me at the third firepit on the right!

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad

Blonde

B,

Backatcha. Actually, going to be in your neck of the woods beginning next Wednesday to visit my parents.

Joyeux Noel, aussie!  ns

Noel,Bring your rain coat. 

Noel,

Bring your rain coat.  It's been unseasonably hot and rainy.  A.C.'s still on, yuck.

Blonde

B,

Actually, it's supposed to cool and dry out a tad for our arrival (typed with fingers crossed): http://www.weather.com/outlook/travel/businesstraveler/tenday/USFL0468?from=36hr_topnav_business.  ns

Noel,Well, I believed the wea

Noel,

Well, I believed the weather guessers last month when I went to Chicago (predictions were for a low around 50 and rain).  I caught the last flight out before the big blizzard....and I was seriously missing my cashmere greatcoat.

Hope you bring the good stuff with you.  Dry and cool is good. 

....and I was seriously missi

....and I was seriously missing my cashmere greatcoat.

 Poor poor girl!

That's envy talkin' there B....LOL!

It's a slow day here, mostly because they haven't got the comment section and whose on line fixed yet, I know it's the holidays and all, but this is terrible guys! Whats the hold up? Just a hint would help....

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

Hey BT,Native Floridian, what

Hey BT,

Native Floridian, what can I say?  I am a big baby when it comes to cold weather.  I head for the winter clothes anytime the temp drops below 65.  That coat of mine has been to London, twice, without me!  I'm serious.

I know what you mean about a hint....this is very time consuming to keep checking where there are new comments.

London you say...man you have

London you say...man you have moolah girl! Don't forget who your friends are!I'm just a poor girl in the deep woods that keeps the fire stoked, the wood split, and changes a flat now and then!

By the way, Noel doesn't know what the problem is yet either....he has been in touch with others but they may have escaped for the rat-race for awhile, er...days?

Time will tell....so like he said, lets wreck the place! Kegger! Roll out the barrel!

It is hard not automatically going to the right side after posting something huh? Laughing out loud, and popping a top!

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

BT -Coat's been to London twi

BT -

Coat's been to London twice, I've never been there. :(      

Laughing about the rest of your post.

Party on, BT! 

Coat's been to London twice,

Coat's been to London twice, I've never been there.....

What happened, is that where you send it to have it cleaned?

Laughing at just the thought....hehehee

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

Blonde: FL is not cold.  FL

Blonde: FL is not cold.  FL is NEVER cold!  AK...now, THAT is cold! 

:-)

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

Weather guessers.  I like th

Weather guessers.  I like that!  True story:  Several years ago, a somewhat-famous local weather man here in Detroit hired my uncle's cement company to pour his pool-area patio in Grosse Pointe.  Everyone in the company figured this guy would be able to nail a good weekend to pour cement, right?  It rained cats and dogs the day of the job.  They don't know any more about the future weather than you or I!

Umm, actually you better be p

Umm, actually you better be prepared for lots of rain there my friend, a front is moving across the Gulf, we here in Tampa are just getting the rain.  Better local weather at Bay News 9, down to the thumbnails for the State radar map.

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius

This is truly sound business

This is truly sound business advice.  And Mr. Rosen is correct in saying that it wouldn't be necessary for them to be rabid about it, just fair!  And, Puh-leeze..  find somebody else for your anchor.  A Brit Hume type would be perfect!  Poised, smart, not image driven, and NOT ANTI-AMERICAN! 

I'm sad to say the liberal me

I'm sad to say the liberal media is FINALLY starting to see the light- Sad because while they might have some conservatives on their programming, they will be smugly sandwiched between outrageously biased liberal programs, and that will just expose more fence sitters to the liberal spin crap that they once avoided like the plague. Now the poison will slowly but assuredly be introduced to the masses who once avoided it.

http://sacredscoop.com

The Fox people that read this

The Fox people that read this blog had better take heed at some of the prior comments.  I've found myself watching less and less Fox News and more "something else".  I haven't turned to CNN or MSNBC, but to other stuff.  The web is becoming more and more my primary source for news and information.  Fox News Sunday was a great show with Hume and Snow in the head chair.  It's not the same with Chris Wallace.  Hume's evening program (at least Hume's part of it) is still outstanding, but Fred Barnes and Mort Kondracke are getting more and more predictable and less and less fun.  Shep Smith needs to run away with the circus the next time it comes to town.  He'd make a great sideshow barker.  O'Reilly is way too full of himself (GONZO).  Spending time with Alan Colmes has worn on Sean Hannity and made him more shrill than before.  Maybe Fox can arrange a swap with Headline News.  Glen Beck for Greta straight up.  In fact, Fox should throw in a draft choice if necessary.  Greta needs to be closer to Nancy Grace. 

Following up on what CWG has

Following up on what CWG has started here, what specifically would you like to see Fox offer?  This could either be in terms of style or substance.

"Fighters are fun but bombers make policy"

Well, for starters, they coul

Well, for starters, they could lose Aruba-girl's show.

And just to infuriate the MsM, they could have a NewsBuster style show....pointing out all of the bias in the "regular" media. 

Aruba-girl

Arbua-girl - you're killing me... ROTF

Now we're cooking.  For the

Now we're cooking. 

For the Jon Stewart counter program, I'd like to see something along the lines of spoofs that we would do as crew members.  Someone, normally an O-3 captain, would make a very direct and pointed comment.  Then another posing as a public affairs staff weeny would "translate" for the captain usually using the phrase, "What the captain means is ..."  It was usually something quite tepid but the clear text message was what came across first.

It is much more difficult to articulate what we think the real news should look like.  Personally I'd just settle for some neutral reporting of facts.

Merry Christmas All!

"Fighters are fun but bombers make policy"

Now we're cooking......with g

Now we're cooking......with gas!

(BTW, the shuttle just touched down....awesome...flying that thing must be amazing).

I wouldn't have clue one about Steward's show, and I actually saw Obernut for the first time the other night.  I couldn't stand watching THAT for more than about four minutes...he looked to me like he was high on coke the way he kept mushing his mouth around.

Okay, another program.  Brit Hume doing news.  No "pop news" either, real news.  And no panel either....Fred & Mort already have the Beltway gig....get them off the news. 

I'd like to see a count-up of

I'd like to see a count-up of something that was "promised."

For example, the democrats kept promising they "have a plan" for...?  I lost count after 16 months.  When something finally came out it (supposedly the plan) was a motherhood and apple pie list of promises that you really couldn't argue with.  What was missing was the connect the dots piece of where the money would come from to pay for it.  Holding the toads acccountable would be a nice thing.

"Fighters are fun but bombers make policy"

B&B,As a bomber guy, you

B&B,

As a bomber guy, you ought to know that stealth plans don't count, unless they're schematics.

And as for that motherhood thing, Hillary is trying it on for size as her campaign slogan.  Sheesh!

Finally, you know what they say about toads, um, frogs.  If frogs had wings, they wouldn't bump their arses crossing the Jersey turnpike.

Ripping off Olberman's Countdown, though, would further inflame the mainstream media.  I like it....Countdown to Accountablitiy, live at 9:00.

Well, Jon Stewart makes fun

Well, Jon Stewart makes fun of it (hilariously, IMO) here, but I want more of this!
JMR

Championship Badminton from Czechoslovakia

Well I would watch CBS news, but one local channel has been showing "Championship Badminton from Czechoslovakia" and that is much more entertaining than CBS news, the other local channel has "Joanie Loves Cha Chi" reruns, and the other local channel has "After Mash" reruns and those are much more enthralling than CBS news.  By the way has Mike Wallace come out and condemned Ahmadinejad's conference from last week, or is he planning on interviewing Duke and fawing over him as well?

"I've always been crazy, but it's kept me from going insane"  Waylon Jennings

It's not in Katie.Liberalism

It's not in Katie.

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

.

Man, this is just crazy talk!

Good stuff.

It's opportunity.FOX, altho

It's opportunity.

FOX, although far better, is a pain in the ass with the shared dem focus. I tivo shows simply to FF through people like Colmes. Real conservatism works here and on the radio, why would it not on CBS? And consider the audience potential.

JDW

Kerry: "You know, education, if you make the most of it ... you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq."

I think this is an excellent

I think this is an excellent idea.  In fact, I have been thinking for quite some time that it was time for Fox to get a Network show.  But this would be even better.  I have a most excellent idea, they should get Michelle Maulkin to do her "Vent" at the end of every show.  She always gets me laughing and thinking, and it would drive the Libs absolutely mad!

I also think it would be really good for our country to get rid of some of the Anti-American apologists from the airwaves.

I love the article. It's an u

I love the article. It's an under-the-radar kick in the nuts. But truly attempting to "convert" an MSM network would be a bad idea all around in my opinion. Let 'em just die out. -PJ

http://www.draftcondi.us/

It must suck to know that you

It must suck to know that you could take your product to the top but cant. ( I assume that those in charge at CBS are privy to the same information this idot is) What a business model. Striving to keep your product as low as possible but still keeping your job. If this is not a perfect example of a "world gone mad" then please somebody help me!

The Donald in Hostile Takeover Bid for CBS

 The Donald in Hostile Takeover Bid for CBS.

Now that would be a great headline.

Seriously, somebody has to acquire CBS and the NYT to straighten out this MSM nightmare.

"Hussein’s scientists were on the verge of building an atom bomb, as little as a year away" New York Times Nov 2006

CBS to go conservative?  Don

CBS to go conservative?  Don't we get served enough lies by Fox News?

He is assuming they are willi

He is assuming they are willing to trade being in 3 place in a three man liberal race to be first with a conservative base. It would seem to me that it makes all the sense in the world, but these are liberals that are out to:(change the world). They don’t want change their views of the news, its not like the example of Fox has not been around. Hell in sports, if something is not working you do something different.  They stop the pass you run, seems simple to me. But you have to want to win the game, if you don’t play to win and only to look good to your mommy and daddy and cheerleaders nothing will change. The dinosaur is not catching on or does it want to.  I do agree with every one that Fox does put too much fluff on like the Rosie and Donald circus act. But with the only game in town you still watch it right?   Hey look the Democrats ran pro gun, pro life, conservative (somewhat) candidates, they own the house and senate. I would love to see it because if someone did it, it could pull the news back to the center, or maybe that’s my wishful thinking.  

Also with the ideas that are coming about Fox and new shows, keep them coming, love it. There seems to be endless material from the likes of PETA, ACLU, Democrat underground, all the A$$ holes in Hollywood, our pals in the UN and France.. the list goes on and on.

Like someone said Rush has a audience of 20 million -VS- 7 million.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

Rush only has 4 million daily

Rush only has 4 million daily listeners which still is alot of sheep, but its not 20 million.

Drive-by troll.Thanks for sto

Drive-by troll.

Thanks for stopping by.

Joe, next time you decide to

Joe, next time you decide to do a "dump and run" do us a favor and sh*t on somebody else's highway, 'kay?

Lies? could you make a list?A

Lies? could you make a list?

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

No, he cannot.  But when did

No, he cannot.  But when did facts and hard data get in the way of the moonbats on the left?

"People everywhere confuse what they read in newspapers with news."  - A.J. Liebling

yep you have that right, pitc

yep you have that right, pitch out a line and then run.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

I don't even no where to even

I don't even no where to even start.  Things are so bad that Fox News edits the transcripts afterwards - deleting O’Reilly’s offending comments  The channel should be boycotted by anyone with a conscience, whatever their political persuasion.  But my all time favorite Fox News lie is that WMD were found in Iraq

You should be ashamed, you cr

You should be ashamed, you creepy little drive-by troll.  If you had an original thought....it might be somewhat amusing.  But alas...

Boring.

TROLL.'nuff said.

TROLL.

'nuff said.

Joe, I think a bigger lie wou

Joe, I think a bigger lie would be: a brain, found in your head. Marry Christmas-Troll.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

It's just business!Once the r

It's just business!

Once the rivalries with NBC / ABC emerge, with all the competitive gotchas & name calling ratings will go through the ceiling. Throw in morning and daytime shows with a right point of view and  they'll gain viewers in droves. All that's needed is someone, a woman perhaps with the testicular fortitude, know-how and the leadership abilities to make it happen. Its such an obvious opportunity, it begs to be done.

IMHO, Britt Hume would be perfect!

Beside that, what does CBS have to lose? Send Ms Perky to co-host with Olbermann, where she belongs.

Hey this is not rocket scienc

Hey this is not rocket science. I ran a bar for 15 years, business slow, change the music, line around the corner… Simple to me. The difference is you have to want to change, or do more business. If all you care about is being a liberal mouth piece and changing elections (George Allen) then you just want to do just enough so you don’t get fired.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

So, my question would be what are the looking for inside Katie?

So, my question would be what are they looking for inside Katie?

In the picture I mean.

Gee, wouldn't it be a little better to start at the brain level?  Or is that a non-starter?

Or am I on the wrong thread again?

ACA

...

Acaiguana says:  "Ya can't win if ya don't play."

Nope, I think you are spot on

Nope, I think you are spot on.  I think they did start with the head and now still...looking for her brain in the... er.. other areas.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

The guy hit it right on the n

The guy hit it right on the nose.

As I understand it, the typical viewer of the evening news is in their 60’s.

A culturally very conservative group.

You are not going to light their fire by covering stories about the joys of gay marriage.

The problem with the 60 year old age group is that they already have everything they want and are not the ideal source of advertising dollars.

But, since the networks haven’t been able to attract the younger demographics, why not cater to the 60+ viewers.

I predict that See BS (CBS) could double their viewership if they reflected the cultural beliefs of their viewers - 60+.

MSM

Why in the world would the Socialist (or worse) MSM embrace capitalism and conservativism? And why, knowing many of them are tanking and losing money, do you think they still stay the same? It's called "brainwashing" and one cannot put a price on it or worry about net profits.

no way

Although the premise that CBS should go conservative for survival is a good idea, it is not viable.  The CBS geeks are too eaten up by liberal disease to save themselves.  Lefties like Klueless Katie can't heal themselves.  Their hate, contempt and acquiescent indulgence of the barbarians at the gate runs too deeply just to be cast off by change for the sake of change.  I don't think we realize the depth of CBS' s hatred of the South and conservatives.  They see us as infterior, knuckle draggers who are not worthy of their elite attention.  To try to appeal to conservatives would be so paradoxical that it would not be possible.  CBS should just ride away into the sunset and be remembered as the network which spawned the liberalism of Cronkite and Rather and then tried to save itself with the radical liberalism of of KatieKouric.  What a laugh.

Cather

CW,

But, what about market differentiation? Hasn't the Fox News experiment on cable proved successful? Here is CBS, in third place and sinking like a stone trying to out-liberal ABC and NBC. Why not go in the opposite direction, and see whether that helps their ratings?

Will they do it? You know, I sincerely believe that in the next five years, one of the three network news organizations is going to make a huge swing to the right. They're going to have to, for their monopoly is being diminished by FNC, talk radio, and the Internet. CBS is learning that you can't just put on a new face and change the set. At some point, one of these organizations will be forced to try something else in order to succeed.  ns

Nobody said changing CBS to

Nobody said changing CBS to an unbiased news source will be easy. Sort of like turning an oil tanker around. That's where the experience, leadership skills and balls come in. A 'Jack Welch'  of news broadcasting needs to be found to get it done.

BTW, not only CBS' contempt for non-Manhattanites but NBC's and ABC's as well biases their news presentations. I worked for ABC. I'm a native NYer but never had I seen such a herd of condescending uptown snots as those in the News Dept.

One of the guys that use to h

One of the guys that use to hang out in my bar worked for CNN in Secaucus and he told me the same thing. Just snotty little brats that were stuck in a mind set and thought the rest of the world were Neanderthals.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower