The View's Hasselbeck To Hillary Clinton: Would Troop Withdrawal 'Create More Chaos?'


New York Senator Hillary Clinton appeared on Wednesday’s The View to discuss politics and the re-release of her book, It Takes a Village. While there was some cheerleading for the 2008 Democratic presidential frontrunner by co-hosts Joy Behar and Rosie O’Donnell, for the most part, there seemed to be a great deal of restraint on all sides during Clinton’s two segments. Asked about a potential run for the White House, Clinton again said she was thinking about it "trying to sort all this out." On the war in Iraq, Clinton only got one challenging question in regards to her support of a "phased redeployment," from co-host Elisabeth Hasselbeck:

Senator Hillary Clinton: "....So, if it's not going to change the mission, if it's not going to be a different strategy, I don't see where putting more troops will make a difference."

Elisabeth Hasselbeck: "Do you think pulling them out too early will–would equate to–sometimes I think of it as, you know, not finishing all of your antibiotics. Okay, there’s a problem there."

Clinton: "Right."

Hasselbeck: "So if you pull out too early, will that create more chaos?"

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Behar was the first to mention Iraq during the Clinton interview. She asked the Senator about how she currently feels about her vote in support of the war in 2003. Clinton responded by calling for a "phased redeployment" of troops, which Hasselbeck challenged:

Behar: "Last time you were here, I asked you if you were sorry that you didn't vote against the Iraq war. Do you remember that?"

Clinton: "I do remember that."

Behar: "How do you feel about it now?"

Clinton: "Well, I, you know, I have said repeatedly that, you know, if we had known then, there wouldn't have been a vote, what we know now. The problem is we’ve got to figure out what to do going forward. It, it really, you know, it’s, it’s, it’s such a serious challenge to us and part of the problem is that I think the comprehensiveness of the need for a strategy is something that I don't get a feel that the President and his advisors are really looking at. So I'm hoping that they will, you know, really follow the lead of what the Democrats have been saying for, you know, more than a year, when we voted for something called phased redeployment, which is, we have to begin bringing our troops home."

Behar: "But that's not what he's saying now. He’s saying increase the troops."

Clinton: "That’s not what he’s saying. That’s right."

Anthony: "He's saying more troops."

Hasselbeck: "He’s saying–[crosstalk] in the short term, right? Is that the plan? Increase the troops short term–"

Clinton: "Right. But, but the problem is that, how will it be different? Will this Iraqi government let our troops go after the terrorists? Will they let them go after the people who are causing the violence or will they say no and pull them back again? So, if it's not going to change the mission, if it's not going to be a different strategy, I don't see where putting more troops will make a difference."

Hasselbeck: "Do you think pulling them out too early will–would equate to–sometimes I think of it as, you know, not finishing all of your antibiotics. Okay, there’s a problem there."

Clinton: "Right."

Hasselbeck: "So if you pull out too early, will that create more chaos?"

Clinton: "That’s right. Well, the, but, but the issue is, how do we get the Iraqis to start taking responsibility for themselves?"

It was during the second segment with Clinton that the ‘Hillary-for-President’ cheering arose from Behar and O’Donnell. Discussing working moms and child care, Hasselbeck asked if a female presidential candidate would have an edge over a male rival:

Hasselbeck: "Do you find that that is–being a mom and having worked as a mom and being able to multitask, does that give a would-be president kind of an edge up on, say, a male rival?"

Behar: "Yeah!"

Hasselbeck: "Do you think that?"

Clinton: "Well, you know, Elisabeth, nobody’s ever, nobody’s ever been in a position to ask that question, cause we’ve never had a mother who ever ran for or held that position."

O’Donnell: "But we need one soon!"

Behar was the most enthusiastic supporter of Clinton amongst the View panel, which was clear during this exchange with the New York senator:

Clinton: "Our schools have to be more in tune with what goes on. I mean, how can working parents get to child conferences if they're in the middle of the work day, if they're not given some time off to be able to do that?"

Behar: "So, do you think it would help to have a woman in the White House? I mean, let's go there!"

Crystal McCrary Anthony [laughing]: "She’s not biased at all!"

One wonders if a potential female Republican presidential candidate would be treated with the same level of awe as Clinton. With O’Donnell and Behar’s track records of attacking the GOP and conservatives, it would seem safe to assume that would certainly not be the case.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Rosie and the Hildebeast toge

Rosie and the Hildebeast together on the same show? That must have been nauseating and then some.  I'm so sorry, Megan.

Clinton: "Well, you know, Elisabeth, nobody’s ever, nobody’s ever been in a position to ask that question, cause we’ve never had a mother who ever ran for or held that position."

Believe me, if Hitlary Rotten Clintax runs and somehow manages to win, she will be a mother, alright.

Hillary lied

Actually, Megan, I think Hillary's being Clintonesque when she says a mother's never run for president. Elizabeth Dole briefly ran in 1999, but wasn't a mother. Shirley Chisholm ran in 1972, but wasn't a mother.

But wait! Carol Moseley Braun ran in the last cycle -- and she has a son!

But hey! Patricia Schroeder briefly ran for president in the 1988 cycle, before her famous teary goodbye. She was a mom!

Typical Clintonese speak. She

Typical Clintonese speak. She expects her gushing fans to never question her on her "inaccuracies" and downright lies. You're not suppose to remember those other women who ran for president and were also mothers, because she's suppose to be to the woman who makes history when she runs for, and in her mind wins, the presidency.

"Today we did what we had to do. They counted on America to be passive. They counted wrong."    - Ronald Reagan

Think we'll see The Red Queen

Think we'll see The Red Queen on Fox News Sunday being interviewed by Chris Wallace?
Or on the O'Reilly Factor? HA!

Hillary is now jumping on the

Hillary is now jumping on the hind-sight bandwagon and declaring that if she 'had known' what she knows now, she would have never voted for the war. Great Hillary- You just told millions of Iraqis that you could have cared less about their dire circumstances- you're humanity has just taken a predictable nosedive- Her new motto is apparently the same old democratic mantra of "Hooray for Hillary, the hell with everyone else! "

http://sacredscoop.com

All this talk about pulling t

All this talk about pulling the troops out is adding to the "chaos."  No politician worth his or her salt should say anything but that we aren't pulling out until the insurgency is quelled...even if it takes 100 years.  But, when we show such irresolution, we send the message to the terrorists that what they're doing is working and so they keep doing it.

Sending a message

Sending a message: " We are crybabies and you can win. We're hurt and can't take it anymore. Even the new leaders and people of Iraq taking 4-5 times the casualties don't want to and can't fight. They won't let us go after you guys. Got the message UBL and the terrorists? "

Wake me when UBL can be said to have been wrong calling the USA a load of wusses.( He's half wrong, but the half that whines gets all the play.)

Hillary Clinton talking about

Hillary Clinton talking about raising a child is ludicrous...we the tax-payers raised Chelsea, and all the help she used at her disposal...she is a pathetic leftist that we had better beware of if we do not get a strong conservative to run for us in the primaries.....

I detest her to put it mildly.

I despise her being on television telling people anything about raising our children, her and her other half are not what I call role models for any child.

She does not speak for any women I know.

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

You're right, The Bushes ar

You're right, The Bushes are definitely a better parent, just take a look at Jenna & Barbara!!

inquiring minds want to know

I have to wonder if Hillary was raised by a "village"? BTW,  wtfdtm?

hillary was reared on the commune

We speak of trailer trash etc.,

But it's well-known Hillary % Bubba only married much later when he was intent on running for office in Little Rock. Before this, they just shacked up, same as most flower childrun (sic). She is commune trash.

Thanks TT....I knew we would

Thanks TT....I knew we would eventually agree on something!

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

At least the Bush dad didn't

At least the Bush dad didn't humiliate his whole family by getting a Lewinsky in the White House.

FLASH BACK - Clintons steal White House furniture!!!

And I think we can comfortably assume that the Bush's will not steal the furniture when they leave the White House, like the Clinton's did.  This is reason enough not to put a Clinton back in the White House...we need to save America's treasures from being STOLEN!  LINK HERE.

Red v. Blue Charity Link

"Walters told CNN that the Cl

"Walters told CNN that the Clintons said they wanted to avoid any questions of impropriety,"

I'm laughing so hard I think I'm going to get sick!

Why are their states Blue and ours Red? Shouldn't it be the other way around?

KW . . . I forgot to say - th

KW . . . I forgot to say - thanks for the reminder.

THEY STOLE THE FURNITURE! The Scumbags . . .

Why are their states Blue and ours Red? Shouldn't it be the other way around?

If that had been the Reagans

If that had been the Reagans or the first Bush family who had taken this furniture, that would have been the scandal of the year for the MSM. Letterman and Leno would be having a field day for weeks, and none of the former Presidents or First Ladies would have been able to make a public appearance without the requisite "so what's the deal with the stolen furniture?" question.

"Today we did what we had to do. They counted on America to be passive. They counted wrong."    - Ronald Reagan

 kw  You would think that i

 kw  You would think that if Hillary was the "smartist woman in the world"  and Bill,  next to the "smartist"  they would know better than to claim the furniture was theirs....              ...MERRY  CHRISTMAS TO ALL,   GOD BLESS YOU AND YOURS     :-)  WW    

"One wonders if a pote

"One wonders if a potential female Republican presidential candidate would be treated with the same level of awe as Clinton."

I think we might have had an answer to this earlier before when the President's sister, Doro, was only shown interviewed by Bawbwa and Elisabeth; with Dumb and Dumber, no shows.

How sad

A female presidential candidate on The View. How telling and how sad for everyone, but mostly for honest, intelligent, hard-working women.

MERRY CHRISTMAS!

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

More Hilary Misdirection

Ives,

This is another little, um, stretch on Hillary's part.

Shirley Chisolm was the first "mom" to run for the presidency.  Libby Dole, of course, ran as a republican, but she's not a mom.

Oh, those impertinent little facts.

Blonde, my checking suggested

Blonde, my checking suggested Shirley Chisholm was married twice, but not a mom.

Thanks, Tim.  My fault.  I

Thanks, Tim.  My fault. 

I should have checked my facts, first,  or added IIRC.

Nicely done on Cavuto the other day.  The constant camera shot on the blurry pages of the magazine was a little strange, though.

Blonde, you should not have a

Blonde, you should not have admitted error.  Tell Tim you got your information from Captain Jamail Hussein of the Bagdad police department.  After all, he is a reliable source for the AP. :-)

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Mistakes

Mike,

It's just the way I was raised I guess...make a mistake, admit it, and move on.

Too bad the members of the media weren't taught the same life lesson.

Blonde, I wasn't being seriou

Blonde, I wasn't being serious.  Nor, was I being serial (cereal?).  You done good, kid.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Clinton was not even answerin

Clinton was not even answering the questions. hmm... Maybe she is having flash-backs to her days of being on the hot seat in the court room. You may recall, she could not come up with answers there either.

As a New Yorker, I was absolutely shocked that a woman could move here for the reason of running for office and actually win. If that is not a career politician, what is? Sadly, many New Yorkers are not wise to her. Fact is, the Clintons are nothing more than hippies with an education, who were probably more shocked than anyone else that they ever got into office the first time. (Yes, 'they!')

The View seriously needs a true conservative woman on it. If I had been there, I would have posted the following questions to "Senator" Clinton with regards to her contemplating running for president: 

1) Senator, with regards to your book, "It Takes a Village" (to raise a child.) Here in New York, that village now includes a male cross dresser for a high school science teacher. Senator, how do you feel about that?

2) Keeping on the topic of your book, Senator; how do you propose running an entire nation, if it took you an entire village to raise just one child?

3) Senator, as the president, you would be the commander and chief of America's armed forces, do you feel that a woman should be such--when women do not go into combat battle?

4) As a follow-up to my last question, Senator; would you seek to put women into combat?

and

5) Senator, speaking woman to woman; how can we count on you to be on your toes regarding traitors to our flag, like the American Muslims responsible for 9/11, when you could not spot a traitor to your marriage in your own home?

Debra...-of: www.InformingChristians.com

For info on the cross dresser science teacher in Batavia N.Y., please see the section on the front page of my site.

Oh Debra....beautiful! Great

Oh Debra....beautiful! Great post!

I wished you would try out for the job if they ever get brainy enough to get a real conservative with great questions that should be asked like that to a possible future President, once again that is! I just know absolutely no one is going to ask her tough questions, and in a debate with anyone they most likely are going to treat her like the did with the debate she had in NY with Lazio, whom I thought did a great job and won the debate as far as I was concerned, and was one of my favorite congressmen.

The msm will treat her with kid gloves, plus she will not go on any shows that would treat her any differently.

Btw...I am not taking anything away from Hasselbeck for those of you who watch the show and like her, I just wished she was more inserting.

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

Thank you.

Thank you... -- I too like Hasselbeck, and yes, she needs to insert more. But I also believe she is holding back from saying how she really feels about some issues--like that of homosexuality, even when she gets the floor. It is probably not allowed, for her to speak against homosexuality, with Rosie on the show. But it should be allowed, or why have a show called, "The View?"

Debra...  

correction: posed* the follow

correction: posed* the following...

Deb, love #5 I will pull out

Deb, love #5 I will pull out that one when my sister in law starts, That should clip a wing or two..

Its funny, I had a house in NJ and worked there, I also had a small house in the Catskills, that is where I voted. I drove 150 miles just to vote against her. I have moved back down south where I belong.  Good job with the post.

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Eisenhower

Hi... thank you... I ended up

Hi... thank you... I ended up turning it into an article. If the link to the article would make things faster for you with your sister, here it is: http://www.debrajmsmith.com/hillary.html ----We should call 2008--STOP Hillary 2008.... :)

Whoah!  Great questions--I'm

Whoah!  Great questions--I'm positive her handlers under her direction would never allow any questions they are not given before any interview.  Clinton is nothing but a political calculator resting her power by polls, disguise and spin.  Until the clintons, I (and most) didn't know what spin was--now we do.

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

Thank you... I wonder if her

Thank you... I wonder if her whole reason for even thinking about being president is a fantasy of getting even with her husband for publicly humiliating her, while he was in office. If Hillary was president, Bill would be the equivalent of a first lady. He would turn into the laughing stock of 'fe-male' jokes. Hillary would be publicly and politically, well umm... how can I say this? mmm... as Dolly Parton would say, "Turning his rooster into a hen!" Ya know, what most any woman would want to do to a man who cheated on her.

You could be on to something-

You could be on to something--a portion or a major part of her innner drive very well could be to even the score with a lout, a real lout. 

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

IMHO the only reason that S

IMHO the only reason that Senator Clinton is speaking out on 'Motherhood' is because that is the one topic that Senator Obama cannot relate to. I do not think for an instant that Hillary Clinton is the epitamy of motherhood. It is just a political calculation that she can use to overcome any of her current Democratic opponents. in the eyes of her voters!

'You lose the debate when you let someone distract you from the original idea of the debate.'

Everything a clinton does or

Everything a clinton does or says is a political calculation.  The likes of Rosie and Joy lap it up like a cat lapping milk out of a bowl.  It's as though they are part of the mindless who fall into their place underneath her highness.  One has to be mindless to think Mrs. Bill Clinton would be a good president and not dangerous for the country.

Another thread concerning the waste of a show called the view--but it is a platform where Rosie and Joy shocks the viewers with the junk that comes out of their uninformed mouths,  We could get as much if they were to hire a koskid or a du'er or three and watch them ramble, babble their nonsense--at a cost significantly less.  That way, at least the advertisers wouldn't be losing so much money. 

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

I think Hillary is an expert

I think Hillary is an expert on Motherhood. She's been married to the country's biggest Mother for years!

When is this yenta-fest going

When is this yenta-fest going off the air???

I pity the poor person who watched this..I bet their eyes are still burning.

Fight Terrorism at home - defeat a liberal!

school records??

maybe somebody can something to this , after the "pillager in chief"got ahead into world of politics, she was able to get her thesis from Wellesley College  (female only during her time there) selectivily squestered and other "papers" hidden from puplic viewing  ,so??maybe there's something to this??