In his "Best of the Web Today" column on Opinion Journal, James Taranto noticed the New York Times recently reported a story on the eagerness in Iraq to see Saddam Hussein executed, but reporter Kirk Semple's piece transmitted that all-too-familiar tendency to identify with the convicts, and not the ones they caused to suffer:
From a New York Times story on Iraqi execution methods, set to be used on convicted murderer Saddam Hussein:
The victims are led up a set of steel stairs to a platform, about 15 feet above the ground, and nooses fashioned from one-and-a-quarter-inch-thick hemp ropes are slipped over their necks. The executioners are different each time, drawn from among employees of the Justice Ministry who volunteer for the job. Many have lost relatives or friends in insurgent attacks, officials said.
With a tug of two large levers, the steel trapdoors drop open and the victims fall through. The doors make a loud clanging sound as they slam against the apparatus, according to people who have witnessed hangings. The jarring noise echoes off the cold, unadorned concrete walls.
Death is supposed to come instantly--a doctor is on hand to certify it--and the bodies are removed to a cooler where they are held before being handed over to the victims' families. The entire process is recorded by a photographer and a video cameraman and the images are stored in a government archive.
You may be wondering why Iraq is planning to hang Saddam's victims. Aren't they already dead? Well, yes, they are. The Times is using the word victim in a rather unconventional way--to mean "criminal."
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Saddam Hussein, the victim, a
December 18, 2006 - 23:42 ET by BlondeSaddam Hussein, the victim, as defined by the NYT.
Charming.
And leftist critics call Fox "Faux News"?
If this weren't so disgustingly sick, it would be funny.
Amen to that!
December 19, 2006 - 00:38 ET by terrigThe NYT will be shedding tears over their latte when he goes to the "necktie party".
Blonde,Just when you think th
December 19, 2006 - 08:19 ET by msh1973Blonde,
Just when you think the NYT has hit rock bottom they come up with a pearl like this one. I can't even wrap my head around anything this crazy. Hussein a victim, sure, tell that to all the families of the people who have been discovered in mass graves with no heads. I am sick.
What's the famous saying of t
December 19, 2006 - 16:54 ET by Darth DutchWhat's the famous saying of the news reporters? "To comfort the afflicted and afflict the comforted"
Well, the NYT has certainly made clear who it views as the "afflicted" in this case and it sure ain't the families of the murdered. How soon until the NYT and others find people whose families were murdered by Saddam saying that they are against his death?
Dutch
"nooses fashioned from
December 19, 2006 - 04:18 ET by sarcasmo"nooses fashioned from one-and-a-quarter-inch-thick hemp rope..."
!!Ack!! Sin of all sins, they're using (re-usable!) hemp ropes! (It must be some sort of evil, nefarious plot on the Iraqis' part to get really-stoned!!)
JMR
I noticed that, too, but wond
December 19, 2006 - 07:34 ET by Tim GrahamI noticed that, too, but wondered -- what would Woody Harrelson do? Oppose capital punishment? But the virtues of hemp?? What a dilemma.
As a pro capital punishment
December 19, 2006 - 08:01 ET by sarcasmoAs a pro capital punishment Floridian (big government's very good at ONE thing, or at least they used-to-be!) I wondered if our "wise" state officials would ever get the clue that our ancestors' method works, humanely, every time, even when administered by inbred, chimp-like prison officials. Anyway, my main point was to make fun of the drugwar-worshippers here, who seem to think the Creator of All Things made a mistake with that particular creation. Some mornings, I just can't resist an easy target.
JMR
Gee Sarc,I thought you were m
December 19, 2006 - 09:35 ET by BlondeGee Sarc,
I thought you were making fun of Florida's inbred, chimp-like prison officials.
What with all the gnashing of teeth and pulling of hair in the media over that last botched execution.
I didn't notice the hemp rope thing until you pointed it out, tho.
blonde
December 19, 2006 - 09:52 ET by foolnomorefair lady : weren't you going ta work ta day??
fnm, Yes, I shall actually go
December 19, 2006 - 09:56 ET by Blondefnm, Yes, I shall actually go, but later. Right now, I'm putting out fires from the comfort of my home. Technology is a wonderful thing. ;)
blonde o k
December 19, 2006 - 10:03 ET by foolnomoretechnology is wonderful: 19*Burr,just glad ta see another trouble maker.
not worth news
December 19, 2006 - 06:58 ET by foolnomoreno problem :let the local's do what ever they want to him , maybe use the shredder that was used,maybe take him for a boat ride an tie his legs and drop'm out, an go trolling for sharks OR let the DOCTORS who he had their hands "CUT" off, over see some of his discomfort's
As far as I am concerned, the
December 19, 2006 - 09:34 ET by InfomanOhioAs far as I am concerned, the longer and more painful Saddam's execution is, the better. No amount of suffering he goes through will make up for the hundreds of thousands of people he and his sons killed, maimed, or simply made to "disappear", but at least some satisfaction will be gained once he is dangling from the gallows. My only worry is that the SOB will somehow escape the hangman's noose.
As far as the MSM goes, they can cry over Saddam's hanging if they want to...the rest of us will be pumping our fists and saying "Yes! It's about time!"
The truth may be ugly, but it is still the truth.
Perfect punishment
December 19, 2006 - 09:42 ET by dagdaMaybe he should be beaten to death with shoes by the families of his victims.
Our real problem, then, is not our strength today; it is rather the vital necessity of action today to ensure our strength tomorrow. Dwight Eisenhower
From what I understand, that
December 19, 2006 - 09:50 ET by InfomanOhioFrom what I understand, that is an Islamic form of punishment, and it is considered to be the most severe as well.
The truth may be ugly, but it is still the truth.
If anything, Saddam's executi
December 19, 2006 - 09:53 ET by JaylouemIf anything, Saddam's execution will make him a victim of justice.