On Thursday’s NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams highlighted how, earlier in the day, First Lady Laura Bush “placed the blame squarely on the news media" for why so few support the President on Iraq. But instead of addressing her contention about how “there are a lot of good things that are happening that aren't covered and I think the drumbeat in the country from the media...is discouraging" as she hoped for “more balanced coverage” in the future, Williams applied a non sequitur to dismiss her assessment of the news media. He noted how “the recent report from the Iraq Study Group, however, specifically found that there has been significant under-reporting of the violence in Iraq." But that’s about the accuracy of U.S. military data collection and categorization, not the accuracy of news media coverage of the situation in Iraq. (Transcript follows)
From the December 14 NBC Nightly News:
Brian Williams: “First Lady Laura Bush had something to say about Iraq today. It was during an appearance on MSNBC. Mrs. Bush was asked by Norah O'Donnell why she thinks only two out of ten Americans, in our latest NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll, said they approved of the President's handing in the war in Iraq. Mrs. Bush placed the blame squarely on the news media.”First Lady Laura Bush, at the White House, on MSNBC: “I do know that there are a lot of good things that are happening that aren't covered and I think the drumbeat in the country from the media, from the only way people know what's happening unless they happen to have a loved one deployed there, is discouraging.”
Williams: “Mrs. Bush went on to say she hopes for what she called ‘more balanced coverage’ in the future. The recent report from the Iraq Study Group, however, specifically found that there has been significant under-reporting of the violence in Iraq.”
—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Propaganda and the bigger picture
December 14, 2006 - 23:01 ET by ron bucknerYunno, the emurging lack of ethics in our media has the potential to literally unravel our entire country. Look at what Ahmanabooboo is doing with media manipulation. It makes no difference what the facts may say, or what people lived through. Before he's done the Holocost will have never happened, and whats worse, is the tenacity of our recorded history will become questionable by our youth. Our political bickering is proving it now. Truth is no longer neccessary to get something said on television. If it gets said enough, it inevitably becomes believed. That is propaganda and if we don't recognize it now and temper it sooner or later the one with the most power will be the one who can "buy" the loudest voice. Guess who that might be?
The troops say the coverage i
December 14, 2006 - 23:13 ET by EdhenryThe troops say the coverage is not accurate. That is the best source.
I support the troops and their mission, until it is completed. To do otherwise energizes the enemy, prolongs the conflict and causes more GIs to die unecessarily. God bless our troops during this season.
Every death in Iraq gets repo
December 15, 2006 - 00:02 ET by AntiMediaEvery death in Iraq gets reported and repeated thousands of times in a 24 hour news cycle. By the end of the day one death seems more like a hundred.
Laura Bush has it exactly right.
December 15, 2006 - 00:28 ET by CTHow many times have you watched an empty talking head state that Iraq is a failure and a disaster. Did you ever wonder where and when these pinheads became foreign affairs experts? How is it they have more insight than any elected official supporting the administration.
What do you suppose the odds are that 99% of our fighting forces in Iraq have got it all wrong because we are really losing the battle?
Don’t you think it’s time for Americans to speak up and tell these self appointed experts that they are full of it.CT ?1=Lot's of!!! ?2=
December 15, 2006 - 01:28 ET by ww thumperCT ?1=Lot's of!!! ?2=<<0% ?3= FAR,FAR PAST TIME!!! .....Political correctness when dealing with Islam will kill america....ww .....
Typical Liberal sophistry: Us
December 15, 2006 - 01:52 ET by mattmTypical Liberal sophistry: Use information about "the accuracy of U.S. military data collection and categorization" to argue against the lack of "accuracy of news media coverage." This is more of a lie than a non-sequitur.
Ya know it's pretty funny Brian that most troops disagree w/you
December 15, 2006 - 02:13 ET by terrigAs others have stated, why is it that 99% of the troops disagree with Brian's assessment? I don't know, maybe they're all "dumb" like Jon Carry said they were. I guess Brian & the MSM are the only smart ones and those of us who are stupid need their guidance to help us see the "truth". Yeah, right and I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell ya. The 'rents will be disappointed that they won't get to watch Boy Brian for the 3 weeks they're with me. Too bad, I am Scrooge.
Ya know it's pretty funny Brian that most troops disagree w/you
December 15, 2006 - 02:13 ET by terrigAs others have stated, why is it that 99% of the troops disagree with Brian's assessment? I don't know, maybe they're all "dumb" like Jon Carry said they were. I guess Brian & the MSM are the only smart ones and those of us who are stupid need their guidance to help us see the "truth". Yeah, right and I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell ya. The 'rents will be disappointed that they won't get to watch Boy Brian for the 3 weeks they're with me. Too bad, I am Scrooge.
Ya know it's pretty funny Brian that most troops disagree w/you
December 15, 2006 - 02:13 ET by terrigAs others have stated, why is it that 99% of the troops disagree with Brian's assessment? I don't know, maybe they're all "dumb" like Jon Carry said they were. I guess Brian & the MSM are the only smart ones and those of us who are stupid need their guidance to help us see the "truth". Yeah, right and I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell ya. The 'rents will be disappointed that they won't get to watch Boy Brian for the 3 weeks they're with me. Too bad, I am Scrooge.
Most initial stories I see
December 15, 2006 - 02:50 ET by Right2thePointMost initial stories I see are later revised down as to the death toll. I can't claim first hand accounting of the validity of any of it for sure. But I have to believe if numbers are getting revised on a daily basis it is because someone in the area is talking to someone else and calling BS. Otherwise the initial number would stand.
Beyond that he was focusing on one facet of a multipart issue.
That is similar to trying to project some kind of assesment of the well being of the USA by the number of DUI's last year.
Interesting in it's own right, but not a conclusion grabber.
NBC Brian Williams
December 15, 2006 - 08:52 ET by Senior ChiefOf course the First Lady was right. On a recent poll released yesterday, journalists were at the very bottom of who are the most ethical (or unethical) people. Mrs. Bush has the highest approval rating of a sitting First lady. So then, who should we believe, Brian Williams and his likes or the First Lady?
The phrase "more balanced coverage in the futue", also suggests to drive-by-media viewers to abandon watching the leftist media and go somehwere else!
With the state of the MSM t
December 15, 2006 - 09:28 ET by Red JeepWith the state of the MSM the way it is, can you imagine 100 years from now a student trying to do a truthful report on the Bush 43 Presidency, or a historian trying to do a book? There is more fiction than fact on record.
If Brian Williams and his kind keep up it will not matter. We will all be speaking Iranian and the one nightly news reader on the sole TV channel in the US will be Brian Williamsabobaloulou, Brian Williams' grandson, and no one will be interested in what was 100 years ago.
You know how it works--the ve
December 15, 2006 - 09:31 ET by Andrew H.You know how it works--the very kind of people he rails against will save his ass so he can go on to dismiss them (us) in an overpaid reader job.
Liberalism is a convenient lie.
This is so disrespectful and
December 15, 2006 - 09:35 ET by rimskyThis is so disrespectful and irresponsible! And so frustrating, because Brian Williams, Katie Couric, and what's his name.. oh yeah Charlie Gibson, and crazy Olberman, and all the other liberal MSM hood ornaments can get away with this kind of thing because so much of the viewing public has been quite duped into accepting as gospel anything that these news readers.. read. Brian Williams, how dare you to undercut the First Lady with deceptive statements like this. You hold yourself up as if you are some kind of symbol of truth and integrity, when all you can do is twist and spin half turths or out right lies.
Typical arrogance of msm. Wil
December 15, 2006 - 09:38 ET by msh1973Typical arrogance of msm. Williams is so disrespectful, now he has chosen to dis the First Lady, nice move slick.
Brian boy, of course, would n
December 15, 2006 - 10:04 ET by HypocriteHaterBrian boy, of course, would never have challanged Madame Hillary the way he did Laura. If he did, he would have been found floating in the East River by now.
It never ceases to amaze me how the media absolutely HATES to be challanged on their conduct. No one circles the wagons to protect each other like the drive-by media does when they feel one of their own is "attacked".
This is the same industry that will rip to shreds any other industry they feel is taking advantage of the public (except for abortion clinics). But if the unwashed masses ask for any sort of accountability from the media, WATCH OUT!!! All we'll get is "How dare you challange us! Do you know who we ARE, you simpletons?!"
"Today we did what we had to do. They counted on America to be passive. They counted wrong." - Ronald Reagan
Three whiny professions
December 15, 2006 - 14:52 ET by UnsaneAs a rule, there are professions that scowl at contempt at all others, but when they themselves are held to account, they sit on the ground and scream like a bunch of two year olds. Journalists are one such profession. I would argue that two others are public school teachers and law enforcement, espcially on the local level.
"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy." -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)
Everytime I think my disgus
December 15, 2006 - 09:50 ET by CrimsonfistedEverytime I think my disgust with Brian Williams could sink no lower, he moves the bar further down.
Insult Mrs Bush? Not the sharpest knife in the drawer is he, this Williams creep?
liar
December 15, 2006 - 10:56 ET by iveseenitallWilliams is a liar. He implies all the time, "I'm not a lefty", "I'm not biased". And right, the slimy bastard chooses whom to disrespect. I wouldn't buy a used car from this guy, or from Russert, Reid, Clinton, Matthews, Olbermann, Gibson, Kennedy, Conyers, Durbin, Rather, Couric, Dowd, Carville, Bugala, Gore, Biden, Edwards, Kerry, Pelosi,O'Bama...---Oh my God; it's as nightmare! Get me out of here!
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
ive,I know exactly how you fe
December 15, 2006 - 11:25 ET by msh1973ive,
I know exactly how you feel. I sometimes think I am living a bad dream and I can't wake up. I don't really see anything changing anytime soon. The hate will continue until Pres. Bush is out of office. If another Republican is elected in 08 we will see the same behavior continue.
Seems to me that mr. williams
December 15, 2006 - 11:06 ET by bassndudeSeems to me that mr. williams missed the entire point of what Mrs. Bush said, and elaborated on his own point and the point of the MSM. He is either a dunce or an idiot. Which is it mr. williams?
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
There's something inherently
December 15, 2006 - 11:09 ET by slvrwlfThere's something inherently unprofessional about Brian Williams correcting the First Lady of the United States on national television for an opinion that, frankly, she's right about. From what I have seen of Laura Bush, she has not pushed her own political agenda in the years since she's been in the White House nor sought media attention to satisfy her own narcissism; unlike a certain former First Lady and current junior Senator of New York. And frankly, Laura Bush has been more than cordial to a media that, on a daily basis, demonstrates their unadulterated hatred towards her husband as a president and human being.
So she treats the press with class and professionalism and what does she get in return? A public "slap-in-the-face". Take some advice Mr. Williams, it's one thing for you to go after the president because of his policy decisions, it's another thing for you to go after his wife simply because you don't agree with her opinion.
And if Mr. Williams did his research, he would come to find out that Mrs. Bush is correct. The troops on the ground hate the media (with the possible exception of Fox News) because of their distortions and disinterest in reporting any of the progress that's happening in both Iraq and Afghanistan; I hear it from my buddies who return from the sandbox. Mr. Williams' behavior may get him a pass from the elitists he cavorts him, but it doesn't from people like me who still believe that there is a line you should never cross when dealing with people on a professional basis, regardless of whether or not you agree with them.
Williams
December 15, 2006 - 11:37 ET by iveseenitallThe arrogance of ignorance. The rooster primps and struts around the barnyard, never realizing who or what he is. Same for Williams. He's the proverbial pig with lipstick.
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
I don't think there's ever b
December 15, 2006 - 12:12 ET by NoMoreClintonsI don't think there's ever been a network anchor so stuck on himself.
Don't take yourself so seriously, Mr. Williams, I can assure you we don't!
Brian Williams...screw you an
December 16, 2006 - 17:11 ET by bigtimerBrian Williams...screw you and the horse you think you rode in on....you disrespectful useless idiot.
"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland