CBS's Harry Smith Fearful Iraq Report Will Only Collect 'Dust Bunnies' At White House


Co-host of CBS’s "Early Show," Harry Smith, highlighted the recommendations of the Iraq Study Group and his worries that they could be disregarded by the Bush administration, and may "end up with the dust bunnies." In the 7:00 half hour of Thursday’s program, Smith interviewed the co-chairs of the Iraq Study Group, former Secretary of State James Baker and former Democratic Congressman Lee Hamilton, and he also spoke with Illinois Senator Barack Obama. In both instances, Smith alluded to the fact that the Bush administration may not follow the Baker/Hamilton Commission findings.

During his segment with Secretary Baker and Congressman Hamilton, Smith lamented to Secretary Baker that the Iraq Study Group had spent months on its report, but it may be discarded by the president:

"Here's my concern, you've been working on this for months, you have this amazing bipartisan cooperation to come up with this document. You present it to the president yesterday. Maybe he has a book like this. What if it gets slid under the bed and ends up with the dust bunnies?"

Mr. Baker dismissed the notion as the nature of commissions, and asserted that the president could be enthusiastic about them, but Democrats on Capitol Hill could thwart the recommendations as well, "And suppose -- let's suppose he might respond to it in a bit more aggressively, but the Democratic majority on the hill doesn't vote reconstruction funds."

Smith continued his push for the implementation of the Iraq Study Group’s recommendations in the subsequent segment, this time in an interview with Senator Barack Obama. Smith neglected to ask Obama about what his plan for Iraq would be, but, rather, seemed more interested if Obama would take the Baker/Hamilton Commission’s recommendations more seriously than the current president:

"If you were the President of the United States, how seriously would you take these recommendations?"

Smith’s questions echoed this past week’s cover of "Newsweek" which asked "Will Bush Listen?" President Bush has said he will consider the suggestions made by the Iraq Study Group, but he will consider them along with recommendations he will receive from the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the National Security Agency. Just because the Bush Administration may not enact all of the Baker/Hamilton commissions ideas, does not mean he did not listen to what they had to say, and it does not mean he is not changing course.

On a different note, co-host Rene Syler misquoted comments made by Robert Gates, who was confirmed by the Senate as the next Secretary of Defense. In a brief anchor read Syler highlighted:

"It was Robert Gates' candor on Iraq that sealed his confirmation as Secretary of Defense. Gates was overwhelmingly approved by the full Senate Wednesday after testifying that the U.S. is losing the war. He'll be sworn in December 18th."

However, Gates never said the U.S. was losing the war. As noted by Harry Smith on Wednesday’s program:

"He said while we're not winning the war; he said we're not losing it either. That should be pointed out, away from the headlines a little bit."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The Iraq Surrender Group Re

The Iraq Surrender Group Report should never have a chance to gather dust bunnies because it ought to go right into the &hit can.


Give a Democrat Party free America a chance!

The Iraq Surrender Group Re

The Iraq Surrender Group Report should never have a chance to gather dust bunnies because it ought to go right into the &hit can.


Give a Democrat Party free America a chance!

Iraq Surrender Group - thats good

Surrender - that's a good one.

I think Michael Savage is on to something. Bush should tell the Army to head South and hang AlSadr and annihilate the Mahdi Army, then wheel North and kill the Sunni deadenders.

I might add, then wheel right and dont stop til you join forces with the troops in Afghanistan. (look at your map for that one).

That's what FDR meant when he said we would win through to 'ultimate victory' - not retreat with honor,withdrawal,cut and run or any of that.

Now that's realism.

Rush started calling it the I

Rush started calling it the Iraq Surrender Group yesterday first off on his show yesterday! Good one indeed! Leave it to Rush!

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

Why leave it where it will co

Why leave it where it will collect dust?  Flush the thing down the toilet!

Great statement Dave! Flush i

Great statement Dave! Flush it indeed!

I am coing to contribute to the environment and light the fire with it if I ever come across it....

"Once the coffers of the federal government are opened to the public, there will be no shutting them again." - Grover Cleveland

Please organize a Burn the ISG report rally

Someone, please organize a Burn The Surrender Group Report rally

 pearl..would it be great if

 pearl..would it be great if President Bush would call a news confrance , and burn it in front of the White House Press Core!!   :^}    (bratt smile)   :-)                .....Political correctness when dealing with  Islam will kill america....ww .....    

Give the ISGR a Thumpin

Now that would give the Surrender Group a Thumpin' indeed.

Actually, that would be aweso

Actually, that would be awesome, but only after he bashes James Baker over the head with it!

Dave R ...I would like to see

Dave R ...I would like to see that!!   wouldn't  that be a hoot!! ?  :^}              .....Political correctness when dealing with  Islam will kill america....ww .....    

Who knows? Perhaps it would k

Who knows? Perhaps it would knock some sense into the guy.

It appears he spent too many years kooped up over at Foggy Bottom (That's the State Department for those of you who are not Clancy fans.)

ISG

Poor George, living with a silver knife in the back. He, surviving with multiple wounds, is now faced with the prospect of either accepting the recommendations of the ISG or, as he is reminded in every Q&A session, being branded as just unable to accept his failure, incapable of change, to stupid to see the light, and on and on. The report is being labeled as non-partisan and I suppose therefor infallible. Two things. It took less than an hour for the Democrats to claim the report as a mime of their own position and to ask the President to admit his failures as the report was said to do. So much for "the water's edge", again. Second, do all assume the Pentagon's reports and recommendations are partisan? Sure the civilian leadership are political appointees, however, it is the folks on the ground and the leaders that send these brave men and women to their possible deaths that prepare such things. They are not political hacks.

I've got to get a copy fo

I've got to get a copy for my house. I'm being overrun with dust bunnies.

Did they patent the formula before P&G or Johnson Wax start to market their own brands. Do all congressional reports and budget plans work to catch the bunnies. The slick paper reports that are mailed to our house from congress don't work at all.

Also, which cartoonist illustrated the ISG report for our yAle eDucated, illiteRate presiDent? <sarcasm off>

PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH is t

PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH is the COMMANDER IN CHIEF .