Dionne's Siren Song To GOP: Renounce Reagan, Embrace Bill

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

Barbra Streisand not yet having weighed in with her advice to the Republican party as to how it might regain power, we'll have to settle for the counsel that WaPo columnist E.J. Dionne, Jr. generously offers in his column of today, Can the GOP Find Its Center?

His advice boils down to a two-part program: forget about conservatism already, and Be Like Bill.

Dionne begins by proclaiming that "this fall's election defeat . . . revealed that the Barry Goldwater-Ronald Reagan political settlement has expired," by which he apparently means that conservatism as a winning political philosophy has gone the way of the parrot in A Fish Called Wanda. E.J. thus goes on to deride Republican leaders such as John Boehner and Mike Pence who in the wake of the GOP's defeat call for a return to traditional conservatives principles, chief among them that of limited government.

Dionne approvingly cites Sarah Chamberlain Resnick, executive director of the Republican Main Street Partnership [a liberal GOP group] who "said moderates had, to no avail, warned their leadership of 'the consequences of pushing a legislative agenda kowtowing to the far right in our party.'"

"A legislative agenda kowtowing to the far right"? Earth to Sarah and EJ: this was the Republican majority that legislated the biggest entitlement expansion in history, that passed out earmark-pork millions like gumdrops, and was led by a president who used his power to veto runaway spending exactly . . . zero times.

Dionne claims "the GOP desperately needs to disenthrall itself from old thinking." Translation: ditch your conservative principles. And in its place? EJ counsels Republican presidential candidates to take their lead from "a politician who liked to condemn 'the brain-dead politics of both parties.' His name was Bill Clinton."

Hogwash. We all know the old saw that, given the choice between a real Democrat and an imitation one, voters will choose the real one every time. Given Hillary's likely presence on the ballot, you might extrapolate to a choice between a real Clinton and an imitation one. Any GOP presidential contender who takes advice from an MSM Democrat like Dionne and thinks the way to electoral salvation is to embrace Bill Clinton will deserve the defeat Republican primary voters are sure to inflict on him. Here's the advice an actual Republican might give: ignore the Siren song of the left, steer to the principled Reaganesque right, and win.

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

History flunkies...

These pathetic history flunkies...but...someone has to be stupid so I am glad types like Dionne volunteer.


I am a member of LSCA (Lazy Spell Checkers Anonymous).

You're right.  It reminds me

You're right.  It reminds me of Mark Twain's quote, "the rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated."  All the pundits are rushing to come to grips with the last election when really we should be rushing to come to grips with the next one.  Conservativism isn't dead, it is just in a weeding out process.

I tried to come up with a limerick for this article, but the only word I could think of that rhymes with Dione is clueless.

Sure, Clinton who has the mor

Sure, Clinton who has the morals of a sewer rat. My hero. 

I love how the left tells us

I love how the left tells us how to win… be like Bill, if it was not for Perot he would not have had his fun in the oval office. Bill.. such a shining example on just how to be president.

So the people that want us to loose is giving us advice on how to win???  I have some advice for you leftist.  Stop running conservatives be who you are.   

America is best described by one word, freedom... Dwight D. Disenhower

Only a fool would think we sh

Only a fool would think we should emulate Disgraced Ex-President Clinton

Naturally, the MSM goes right along with anything the former Harrasser-in-Chief did.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The MSM supports the troops.  The enemy's troops!

Somebody please correct me if

Somebody please correct me if I am wrong, but wasn't the republican defeat more or less related to the fact that they had been acting more like Clinton and the dims?

Exactly

Exactly, Dave. Republicans lost because they gave up their principles to "get along" with the left. Until they get THAT message, they will not succeed.

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal 

isia...Amen to that!!!!

isia...

Amen to that!!!!

The day the GOP starts taking

The day the GOP starts taking advice from arrogant idiots like E.J. Dionne Jr. is the day I officially join Constitutional Party.

EJ Dipoinne Jr

EJ Dipoinne Jr < looks like a lib name.

He looks like Barney Franks brother. I bet he's a pedo.

Yes, it seems so many of the libs are freaks. That's how they adopt their poor me pity platform of victimization. They came out victimized at birth, and never got over it.

Why say anything else to the idiot ? Look at that pic.

My god... Why would Dionne

My god... Why would Dionne ask the GOP to find it's center to accomodate some like Clinton...? There isn't enough room in the GOP center to accomodate Bill Clinton's ego much less accomodate his idiotic political philosophies of neo-socialism, the polticals of personal destruction, and envy...

Uh, Dionne--no.  We're still

Uh, Dionne--no.  We're still out here and know what clinton did to the country was terrible and something to never be re-done.  Are you another media face who didn't study his economics in college?  I thought so. 

Never relent.