An Inconvenient Truth: Olbermann Bullies the National Science Teachers Association

Photo of Amy Ridenour.

With the final line "Linda Froschauer, president of the National Science Teachers Association, available at the right price," Keith Olbermann of MSNBC Monday named Froschauer his "Worst Person in the World."

How did Ms. Froschauer get labeled a policy prostitute on MSNBC? The organization she heads declined a donation of 50,000 DVD copies of Al Gore's documentary-editorial "An Inconvenient Truth."

Yep. Apparently that movie is so good, people have to be paid to turn down 50,000 copies of it.

As movie producer Laurie David said in an indignant op-ed in the Washington Post (one of four pro-global warming theory articles the Post ran over the last two-day weekend, by my count), the movie's producers donated the 50,000 DVDs "for educators to use in their classrooms."

David called the producers' offer a "no brainer," and she was probably right, just not in the manner she thought. Distributing the movie would have harmed the National Science Teacher's Association's reputation.

David described the National Science Teacher's Association's reasoning this way:

In their e-mail rejection, they expressed concern that other "special interests" might ask to distribute materials, too; they said they didn't want to offer "political" endorsement of the film; and they saw "little, if any, benefit to NSTA or its members" in accepting the free DVDs.

Fair enough. Despite David's denials ("Gore... is not running for office") Gore's movie is political. "Political will is a renewable resource," the movie's website says, and it goes on to urge people to take actions it recommends, some of which are legislative. We can assume not all these legislative recommendations are endorsed by the students' parents.

An Inconvenient Truth also is a bit hysterical. Consider the first paragraph of the first section on the movie's website:

Humanity is sitting on a ticking time bomb. If the vast majority of the world's scientists are right, we have just ten years to avert a major catastrophe that could send our entire planet into a tail-spin of epic destruction involving extreme weather, floods, droughts, epidemics and killer heat waves beyond anything we have ever experienced.

I'm going to go out on a limb here and guess that even most believers in the global warming theory would call this misleading at best. "The vast majority of the world's scientists" don't even work on climate. Among those scientists who do, "the vast majority" DO NOT claim "we have just ten years to avert a major catastrophe."

An Inconvenient Truth also provides an "AIT [An Inconvenient Truth] in the Classroom" educator's guide that includes such assertions (pdf) as "If the warming continues, we can expect catastrophicc consequences. Deaths from global warming will double in just 25 years -- to 300,000 people a year."

Perhaps "AIT in the Classroom" can direct us to a list of names of the 150,000 people who are currently dying annually because of global warming? Or any other specific information about the unfortunate 150,000, to permit the thorough verification of this rather dramatic claim?

That the National Science Teachers Association, a group that appears to take its work seriously, doesn't want 50,000 copies of this movie to distribute at (apparently) its own expense makes sense to me, but not to Laurie David, Keith Olbermann or MSNBC.

But then, Laurie David, Keith Olbermann and MSNBC are after something other than the National Science Teachers Association. They're after the usual culprit in these tedious envirodramas: ExxonMobil.

You see, according to David, ExxonMobil, Shell Oil and the American Petroleum Institute have donated to the the National Science Teachers Association. So, in a move reminiscent of the ill-grounded assertions of Britain's Royal Society and Senators Rockefeller and Snowe, Laurie David, Keith Olbermann and MSNBC assume the oil industry is ultimately responsible for the decisions and positions of the the NSTA.

Al Gore's movie, like it or lump it, is a movie expressing strong opinions and political content. Are we to assume that the only NSTA donors who might question distributing 50,000 copies of such a film to teachers for classroom use are oil companies?

Furthermore, do we really want education associations distributing to teachers copies of everything they are given for free? Should money in the form of free DVDs have trumped the NSTA's judgment?

P.S. Note in this <src="http://www.nationalcenter.org/uploaded_images/MSNBCOlbermann112706.jpg>screen capture how MSNBC's website misleadingly described the Froschauer-led National Science Teacher's Association's decision not to accept and distribute a movie with political content. Not quite accurate, is it?


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Guilt, guilt, and more guilt - the Left can't get enough!!!

Seems Olbermann is pushing around his own wheelbarrow of guilt too!

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

But we have to listen to Al

But we have to listen to AlGore about Global Warming I mean after all those killer hurricanes
we’ve had this year…What? oh there weren’t any killer hurricanes this
year….but Al promised there would be…if he was wrong about that..is it
possible he could be wrong about other things too? Well then I quess we
shouldn’t be giving students false one sided info after all.

Amy, you have to like Krazy K

Amy, you have to like Krazy Keith comparing Al Gore to Galileo, as he joked about the supposedly science-hating NSTA:

"I got Copernicus and Galileo on the phone. They say the earth revolves around the sun. What, hang up on them? All right, I'm sorry, we have taken millions from the Flat Earth Society.”

Krazy Keith comparing Al Go

Krazy Keith comparing Al Gore to Galileo

That is funny considering both Krazy Keef and Al Gore think the earth revolves around them!.

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast
militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

The thing about that is that

The thing about that is that while it makes a point efficiently, neither Keith Olbermann nor Laurie David actually proved the NTSA turned down the DVDs because of pressure from oil industry donors, or even that the group's industry donors even knew about the proposed donation. Accuracy ought to count for something.

I note also that Olbermann didn't say anything he couldn't have gotten from Laurie David's op-ed, and she has a conflict of interest in reporting a matter in which she was a major participant. Some reporting that is!

it is really embarrassing

You're right; and it reminds me of some things I observed back in the 90's, working for a Mexican gov't exporting firm.

This is the exact way the Mexican news media reports.

If only we could convince B

If only we could convince Blabbermann and Laurie David to limit their comments to just those things on which they are qualified to render an opinion. Blabbermann could have his tongue surgically connected to the end of his nose, and David could spend her time eating bonbons and watching Green Acres reruns. And the rate of global warming would be reduced enough to save the lives of 2 or 3 kids in Dafur.

Mommie Dearest Remake

I think I heard they are making a "Mommie Dearest" remake, and that Olbermann went to try out for the part of Mommie Dearest, but the director said he was too angry for the part.

"No wire hangers, ever!"

Response

So they cast Rush Limbaugh instead.

for you CRD

You heard wrong, they cast Howard Dean for the role.

And they are going to release the movie in VIRGGGGIINIAAA, and MARRYLAAND, and MIGHHIIIIGAAAAN, THEN WE ARE GOING TO TAKE IT ALL THE WAY TO THE WHITE HOUSEEE. YIPPEEEEEEEEEEEE

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

Response

Oh, you bitter loser .

If Olbie gets his way, Totalitarianism isn't far behind

Linda Froschauer possibly, or likely… probably knows Gore’s adventure into the sciences holds no credibility.

Of course, vitriolic Olbermann, who, as we know, cannot add or subtract, is once again rabid that someone dare turn their learned heads away from Gore’s hyperbolic production. This woman explained the whys and wherefores; however, that was not good enough for Keith and others whose diktat is… “We know what is best for America and its children…”  Totalitarianism isn’t far away, if Olbie and his comrades get their way.

If Ms. Froschauer is a worst person in the world nominee; it doesn't bode well for any of us here.

We're probably safe from Olbe

We're probably safe from Olbermann unless someone else attacks one of us first. He likes to crib off of other people's work.