GMA Lauds Carter Book Accusing Israel of Apartheid As Working For 'Peace'

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.

I actually have a soft spot for Good Morning America's Robin Roberts, finding her among the most even-keeled of the morning news show hosts. But again this morning she evinced a tendency to get star-struck in the presence of a big name, and wound up lavishing praise on Jimmy Carter and his book, Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, which depicts Israel as a second-rate South Africa from the bad old days.

Roberts actually began with what amounted to a DNC disclaimer:

"Now to your book, which many people find surprising, that you come down a little hard on Israel and that there have been key Democrats who have distanced themselves a little bit from your view on Israel. In fact, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi [jumping the gun there just a tad, Robin] said it is wrong to suggest that the Jewish people would support a government in Israel or anywhere else that institutionizes ethnically-based oppression and Democrats reject that allegation vigorously. What is your response to that?"

Carter replied by claiming that he has spent the last 30 years trying to find peace for Israel and its neighbors, but adding "you can't find peace unless you address the existing issues honestly and frankly." Translation: it's all Israel's fault.

Carter then patted himself on the back: "I think the most important step toward peace for Israel was when I negotiated a peace treaty between Israel and Egypt in 1979."

Carter then went off on this Israel-bashing spree:

"There is no doubt now that a minority of Israelis are perpetrating apartheid on the people in Palestine. This occupation and confiscation and colonization of land on the West Bank is the prime cause of the continuation of violence in the Middle East."

Really! So Sunni is slaughtering Shia in Iraq over Israel's intransigence? Who knew? And not a word from Carter about the Camp David meeting at which Israeli PM Barak offered Arafat 97% of the land he had demanded. Not only did Arafat refuse the offer, he didn't even deign to make a counter-proposal.

Continued Carter:

"What is being done to the Palestinians under Israeli domination is really atrocious. It's a terrible affliction on these people."

Timidly and haltingly, Roberts did try to respond: "Some would say by electing Hamas, the Palestinians are in effect, kind of, the reason why there is a sumbling block for peace."

The vainglorious Carter: "I was there and the Carter Center was in charge of the election. . . And there hasn't been one day of substantive negotiations between Israel and her neighbors in the last six years. So you can't say that the election of Hamas interfered with any sort of peace effort because no peace effort has been going on. And the prime choice by the United States and Israel of an interlocutor that was known as a voice of moderation, that is, Abbas, was chosen as prime minister when Arafat was there and for three years he was not called upon to negotiate and then when he became president he still hasn't been called upon to negotiate. So there is no effort being made in the Middle East at all to bring about an accommodation between Israel and the Palestinians."

Translation: repeat after me - it's all Israel's fault.

That's when Roberts caved, with this fawning goodbye: "President Carter, always optimistic, and your book reflects that. I know the Carter Foundation, you are trying to find world peace and this book is part of that."

Right. If your definition of peace is the elimination of a viable Israel.

Finkelstein recently returned from Iraq. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Why can't the msm (Lsm) leave

Why can't the msm (Lsm) leave Cater rest in peace? Oh, he's still alive? Have a peanut mr. pres, wash it down with some Billy Beer.

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad

Jimmy's problem is that not o

Jimmy's problem is that not only was he too naive to understand the world his Presidency had to deal with back then, but even that naivete is grossly dated and obsolete. 

Carter then patted himself on the back: "I think the most important step toward peace for Israel was when I negotiated a peace treaty between Israel and Egypt in 1979.

Apples and oranges.  The continual state of war that existed between Egypt and Israel --- even if it wasn't always "hot" -- was crippling the economies of both countries.  Egypt recognized Israel's sovereignty, for one thing.  The land in dispute --- the Sinai --- provided ample distance between the two populations areas.  US security assurances in the Sinai --- in no small part in the way of a US infantry battalion as observers between the forces ---- allowed the IDF to withdraw mostly back to Israel.   Additionally, both Israel and Egypt received more US foreign aid --- principally for their armed forces --- which allowed the IDF and particularly the Egyptian military to modernize a lot of their weapons systems.  That aid made those countries the #1 and #2 recipients of US aid.

Palestine is another case.  One, as far as I know, the current government -- controlled by Hamas --- does not recognize the state of Israel.  For another, not only are the population centers very close to each other,  but the land in dispute --- the West Bank --- is adjacent to the city most coveted by both sides:  Jerusalem.   And a third point:  Egypt had economic potential; Palestine does not.

And speaking of the West Bank, it's apparent from Carter's comments which side he takes in the dispute.

Carter

Jimmuh,

There is no Palestine. There are no Palestinians. Those who claim to be are vagabonds and gypsies who were thrown out of Jordan. Jordan doesn't want them. Egypt doesn't want them. Syria doesn't want them. I don't want them either.

My favorite "Palestinian" story was when Yassir Arafat was kept waiting to see President Clinton at the White House while Mr. Clinton was being blown by Monica Lewinsky. El Rushbo opened his show the next day with a musical dedication for Arafat... Sam And Dave's "Hold On... Cause I'm Comin'".

Gordo

Melmac

Carter

Jimmy Carter was the worst president in my lifetime. Clinton was a close second.

NEVER, NEVER trust a liberal

Carter did so much to help th

Carter did so much to help the middle east.All good rapport was destroyed by bush, the worst and most embarassing leader in our history.

"No one can terrorize a whole nation, unless we all are accomplices."

E. Murrow

I agree President Carter is a

I agree President Carter is arguably one of the worst if not the worst leader in recent history. 

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark. -- save my gun, shoot a liberal.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!  

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!   Never read Guests of the Ayatollah, have you???

neohayes, look up 4 November 1979, find out what happened on that day, and find out who was President that day.

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

While your at it. look up whe

While your at it. look up where that raghead was nursed back to health, and at whose urging.

Careful. You may no like what you find.

90 were held hostage. Of cour

90 were held hostage. Of course we blame carter.

2000 dead americans in Iraq- Whos to blame?

is our popularity and rapport in the middle east better now?

surely you must be joking.

"No one can terrorize a whole nation, unless we all are accomplices."

E. Murrow

"2000 dead americans in

"2000 dead americans in Iraq- Whos to blame?"

I blame dimwit naive poloticians like Jimmuh and Bubbya and their brain dead followers like you.

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

ditto

ditto

We dont blame President carte

We dont blame President carter for letting the hostages get taken by the Iranian revolution, we blame him for his gross incompetence.  It was a simple matter of freeing 90 embassy hostages and he took over 400 days and did practically nothing but talk.  Carter was a talker, but thats all he did was talk.  It took a real leader like Regan who said give us our people or else.  Just one simple statement  that they understood.

President Bush is not responsible for the dead the terrorists are.  The President is responsible for keeping the USA there as he is for keeping any troops anywhere.  The troops recognize the danger and accept it as part of thier job.  The job of keeping the free world free and safe.

Who gives a shit about being popular when you are dead.  The USA wasnt popular before this what makes you think we will be after this or if we capitulate because of weenies like you?  Being popular did not stop the terrorists from attacking us prior 911 so why should it stop.  The countries who hated us then hate us now and will continue to hate us afterwards no matter what the outcome.

God forgive him for he is a weenie.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark. -- save my gun, shoot a liberal.

We dont blame President carte

We dont blame President carter for letting the hostages get taken by the Iranian revolution, we blame him for his gross incompetence

and who are you going to blame for the incompetence from Bush?? did you vote for him?

they let them go the day reagan took office as a slap in the face to carter.

"No one can terrorize a whole nation, unless we all are accomplices."

E. Murrow

President Bush freed a nation

President Bush freed a nation from Saddams tyrany, freeing a nation is much more than 90 hostages.  We may have made a few mistakes but not many and the mistakes were made becuase of many factors including the MSM pounding on him every chance they got.  Making mistakes is part of life and learning from them is also part of life.  I voted for President Bush 2 times and proud of it.

I wish President Reagan would have slapped President Carter but he instead resigned himself to rectifying the problem at hand.  Then he started correcting the economy he inherited.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark. -- save my gun, shoot a liberal.

bush

Making mistakes is part of life and learning from them is also part of life.

It's pretty damn difficult to learn from mistakes you are unwilling to acknowledge. Bush and his administration have yet to honestly admit any mistakes. They just cannot find it within themselves to admit to something that is so genuinely human.

It's pretty damn difficult to

It's pretty damn difficult to learn from mistakes you are unwilling to acknowledge.

Is that why you keep voting Demoncrat?

d

In case you are as blind as you are stupid, I was referring to the BUSH administrations failure to admit failure on anything. Who I vote for is irrelevant. Tell me I am wrong about his.

You are wrong on this.Would t

You are wrong on this.

Would this be like Pelosi admitting she was wrong for nominating Murtha? Or Pelosi admitting she was wrong about Hastings?

You are so tunnel visioned on hating Bush, that you cant see the world around you. Its a dangerous position to be in.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

d

How am I wrong on this? You are the one who cannot see the world around you. Give me one honest admission of mistakes made by the Bush administration. Just one!

Failure to secure the US sout

Failure to secure the US southern border.

d

Nice try. I want a genuine admission of a mistake made, not an admission of getting caught with your pants down.

Very few of us here stick up for

Very few of us here stick up for Bush(43)'s failure to secure the southern border.

But I will just bet you defended everything Clinton ever did.  :-p

d

Wrong again. Didn't even vote for Clinton in 1996 because of certain policy decisions. Try again. I'll return in the morning.

And don't go away angry . . .

And don't go away angry . . .

She voted for Mary Cal Hollis

She voted for Mary Cal Hollis, the Socialists party nomination.  Fits more with her policy decisions.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

PDMP

LOL!   I would have guessed the People's Democratic Moonbat Party  ;-)

count me in on that one

One thing that annoys the heck out of me is the failure to secure the Southern Border.  It drives me absolutely nuts!

If he had done that the right

If he had done that the right side of this country would have retained the congress hands down.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

That is a genuine admission o

That is a genuine admission of a mistake.

Out of curiousity, did you ever demand an apology from clinton for the mistakes he made?

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

I would have to say this one

I would have to say this one too.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

Anything else we can be of assistance with?

Tell me I am wrong about his.

You are wrong.

Anything else we can be of assistance with?

d

Details, you stupid 

Temper, temper.Watch it with

Temper, temper.

Watch it with the potty mouth, child.

Look at that anger, your more

Look at that anger, your more mad than rosie o'donell at a male strip club.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

Do you kiss your momma with that mouth?

I think you need your mouth washed out with lifeboy.  It's always funny to me that libs can only use bad language because they don't know any other adjectives besides the f word.  Guess they slept through English class.  Perhaps that's why you're so angry as a group all the time.

Its a defensive trigger, when

Its a defensive trigger, when they realize they are being outdebated they turn to personal insults and foul language to distract and angry the other debater until the debate is so degraded no one can tell who won. Stay on topic and it drives them nuts.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

d

I'm back and I only used the f-word because you refuse to give me details, and you refuse to stay on topic! All I want is record of ONE instance of "we made a mistake" by this administration and you can't do it! All you do is DEFLECT, call me a liberal gasbag, and then talk about Nancy Pelosi???!? Please!

gjgil82 stop whining please, you left wing fool...

gjgil82 stop whining please, you left wing fool...

WAPO Staff Writer
Monday, April 24, 2006; 4:39 PM

Bush Admits Mistakes in Iraq, Defends TacticsRemarks Come at Immigration Forum

President Bush today said mistakes were made in planning for the Iraq invasion]

OK,  so are you done having your ignorant sissy fit ?

________________________________________

NOW I WANT AN EXAMPLE OF SLICK WILLIE ADMITTING HIS MISTAKES, AND LYING ABOUT SEX DOESN'T COUNT.

d

"President Bush today said mistakes were made in planning for the Iraq
invasion, but he defended the troop level he ordered in the initial
strike, saying he would have committed the same number if given a
second chance." (From WAPO article)

So what mistake, exactly, is Bush admitting to? Here he says he would not have changed anything. That is not admitting to a mistake. As he says later in the article, "I'm getting down in minutiae." Which is to say he may admit to minor little details that could have been better, but none of this really amounts to more than lip service.

Clinton just admitted to mistakes on Chris Wallace's show a few months back. With regards to OBL, he stated that he tried and FAILED to get him.


gigi...Big difference.... Cli

gigi...

Big difference.... Clintons mistake was no mistake, he failed on purpose!

Do Liberals understand what's at stake? Let's find out, go here... http://newsbusters.org/node/9253

d

Where is your proof for that?

Impeachment.

Impeachment.

Point, Set, Match.Quick and t

Point, Set, Match.

Quick and to the point, I love it.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

wrong

I sincerely hope you come back to read this. The articles of Impeachment against President Clinton were for the Lewinsky scandal you imbecile! I wanted proof of Clinton having failed to get bin Laden on purpose, as you or someone else had suggested. Point, set, and match???!? Please, try harder than that.

Imbecile fits you perfectly g

Imbecile fits you perfectly gigi.

Think Paula Johns and sexual harassment trial...okay.

Btw....Clintoon never did a thing but look the other way, stick his ugly finger in the wind to not defend this country time after time of being attacked by al Qaeda because it wasn't politically correct for him and his leftist party....

On top of that he is a rapist...Juanita Broderick ring a bell.

Clinton/Carter...the two worst Presidents in our history.

Clinton is a thieving (illegal political commie money) weakling, scaredy cat, slack-jawed impeached President...like it or not.

On top of that...a heck of a lot of people met their deaths knowing and being involved with the Clintons...just a fact...simple as that.

d

This is all hearsay, conjecture, and opinion. You still fail to offer any DEFINITIVE proof that Clinton purposefully failed to get bin Laden.

9/11 should be all the proof

9/11 should be all the proof you need gigi...9/11.

d

So, Clinton purposefully failed to get bin Laden, and your "definitive" proof for this is 9/11??? Are you high??!? To repeat since you fail to see, Clinton, in his interview with Chris Wallace, said that he went after bin Laden, and failed to get him. This was admitting to a mistake, something BushCo cannot and will not do. Your comment shows just how asinine you are.

What?  Are you mad because

What?  Are you mad because the government (not yet, anyway, and never, if I have any say in it) will not give your FREE COOKIES and a TALL GLASS OF COLD MILK before you go to bed?  Are you mad because the government won't read you a bedtime story?  Are you mad because the government won't tuck you into bed at night?

Do you need the government to refill your nursing bottle and change you? 

(Us self-reliant ones neither need those things nor resort to anger when they aren't given...)

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

d

I need you or anyone else to give me one instance of the bush admin. accepting that they  up. It seems none of you have anything.

gjgil82 stop whining please, you left wing fool

gjgil82 stop whining please, you left wing fool...

[ Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, April 24, 2006; 4:39 PM

Bush Admits Mistakes in Iraq, Defends TacticsRemarks Come at Immigration Forum

President Bush today said mistakes were made in planning for the Iraq invasion]

OK,  so are you done having your ignorant sissy fit ?

20 January 2009

Okay.  Bush won't change you, tuck you into bed, read you a bedtime story, give you your free milk and cookies, and otherwise spoil and coddle you.  This makes you VERY VERY ANGRY because that is ALL government is supposed to do for its citizenry.  Feel better?

If you hate Bush so damn much, all you need to do is to not vote for him when he runs again in 2008! 

Wait a minute...

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

g

What an asshole you are! Where in any of this current thread do you pick up that I want Government to give me everything I want? Please cite specific statements in your response. I swear, some conservatives on this post come across as being such great debaters, and then go off on some wild tangent when a thoughtful response eludes them. I'm ready to be called a whining, stupid liberal now.

Someone got caught!

Thank you for your kind compliments.  Was it not you who hates the fact our military is involved in Iraq?  Didn't you say you prefer them to be in Darfur, Chad, and Zimbabwe...what would be humanitarian missions?  Haven't you demonstrated that you hate corporations later on, right here on this very thread? 

Sounds like you are a Socialist to me, who thinks the Nanny States of Europe are the wave of the future.  If you can't be honest about what you believe, I suggest you begin blaming yourself instead of me. 

Or perhaps you are resorting to a profanity laden post with attempts to insult me because I caught you?

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

g

You caught NOTHING! I asked you to cite from this specific post, not ones from before. And why are you so bent out of shape by profanity? I find some of the comments on this blog to be quite profane without the use of curse words.

gjgil82, We are not bent out

gjgil82,

We are not bent out of shape by profanity, It is of course the sign of an un-educated mind. Profanity just shows a complete lack of intelligence. 

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

lack of intelligence sometimes

More often obscene and profane words are a result of having no vocabulary. You can be very smart and yet make obscene statements. But a bad vocabulary makes you fall back on dirty language.

Well from seeing the depth of

Well from seeing the depth of the gjgil's post, We can draw the conclusion that the poster has not put much thought in the replys.  Its a bunch of talking points and absurd statements.  With no facts or constructive comments to add to a debate, I think its safe to say we are talking with a liberal who does not think for theirselves. Instead relys on DU, Huffington, or KOS to give them their thoughts.

When questioned about the statements posted, gjgil instantly turns to insults and attacks showing a lack of vocabulary and a lack of understanding of what they are talking about.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

Yeah, unlike SportPolitics

Yeah, unlike SportPolitics and Unsane, etc.

We can draw the conclusion that the poster has not put much thought in
the replys. Its a bunch of talking points and absurd statements.

Or you.

That was profounding deep. Th

That was profounding deep.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

Cry all you want, but at leas

Cry all you want, but at least I do my homework.  And I definitely live in the realpolitik,Machiavellian world of foreign policy.  Any bitter, caustic sarcasm eminating from me should be taken as a reaction to drowning in the bile of millions (hat tip to Meshuggah, "I") of Leftists...and a fair amount of suffocating, intense frustration. 

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

g

<When questioned about the statements posted, gjgil instantly turns to
insults and attacks showing a lack of vocabulary and a lack of
understanding of what they are talking about.>

You should be careful accusing me of not having a vocabulary or understanding, I am only emulating our illustrious, verbose, and intellectual commander in chief.

Well, at least you admitted i

Well, at least you admitted it.  Attending Harvard and Yale are not easy things to accomplish. 

What will you do with yourself on 20 January 2009, regardless of the election outcome, when Bush goes on home to Crawford?  It is truly amazing to witness how such blind, intense hatred has consumed you to the point where you can barely think straight.  Do you have a political philosophy of your own that is NOT based on the extreme hatred of certain individuals?

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

d

In case you missed it I was being sarcastic.

Sure.&quot;Socialism is the p

Sure.

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

Too bad, you have been caught

Too bad, you have been caught.  Unless your mind changes so frequently that your previous posts mean absolutely nothing.  Which means you have zero spine, which means...why are you even here?  Socialist!

Incidentally, I am not bent out of shape about profanity...some of my favorite movies are Full Metal Jacket and Pulp Fiction.  What I am bent about is the fact that, just like any other Leftist, you have been adequately challenged and you can't hack it, so you resort to profanity as if it will somehow magically strengthen your argument.  But it won't.

And what do you find profane out here without the requisite words?  Eloquent defenses of a strong, proactive, realpolitik practicing America with a powerful military?  Vociferous support of free markets and minimal government intrusion? 

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

I'm ready to be called a whining, stupid liberal now.

"I'm ready to be called a whining, stupid liberal now." 

I should hope so, foul mouth!

d

Why don't you go to church and pray for me!

Pray for you?

Giggly  I will do that. You can mock me if you want, but I will do that.

Pray?  At this rate, you may

Pray?  At this rate, you may want to cloister yourself in a monastery on his behalf...

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

giggly "What an a**h*** you are!"

"What an asshole you are!"

Giggly, in the eloquent words of PeeWee Herman,

 "I know you are, but what am I?"

Quit the foul language...thei

Quit the foul language...their are other ways to express yourself with the same word...do you friggin' understand gigi?

g

Friggin?!? Quit being a wimp and say what you mean! What a bunch of pansies on this blog.

giggler

I am ready to meet you in the parking lot. I will put on some clean depenz, grease my wheels and kick the tar out of you girly boy!

Translation: &quot;I have not

Translation: "I have nothing more to add on this thread.  You guys and gals win."

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

Incompetence

Razey--cite the incompetence, then state your resolution to a few of the problems. Then explain how you will get it accepted by about 500plus Senators and Congressmen. If we agree with you, I will do a write in for you at the next Pres elections.

(As of now, you cannot find more than two bloggers here who  agree with you.)

rhayes...just how many presid

rhayes...just how many presidents in the past have allowed mortgage intrest rates to rise to 18% and most other loans, (cars, boats) rise to 21%? How many managed to cower enough before the islamist to allow them to confiscate the oil fields we developed and built, and cut the US off completely? How many allowed a US embassy to be invaded, citizens to be held hostage, and dident lift a finger? How many others cut military spending so much that even the Special Forces couldent train? The only training the military could do was once a year, for 2 whole weeks. Carter did all this in just 4 years. Just cowered deeper into his hole. Thats for starters...care to go on?

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

bassndude Don't mess me up

bassndude Don't mess me up--the dems told me those were all good things to happen to us. I confessed some time back that I voted for that do-nothing wimp, traitor. He proved me to be a fool! A short while ago I sent an email to his supposed email site and told him that his recent behavior bordered on treasonous. Of course, I never got a response.

Sorry misterbill...one questi

Sorry misterbill...one question tho. Bordered on treasonous? Bordered? I think he crossed that border sometime back. About 1976 I think.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

bassndude -polite

Bass I am sorry. I do not want to get bounced from the site so I did not say what I really felt about that ineffectual, little a$$ ki$$ing, cowardly, f***. But, again, he tricked me into voting for him so I guess I should just swallow my pride.

misterbill...dont swallow you

misterbill...dont swallow your pride, puke it up on the little castro loving commie....he likes to wallow with the commie pigs anyway...he should like it.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

 How many managed to cower e

 How many managed to cower enough before the islamist to allow them to confiscate the oil fields we developed and built, and cut the US off completely?

good thing we are back there where the oil fields are... we deserve to have them since we built them. That's enough reason to invade the middle east! tdf

I guess we should have invaded Iran. War is good for the economy and the military industrial complex. Maybe we'd get out of there with mission accomplished in less than it took for us to win ww2??

Razey--cite the incompetence,  what has bush done with competence? Katrina??, going into war with phoney evidence??, his record on helping the environment??, no child left behind?? social security?? Bush's legacy for incompetence will go down in history in all history books, revised and unrevised! The largest debt, the gap between the poor and rich larger than ever, and creating another vietnam!

President Bush freed a nation from Saddams tyrany and left a vacuum for a huge civil war with more death and destruction than ever! Are things better now?? Is is safe to live in Iraq now??

maybe a generation from now the world will wonder how we believed that the reason for invading the middle east was not oil but terrorism? some even believed saddam was behind 911...what is the neo definition of gullible??

 we wonder how germans believed the Nazis??

"While it's wrong to say that we invaded the country to take over its oil supply, Koppel writes in the Times, "the construction of American military bases inside Iraq, bases that can be maintained long after the bulk of our military forces are ultimately withdrawn, will serve to replace the bases that the United States has lost in Saudi Arabia. There may be other national security reasons that the United States cannot now precipitously withdraw its forces from Iraq, including the danger that the country would become a regional terrorist base; but none is greater than forestalling the ensuing power vacuum and regional instability, and the impact this would have on oil production....

"Perhaps the day will come when the United States is no longer addicted to imported oil; but that day is still many years off. For now, the reason for America's rapt attention to the security of the Persian Gulf is what it has always been. It's about the oil."

Noting arguments for many years about the importance of oil to our economy, Koppel observes, "If those considerations did not enter into the Bush administration's calculations when the president ordered the invasion of Iraq in 2003, it would have been the first time in more than 50 years that the uninterrupted flow of Persian Gulf oil was not a central element of American foreign policy."

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/15

And how about the Iran bungle? hmmm and the Iran bungle compared to the Iraq bungle?? comparing the two is like comparing Grenada to vietnam ...and didnt reagan and Rummy help saddam to keep Iran in check?? Don't we still have the receipts for his so called wmds?? tdf

"No one can terrorize a whole nation, unless we all are accomplices."

E. Murrow

Katrina?  Go cry to Gov. Bla

Katrina?  Go cry to Gov. Blanco and Mayor Nagin.

The environment?  THANK GOD Bush called Kyoto "fatally flawed" and took off the U.S. signature.  I LIKE living in a First World country, neohayes.  And I do so with zero guilt, unlike you.

No child left behind?  Not enough server space on here for my complaints about education.  Like hiring incompetent teachers!!!

Social security?  Bush TRIED to have it partially privatized, which would have meant a better retirement for me.  People like you THREW A FIT about it.

You are just going to have to accept that Iraq is undergoing a wave of sectarian violence just as Northern Ireland has.  And you are just going to have to accept that foreign policy is a very adult game; it is NOT a contest for who gets to be prom queen, as you want it to be.

Also, you need to study a lot more geography and accept that Mideast oil goes to Europe, Asia, and your beloved Australia.  Not much goes here because of the transit costs.

As for your accusation for who supplied WMDs to Saddam...guess who supplied the arms to Iraq?  Not the United States.  Why...France and the Soviet Union/Russia.  Their tanks were T-72s, many of their fighters were MiGs and Mirages.  Did we quietly back Iraq in order to keep the heat on Iran?  Absolutely.  Was there anything wrong with that?  Well...when I was in elementary school and walked to class down the hallway every day, I would pass lockers with some stickers on them: the stickers were white, with the Stars and Stripes, with the words FREE THE HOSTAGES underneath.  You tell me. 

The full list of who supplied WMDs to Iraq will make you extremely uncomfortable, as it will make most Leftists extremely uncomfortable.  The United States does not make the list.  Sorry.  But you'll parrot that line anyway, because you so enjoy being wrong and clinging desperately to myths...

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy."  -Sir Winston Churchill, British statesman (1874-1965)

No child left behind? fortun

No child left behind? fortunately its done less harm than his screw up in iraq, but its still a disaster like his social security plan...any plans neos start, ends in disaster.

Environment-george has done a big 0 there also, but he sucessfully let the oil companies do a white house led campaign against the inevitable facts of global warming. It succeeded in duping (brainwashing) even somewhat intelligent neocons.  Bush has succeeded in sending science back to the middle ages.

Also, Bush needs to study a lot more geography and accept the fact that he loves only the oil in the Mideast ...so he can sell it to Europe, Asia, and our beloved Australia.  Not much goes here(only 5% but the oil companies still make a killing. Thanks for helping the good oil boys too) because of the transit costs.

"No one can terrorize a whole nation, unless we all are accomplices."

E. Murrow

Your right there isnt enough

Your right there isnt enough server space on here to complain about your education

Edit: Rhayes edited out his post, therefore my post no longer makes sense.

This nation will remain the land of the free only so long as it is the home of the brave. 

ChemO,Haysie does that alot..

ChemO,

Haysie does that alot....

The trick is to just post a word to prevent the edit function from working....then have at it.  Personally, I am trying to refrain from posting to the trollish ones here...it's worked for about three days. 

Not to worry, though, all of the rest of your posts make perfect sense....and anyone who's read hayse knows the little wombat's great bent for screaming "censorship", while self-censoring and editing to his heart's content.

The facts of global warming,