AP Ignores Congressman’s Bush is Hitler Remark Until He Apologizes

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

If you had any questions about the political leanings of the Associated Press, they were answered Tuesday when the wire service finally noticed nine days after the fact that a Democrat Congressman had made some despicable comments about President Bush, Adolf Hitler, and 9/11.

Of course, the AP getting around to this issue when the Congressman apologized for his deplorable remarks is icing on the cake.

As NewsBusters reported Monday, Keith Ellison (D-Minnesota), speaking in front of an atheists’ meeting in his home state, said (emphasis added):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

[9/11 is] almost like the Reichstag fire, kind of reminds me of that. After the Reichstag was burned, [the Nazis] blamed the Communists for it and it put the leader of that country [Hitler] in a position where he could basically have authority to do whatever he wanted. The fact is that I'm not saying [Sept. 11] was a [U.S.] plan, or anything like that because, you know, that's how they put you in the nut-ball box -- dismiss you.

This occurred on July 8, and was reported that evening by the Minnesota Star Tribune.

Yet, the AP – the world’s leading wire service – didn’t feel this was newsworthy until Ellison apologized nine days later (emphasis added throughout, h/t Glenn Reynolds):

The nation's first Muslim congressman said Tuesday that he erred in comparing the Bush administration's response to Sept. 11 to an event that led to Adolf Hitler's consolidation of power in Nazi Germany.

As Reynolds noted, “Well that’s big of him.”

Charles Johnson at Little Green Footballs was similarly nonplussed by Ellison's "sorta, kinda, almost-like-an-apology apology":

"In hindsight, I wouldn't have used that reference point," Ellison told The Associated Press in a telephone interview Tuesday. "It was probably inappropriate to use that example, because it's a unique historical event, without really any clear parallels."

Why wait nine days to call this man? Did all the AP reporters have something more important to do? Would there have been such a wait if these comments had been made by a Republican member of Congress about a leading Democrat?

Doubtful, correct?

Making matters worse, Republicans on Tuesday called for Ellison to be reprimanded. As reported by The Hill:

Two House Republicans Tuesday called on Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) to reprimand Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.) for reportedly drawing a comparison between President Bush and Adolf Hitler.

“We call on you to swiftly and immediately reprimand Rep. Ellison for his flagrant and irresponsible comparison,” Reps. Zach Wamp (R-Tenn.) and Eric Cantor (R-Va.) wrote in a letter to Pelosi. “These comments inflame hatred and division at a time when we should be promoting our unity and reconciliation.”

This raises another question: why didn’t the AP report this in its story about Ellison?

Furthermore, why have virtually every major media outlet with few exceptions continued to boycott this story?

Think about it: a Congressman over a week ago made some disgraceful statements about a sitting U.S. president. Nine days later, he was asked by the Anti-Defamation League for an apology, and requested to be reprimanded by members of Congress.

And the New York Times, the Washington Post, USA Today, ABC, NBC, and CBS still haven't reported it?

Would this be the case if Ellison had an “R” next to his name?

To put this in perspective, two days after Ellison's comments were first revealed, Sen. David Vitter (R-Louisiana) admitted having been on the phone record of an infamous D.C. prostitution ring. Think any major news outlets have missed this "vital" story?

Well, since July 8, CBS has done nine stories about Vitter. ABC seven. NBC six. The New York Times eight. The Washington Post fifteen. USA Today three.

Oh, that's right. A Republican Congressman involved with hookers is much more important than a Democrat Congressman comparing the President to Adolf Hitler while implying said President was involved in the biggest attack on America in almost 60 years.

I get it now.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Apologies and Apologies

 

There are apologies and there are apologies.  Is this a Jessie Jackson ("Hymie Town") apology where all is forgiven, or is this a Don Imus (or Trent Lott or Mark Foley) style apology?

Don'cha get it yet?  The

Don'cha get it yet?  The left doesn't have to apologize for ANYTHING, while the right has to beg forgiveness if they pass gas in public.  Sigh...

I only wish Rupert Murdoch could afford to buy one of the bit three networks so all those without cable could get a clue broadcast into their home regularly.  That, after all, is the one thing the libs can't tolerate - their world view can only exist when there all the more reality-based views are supressed.

That's a pretty lame

That's a pretty lame apology. Given what the gentleman was clearly implying -- that the government is using 9/11 as a pretense to discriminate against Muslims, and may have been involved in producing the pretense itself -- I'd say the Reichstag fire was a fairly precise historical parallel. Notice that he didn't apologize for the implication, only for using a comparison that others found offensive.

Do Democrats teach a class on how to apologize like this, or what?

This is where "we" need to learn

Unfortunately, we here on the right (correct) side of the aisle back down and "apologize" when most of the time it's not necessary. Ann C. has got the right idea by sticking to her guns. After the racist Al, the LSM or whomever sees that she's not backing down, they let it die.

Imus still got canned even after the apology. He should have just stayed pat.

"All generalizations are false, including this one.” Mark Twain

 I'm not even sure that

 I'm not even sure that was an apology...

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

On second thought, I agree

On second thought, I agree with you. Admitting an error isn't the same thing at all.

Yeah, it was like saying,

Yeah, it was like saying, "I shouldn't have compared him to Hitler, but to someone else, equally evil, who's mention doesn't push the wrong  buttons." Some apology... 

 

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

It's not an apology

Chis it is not an apology at all. Ellison just said it was a mistake to use the Hitler analogy, he did not retract the statement otherwise.

it's really pretty simple,

it's really pretty simple, if the NY Times and the AP decide it's not news, then it's not news. Got it?

I'll sure be glad when the

I'll sure be glad when the era of "The New Tone" is over.  I'm ready for my elected leaders to start fighting back and defending themselves.  It's not right that talk radio and bloggers have to do all the dirty work.

Hear, hear. Mr. Bush has

Hear, hear. Mr. Bush has turned his other cheek until he's wrung his own neck. I'm voting for the guy who's best in the bar fight this time around. Rudy looks to have the edge in that category, but it's early yet.

According to the MSM

According to the MSM conventional wisdom, when Democrats viciously attack Republicans, it's just good old tough American politics. When Republicans defend themselves, it's divisive politics of hate, 

 

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

Keith Ellison is a bigot and a racist

Two weeks ago Keith Ellison was on the Minnesota PBS program Almanac and it would do Newsbusters a service to get the transcript, because in it Ellison spews racism and bigotry.

I have written on this, but Ellison is a Muslim Brotherhood operative whose pollitical purpose is to bring down the United States government. His current acheivements are signing up with 7 other liberal idiots to impeach Cheney and to sponsor a bill to help alien Liberians stay in the United States leaving Minnesotans in the cold. The only reason he is aiding the Liberians is their skin color.

His biggest bigotry and racism were let go with a smile by Kathy Wurzer of Alamanac when Ellison stated, "You have to know how to talk the language OF THOSE PEOPLE", in order to get bills started.

"THOSE PEOPLE" whom Ellison was referring to were white people who are Christian.

Now if the world would hear Ellison in his own words spewing bigotry and racism, it might make a difference in exposing this anarchist racist bigot.

If George Bush, Rush Limbaugh or Bill O'Reilly has referred to "needing to talk the language of those people" in order to con them into doing things, and those people were blacks, Al Sharpton would have raised more hell on that than on Imus.

Keith Ellison is a bigot and racist.

 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

You may want to check out a

You may want to check out a couple of the "Northern Alliance" blogs, namely Power Line and Captain's Quarters. Both of them have been covering Ellison's escapades over the past few weeks.

The only thing good about

The only thing good about this is nobody...nobody...watches Almanac.

Minnesota has shown its true hatred for America by choosing to be governed by this trash.  They have chosen ignorant wrestlers...they gave us the number one commie of the 20th century in Gus Hall. They have maybe the most left wing paper in the country.

Minnesota: Home of the America Haters.

Rochester, Minnesota: A Fem_Leftist City!

deafening...

The response from Mr Ethics, Barack Obama, has been deafening.

[So much for cleaning things up...when is Obama gonna start with his fellow libs.]

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.
Thompson/Rice

Reichstag fire (false flag

Reichstag fire (false flag attack) -> blame communists -> rally the people -> go to war with the opposers..

Set up Fatherland security and the Enabling Act...

 

9/11 (false flag attack)-> Blame Islamic muslims -> rally the people -> go to war with the opposers...

Set up Homeland security and the Patriot Act..

 

/End History lesson. Any questions?

"/End History lesson. Any


"/End History lesson. Any questions?"

Yeah, what are you smokin' now?

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Is it a full moon again?

Any questions?

Yes, why have you stopped taking your medication?

History Lib Style

 Add:  Excessive whining from the left and Peace nicks.  Any Questions?

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

ThoughtPolice, Would you

ThoughtPolice,

Would you like to actually comment on the apparent double standard exhibited by some in the MSM in their coverage of Mr. Ellison and Mr. Vitter?

You know, the main point of Mr. Sheppard's post.

But if sticking to the point isn't really your thing - maybe you can go off on another tangent and tell us about Hitler's views of the occult or his interest in Wagner.

TP...hilarious

In your analogy, would you mind clarifying in each instance who you consider to be the "opposers".

My history would not be complete without properly identifying them.

You people are asking TP

You people are asking TP serious questions? What are YOU smoking?

Gay haters unite!

TM...

Why not ask TP questions? When he is forced to answer them, either he will gain some clarity or give us more fodder. Either way, it is a Win-Win from my perspective.

Ok Lion King - if you're

Ok Lion King - if you're having fun then that's what matters more to me!!!

Why not ask him - don't get me stahted on that mashuginna - oy vay

Gay haters unite!

TM...hit and run

TP has done his usual hit-N-run routine. Too bad, so sad.

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.
Thompson/Rice

Damn. When do we get in

Damn. When do we get in invade France?

 

Sympathy for the sympathizer?

No, Mr. Ellison, you didn't apologize, or express anything resembling remorse.  You did, however, lament your level of oratorical skill and your ability to analogize; to coin a phrase, big deal.

When you apologize, or exhibit anything resembling remorse, for being a terrorist sympathizer, that will be newsworthy.

--Mike

www.thebrattonreport.com

 

Why would being like Hitler

Why would being like Hitler be a negative thing to a Jew-hating, terrorist-enabling islamofascist like Ellison?  Hitler and Arafat's uncle we're good buddies.  The Muslims and the Nazis had the same goal to wipe out the Jewish people...Ellison has never renounced anti-semitism.  The guy needs to be removed from office, either by re-call or simply by voting him out of office next time around.

Excellent questions matt.

Excellent questions matt. So don't expect the Lame Street Media to be asking them of Ellison.

It wasn't just that Arafat's uncle and mentor (the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem) was good buddies with Hitler, he was actively involved in the "final solution" and the extermination of the Jews.

You've seen the spoof. Now see the spoof of the spoof on YouTube: The Clintpranos: Bada Bong