Last week, the New York Times ran an article feeling sorry for an illegal immigrant turned immigrant's "rights" activist who was discovered by a random immigration check on an Amtrak train and subsequently slated to be deported back to Chile, his homeland. The Times tried to massage readers into feeling bad for the man because he had been here since 1984 when he illegally crossed the Mexico/US border -- apparently the Times imagines that time bestows legality as opposed to obeying laws serving that purpose.
An axiom has resonated throughout the country that the NYT doesn't seem to grasp; "What part of illegal don't you understand?"
The Times sets up their story presenting their subject, Victor Toro, as some sort of pillar of the community. He has "meetings" and does community work for battered women. He has battled the government for immigrant's "rights." He's an all around important sort of fellow, you see.
Since the late 1980's, Toro has involved himself openly in many causes.
Mr. Toro and Ms. Ayress, both political activists, started Vamos a la Peña del Bronx in 1987, a storefront group that provided clothing and food for poor people, help with immigrants’ problems, shelter for battered women and health education for those who were H.I.V. positive.
In 1998, the group won an award and a $50,000 grant from Union Square Awards in Manhattan for community service. “We were looking for groups that were operating on pure passion but who had no economic resources,” said Iris Morales, director of the philanthropy.
All commendable activities, generally.
And here is the Time's excuse for being allowed to stay, ostensibly.
During more than two decades in the public eye, Mr. Toro was hiding his immigration status in plain sight, his lawyer said. Mr. Toro was arrested three times in the 1990s for nonviolent offenses: once for a political demonstration, a second time for a noise complaint, and a third for a building permit dispute.
Mr. Toro was never asked about his immigration status after his arrests, Mr. Moreno said. In addition, his home is opposite the 40th Precinct police station.
Unfortunately for him, though, he is still an illegal alien. One who scoffs at our laws. So, why should we feel so bad for him? He knew he was here illegally and, just because the nitwits and multicultralists in New York City never had the guts to bust him on it, doesn't mean he should be let off for his violation of the law. A crime is still a crime no matter how much time has passed since its commission.
The most offensive part of the NYT article on this lawbreaker, though, is the Times' attempt to equate US immigration laws to the despotic regime of Augusto Pinochet in Chile.
For Mr. Toro, 65, interactions with governments are filled with dread. When he was a left-wing political activist, General Pinochet’s regime tortured him after the coup that toppled Salvador Allende on Sept. 11, 1973, he said.
So, he was tortured in Chile -- a terrible thing to be sure -- but in all the many decades he has been here he has neither applied for citizenship, nor applied for political asylum it must be pointed out. Yet because he had a "dread" of the 1970s government of Augusto Pinochet, we should suspend our own laws just for him? And we should get all weepy about his status, something he never bothered himself with much in over 20 years?
I'd venture that if he has spent over 20 years here and has yet to learn that there is a monumental difference between the totalitarian government of Augusto Pinochet and that of the USA, then he is the sort of citizen that we don't really want anyway!
Perhaps the Times is right that Toro is a good candidate for political asylum, but why exactly should we get too upset if even Toro himself didn't take our laws seriously enough to be bothered with them? I, for one, cannot force myself to get all weepy over this man.
But, I'd bet Augusto Pinochet wouldn't have been so easy on him


















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Not only "still illegal"
July 18, 2007 - 08:45 ET by vrwc13Not only "still illegal" but costing us "legals" money. Let's fast-forward a bit:
Men stumble over the truth from time to time, but most pick themselves up and hurry off as if nothing happened. -Winston Churchill.
cheeet mon---if I go for citizenship--
July 18, 2007 - 08:52 ET by misterbillcheeet mon---if I go for citizenship--I will have to start paying for all the freebies I get now!! I am an advocate! I am accepted in New York City. Who needs citizenship?
A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government.
Author:
Wait a minute there!
July 18, 2007 - 08:52 ET by dscottWait a minute there! Hold up the show. We had so called amnesty in 1986? Why didn't this guy apply and get amnesty when offered?????? Could it be that no matter what the government offers, those who operate outside the laws have no interest in even attempting to obey them? This guy's own track record of ignoring the law speaks to this. Why should any illegal apply for a work visa when doing so just gets them under the inattentive blind eye of the government? Immigration reform is nothing more than a paper shuffle to hide the incompetence of politicians who are so busy playing politics they don't have time to do their J-O-B. Just look at what the Senate did last night and they still haven't gotten anywhere with the basic funding bills due on October 1. I rest my case.
“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
Speaking of Illegals.....
July 18, 2007 - 09:20 ET by JayTeeThe Illegal in seattle that Killed the 12 yr. old girl (russian Legal Immigrant) was supposed to be Deported after his first Felon/Sexual offense .
Me Thinks that this Incident is going to put some HEAT on the ICE and Immigration people for spending ALL of the $$'s alloted for Deportation.....and as Michelle Malkin said....Don't wait for Congress....act at the local level. That piece of Advice seems to be catching hold like wildfire.
Meanwhile, as you listen to the Drivel coming off the Congressional floors, I have noticed that when they put things (speeches) in the Congressional Record, that there is a significant amount of DIS-Information, lies, and downright in-accuracies. Maybe a Congressional RECORD BUSTER site needs to be Developed...to Correct the Congressional record and inaccuracies.....although most "speakers" are at the High Generic level, for instance "Terrible War" "Exhausted Troops" etc... without ever Quoting Facts and Figures......There is a NEW WEBSITE in there somewhere ? Keeping Congress "honest"......Whoa...maybe that TOO BIG a Job for anyone to undertake.
What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ? David Foote GoE
The immigration debate
July 18, 2007 - 09:22 ET by iveseenitallWhy is this even being discussed? Mel Martinez announced that nothing more will be done about border security or illegal immigration until after the 2008 election. You see, Congress didn't get its way, so they took their marbles and left. Now they will do nothing. Oh wait, that's exactly what they've been doing on every important issue which faces this nation---NOTHING! Meantime they've taken plenty of vacations, spent hours in the Congressional gym,and contacted DC madams for some "stress relief". Come on, raise their salaries.
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
Ask Your Reps to Take a Stand on Immigration Enforcement
July 18, 2007 - 10:13 ET by misterbillAsk Your Representatives to Take a Stand on Immigration Enforcement!
Peter King (R-NY), and House Immigration Reform Caucus Chairman Brian Bilbray (R-CA) introduced a resolution calling on President Bush to vigorously enforce U.S. immigration laws.
"House Resolution 499 urges the Bush Administration to take the following steps in order to substantially reduce illegal immigration and greatly improve the border security of the United States:
There are a number of items which, I believe, are issues that conservatives want to have performed. More info can be found at fairus.org
I list the items from an email I received.
o Implement the entry and exit portions of the United States Visitor and Immigrant Status Indicator Technology program (U.S.-VISIT), as required by the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996;
o Reverse the Treasury Department's decision to allow financial institutions to accept the Mexican matricula consular cards as valid identification for the purpose of opening bank accounts;o Enforce legally binding affidavits of support that sponsors of immigrants sign;
o End the practice of catching illegal immigrants at the border and returning them without prosecution;o Enforce the employer sanctions enacted as part of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986;
o Enforce section 505 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, which prohibits in-State college tuition for illegal aliens;o Require prosecution of anyone caught smuggling aliens across the border illegally, irrespective of how many aliens are being smuggled;
o Increase the number of full-time Border Patrol agents by at least 1,306 by the end of fiscal year 2007, as authorized by the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004;
o Increase the number of detention beds for illegal immigrants by at least 15,944 by the end of fiscal year 2007, as authorized by the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004;
o Increase the number of full-time immigration investigators by at least 1,600 by the end of fiscal year 2007, as authorized by the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004;
o Comply with the Secure Fence Act of 2006 by building over 700 miles of fencing along the U.S.-Mexico border; ando Increase the use of expedited removal procedures for all illegal immigrants eligible for expedited removal under United States immigration laws.
A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government.
Author:
Thanks Misterbilly
July 18, 2007 - 11:57 ET by JayTeeThanks Mr. Bill for that post, and Details. I had heard someone had Intro'ed a similar bill in the house, but he was a Democrat...so, there must be a Group Think going on, as you show Republicans intro'ed this bill, Bill.
I think the Immigration message was understood.....by those who are wanting a Political carreer.
Politicians TAKE NOTE......Your Career goes thru the Mexico Border....be the First one on your Penns Ave. Block, to do what the Americans people want.
What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ? David Foote GoE
So, when do we get the NYT
July 18, 2007 - 09:53 ET by Dave RSo, when do we get the NYT piece stirring up sympathy for American citizens who have lost their livilihoods, or seen their standard-of-living seriously impaired by the seemingly ceaseless influx of illegal criminals into our country?
Mr Toro could probably already be a legal citizen had he taken advantage of the opportunities made available to him and followed the law. I don't care if this guy went arround rescuing homeless puppies for the last twenty-three years, he is still in this country illegally.
That makes him a criminal.
Help Fred defeat the RINOs, along with the Hitllary-Obama Axis, & win the White House in '08.
Lexicon
July 18, 2007 - 10:03 ET by FlashmanWe need to take control of the lexicon when discussing immigration. I always use the term foreign criminals when I discuss immigration with people. If you frame the question as "Do you think foreign criminals should …. ?", the answer is pretty much a given.
Holy lord, a Che Flag?!
July 18, 2007 - 10:09 ET by BinxlyHoly lord, a Che Flag?! Are we even *SERIOUS*?!?!
A big banner that claims 'we are america' yet they are flying not only a mexican flag but also a che flag. Che is everything *against* what America is. That'd be like someone holding the damn Soviet Union flag and claiming to be 'American patriots.' People have really lost their flipping minds.
Slow News Day?
July 18, 2007 - 11:11 ET by HadEnoughWaaah! Cry me a river, what great reporting, they should be so proud!
huh? Is that comment aimed
July 18, 2007 - 11:37 ET by Binxlyhuh? Is that comment aimed at me? If so, I don't see why. I was in agreeance that its ludicrous that these people are treated as credible and not laughable. If you're an American, BE an American, speak English, and for GOD sake, get off the Socialist activist worship. Thats why I was appauled. Who would bring a che flag when they want to be taken seriously as Americans in a democratic society? This isn't the Socialist Collective of the 'American' States. At least not yet, praying that Hil doesn't have a shot, which Im all but sure she doesn't.
If Che is their hero, and
July 18, 2007 - 11:42 ET by bassndudeIf Che is their hero, and Mexico is so great, why are they here instead of Cuba or Mexico? We should round up every last one of those people and ship them off to Cuba, where they can be happy, fat, health care, nice beaches and sit and enjoy life.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
haha I couldnt have put it
July 18, 2007 - 11:44 ET by Binxlyhaha I couldnt have put it better.
Yeah, these people really
July 18, 2007 - 11:46 ET by bassndudeYeah, these people really hack me off sometimes.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
Amazing to me that these
July 18, 2007 - 11:52 ET by WhoIsJohnGaltAmazing to me that these nitwits who want us to feel sorry for illegal immigrants never shy away from telling us how many times they've been arrested for "only" this or that. I'm middle aged, and I don't think I've ever-no wait, I'm CERTAIN that I've NEVER been arrested for ANYTHING.
And honestly, how hard do you have to push a cop's buttons in order for him to want to arrest you for a noise violation? Pretty damn hard, I would imagine. Usually they'll just tell you to tone it down and then leave. Those type of illegal immigrants we DON'T want or need.
"We are America?" Uh....
July 18, 2007 - 16:58 ET by Army Brat"We are America?" Uh.... I don't think so...in fact I'm sure you are not America. What you are...a bunch of criminals that snuck into my country without going through the syatem we Americans set up for those who wish to become citizens or visit here in a legal fashion. How long would any other country on this planet put up with millions of foreigners,(this isn't just about Mexicans.), entering their economies without permission? Is there any other country that has even 1 million illegals in country?
With regard to the whole problem with Mexican immigrants leaving their poverty stricken country behind...how about we make Mexico the 51st and second states? They give up their status as a country and...oh wait... I don't think we have enought cops to straighten that mess out. Happy Trails...
All "Hail", illegals?
July 18, 2007 - 18:22 ET by goldenthroatAs the result of a wicked hailstorm that hit our part of Ohio on June 8th, many homes and garages sustained widespread damage.
Since then, roofing companies have been blitizing our neighborhood with offers to repairs roofs and siding. Their signs are everywhere and guess where they are getting the labor?
Bing, bing, bing! WE HAVE A WINNER! All of a sudden, our part of the city is beginning to look like Tijiuana! The Mexican labor we're seeing on rooftops seems to be coming out of the woodwork! And my guess is these knucklehead neighbors of mine who are buying into this scam aren't even asking questions as to their legality, bonding, insurance and all the things that are needed for follow-up should something go wrong.
If it smells like a duck...
"Yeah, that's the ticket!" - Tommy Flanagan