Bozell Column: Michael Moore's Jihad on CNN

Photo of Brent Bozell.

Let’s be blunt: Michael Moore is one ungrateful leftist hack. CNN had showered him with three hours and ten minutes of face time (repeats included) on "Larry King Live" and "The Situation Room," helping him sell his latest socialist film "Sicko." That kind of attention would make a conservative drool. But when CNN aired a "fact check" piece on his documentary, adding a fraction of balance, he declared jihad, promising in a letter to be CNN’s "worst nightmare."

CNN medical reporter Dr. Sanjay Gupta put together a fairly mild report taking issue with some of Moore’s cinematic claims. For example, Moore gauzily promoted the health-care promise of communist Cuba. In the film’s most publicized stunt, he traveled with Americans suffering from 9/11-related symptoms and had them treated in Cuban hospitals. Gupta pointed out that while Moore highlights that the United Nations World Health Organization cites the United States as 37th in the world for health care, the same study ranks Cuba as 39th. This is the kind of fact checking that drives Moore into a frenzy. He cannot tolerate someone insisting that the infallible Michael Moore would ever mangle a fact.

In a response on his Web site, Moore didn’t say Gupta was wrong. Instead, he declared, "CNN should have its reporter see his eye doctor," since that list with Cuba two slots down is clearly on screen, even in the trailer. Technically, he’s correct. A sharp-eyed viewer can see Cuba. But that’s not the point, and Moore knows it. Moore’s voice-over was focusing the viewer on how the United States ranks just above poor Slovenia at #38.

Then he walked away from the facts, making the outrageous claim that communist Cuba’s dismal ranking is all America’s fault: "The fact that the healthcare system in an impoverished nation crippled by our decades-old blockade (including medical supplies and drugs) ranks so closely to ours is more an indictment of the American system than the Cuban system."

The chutzpah level is so high he should seek medical attention.

Most of Moore’s attack on Gupta doesn’t claim Gupta has mangled the facts, but instead argues that Gupta’s facts are not important. Moore isn’t saying Gupta is "untrue" – he’s "true, but." Gupta noted America ranked number one in patient satisfaction. Moore admits: "True, but" when the WHO took patient satisfaction into account in its comprehensive review of the world's health systems, we still came in at #37.

Gupta reported that Americans have shorter wait times than everyone but Germans when seeking non-emergency elective procedures. Moore doesn’t say that’s untrue, but "This isn't the whole truth. CNN pulled out a statistic about elective procedures."

In his boastful letter to CNN, Moore demanded the network cry uncle and admit that everything Moore says is to be accepted without qualification: "What I want to do is help you come clean. Admit you were wrong. What is the shame in that? We all make mistakes. I know it's hard to admit it when you've screwed up, but it's also liberating and cathartic. It not only makes you a better person, it helps prevent you from screwing up again."

This is incredibly rich coming from Moore, whose M.O. is not to deal in facts as much as in cheap stunts and socialist innuendoes. This is a man who ended "Fahrenheit 911" with the less-than-factual claim that the "war effort" was "always planned to keep society on the brink of starvation." Footnote, please, Mr. Moore? Can anyone forget his gauzy video of Saddam Hussein’s Iraq before the invasion, with pastoral pictures of children with kites?

In fact, on one point in Gupta’s report, CNN did retract a claim and apologize. Gupta said Moore’s film claimed Cubans pay $25 per person a year for health care, when Moore said $251. But CNN’s response also pointed out that Moore is playing apples and oranges with the numbers, plucking the Cuba number from a BBC report and then selecting his American cost-per-person number from our Department of Health and Human Services. The HHS number for 2006 is not a fact, but a projection, CNN pointed out: "Actual numbers for the years 2006 and 2007 are not yet available, which is why CNN could not use them."

Even people who don’t believe that CNN is always Exhibit A for fairness and accuracy can easily find CNN to be a superior fact-finder to Michael Moore. So why does Moore, sloppily disorganized and so often, factually untruthful, register such credibility with the press? Because his work provokes all the right people and shoots at all the right targets. If they really cared about the facts and people who handle them, they’d take away Moore’s six-foot-high soap box. Gupta’s report was a small step in the right direction.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

How does movie attendance

How does movie attendance translate to public acceptance of dem health care and or socialized medicine?

 

JDW

News media: Scoreboard for terrorists

 

Think polling

If people see it, they must agree - sorta like, "Do you want our troops home and out of harms way" becomes "Poll shows people want OUT of Iraq!".

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

Consider the fact that news

Consider the fact that news media is 100% pro-out-of-Iraq. Some poll just revealed 68% agreed. So after the 70 whores in the sky treatment for the past 4+ years why does one third support the troops?

Yesterday's Rass poll revealed 51% want a progress report in September from the generals before considering anything.

The news media cannot spin the truth well enough to create pinheads out of an educated public. How many positive stories have you read about progress in Iraq? Why would any sane individual believe our military consists of nothing but losing morons?

JDW

News media: Scoreboard for terrorists

 

Let's make a documentary

Let's make a documentary about Michael Moore. 

Titles anyone?

The Blob? No.. that ones

The Blob? No.. that ones taken...hmmm...

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Creature From the Black

Creature From the Black Lagoon?

I think that ones been done

I think that ones been done also Del.. Howabout "It came from outer space"?

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Howabout "It came from outer space"?

No no no. How about "It takes UP to much space"

Rosie and Moore having sex:

Rosie and Moore having sex: (as if):

"When worlds collide!"

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Mighty, Please, for the

Mighty,

Please, for the love of all that is good, that is one image I don't even want to try to visualize.

I have to go take a Clorox bath now. 

Liberal: a power worshipper without power. George Orwell

I do apologize and my shame

I do apologize and my shame will last at least another 10 minutes, sorry!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

The Day the Dearth Stood

  • The Day the Dearth Stood Still?
  • Slobzilla?
  • Simple and Plain?

others

  • Michael and Me
  • Psycho
  • Dumb and Dumber
  • My Big, Fat, Dumb Movie

Michael Moore falls of a

Michael Moore falls of a ladder: "Deep Impact!"

I could go on all day. someone please tell me to stop!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Sicko x 2

Sicko x 2

Polling for Dollar Signs.

Polling for Dollar Signs.

.....or Trolling for Dollar

.....or Trolling for Dollar $igns...

Rebel Without A Cause

Rebel Without A Cause

The Big, the fat, the ugly,

The Big, the fat, the ugly, the slob?

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Titles anyone

I came up with 5 but I can't post them here. hehehe

There's already one out

There's already one out there..really...'Michael Moore Hates America'....quite good actually....

 

Now, this might sting just a little bit.....

The Lard of the Onion

The Lard of the Onion Rings

The Ham Hock Redemption

Fat Man Squawking

Plump Fiction

One Loo Spilled Over This Cuckoo's Mess

How to Silence the Lambs (Michael's tips on making love without waking the farmer)

Raging Bull Sh*t

Forrest Plump

The Sick Sense

Bitch KOSidy and the ScumPants Kid (The adventures of Rosie & Michael)

 

When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment
vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any
President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Sick? Oh......

Michael (Dinty) Moore once again is "stewing" in his own juices because someone actually challenged him on his views that he masks as facts.  It's the typical liberal mantra- "if we can't win on popularity, on views, on politics, on reasoning or any other avenue, just attack, attack, attack..........

Amazing

I used to be amazed that the MSM would allow someone like Michael Moore to berate them on their own shows, as a guest.  Now that they have done a tiny factual report on his movie, and he sends them a fanatical letter telling them they are wrong and that he is always right, tells me that the MSM and CNN must be smoking some harsh drugs... because they are all delusional.   

If you don't stand behind our troops; please feel free to stand in front of them!

Moore suffers from AGGWS

Michael Moore suffers from AGGWS, ie., Al Gore Global Warming Syndrome--you know that condition where you think the debate is over.  Michael Moore is such a liar I am surprised he can keep his facts (oops, lies) straight.

Mr Bozell: The chutzpah

Mr Bozell: The chutzpah level is so high he should seek medical attention.

I disagree that Mikey Moron has chutzpah.  In order to have it, one must have cojones and when it comes to that, our favorite media skunk is severely in want.

I do agree, however, that he should seek medical help - the type only his Cuban doctors can give him. 

Liberal: a power worshipper without power. George Orwell

We're 37th?!?  And only 2

We're 37th?!?  And only 2 ahead of Cuba?  That's pathetic.  I'd never heard that stat before.  Is the WHO a liberal-learning organization?

blogonator... The World

blogonator...

The World Health Org is a branch of the United Nations. Now do you beleive the stats? 

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

blog...

The real question is what is the criteria used to achieve this ranking. Is it purely statistical or is it subjective?

Granted...I think our overall healthcare system could be improved...tort reform to reduce malpractice liability/costs would be a start. In the end, there is nowhere else in the world that I would want to go to get medical care.

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.
Thompson/Rice

37th

Blog 

this was posted here some weeks ago the abstract from the study is 'wery interesssttinngg' as it enumerates how the stuff was rated subjectively

"The more I study science, the more I believe in God."     Einstein

"We're 37th?!? And only 2

"We're 37th?!? And only 2 ahead of Cuba? That's pathetic. I'd never
heard that stat before. Is the WHO a liberal-learning organization?"

Does a polar bear crap in the Arctic, well, the ones that haven't drowned yet? Approximately 25% of the WHO ranking system is based on how Socialist the health care system is. As a result, we get penalized for not being more socialist. In other words, expecting people to pay for their health care is bad.

   I just ran a quick

 

 I just ran a quick search, and found a Department of Agriculture site that claims that Cuba's per capita income is $1500 (or purchasing power parity of $3,000)per year. (sorry, lost the link)  If Moore is correct that Cubans pay $251 per year for healthcare, that means that they pay 16.7% of their income for health care. (WTH? I thought Cuban healthcare was FREE!)  I could only find purchasing power parity per capita income for the United States.  It was at this site.  It shows a ppp per capita income for the US of $41,440.  For Americans to spend a proportional amount for healthcare, every man, woman, and child would have to spend $6700 per year.  So, proportionally, healthcare is cheaper in the US than it is in Cuba, with a quality that is orders of magnitude better than you'd get in Cuba.  This isn't to say that US healthcare is perfect: it isn't.  But I, for one, would not want to institute Cuba's healthcare system in this country.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan