Michelle Malkin Responds to Geraldo Rivera's Attack

Photo of Ken Shepherd.

Fox News resident liberal blowhard Geraldo Rivera used his Saturday program to skewer conservative blogger and illegal immigration critic Michelle Malkin on the issues of illegal immigration and border enforcement.

But Malkin did an excellent job fisking Rivera's program and defending herself on her eponymous blog this morning.

Here's an excerpt:

If you want ignorant ranting about immigration and the Zina Linnik case, go watch Geraldo Rivera (thanks to readers for e-mailing me about it over the weekend and AP for clipping the vid). Utterly shameless. Geraldo teased his Saturday night segment on the case by claiming that Zina’s uncle, Anatoly Kalchik, would argue that Zina’s accused murderer should be called a “monster” instead of an “immigrant:”

GERALDO: The tragic story was twisted to aggravate the immigration debate… A little girl snatched and brutally murdered. Tonight her family speaks out on why his “immigrant” label should be replaced by "monster."

The only thing twisted, though, was Geraldo’s big tease. Mr. Kalchick did not say what Geraldo said he would say. Geraldo didn’t even ask him about the immigration angle in the interview that aired.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓
Why not?

Perhaps because Mr. Kalchick would have told Geraldo what he told the Seattle Post-Intelligencer (noted in my post yesterday)

[...]

This case and its ramifications have everything to do with open borders. Clue: “Open borders” is a metaphor for the willful, malign neglect of the entire immigration and entrance system–not just at the physical borders, but on the interior, at our consular offices abroad, on the immigration services side, throughout the investigations and enforcement bureaucracies, and in the detention and deportation offices.

But with clueless Geraldo, the immigration debate is always and only about one border–the southern border. It’s only about one kind of immigrant: Hispanic illegal aliens. And it’s all about one cheap set of talking points: All illegal aliens are hard-working angels, all ICE agents are jack-booted thugs, and everyone who believes in enforcing immigration laws is an “anti-immigrant radical.”

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

If I must be labeled “ant

If I must be labeled “anti-immigrant radical.” to try to save lives so be it. Also Gerryaldo Rivearea there are 4 borders to be protected, not just the one you maybe came over.

............From My Cold Dead Hands..................

}}----> Stand your ground MWK

Insist on being labelled "anti illegal immigrant radical".  Never let it be forgotten we believe laws should be upheld.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

You know, I'm really sick of

You know, I'm really sick of this guy discounting the crimes, especially the violent and/or senseless ones that end someone's life, commited by illegals as their illegal status has nothing to do with the crime ... BULL!!!  IF the SOBs had NOT been in this country, or had been deported when caught in the first place they would NOT have crossed paths with their victims. (A few months ago Geraldo went head-on with Bill O over an illegal alien drunk driver killing two teens on the east coast).

What doesn't he understand about THAT logic and reasoning??  After all, it makes a hell of a lot more sense than Geraldo's liberal pals trying to pin 9-11 (via the stupid truthers wild ideas, or those who don't blame the terrorists at all, but our own country's policies and big business) us.

}}----> Geraldo's shallow mind

Did Geraldo mention the problem Thailand has with child molestation?

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Perhaps if we get Geraldo---

Perhaps if we get Geraldo---to leave the country, a great deal of false and wrongly directed sympathy will go with him. I will never understand those who put these feelings in front of American safety.

Geraldo Rivera = Low Ratings

Whenever I see Geraldo on my TV I reach for the remote to correct the problem.  Seems like I view a lot less Fox News lately.

I pause my TiVo 30 minutes

I pause my TiVo 30 minutes in advance just so that I can fast forward Geraldo whenever he appears on FOX.

Murdoch needs to get rid of him before he does any more damage to the FOX brand.

Youre not the only one

AMEN brother you are not the only one.  I love Fox news I pay for 250 satellite stations to watch only about 6 the main one being Fox News, but lately seeing Gerold DO and that idiot Colmes and Hennican. I now just switch the channel while their are talking, I don't even want to hear their stupidity, I'm all for two sides of the story but out right far left wing ignorance I just can't  that is don't want to deal with.

Geraldo vs. Malkin: The Loser? Us.

I'm not a fan of Geraldo or Malkin. One is a rambling apologist for illegal immigration, the other is an arrogant right-wing fanatic. Their little spat seems peripheral to intelligent debate.

"Their little spat see

"Their little spat seems peripheral to intelligent debate."

Well, why don't you enlighten us on what a real "intelligent debate" should be?

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Actually she is a conservativ

Actually she is a conservative.As far as arrogant you might of been viewing a mirror when that popped in your head.I noticed you only labeled Michelle (right-wing)so maybe that is because your a left wing fanatic?

Anyhow the goverment needs to get their act together.To many illegals get away with murder.They need to start holding the agencies and people in charge responsible.

I'll accept an'...arrogant

I'll accept an'...arrogant right-wing fanatic' over a pompous lefty any day.
After 911, Geraldo did his best to entice viewers with his new-found right-leaning
facade. Fox picked him up and now his true colors are on display each time he opens
his chalkboard screeching voice. I heard there's another Al Capone vault in Siberia;
perhaps Geraldo will do everyone a favor and spend 20 years looking for it.

Sidebar: Arrogance vs. Ignorance

Concurred. Although both are visibly in love with themselves (this is not an unusual phenomenon for media types), Geraldo has the more negative quality of being an apologist for several liberal lost causes. I wish when he opened up Al Capone's vault they would have pushed him in and sealed the door (of history). Dittoes.

 

I am always ready to learn although I do not always like being taught. - Churchill

"A little girl snatched

"A little girl snatched and brutally murdered" is not a "tragedy", Rivera. It is an atrocity and an abomination. I get so sick of the word "tragedy" being misused - as it was in regards in the events of 9-11. Human life lost in hurricanes and floods are tragedies. Heinous murders are not. But, then again, Rivera excels in twisting facts and words.

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

Chris Norman,Bravo...that was

Chris Norman,

Bravo...that was brilliantly said!

It's the misuse of a term, t

It's the misuse of a term, that has bugged me for a long time. Now, if I could just get people to stop using "basically", before every sentence...

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

Chris Norman,I will try to n

Chris Norman,

I will try to not to use either of those words when posting, LOL!

Basically, that's all I'm ask

Basically, that's all I'm asking. Thanks. :)

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

And basically its a tragedy

And basically its a tragedy that you even have to point it out ;)

Basically, you're right... :)

Basically, you're right... :)

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

Has anyone else noticed FoxNe

Has anyone else noticed FoxNews is using Rivera more and more? Some weekend nights, it looks like he's taken over. Add in his guest appearances and he seems getting to be the face of Fox. What are they thinking?

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

veiled attempt

Veiled attempt to be Fair and Balanced...in the eyes of liberals. Presenting the facts is not balanced enough, now you have to have an injection of liberal crap to offset the truth.

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.
Thompson/Rice

Yeah, but Geraldo? He seems t

Yeah, but Geraldo? He seems the sort one would be embarrassed of - like a crazy uncle, who doesn't behave at the dinner table...

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

Chris Norman I have noticed

Chris Norman

I have noticed too. I think FoxNews with the exception of Michelle Malkin on an occasional segment is pro open borders.

They think by having Geraldo on pushing the racist angle will get them converts.

They are ruining their credibility they used to have by allowing nut cases to spread propagands IMHO.

O'Reilly keeps having on pundits that say there is a racial element with people that oppose Illegal Immigration with the most recent example just last Friday. The guest said immigration today is no different than the immigration we had with Ellis Island.

I was so outraged I had to change the channel to avoid scaring the neighbors with my comments yelled at the TV screen.

Is this Mexico or the USA