On Monday's NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams highlighted a "surprise" letter presented to President Bush by high school students visiting the White House who wanted the President to "stop the practice of torture." Williams: "When they got there, 50 of them [out of 141] presented him with a handwritten letter that they had signed demanding that the United States stop the practice of torture."
During the 37-second segment, Williams recounted the story and at one point showed a copy of the letter on-screen with the sentence "We do not want America to represent torture" blown up so it was readable to viewers. The NBC anchor concluded by relaying the President's response. Williams: "The President told them the United States does not practice torture, the very same thing the President has said publicly in the past." (Transcript follows)
Below is a complete transcript of the segment from the Monday June 25 NBC Nightly News:
BRIAN WILLIAMS: A surprise for President Bush today at an otherwise perfectly ordinary annual event on the President's schedule -- 141 high school seniors from around the country, this year's class of presidential scholars, came to the White House for a meet-and-greet with the President. When they got there, 50 of them presented him with a handwritten letter that they had signed demanding that the United States stop the practice of torture. Afterward, one of the students told our NBC News White House producer that the President told them the United States does not practice torture, the very same thing the President has said publicly in the past.
—Brad Wilmouth is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
NBC practices torture when it
June 26, 2007 - 00:28 ET by rbosqueNBC practices torture when it comes up with these stories designed to smear the Administration & the U.S.
Hey Brian, how 'bout sending letters to Hamas, Iran, Cuba, N. Korea, and China. They kidnap, torture, imprison unjustly and kill. Alqueda beheads and tortures on TV thanks to you fools in the lame-stream media.
Mrs Williams
June 26, 2007 - 06:59 ET by allanfWell I guess Brian doesn't save his opinions form Mrs. Williams any longer.
Williams' viewership is plu
June 26, 2007 - 00:46 ET by daveinbocaWilliams' viewership is plummeting so rapidly that he will soon be within hailing distance of the sub-basement dweller Katie C. He affects in his adenoidal fashion not to even look at his ratings, which indicate his viewership has shrunk MORE THAN three million in the last two-plus years.
So by 2012, Brian should have less than Keith Odorboy, who's stuck at 500K deluded onlookers.
How did this get on the eveni
June 26, 2007 - 03:01 ET by KC MulvilleHow did this get on the evening news? Did someone think this is a revealing snapshot of the need for the innocent high schoolers to "speak truth to power" to the president? And that it was a story that all of America needed to hear? Some network editor sat in a meeting and decided that a high school prank was worth comment on the evening news, only because it embarrassed the president. And yet, that same editor still hasn't put on any reasonable discussion of any of the topics that confront our country. That same editor put on Paris Hilton stories.
So tell me again about this frickin' Fairness Doctrine for talk radio????
Any chance the teachers had u
June 26, 2007 - 03:54 ET by EdhenryAny chance the teachers had undue influence over these kids? Probably not.
The Fairness Doctrine, IMO, w
June 26, 2007 - 06:04 ET by ThisnThatThe Fairness Doctrine, IMO, will have the same results (or worse) that Title IX has had on college sports. It will start out with stations trying to accomodate "equal time". When the public tunes out, and the stations realize there is no demand for "equal time", then the market-force talk show programs will have to be sliced until their length accomodates the short left-generated, non-interesting talk time.
Same thing as Title IX. When the girls don't want to play sports, the men's sports have to be cut so that the total participation is "equal".
The Left continues to incorrectly interpret "equality" as "Equal Results", not "Equal Opportunity", much to our detriment and to the detriment of a free society.
Just as they say "Choice" occurs after pregancy, not before.
I agree, TnT re the fairnes
June 26, 2007 - 06:55 ET by motherbeltI agree, TnT re the fairness doctrine. Liberal talk radio does NOT have an audience that can generate revenue (maybe because Liberals believe in having things "given" to them, not the free market.) When stations are forced to carry a Liberal 3 hour left-wing tirade to counter Rush Limbaugh, and they can't get advertisers to buy time on that show, it will be in their financial interest to scrap the talk radio format and start playing country music instead.
It's amazing, the MSM spouts their liberal viewpoint for 95% of the time; Rush Limbaugh says a dozen words in opposition, and they yell that that needs to be "balanced" by another liberal view.
That same editor, back in the
June 26, 2007 - 06:28 ET by ThisnThatThat same editor, back in the Clinton years, would not have put on a school-kids letter demanding that Clinton stop lying, or that he pull up his pants, or stop bombing Kosovo or Iraq. Instead, this editor would be telling us to just "move on, put it behind us -- this president just keeps getting beat up over the same things, and it's getting tiring". This editor doesn't tire of Bush-bashing, though, does he?
Wow 50 out of 141 (35%) dec
June 26, 2007 - 05:41 ET by GatorgradWow 50 out of 141 (35%) decide that the most important thing in the world today is the supposed torture of prisoners in US custody. And of course and as always... No context, no real rebuttal, just the "moving" letter and a generic statment from the president.
Perhaps the students should be forced to watch any number of "Jihad" behedings of prisoners or some video of Iranian "fashon" police beating the crap out of people for dressing in non muslim attire should be shown as well. I just find it so interesting that some in this country are so quick to deem us the "Hitlers" "Killers" Torturers" ETC. . . yet those same people do nothing but appease the enemy and turn the other cheek at their atrocities.
On a side note: I am willing to bet that at least 1 of the 50 students that signed that letter have a Che t-shirt. I bet they never read about his torture techniques.
"Perhaps the students sh
June 26, 2007 - 07:05 ET by Seabeach4348"Perhaps the students should be forced to watch any number of "Jihad" behedings of prisoners or some video of Iranian "fashon" police beating the crap out of people for dressing in non muslim attire should be shown as well. "
Oh NO, no Noooooo! Can't have that! Why it might upset them, and their creative little minds might be forever stifled!
And what about teaching the cute little darlings to be objective when dealing with the real torturers, murderers, and terrorists? Blaming it on American is so much more fashionable, fair and balanced!
Yeah, they should watch those horrible videos ( and so should some of their parents who allow them to wear Che t-shirts) Maybe they'll finally "get it" afterwards.
And the school officials who approved the kid-cute America bashing stunt needs a session in the woodshed!
I wonder what was the most im
June 26, 2007 - 11:17 ET by shannon20I wonder what was the most important issues of the other 65%, guess we'll never know.
Probably something along the
June 26, 2007 - 16:52 ET by sunandsteelProbably something along the lines of "Please defeat the terrorists so we dont have to live in an ass-backwards country like Iran."
Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.com)
[Dana Carvey voice] Well, i
June 26, 2007 - 06:42 ET by motherbelt[Dana Carvey voice] Well, isn't that speciaaaaal......
There's a good little Liberal in the making. The new Democrat standard of toughness: being rude in the White House.
No class, all a$$.
This story is ugly in so many ways.
June 26, 2007 - 07:13 ET by Jonah JohansenYou have the obvious network bias against the President.
You have the media making trivia into news if it suits their purpose.
You have educators indoctrinating students.
You have an anti-American slander accepted as wisdom.
You have the misfocus of concern on the treatment of terrorists in captivity instead of on the victims of terrorism and the stopping of terrorism.
You have the self rightiousness of left.
You have the bad manners of the left.
You have the hijacking of an event by people with political motivations.
You have a publicity stunt that was obiously co-ordinated with members of the media. (like the reporter in Iraq who gives a soldier an embarassing question and then covers it as if the soldiers question was spontaneous an genuine)
Finally you have the a news anchor who sees himself as a noble journalist, when he is in fact a Democratic party shill.
...you forgot about the MSM &
June 26, 2007 - 11:26 ET by TruthMonger...you forgot about the MSM "SUPPORTING" OUR TORTUROUS TROOPS:)!
So the kiddies got their time
June 26, 2007 - 07:27 ET by rimskySo the kiddies got their time in the lime light.. well, terrific! I can just see some home room teacher strolling back and forth in front of his/her class, saying something like,
"So, class, isn't there something that you want to say to the President? What's bugging you? Do you like what you hear about our involvement in Iraq? What about Gitmo? What about torture? How does it make you feel that the USA might use torture?"
And of course as they all sit there wide-eyed, all pumped up on BDS, pushed on them by their liberal teacher, like little robots, they decide to write a letter to the President and let him know just how much it bothers them that we, you know, are like, what was it.. oh, yeah.. that we do not want America to represent torture.
Hey Teach! Whoever you are, where ever you are, STOP trying to indoctrinate our young people with your leftist spew!
Maybe if my freinds and I wri
June 26, 2007 - 08:04 ET by tkeefeMaybe if my freinds and I write a letter the President will also stop pooping on the floor. Oh My God these puke's will say anything won't they.
Two observations:1. The
June 26, 2007 - 08:13 ET by mtwokayTwo observations:
1. The ceremony is a celebration of their achievement not a political event, and they have been used by the political left to spew some agenda. I guess that’s what you call “looking out for the children”. Their achievements have now been overshadowed by their political stunt. Welcome to liberalism.
2. These children were “invited” by the office of the President to be recognized for their achievements and they gladly accepted their award from the very same person they disrespected for supposedly torturing. Now if they rejected their award that would be saying something. This tells you all you need to know about these little leftist crumb crunchers and their supporters.
It’s a shame these kids were indoctrinated/used by the whacko left to promote their agenda. They will now be remembered for having the courage to diss the president, not their accomplishments. Now that's something to write home about.
They will now be remembered
June 26, 2007 - 09:26 ET by motherbeltThey will now be remembered for having the courage to diss the president, not their accomplishments. Now that's something to write home about.
As I said in my comment above, this is what passes for "courage" in the Democrat party nowadays. The Jim Webb school of manners. If simple disrespect doesn't do the job, brag later that you felt like slugging the President.
First of all, this demonstrat
June 26, 2007 - 08:23 ET by BeowulfFirst of all, this demonstrates the brainwashing of our youth, and the encouragement from the MSM to continue to do so. Secondly, I want... no, I DEMAND of clear definition of "torture". I want to know exactly what is and what isn't "torture". All I hear are arbitrary statements to the effect that "such and such is torture" and generalities that the US practices torture. These loud-mouths need to come up with an actual definition. Of course, it'll never happen, because even they know much, if not most, of what they whine about doesn't even come close. Some of these morons have gone so far as to label harsh words and loud voices as torture. In their world, we're supposed to hand captured terrorists the iced drink of their choice while they're sitting in the easy-chair we provided, and quietly and nicely ask them about their knowledge of murdering our citizens and attacking our military from hiding, all the while preserving their dignity and showing the proper deference and respect for their person and philosophy... These people make me seriously ill...
The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers
It wouldn've been nice if Bus
June 26, 2007 - 08:26 ET by Prester JohnIt wouldn've been nice if Bush had answered that if the terrorists just told us about what nefarious plans they had to kill hundreds if not thousands of innocent people there'd be no need to torture them.
Via HotAir.com:He seems unu
June 26, 2007 - 09:18 ET by BacchusVia HotAir.com:
http://hotair.com/ar...
This was just the latest example of what the enemy is willing to do to kids. Will Brian Williams report to these students the types of atrocities commited against children by our enemies?
The fact that 91 of the 141 did not sign the letter is encouraging. Good for them.
Williams highlights the losing side again - typical.
BRIAN WILLIAMS: A surprise fo
June 26, 2007 - 10:43 ET by CapitalismRulesBRIAN WILLIAMS: A surprise for us at NBC news today at an otherwise perfectly liberal event on our schedule -- countless individuals from around the country, many of them well-educated and very informative, came to our headquarters for a meet-and-greet with our staff. When they got here, many of them presented us with handwritten letters that they had signed demanding that we stop the practice of glorifying America's enemies. Afterward, one of the individuals told our NBC News White House producer that the our news staff told them the NBC does not practice journalistic bias, the very same thing we have said publicly in the past.
Yeah ...
June 26, 2007 - 11:44 ET by Some GuyMy friends little brother is graduating from High School (or I guess he just did) and is headed on full scholarship to Stanford ... so i'd put him in the category of "Presidentially Scholarific" or at least in league with these dinner guests. Anyway ... we had a lovely conversation the other day concerning why he thinks Bush is "evil". According to him ... he's quite convinced that (as we hear quite often) #1 - 911 was a government staged cover-up (and not the typical one ... but he paid the terrorists to do it) ... so he could invade Iraq and get revenge for Daddy. ... and he drivelled off some other stuff i'm sure he got from the View or somewhere else. He had no facts or anything to back up his thoughts ... but he was 110% certain he was right.
So ... if he is so informed i'm certain this 35% at the White House probably is right to. To bad we are so un-informed and un-elightened. All I ask is if you are going to open your mouth ... actually have taken the time to figure out if you know what you are talking about.
I hear outer mongolia is nice this time of year ...
How rude! I wonder if the t
June 26, 2007 - 12:30 ET by SnowWhiteHow rude! I wonder if the teachers knew these kids were going to do this. Guess they didn't take, Terrorists101, as a subject. A friend of ours has a cousin who's half Iraqi. This girl's college was blown up by insurgents just days after the school was closed because it wasn't safe for them to take classes there any more. She's now back in Canada but her brother is still in Iraq with her father. Maybe those kids should take a field trip to Iraq to see what the lovely terrorists are doing to their own people. Not to mention what they would like to do to all of us 'infidels'.
"I wonder if the teach
June 26, 2007 - 12:35 ET by MightyMouth"I wonder if the teachers knew these kids were going to do this."
Snow White, this is a guess but I'll bet dollars to donuts, that the teacher(s) put them up to it.
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
You are probably correct, MM,
June 26, 2007 - 12:54 ET by SnowWhiteYou are probably correct, MM, which is pretty sad. Any 'teacher' who would influence their students in such a manner shouldn't be a teacher.
SnowWhite, you just described
June 26, 2007 - 14:06 ET by BeowulfSnowWhite, you just described half the school teachers in America and most of the college professors...
The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers
students
June 26, 2007 - 12:37 ET by LionKingStudents: Mr. President, please stop the practice of torture.
Pres. Bush: I wish I could. I would be guilty of censorship by banning An Inconvenitent Truth.
Brian Williams, you and NBC a
June 26, 2007 - 13:00 ET by bigtimerBrian Williams, you and NBC are beyond despicable.
Does the enemy within even understand they are defeating themselves in the long wrong.
Fools...nothing but vain leftist elite fools with an agenda...who will end up doing their own-selves in with time.
Btw...Pretty convenient to use kids when convenient now isn't it?
Oops wait a minute...the left has been doing that since I can remember...throw in the elderly too.
Btw...the leftist msm are the critters who are guilty of torture to the sane people in the real world.
More torture goes on every da
June 26, 2007 - 17:05 ET by m4ster chiefMore torture goes on every day on the playgrounds of American public schools than in military prisons or in Guantanamo. Check the suicide rates for kids due to merciless bullying by peers.
Sunrise at sea; a breeze across the deck, salty spray tickles the face, the aroma of fresh coffee, stack gas, and haze-gray paint is in the air. Another Navy day aboard ship as a Navy Chief...the perfect life!