Angelina, Aladdin, 24, Racist? WashPost Holds Racial Hypersensitivity In Cinema Day

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

The front of the Washington Post Style section on Saturday was dominated by two features on Hollywood stereotyping. At the bottom was Teresa Wiltz suggesting that Angelina Jolie playing Afro-Cuban Mariane Pearl in "A Mighty Heart" is somehow comparable to blackface minstrel shows. But that's not as odd as the top story by William Booth on stereotyped Arab villains, illustrated by the cartoon image of Jafar, the villainous vizier in the Disney cartoon "Aladdin." Earth to the Post: everyone in "Aladdin," heroes and villains, is Arab.

Booth's story actually only raised the issue of the opening song lyrics of "Aladdin," which joked about vicious ear-slicing barbarians, which the Arab-American activists successfully pressed Disney to remove. After that scrubbing, I imagine the children would also hear about "Ali Baba and the Forty Upstanding Merchants." The star of the Booth piece, retired professor Jack Shaheen, also deplored the Fox drama "24" as "the worst of smears" for portraying American Arabs as the terrorist next door. Booth began in Los Angeles:

A full house has turned out at the Directors Guild of America for the L.A. premiere of the new documentary "Reel Bad Arabs," which makes the case that Hollywood is obsessed with "the three Bs" -- belly dancers, billionaire sheiks and bombers -- in a largely unchallenged vilification of Middle Easterners here and abroad.

"In every movie they make, every time an Arab utters the word Allah? Something blows up," says Eyad Zahra, a young filmmaker who organized the screening this week with the support of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee.

Shaheen also complained, for example, about Eugene Levy playing a ripoff artist called Mr. Habib in "Father of the Bride II." Shaheen told Booth to imagine Mr. Habib as a Jew and see if it was funny. But Booth never pressed Shaheen in print to imagine how the Jew is caricatured in the Arab world of images. Is the pot calling the kettle black? The Post doesn't seem to think that's worth asking.

Wiltz's article on Angelina Jolie doesn't so much attack Jolie or her husband Brad Pitt (who won the movie rights to the Pearl biopic) as much as it dwells on our collective guilt for historic American racism and racial stereotyping. "Ponder the societal implications of Jolie sporting a spray tan and a corkscrew wig. Discuss: Is this the latest entry in the American canon of blackface --21st-century style?" After a bit of dueling bloggers, including a challenger to the blackface charge ("what are you practicing here, the one drop rule?"), Wiltz quickly turns to history:

The debate is cast against the backdrop of the United States' troubled legacy of minstrel shows, where white actors slapped on burnt cork or shoe polish, the better to mock African Americans. Film stars Bing Crosby, Bob Hope and Eddie Cantor performed in blackface, as did actors in D.W. Griffith's "Birth of a Nation," using greasepaint and murderous stereotypes to reinforce America's worst fears about black men.

It's a little odd to drag in films like Griffith's -- from 1915 -- as easily comparable to 2007. When Mariane Pearl proclaims she liked the choice of Jolie, Wiltz patronized her:

As a European, Pearl may well process race differently than an American woman of a similar mixed-race heritage, who historically in this country would have been deemed "black" and therefore subject to the peculiarities of American-style racism.

Wiltz then returned to the ancient slights of Hollywood as she wrapped up:

But Hollywood has long been conflicted when it comes to telling the stories of mixed-race people. In 1949, Lena Horne was up for the title role in Elia Kazan's "Pinky," playing a light-skinned black woman who looked white. Jeanne Crain, who was white, got the part. In 1951, Horne was slated to play "Julie," the "tragic mulatto" in "Show Boat." But Hollywood wasn't too comfortable with interracial love scenes, so Ava Gardner ultimately got the part, and makeup artists used Horne's makeup (Max Factor's "Egyptian Tan") to give Gardner that cafe-au-lait look.

But there were much worse injustices committed against American blacks in 1949 or 1951 than casting decisions. It's just strange that the Washington Post thinks all these old stories are plausibly connected to Pitt and Jolie and their peculiarities of their liberal humanitarian activism and their multi-racial family matters.

With this kind of sensitivity to Hollywood and race, when will the Post acknowledge Robin Williams slamming Catholic priests last week on the Leno show? A search of the Post archives shows no Williams-Leno story yet.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Did anyone protest when the r

Did anyone protest when the remake of the Honeymooners was all African Americans?

Although I didn't see it, not because I was bothered by that fact, I just don't give my support to Hollywood anymore, I can only wonder if the remakes of Foxy Brown and Shaft starred white guys, if people would have been upset.

As for the 24 thing, it just goes to show that the only villians that can be shown in Hollywood are white guys.  I remember a few years ago when there was some stupid movie out and the killer was a clown, and clown groups, whoever they are, actually were out protesting the movie.

Hi mikej...As for the 24 thin

Hi mikej...

As for the 24 thing, it just goes to show that the only villians that can be shown in Hollywood are white guys. 

....it has even stretched in to the commercials now if anyone noticed.

Pretty pathetically PC if you ask me...besides disgusting anymore in my opinion.

Getting beyond tiresome and old.

What part of, The Islamic god

What part of, the Islamic god (allah) calls for the killing of all infidels, do these nuts not  understand? Or do they understand and they are Islamic themselves?

And just what are they after here? Do they not realize that we do not have to like anyone who we do not choose to like?

Debra...

As a European, Pearl may we

As a European, Pearl may well process race differently than an American
woman of a similar mixed-race heritage, who historically in this
country would have been deemed "black"

So is the author trying to say that American blacks (oops, I mean 'African-American', the current popular divisive term) are biased??

D


Go here and here to let your reps know what you think of the shamnesty bill!

Seems there are a few folks a

Seems there are a few folks at the WaPo with waaayyy too much time on their hands ...

I agree. I guess the point

I agree. I guess the point is that they should have found a Cuban-African actress to play Mariane Pearl. When "Miss Saigon" debuted on Broadway, there was a bit of a stink because it wasn't a Vietnamese lady in the lead role.

Here's a news flash for the guys at the WaPo....that's why it's called "acting."

Gosh, wait until they get a l

Gosh, wait until they get a load of John Travolta in "Hairspray." Yet another example of a white male taking a job from a more qualified woman.

*****

"I'm sorry, you must have mistaken me for a clown that gives a damn!" - Sticky the Clown

the issue of the opening so

the issue of the opening song lyrics of "Aladdin," which joked about vicious ear-slicing barbarians

In contemporary Iran, Jafar would have Jasmine hanged from a crane.

Ear-slicing IS a joke.  Muha

Ear-slicing IS a joke.  Muhammad personally participated in the massacre by beheading of several hundred  male Jewish prisoners of war (and the taking of  women and children as slaves).  Neck-slicing would be much more accurate. 

"Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him." -Muhammad

Jihad??? Death to the infide

Jihad???
Death to the infidel??

Sounds like a villain to me!

I am still waiting for the Mu

I am still waiting for the Muslim community in this country and around the world to stand up in resounding chorus to condemn the extremist elements in their very midst.

They want to be known as a religion of peace, but have been largely silent in calling out the terror generating types among them.

If they want to be treated like true citizens of the world, let them renounce all of the extremism within their ranks, and fully integrate themselves into the universal culture.

Until they do, however they are portrayed in films and TV shows is mostly of their own doing.

That reminds me ... In Tom Cl

That reminds me ... In Tom Clancy's book, "Sum Of All Fears", the bad guys with the nuke were Islamist terrorists.  Hollywood intentionally changed it to neoNazis for the movie.  I understand Clancy was none too happy about that revision.

Where were the Christians

I was not amazed that Christians did not come on Billy Booth's radar screen in the recent Noah slap Hollywood came up with appearing this weekend.

What I continually am amazed by though is people like Billy who wake up every morning and go through their entire day looking at people's race in every situation. Honestly, I would love for the Post to hire me to write such absolute nonsense for a 5 or 6 figure salary.

I could write about Bob Barker being a sadistic danger to cats and dogs hacking out their genitals and how it all is tied into big oil as Barker gives away cars on CBS.

All kinds of looney associations can crop up as Billy delves into his cauldron of Post traumatic distress over his big paycheck syndrome. Angie Jolie is bad for playing a black actress, but not bad when she plays a woman who is not Anglo American as that is her background. Jack Bauer is bad, because 24 actually showed reality in the 9 11 attacks were performed by Muslim Arabs, but 24 in past seasons portraying Mexicans as mafia does not seem to register on the Billy scale.

Please Post of all liberal knowledge drop NB a line to contact me and I can fill your pages with looney toon nonsense about liberals too. It just takes a Dr. Seuss imagination.

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

"Noah slap"?

"Noah slap"?

“The West is accusing Musli

“The West is accusing Muslims of extremism and terrorism. If someone exploded a bomb on his body, he would be right to do so unless the British government apologizes and withdraws the ‘sir’ title,” ul-Haq said.

Previous quote from the Salman Rushdie controversy, by the Prime Minister of Pakistan.

Now, can anybody give me a clue as to why we would ever consider these guys Villains?
/sarc

Mother nature is a bitch - Ninth Corollary of Murphy's Law

US allies as staunch and free

US allies as staunch and freedom oriented as Pakistan wouldn't dream of hiding Osama Bin Laden!
JMR

This is a little late to the

This is a little late to the party, but I believe that in the accurate translations of the Arabian Nights tale "Aladdin", the villain is described as an "African magician" and "from darkest Africa".  How dare those Arabs stereotype Africans in that manner?

Without recognizing the ordinances of Heaven, it is impossible to be a superior man. - Confucious

That's because Africans are s

That's because Africans are still expendable to the left.  You know, Africans must continue to die so the left can shout about more money for malaria, instead of drastically curing the problem by bringing back the DDT cure.  AIDS needs to remain a killer in Africa, because the West can not force modern safe sex practices on their centuries' old bad sex practices culture.  Famine must die on because the left doesn't believe changing bad government in those affected countries so that the people can actually get the food and aid the West has sent isn't what is needed ... but millions more American $$$ is the only plan they want to see.