After reporting on the compassionate U.S. soldier rescue of abused Iraqi orphans, CBS’s Lara Logan ran a follow up story on the June 21 edition of "The Early Show." To her credit, Logan continued to defend the soldiers. She noted that an Army captain went "back to check on the 24 boys he and his soldiers rescued" and "thanks to these soldiers...the boys’ lives were saved."
Upon reporting that the Iraqi labor and social affairs minister accused Lara Logan of reporting a "lie" and that the U.S. soldiers that rescued these emaciated boys "have no compassion," Logan played a gracious remark from an unidentified U.S. soldier.
"We'll leave here and he'll never be able to tell us thanks, but he doesn't need to."
When questioned by host Harry Smith, Logan clearly sided with the U.S. soldiers against the denying Iraqi government official.
"Well, what's upsetting about the controversy, Harry, is that the plight of these boys is actually being lost in all of this. But incredibly, the Iraqi ministry is trying to make the U.S. the bad guys. They're blaming them, America as Iraq's enemy, we're being told, instead of acknowledging what was done by the soldiers who rescued these boys. And -- and, in fact, it's important to know that they were local Iraqi leaders who helped the U.S. rescue the boys that night. And when I spoke to them a week later, Harry, they were still in shock about what they'd seen. They wept constantly, throughout the interview as they recounted the horror. And that horror is now being denied by the ministry."
The entire transcript is below.
HARRY SMITH: Two days ago, we first showed you the heartbreaking pictures from a Baghdad orphanage where two dozen disabled children were being left to die. This morning, the children are doing better while Iraqis are showing their outrage. CBS News chief foreign correspondent Lara Logan, who broke this exclusive story is live in Baghdad with us. Good morning, Lara.
LARA LOGAN: Good morning, Harry. Well, Iraq's prime minister personally ordered two investigations and the arrest of everybody involved in mistreating these children who we visited again. And although they're still severely malnourished, we were amazed that they're recovering remarkably well. It was a welcome Captain Ben Morales couldn't resist. He was back to check on the 24 boys he and his soldiers rescued just over a week ago. They were literally starving to death in a government-run orphanage for special needs children. Those in charge left them naked and tied down while piles of new clothes and food were stored right down the hallway. Thanks to these soldiers and the joint Iraqi/U.S. patrol that first found them, the boys' lives were saved. It's obvious how much better off these boys are at this orphanage. But the problem is, they're still special needs children with no access to specialized care. But here, they're understaffed, underpaid, and the social workers lack specialized training. This little boy almost did die. When the soldiers found him, he was covered in thousands of flies, unable to move. They never thought he'd recover as much as he has. The plight of these boys has outraged Iraqis with excerpts of our report aired constantly on local TV for almost two days. The public pressure forced labor and social affairs minister to speak out, but instead of taking responsibility, he lashed out at the U.S., calling America Iraq's enemy. As we were filming these scenes, the minister was telling the nation these boys are perfectly healthy and our report was a lie. And these are the same soldiers the minister said have no compassion.
UNIDENTIFIED SOLDIER: We'll leave here and he'll never be able to tell us thanks, but he doesn't need to.
LOGAN: The fear here is there may be other vulnerable children in similar or worse conditions who haven't yet been found. What's shocking, Harry, is that the Iraqi ministry responsible is defending the treatment of these boys, saying they had to be tied up for their own good because they're mentally disabled, blaming the lack of electricity as the reason they didn't have any clothes on. But that certainly doesn't explain why they were so badly dehydrated and starving to death, lying in their own waste, covered in flies and bleeding sores. And a doctor who treated them that night at the Iraqi hospital actually said that two more days, and four of those boys would have been dead. Harry?
SMITH: This story is causing so much controversy over there. Explain that a little bit.
LOGAN: Well, what's upsetting about the controversy, Harry, is that the plight of these boys is actually being lost in all of this. But incredibly, the Iraqi ministry is trying to make the U.S. the bad guys. They're blaming them, America as Iraq's enemy, we're being told, instead of acknowledging what was done by the soldiers who rescued these boys. And -- and, in fact, it's important to know that they were local Iraqi leaders who helped the U.S. rescue the boys that night. And when I spoke to them a week later, Harry, they were still in shock about what they'd seen. They wept constantly, throughout the interview as they recounted the horror. And that horror is now being denied by the ministry.
SMITH: What's going to happen to these kids now Lara?
LOGAN: Well, that's the devastating part about all of this. You're so happy to see them doing so much better, but you know nothing is going to happen to them. They don't get special care. They don't get special medical care. They don't get special attention. And they need all of that. And they're very loving boys, Harry.
—Justin McCarthy is a news analyst at Media Research Center.















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
What's really sad about this
June 21, 2007 - 13:48 ET by BeowulfWhat's really sad about this is the minimal coverage, as well as the non-coverage of similar stories. The American fighting man is the most compassionate of soldiers, and pays no mind to the disparity of the terms. Americans, especially our military, are the best of friends, yet the worst of enemies, as many have found out in the past. Nobody can kill and destroy like an American, yet this ability is kept totally seperate from his compassion. Our military members know when it is time to fight, and when it is time to save. And very few prefer the fighting over compassion. If our members could do nothing but humanitarian missions, few would complain.
I know of a story where an Air Force Chief Master Sergeant in the medical field was involved in the treatment of a severely burned little Iraqi orphan girl (wounded by "insurgents" in case anyone was wondering). She would cry and scream unless he was holding her. So he spent every single minute that he wasn't working on someone else, including all of his free off-duty time, simply holding her. He held her in between patients. He held her long after his 12-16 hour shift and slept with her in his arms. The last I heard, he was in the process of adopting her to take her home with him, with the full support of his wife and family. These are the actions of a career military member with at least 2 decades of service.
And this is, by far, not the exception to the rule. You never hear about the G.I.s who send home for things to give to Iraqi children and families, at their own expense. You don't hear about Americans taking wounds by refusing to return fire for fear of wounding civilians in proximity to firefights. You don't hear about the daily compassion from our fighting forces. What a surprise from our "professional, unbiased" mainstream media elite...
It's a crying shame and a friggin' discrace!
The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers
Here's the story on USAF CMSg
June 21, 2007 - 14:02 ET by Mean Gene Dr. LoveHere's the story on USAF CMSgt John Gebhardt. And here is a website that highlights the caring and compassion American warriors.
Not one of the news outlets focuses on the goodwill of our troops. The media makes a passing mention now and then, but their main focus is anything and everything that is negative.
It makes me ill. It is a disgrace of epic proportions.
"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants." --Thomas Jefferson
Thanks for the link Mean Gene
June 21, 2007 - 14:34 ET by BeowulfThanks for the link Mean Gene. While the version I heard had some items wrong, the overall story remains the same. And the point remains made.
The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers
I agree.It ticks me off to n
June 21, 2007 - 15:50 ET by well99I agree.It ticks me off to no end how the media purposely will not show stories of all the good our troops have done over there.This was one of the few exceptions.It was a good story and I am glad at least it was covered.
Hey I know him!!!
June 21, 2007 - 22:20 ET by Ole_SargeWow!!! I have to get on the phone, I heard he was over there from other friends, like WOW!!! And does not surprise me in the least... The Wow! is that the MSM paid "any" attention at all. He really is a GREAT man.
Exactly Dr. Love...The leftis
June 21, 2007 - 22:31 ET by bigtimerExactly Dr. Love...
The leftist msm only shows anything positive so they can use it as a bean-counter to show that they are NOT biased and DO NOT have an agenda.
They could give a rats rear less unless it is defeat for us for this war against the enemy called the Muslim radical jihad terrorists.
Cut off their nose to spite their faces...all for their agenda of complete political leftist power.
Enemy within...pathetic at that...we must fight them.
"But incredibly, the Ira
June 21, 2007 - 17:16 ET by Chris Norman"But incredibly, the Iraqi ministry is trying to make the U.S. the bad guys."
Yeah, Harry. Those Iraqi's are trying to take your job...
The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.
- Arabian Proverb
I get the joke, but I don't
June 22, 2007 - 04:40 ET by sarcasmoI get the joke, but I don't get "it." Doesn't it take time to starve kids? How could US soldiers running across them be to blame? And doesn't the fact that US soldiers could be blamed for this argue for a policy change, perhaps??
JMR
The compasion of the "religion of peace"
June 21, 2007 - 19:15 ET by c5thenWe see it time and again. Deny, deny, deny, and if there is proof, blame the rescuers and the people trying to report.
We see how concerned the minister is about the plight and condition of the boys. Is it any wonder that the Iraqi government is not ready to govern themselves?
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic