In an ideal world, a news consumer would get his or her essential facts from hard-news coverage, and would read op-ed columns solely to learn writers' opinions on particular topics of interest -- while perhaps being entertained in the process.
We clearly do not live in an ideal world. If fact, the "news" is all often turned upside-down, as journalists supposedly covering the hard news end up focusing on trivialities and personalities, while subtly (or not so subtly) injecting their own opinions into their work. This leaves the necessary work of substantively informing the audience to op-ed writers.
No one does the job Old Media hard-news reporters won't do better than Mark Steyn.
In his Chicago Sun-Times column today, Steyn, in his typical engaging style, does more in under 1,200 words to inform readers about the real-world implementation difficulties and disparate-treatment outrages in the immigration bill under consideration in Washington than all of Old Media's hard-news reporters have in several weeks.
Here are just a few of the nuggets in Steyn's piece that I was not aware of, and that you probably haven't seen or heard anywhere else:
..... the truth is that America's immigration bureaucracy cannot cope with its existing caseload, and thus will certainly be unable to cope with millions of additional teeming hordes tossed into its waiting room. Currently, the time in which an immigration adjudicator is expected to approve or reject an application is six minutes. That's not enough time to read the basic form, never mind any supporting documentation. It's certainly not enough time for any meaningful background check. Under political pressure to "bring the 12 million undocumented Americans out of the shadows," the immigration bureaucracy will rubberstamp gazillions of applications for open-ended probationary legal status within 24 hours and with no more supporting documentation than a utility bill or an affidavit from a friend.
..... one of the little-known features of this bill is that in order to "bring the 12 million undocumented Americans out of the shadows," millions of legal applicants are being hurled back into outer darkness. Law-abiding foreign nationals who filed their paperwork in the last two years would be required to go back to their home countries and start all over again. Not only does this bill reward law-breaking, it punishes law-abiding.
..... The young Muslim men who availed themselves of the U.S. government's "visa express" system for Saudi Arabia filled in joke applications -- "Address in the United States: HOTEL, AMERICA" -- that octogenarian snowbirds from Toronto who've been wintering at their Florida condos since 1953 wouldn't try to get away with. The late Mohammed Atta received his flight-school student visa on March 11, 2002, six months to the day after famously flying his first and last commercial airliner.
Along the way, Steyn reveals many of the failures of and biases in the pitiful "hard-news" reporting on the subject, the most obvious of which is this one on the annoying use of the term "undocumented workers":
Being "undocumented" means being documented up to the hilt as far as everyone else is concerned but "undocumented" only to the U.S. government. Which, when you think about it, is a very advantageous status to have.
He also recounts a telling example of how quickly Old Media members will jump on the bill's opponents with unsupportable accusations:
On Fox News the other night, I was told by NPR's Juan Williams, "You're anti-immigrant!" Er, actually, I am an immigrant -- one of the members of the very very teensy-weensy barely statistically detectable category of "legal immigrant." But perhaps that doesn't count anymore. Perhaps, like Colin Powell's blackness, it's insufficiently "authentic."
Williams's rip at legal immigrant Steyn briefly revealed just how despised he (Steyn) is by many beat reporters and Old Media members. It never seems to occur to them that if they would simply concentrate their work more on digging up and reporting the facts and less on injecting their opinions (i.e., if they would just do the jobs they're supposed to do), there wouldn't be any need for readers, listeners, and viewers to go to the Steyns of the world to get even the most basic information -- though in Steyn's case, the entertainment value of his writing would still make visiting his work quite worthwhile.
Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.
—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
This guy should have his own
June 17, 2007 - 10:56 ET by NewsbusterbrownThis guy should have his own television show. Besides having a great mind, he's a superb communicator. Next to Walter Williams, he may be my favorite Rush fill-in.
I don't think Mark Steyn fi
June 17, 2007 - 11:04 ET by motherbeltI don't think Mark Steyn fills in for Rush (are you perhaps confusing him with Mark Levin?) But he does frequently appear on "The O'Reilly Factor" and on Glenn Beck's program on the CNN Headline News Channel. He is one of the true voices of logic and sanity, on not only immigration, but terrorism and other issues as well. I
Rush
June 17, 2007 - 11:22 ET by Tom BlumerI did hear Steyn filling in for Rush once. Don't know how frequently it occurs.
I believe it was only once, g
June 17, 2007 - 16:51 ET by NewsbusterbrownI believe it was only once, guys, but that was enough for me.
Good points by Mark.You get a
June 17, 2007 - 11:26 ET by well99Good points by Mark.You get all this agenda driven garbage anymore.
Police Oaths
June 17, 2007 - 11:51 ET by StokeyBobThe media is shamlessly selling out the United States of America but one thing I can say is at least they didn't take an oath like the criminals in the government and law enforcement.
They've brought new meaning to the term, "Stinking Badges".
I saw Mr. Steyn on Hannity
June 17, 2007 - 12:49 ET by happyuscitizenI saw Mr. Steyn on Hannity & Colmes when he made these points he was the guest opposite Juan Williams.
Williams was not his normal controlled self rather unhinged yelling and screaming down Steyn along with Colmes on every one of his points.
I think in one of Steyn's op-eds he also argues that while you may succeed in legalization for these "immigrants" you are creating a defacto indentured servitude class beholden to the proponents of cheap labor.
I usually like Juan. Previously on other shows before this appearance he had given in my opinion thoughtful and heartfelt analysis of several other issues. Although I do not agree with him 99.9% of the time he had always come across as an effective debater, someone that I could agree to disagree with. This appearance was not one of them.
Unfortunately I was not surprised with his cries of the Steyn being anti-immigrant and others. Typical stuff when you have a hollow argument you just out yell the opponent.
HappyWhen you have the facts,
June 17, 2007 - 12:59 ET by botgHappy
When you have the facts, pound the facts; when you have the logic, pound the logic; when you have neither, pound the table.
LOL the last part could expla
June 17, 2007 - 18:11 ET by well99LOL the last part could explain HOWARD DEAN...
Juan Williams
June 17, 2007 - 18:19 ET by Cool ArrowJuan almost lost his card carrying Liberal status when he threw in with that hatemonger Bill Cosby.
Juan's little "anti-immi
June 18, 2007 - 16:31 ET by BeowulfJuan's little "anti-immigrant" tirade shows how uninformed and out of touch these incredible morons truly are. How in the HELL can he get away with calling an IMMIGRANT "anti-immigration"??? And why is that this is the first time I have heard mention of legal immigrants having to start their applications from scratch? That is a big deal, especially if ILLEGALS are being placed before them.
If these people really want to see "anti-latino" and "anti-immigration", then by all means press on with this legislation that very few Americans want, and force the PC terminology of "undocumented"-whatever down our throats. People in this country are just getting riled. Wait until we get pissed... That's when the feces will impact the occilating air circulator...
The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers
"Not only does this bill
June 17, 2007 - 13:18 ET by mattm"Not only does this bill reward law-breaking, it punishes law-abiding."
That's true now, without the bill. This bill would simply make it worse.
Regardless of what happens, every single House and Senate member who supports anything approaching amnesty should be turned out in '08 (or the next time their Senate seat is up.)
Reporters Worth Praising
June 17, 2007 - 13:25 ET by Lame CherryI like the growing majority of Americans find distasteful to traitorous the Dana Milbank, Seymour Hirsch, Lara Logan etc...., but I wanted to praise a few journalists who everyone should say thank you to.
Thank you to Tom Blumer for calling attention to Mark Steyn. I would though like to submit another Chicago Sun Times journalist in Robert Feder. In contact with him, he was absolutely a gentleman and the nicest person in media.
Add to the list Jim Howell of the Washington Times whose branch is associated with the equally fine site World Tribune online.
Lastly, Joe Lauria of the London Times and Boston Globe, who is dinosaur media, but in a nice note after he expose the notorious Molotov Mob, Jason Leopold, who impersonated him did some of the finest reporting on what the main stream media does in propaganda stories. He found out what it is like to be on the receiving end of the rabid left. Mr. Lauria in still ignorance on gun issues will at least blame liberals for their full share.
The fossil yard does have a few cave hunters doing their jobs and they should be noted.
*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS
One of the most outrageous provisions of the shamnesty bill.
June 17, 2007 - 13:48 ET by RJThere are many outrageous provisions in the shamnesty bill, but this must be put at or near the top of the list:
"The bill transforms the federal Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) from a law-enforcement agency into an amnesty-distribution center. If ICE officials apprehend an alien who appears eligible for the Z visa (in other words, just about any illegal alien), THEY CAN'T DETAIN HIM. Instead, ICE must help him apply for the Z visa. Rather than initiating removal proceedings, ICE will be initiating amnesty applications. It's like turning the Drug Enforcement Agency into a needle-distribution network."
Got that? ICE will be rendered irrelevant.
Below is a comprehensive site that breaks down this outrageous bill and shows how it will destroy America. It's worth adding as a "favorite"....
http://www.cairco.org/pol/us_senate_amnesty_compromise_2007may.html
RJ,Great post and a fabulous
June 17, 2007 - 14:07 ET by BlondeRJ,
Great post and a fabulous link, thanks.
And isn't it pleasant to be able to have a reasonable conversation without the train going totally off the track?
I think happyuscitizen's post is right on. What can these idiots in Congress possibly be thinking? That we'll just sit back and let them shove this down our throats? I'd like to start a recall on my august senators from Florida....the space shuttle flying dem Nelson, and the RINO Martinez. He'll not ever see another vote from me.
Blonde--did you tell him???
June 17, 2007 - 14:20 ET by misterbillBlonde--did you tell him??? Johnny Isakson had a great bill re: immigration. He was out-manouvered into a position where the only way, (he thought), to get his bill through was to integrate it into Ted (Chappaquiddick) Kennedy's "compromise". The weight of the telephone calls , faxes and emails from Georgia voters got him and Saxby Chambliss to vote "no" for cloture. All on this site should check Numbersusa on a regulal basis (I am a member) and when Roy Beck calls for help, answer it. Especially the states with Senators with (R) after their names who voted for it.
As for Florida--you folks should send him emails telling him that just because his name ends in "Z" he is an American representing America and no other country.
Immigration is the issue that has me no longer a Bush supporter. His arrogance regarding Republican voters can cause the collapse of the party.
Yeah, misterbill. I know.Me
June 17, 2007 - 14:41 ET by BlondeYeah, misterbill. I know.
Mel is George's fair haired boy and chairman of the RNC. How do you like that?
I'm not so sure about Bush's arrogance causing the collapse of the party. As a conservative, I believe this is becoming the litmus test issue for us, even moreso than abortion. The Supreme Court won't even hear anything close that might have a shot at overturning Roe as it's currently constituted. Another reason to get down & dirty to elect a Republican president.
If you look at the numbers in the link RJ posted, people are totally fed up with this arrogant Congress. We've got their attention, and I suspect the presidential candidates' attention as well. McCain is going down faster in the polls than a shot up A-4. He knows the reason why, and trust me when I tell you, so do all of the rest.
Our fellow poster happyuscitizen said it perfectly...and he's a naturalized citizen. Don't you think all of the naturalized citizens and legal immigrants here agree with him? The patent unfairness of this shamnesty bill shoving all of those who are here legally and going through the naturalization hoop jump has got to have them absolutely furious.
In my neighborhood, we have a family from Bangladesh who've opened up a great convenience little store. They employ a young kid from Nepal, who relates absolutely fascinating things about his country. At work, there's a guy who was a judge in Columbia, and who fled the drug cartels...he took a job as a janitor here to improve his English! I took him out to lunch...and had the funniest conversation about how "bad" words are good....like it's "terribly good to see you"....I'm not much of an ESL coach, apparently. But my point is, all of these good people would be pitched to the end of the line, perhaps never to be given an opportunity, for a bunch of law breakers. And that's just wrong.
Mark Steyn is intelligent and
June 17, 2007 - 13:51 ET by KC MulvilleMark Steyn is intelligent and entertaining. He also personifies the difference in the immigration debate. Steyn came here, not just for the money, but because he supports the general culture. Our culture is far from perfect, but we do have some values (e.g., personal freedom, minimal government, etc.) that are worth the trouble. That’s different from the illegal immigrant industry, which worships only one value: money. That industry is a coalition of foreign governments, domestic businesses, coyotes, and various others who exploit the immigrants completely. What’s even more discouraging is the willingness of the immigrants themselves to accept that inhumanity because they have no other option. To all of them, America is only an economic skeleton that has no heart or brain. I think the illegal immigration industry is as inhuman (and especially un-Christian) as any slavery or prostitution ring. It sees human beings and human culture strictly as economic pawns. It's a view of America that Marxists see in their nightmares.
Show me an immigration bill that changes that, or even addresses that, and I’ll vote for it. Until then, I’ll oppose any bill that allows that inhuman industry to survive a day longer.
One of my favorite points i
June 17, 2007 - 14:32 ET by ckc1227One of my favorite points in the piece is where Mark points out Reid's hypocrisy on the economy. On one hand, Reid says it's the worst economy since Hoover; on the other hand, Reid says we need illegals because the economy is so strong, lol.
I'm with MisterBill, finished
June 17, 2007 - 17:14 ET by iveseenitallI'm with MisterBill, finished with the president. And we here in Florida have been on Matinez's back from the beginning of this. The other day either his mail was loaded or he simlpy shut it down--- couldn't get through to the creep. But, just as with Bush, the entire country could tell him he's wrong and it wouldn't matter. My questions remain the same: Why the rush? What's truly behind this thing? Why are my representatives working harder for illegals than I've ever seen them work for me? I suspect we must follow the money to find the answers.
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
ISIA--I just posted the last para of a Pat Buchanan--
June 17, 2007 - 17:37 ET by misterbillISIA--I just posted the last para of a Pat Buchanan--b;log. I am not A fan of Pat but when someone is right, they are right. I will include it here:
"It is about globalism—and about greed. And, as the Bible says, love of money is the root of all evil. But they have a problem. The nation has begun to awaken to the reality that the vision of the global corporation and the transnational elite cannot be realized without the death of the American republic. And so they are in a fight that is long overdue. "
You probably have read many of my rants about the death of the republic. I sincerely, in all my heart, believe that GW Bush has us on a steep downward slide into a major uprising, a revolution. I will not allow myself to be subjugated to the North American Union. I do not want my fellow Americans wages attached in the name of Social Security to balance out the incomes of our southern neighbor in the NAU. Bush is willing to destroy America to fulfill his dream. Unfortunately, half or more of our Congress stand with him.
This utopian dream of a one world open door, no borders, concept is doomed to failure. It is a fool's pursuit. While increasing the wealth of the very poor, it will destroy the wealth and the jobs of the great American middle class. The next step is complete open hiring of Chinese and Indian employees to come to America, share housing and work for less than half of American wages. That will be the final nail in the middle class coffin.
How many of you sitting out there reading this are earning 162,500 a year. How many of you will have the same retirement plan as a Congressman??? They will be protected by their wealth, even enhancing their wealth relative to the median income on America. It is time to impeach GW Bush.
God forgive me. I wouldn't even stand for that for Clinton, but Clinton's pursuits were for personal wealth not some "dream" that benefits other countries and destitutes ours.
Corruption
June 17, 2007 - 17:52 ET by iveseenitallMisterbill:
There truly is more to this than American citizens are being told. I, too, am not a big fan of Buchanan. But he is a well-educated, intelligent man who has seen plenty in Washington. His books are well-reseached and well-documented.This entire thing stinks to high Heaven. In my long life, I have never seen a defeated bill come up again this fast. As a student of history, I believe that when there is this much excitement in the air, something is up. For example, La Raza is involved here. Isn't this the same group which believes we stole New Mexico and Texas from Mexico in the 1820's? This is not just about giving poor Pablo citizenship. Americans better wake up soon.
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
La Raza is a big force in Ca
June 17, 2007 - 21:57 ET by lnthompLa Raza is a big force in California government, with the publicly stated goal of making California a part of Mexico again. I think they would like to get TX, NM, AZ, CA, UT, CO and NV. Not sure they would stop with that, either!
Lee T.
U.S. Navy (ret.) / Vancouver, Washington
The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain
la Raza
June 17, 2007 - 21:59 ET by Cool ArrowIn Texas it's LULAC. Not much difference.
Why? Do they want Californ
June 17, 2007 - 22:03 ET by Free StinkerWhy? Do they want California to be as bad off as Mexico is?
Then we can look forward to people illegally entering Oregon from "Mexico" in search of jobs?
Also they may want to make su
June 17, 2007 - 22:13 ET by zfAlso they may want to make sure the federal government is to be as badly run as California's state government.
ivseenitall, don't let our ot
June 18, 2007 - 10:59 ET by JABivseenitall, don't let our other "creep" (Nelson - (D)) off the hook either. I've faxed and called both their offices. I told Martinez's phone help that he was commiting political suicide on the (R) side of the aisle.
"Too bad Ignorance isn't painful..."
A new week for GW
June 18, 2007 - 10:43 ET by misterbill