Russert Doesn't Connect Dots Between McCain Poll Collapse, Immigration Stance

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.

A quick hit this morning, as I'm on the road . . .

Question for our readers, astute observers of the political scene that they are. Scanning the news this morning, you see a report on the latest presidential poll. John McCain has lost over 1/3rd of his support. What's the first thing that pops into your mind? OK, the headline here is a hint, but isn't it obvious that McCain's pro-amnesty stance has hurt him badly among Republican voters? Well, apparently not so obvious to Tim Russert. Here's how it went on this morning's "Today."

TIM RUSSERT: John McCain's lost eight points since April, Matt.

MATT LAUER: What's wrong with his campaign?

RUSSERT: Well, he's having some fund-raising problems and I think Fred Thompson's presence is starting to draw folks away.

View video here.

A classic case of confusing cause and effect on Russert's part, no? What explains McCain fund-raising woes? Why did Thompson, testing the waters, find them friendly? Because -- as would seem obvious -- McCain's belligerent advocacy of the amnesty-first immigration bill has demolished his support among Republicans. But for whatever reason, Russert failed to connect the dots.

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Why is money always the rea

Why is money always the reason? It wouldn't have anything to with his message, right? I didn't know that conservatives were unhappy with the current field of Republicans because of their finances? So, does that mean that Thompson has more money than the rest? What gives?

I read last week that a lot o

I read last week that a lot of Republican donors had been waiting in the wings, many of them came out to support Thompson right after his "outing" on Drudge.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

Sure, I can understand that

Sure, I can understand that.. but, the way the reporting is framed, it's as though this guy or that guy has so many percent because of his bank account - not for what he stands for.

Money has a lot to do with it

Money has a lot to do with it.  A lot of good candidates carry low numbers because they do not have the money.  On the otherhand, hillary, and Romney carry a lot higher percentage of support right now because of their money.

Alot of politics has to do with name recognition.  The more money the better chance your name has been heard in one form or another.  An old adage of politicans is "get your name in print, good or bad, for people will forget the why but remember the who." 

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

Huh? How does that find it'

Huh? How does that find it's way into these polls? Are they asking 'In your opinion, who has the most money in the current field?' As opposed to who will you vote for? I think that you're missing the point.

No, my point is that after wa

No, my point is that after watching "real" (not some of your msm fairytales) polling for many years, in the details is a not so well known catagory where the poll asks a question like:

  • B. Hussein Obama - is your opinion a) favorable  b) unfavorable or c) not familiar with this person

Early on responses to the above were highly on answer c.  It took a lot of money to get where he is today.

 

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

That's because Obama Bin Ba

That's because Obama Bin Barrack is the current media darling, not because he came in with millions of dollars from the gitgo. Of course, the result of this FREE media coverage has garnered him more money.

I'm not discounting the fact that money has an impact on opinion, just that it's not the driving force as the MSM alleges. Like in this case.

I am afraid we will just have

I am afraid we will just have to agree to disagree on this one.  It's a noble thought to think that we elect people based on the "best man for the job", but (and I could get a lot of mail for this one) one family that comes to mind that would have never had its role in American politics that it has if it was not for tons of money - kennedy...

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

I agree that you're missing

I agree that you're missing the point.

I'm with ya Rock...the Repubs

I'm with ya Rock...the Repubs always raise more money then the Dems - looks kinda bad for the value of the Dem platform - so what's a Dem to do? Take a hard look at the Dem platform and fix it? Naaaah. Do "news" stories that make money look evil! Let's "get the money out of politics!" McCain Feingold...

McCain's problems are strictly due to his positions. He's a RINO. A true newsperson would report this correctly. But we all know how hard it is to find one of those...

BTW Obama's "free" publicity so far has literally been worth about a billion dollars...

And you'll note that money

And you'll note that money has never been an obstacle to FREE, most often favorable, coverage of media darlings like McInsane and Obama.

Free you say...just follow th

Free you say...just follow the money.  All the "freebees" get payback, and in turn favors.  As my Dad used to say "nothing is free, you pay for it somewhere"

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

Follow what money? Why woul

Follow what money? Why would there be payback when you are part of the liberal agenda? You have it backwards.

Obama's "paying for it&q

Obama's "paying for it" - he's an MSM bootlicker now...if he wants to keep getting on the frontpage of snoozweek and time anyway...

I think you have it backwar

I think you have it backwards too. If you were talking about Dick Cheney getting favorable coverage for a price, then you might have something!

Has nothing to do with politi

Has nothing to do with political party and everything to do with politics.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

(and I could get a lot of mail for this one)

(and I could get a lot of mail for this one)  you may be correct. One would hope that it would all be in agreement with what you said. I certainly agree. The mindless voters of MA continue to "prove" their "unbiased lack of prejudice" by repeatedly re-electing that obese sinner, Teddy and sending Barney Frank and Gerry Studds to the Congress. I have not singled out the latter two for their sexual preferences, which is their business, but rather for their sexual escapades. Frank's DC boyfriend use Frank's  DC abode as a trysting place for homosexual prostitution. Studds had an affair with an underage boy. The hero worship of Kennedy (all of them) is unexplainable.

Money that is the way the MSM

Money that is the way the MSM sees it, the more cash they have the less the MSM can do about their exposure. They never talk about the second tier candidates, because they are purposely controlling their air time. And yes, it should be obvious that the Dems get free and more positive press. Why else would we need News Busters

The real bias is in a news

The real bias is in a news media that tries in concert to pretend either of those 4 sets of 4 numbers adds up to anything close to 100%, especially this early in the race. As we've repeatedly-seen, I'm used to busting this kind of bias at this point. I'm easily doing it now one-handed and -- as Limbaugh says -- with half my brain tied behind my back.
JMR

I have been waiting for a mor

I have been waiting for a more "conservative" candidate to rise from the pack.  Is Fred Thompson for real? 

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

I think Romney is about as &q

I think Romney is about as "electable" a conservative as your going to get - the victors always need moderates in order to win the election...

You may be right, but I perso

You may be right, but I personally cannot get past his "religion".  With that said, and all the mail to follow, if hillary is his opponent, she'll kill him with them feminist view versus (gulp) his religion's point of view on women.  I think that's why the dems are secretly hoping for him as their opponent.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

I'm an evangelical protestant

I'm an evangelical protestant and I'm just fine with Romney in the oval office...don't tell me you're concerned about the polygamy...

No, it's "secret/scared&

No, it's "secret/scared" stuff.  Studied a lot about faiths other than the one you and I subscibe to.  The more you know, the harder it is to believe.  Trust me we do not want to go there, here.  But "They" (the libs) will if/when it becomes necessary.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

 

What are you afraid that Ro

What are you afraid that Romney might try to do in office - worst case scenario...?

School prayer?

School prayer?

Dear God-----

Dear God-----prayer--Oh, not that. The next thing you know. they will be encouraging our youth to  live good, clean, moral lives. How dangerous!

Exactly. Kids need to grow

Exactly. Kids need to grow up 'crack heads' so that they can wander the streets of America without a care.

pray for our schools please!

In my dreams...so what has Romney done so terribly bad as the Mormon governor of Massachussetts? The MSM would surely have organized all of their summer entertainment around it by now - news, weather, sports, prime-time tv, films, etc...

I would be more comfortable

I would be more comfortable with him had he been governor of any other state.

He was RE-ELECTED governor of

He was RE-ELECTED governor of that state - that's almost God like - maybe his Mormon ways ain't so "whacky" after all:)?

Exactly my point. How is it

Exactly my point. How is it that happened in such a state? And how is it that lard @ss Kennedy keeps getting re-elected? Something doesn't add up here.

I see Romney as a conservativ

I see Romney as a conservative person of faith, and a problem solver...I see his re-election there as a plus for the badly-needed conservative movement in MA...

The Kennedy family is royalty in MA - you can always put a Kennedy sticker on a turd there and sell it for $100...in fact that's probably how Ted gets re-elected...

However, it is not unreason

However, it is not unreasonable to be a little wary of Romney because of shifting positions on the issues. Maybe having Alan Keyes or John Bolton as a running mate would make him more appealing?

Yes I'm wary of him, too...ev

Yes I'm wary of him, too...everyone actually...good policy...

He will need a southern running mate - Thompson would qualify and shore up Romney's conservative shortcomings very nicely - not perfect but nothing ever is...

I suspect that this is Fred's and Mitt's plan...

Being wary of any politico is intelligent

Being wary of any politico is intelligent.   I have doubts about all of the contenders, including Thompson, but will vote for any of them against any of the socialist fools the Democrats will put up.

As for Romney, my main concern is that some of Jeb Bush's staff have joined him.   That makes me worry that Romney shares the Bush family attitude toward immigration.

You know the pres could be mo

You know the pres could be more on board with proper immigration policy if the spineless Repubs in congress grew some stones...it's not a one-man job

A new prez won't solve that problem...

Disagree, TM

Disagree, TM.    What we are seeing is the real George Bush.   He's been dragging his feet on the border all along and in the face of a true uprising against him that stiffened the spine of more than a few Republicans, he's coming back for a second shot at his amnesty bill.

Hi RJ - I have to disagree

Hi RJ - I have to disagree here. The real George Bush told us from the start that he wanted a guest worker program so I don't think anyone can fault him on that. He ran with it out in the open both times. I happen to agree with him on the guest worker thing. I know I'm probably the only conservative on here who does, but I have yet to see any type of realistic solution to the problem from conservatives.

No disagreement, Dee

No disagreement on the real GWB, Dee.    I said he's been dragging his feet on the border all along.   This bill just confirms again what he believes. 

Yes, we'll probably have to do something like a limited guest worker program, but not before making a serious attempt to fix the border and to enforce current laws.   In any event, the current bill is just a giveaway of the Republican Party and of America.

RJ

what is Bush's motivation right now?

I would say his legacy, but I

I would say his legacy, but I think he really believes in his plan.

TM --RJ

I am with RJ all the way on this one. To my surprise and disgust, this has been Bush's plan all along.

"Even though the Mexican political class is notoriously corrupt, they can often count on stronger support in Washington than can several more worthy world leaders who are genuinely attempting to reform and improve their countries. The history of the Bush family is symptomatic."

Fredo Arias-King

MisterBill - Bush has always

MisterBill - Bush has always talked about a guest worker plan. Its not new, 9-11 just stopped it for awhile.

fc...You are correct...Presid

fc...

You are correct...President hasn't changed a lick about his views...you are also correct about it being slowed since 9-11...and that is exactly when any thinking President would of shut the damned borders...COMPLETELY...with few exceptions...until this whole danged invasion could be stopped....

We had an opportune time with National Security....and lost it....PC, msm, and lobbyist wise that is.

I couldn't agree more bigtime

I couldn't agree more bigtimer. The border should have been closed to illegal immigration when the repubs had control of congress. If they had done that they would still be in control IMO.

Sgt. Rock...Excellent running

Sgt. Rock...

Excellent running mates you mentioned...both of them.

I too have mentioned here John Bolton would be excellent...plus it would be priceless after what has been done to him in the press and in the Senate.

This country would get straightened out fast if he had two terms, and a Congress that would work with him...but none of that is to be....unfortunately for us all.

Anyone who has followed Keyes forever as I have, knows what the leftists in the msm have done to him.

I voted for Keyes. He moppe

I voted for Keyes. He mopped the floor with the others in those debates. I like Bolton, he pulls no punches and is tough. At the very least, I would have him as Secretary of State or Defense.

Of course, you'll be faced with the 'sure, he's a good guy, but he can't win' crowd. Because, you see, it's more important to win than anything else.

sarge...learn from the past

sarge...I understand the dilemma. Do you remember Bob Dole? A TRUE War Hero and a very decent man. He probably deserved to be elected POTUS. His problem was that he was not charismatic enough. It's crap and it's not fair...blah,blah,blah...but that is reality.

All of that to say this...ELECTABILITY is important. Winning is important, because of the cost of losing.

If conservatives are RIGHT, then liberals must be WRONG.

But you left out the most i

But you left out the most important thing - he was no more conservative than GWB.

Another turn-off was his alleged staement about it being his turn to be President.

What I'm tired of is being stuck with the lesser of two evils every election. And the idiotic thinking behind vote for the guy that can win.

true conservatism

Sarge...look to the Constitution Party for true conservatism. I would love it if they could become a serious factor. Until we have term limits, it will always be the lesser of 2 evils...TOO MUCH PORK in DC !!!

Yeah, I've taken a look at

Yeah, I've taken a look at them. I think we would be better off if we can over-throw the current GOP leadership and put conservatism back on the front burner and end the capitulation to the left.

Dole was indeed a true war

Dole was indeed a true war hero, but he was a bit too decent to Archer Daniels Midland to also be decent to taxpayers like me. I voted proudly against him, by voting for the Libertarian "NOTA" choice.
JMR

Sarc--Dole may have been shot

Sarc--

Dole may have been shot during WWII but I certainly don't consider him a 'hero'.  He's a political hack who became a multi-millionaire 'working' for the government.  The country would have been better off if the Nazi who shot him had a better aim.  The same is true for McCain.  Wish he never made it out of Hanoi.  Both are pieces of trash as are most politicians.  

I've seen, and actually got

I've seen, and actually got to shoot, the kind of machinegun Bob Dole experienced that day, and it's very impressive. I don't think those of us who weren't there should try to deny his heroism, or McCain's, just because we disagree with their subsequent politics. Politics is a separate issue. IMO it's a miracle Dole survived that lead-hose. I managed to knock-over a water heater instantly using only part of a belt... My problems with Dole centered on corn subsidies. Sadly for US taxpayers today, that's another of yesterday's battles I lost.
JMR

Gross, TruthMonger

The mental image of the lips that dropped that chaw is disgusting.

Lysdexics Untie!

ROCK--I referenced this in a previous post--

ROCK--I referenced this in a previous post. The people of MA, for some inexplicable reason, feel a strong need to do things that they believe show that the are not prejudiced, bigoted people. Witness girl killer Teddy, Barney Frank, Studds. It is a compulsion to challenge the possibility that they may be prejudiced. The predominant religion in MA is Catholicism. I know it is a syllogism, but therefore they must elect a non-Catholic  to show we are not prejudiced, they must elect the first ever black man to the Senate (Brooks), or so they claimed that he was first,etc, etc. I left a long time ago. Many of my old friends (and I still love them) were and are beneficiaries of the MA spoils system and the contacts are all through the Kennedy political machine.

One other experience I will share--while back in Boston on a 2 year assignment, I had two workmates (a man and a woman) encourage me to have a homosexual affair so that I would understand  there was nothing wrong with homosexuality. I never had expressed an opinion. I do not know why they brought it up with me. Go figure!

They weren't successful, we

They weren't successful, were they???

sergeant----no--

sergeant----no--you silly you (limp wristedly.) I am and have been a very happily married man. I must admit that the woman was quite attractive and I was thinking of a con job by saying, "well let's start with the hetero half of this first."

Actually my rejoinder was not particularly brilliant. I asked them what they thought of suicide and I told them they would have to try it before they passed judgment on it.

Ok then.. I'm relieved to h

Ok then.. I'm relieved to hear that (some others on here are probably envious of you though).

Your guess is as good as mine

Truthmonger, Sarc has part of

TruthMonger, Sarc has part of it right in his link.  I am not quite sure what he would do in office...has more to do with the "ends justify the means" in both his political and personal life.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

So who's a better candidate t

So who's a better candidate then Romney on any of that?

That's what the primaries are

That's what the primaries are for, unfortunately some of the more qualified conservatives are at the bottom of the polls.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

IMO this guy. (Hey, you ask

IMO this guy. (Hey, you asked!) And Reason is, as usual, right about Wolf Blitzer needing to watch and learn -- Colbert's excellent "raise your hand" questions SHOULD be posed to the entire sorry bunch, but it won't.
JMR

Thanks sarc...I guess we'd al

Thanks sarc...

I guess we'd all pull Reagan out of the grave if we could but it's not an option...

Didn't read anything there about Romney pushing polygamy, etc...

Seems to be a story about Romney smarting up from his old RINO ways...

No, it's more of a story th

No, it's more of a story that rightly -- albeit disturbingly -- compares Romney to Edwards.
JMR

What kind of bigoted whisper campaign is that?

"Trust me, we do not want to go there here." 

vrwc13, what kind of bigoted whisper campaign is that?   Say it openly or stop making dark, sneaky allusions.

I didn't understand vrwc's co

I didn't understand vrwc's comment either.... Does he think Mormons are women haters?

vrwc, don't elude to something unless you are willing to back it up. 

No RINOs in '08 - Thompson/Hunter would be a good ticket; Thompson/Steele would be a great ticket

here

And you're afraid that this 

And you're afraid that this might be part of Romney's plans for the US Government?

No, just like you and me clai

No, just like you and me claim our faith is our most important attribute, underlying all we do, or at least we try to do, he is very likely to feel this way about his faith.  To me that's scary, again the "ends justify the means".  This issue is a ticking time-bomb in the hands of the libs. 

I see.. you're part of the

I see.. you're part of the winning is the most important crowd?

Not at all, I am for the righ

Not at all, I am for the right person, one who supports:

  • the unborn
  • the Constitution, et al
  • Judean/Christian morals
  • the freedom our ancestors came here for, fought for, and died for

and you?

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

I voted for Alan Keyes beca

I voted for Alan Keyes because he was the right person. What about you?

vrwc13, you are a bigoted fanatic

Another of your hate the Mormons sites, vrwc13.   Do you spend a lot of time "studying" up on Mormonism, so you can hate better?   Clearly, you're a bigoted fanatic. 

Sorry RJ this is public recor

Sorry RJ this is public record with noted LDS references, my Bible says the truth should not be hid.  No secret stuff with my Jesus.

Right on vrwc

Now let's go after those churches that condone Masons and Knights of Columbus. 

We know what they're really about, huh?

Lysdexics Untie!

I am right behind, er right w

I am right behind, er right with you.  They are here too.

Yeah, logic, reason, facts play less of a role now in the way we make decisions in America. – Al Gore

vrwc13, you doofus! Riled One was mocking you.

vrwc13, you doofus!   Riled One was mocking you....but you jumped right in and gave us another of your fear-and-hate-mongering sites. You spend a lot of time learning to hate, eh?

Funny thing is, you and Debra behave more like "cultists" than anyone on this board. ;^>

Thanks RJ

But I was revelling in having so easily zinging one over his head.

Lysdexics Untie!

Correction?

Having so easily zung one?

Lysdexics Untie!

zanged?

Having so easily zanged one? 

Zing Zang Zung

Forgot the rules of verbal declension.  Thanks, I thunk.

Lysdexics Untie!

Ya know RJ, my Jesus would no

Ya know RJ, my Jesus would not like me calling others names, apparently yours doesn't mind.  As far as hate, hate the sin love the sinner.  Don't hate you RJ, just think you are mis-led on a path that leads to an eternity you are not counting on.  

You guys have to lay off vr

You guys have to lay off vrwc13. Speaking out against mormonism is similar to speaking out against homosexuality. Both are a mindset/behavior that according to Christian doctrine leads to an eternity in hell. If vrwc speaks out against it because he's concerned about the eternal destiny of someone he's acting in love. If another is willing to say go ahead with your destructive behavior they are complicit in the sinners damnation. Who's the hateful one again?

The man with an experience is not at the mercy of a man with an argument.

This isn't really a thread fo

This isn't really a thread for a detailed theology debate...

Bigoty is "love?"

Bigoty is "love?"     Jeez, sounds like 1984...

Yeah sorry RJ i'm just not

Yeah sorry RJ i'm just not comfortable with watching people march off to an eternity in hell without trying to reach them with the truth. If you call that bigotry then fine I'm in some super company with Jesus, Paul, and the other apostles.

The man with an experience is not at the mercy of a man with an argument.

Trying to convert people to

Trying to convert people to your faith isn't bigotry, disagreeing with another faith isn't bigotry. However, not voting for someone who is of a certain faith ( especially if they are just as conservative as you are line by line ) is bigotry, not hiring or working for someone of that faith because of that faith is bigotry.

To be a bigot you have to be prejudice and be intolerant. I am intolerant of many things...doesn't make me a bigot. I can be prejudice of many things...doesn't make me a bigot. If you are judging people by their fruit, then you aren't being prejudice.

That's a frivolous comparison, WC

Tsk.  That's a frivolous comparision, WC.  I doubt Jesus, Paul or the other apostles would have concerned themselves with which politicans had which religion for purposes of voting.   If you're going to put yourself in their class, you'll have to shun politics entirely.  

Mormon Doctrine is akin to

Mormon Doctrine is akin to Homosexuality? Wow

I'm sorry vrwc13

I'm sorry, vrwc13, that you are a doofus.

So your cult disapproves of "name calling?"   tsk.   I remember you doing just that awhile back.  Does that make you a liar, or just a cultist with a bad memory?

And how about making sly, dark allusions?  Is that ok with your cult?  You did just that on this thread until you were called out. 

I won't ask if your cult approves of bigotry, because we all know that it does....

Doofus it is RJ.  I will jus

Doofus it is RJ.  I will just turn the other cheek.  No name caling on my part though. Regardless of what you and BT say, there is none. 

Dark, sly, allusions?  That's funny.  Just did not want to take this thread right where you took it. 

Oh, give me a break

Oh, give me a break.    You've given up the right to even pretend to take the high road.   You're a name-calling, hate-pushing bigot who attempted a whisper campaign.  Now you want to be a liar, too.