NBC's Williams Showcases Obama Blaming Bush for Black Despair Going Back to 1991

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

Touting it as “some unusually direct talk today from Democratic candidate Barack Obama on the issue of race, something he rarely focuses on in his speeches,” NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams on Tuesday decided to showcase a clip of Obama delivering a standard liberal critique of President Bush for not spending enough federal money on social programs. Williams relayed how “Obama said the Bush administration has done little to address what he called 'a quiet riot' of discontent and despair among blacks in this country, one that erupted in L.A. 15 years ago and has been building again since the administration's response to Hurricane Katrina.”

In the clip, NBC viewers heard Obama issue the hardly unusual liberal talking point that “this administration was color blind in its incompetence” before he avoided holding those in question responsible for their own plight: “All the hurricane did was make bare what we ignore each and every day, which is that there are whole sets of communities that are impoverished, whole sets of communities that don't have meaningful opportunity and don't have hope and are forgotten.”

The AP's article on Obama's address to a conference of black clergy.

A transcript of the segment on the June 5 NBC Nightly News, which led into a story on the “candor” about faith expressed by Democratic presidential candidates during Monday night's Sojourner's forum carried by CNN:

BRIAN WILLIAMS: “Now to presidential politics in this country, and we begin with some unusually direct talk today from Democratic candidate Barack Obama on the issue of race, something he rarely focuses on in his speeches. But today, speaking to a primarily black audience at Hampton University in Virginia, Obama said the Bush administration has done little to address what he called 'a quiet riot' of discontent and despair among blacks in this country, one that erupted in L.A. 15 years ago and has been building again since the administration's response to Hurricane Katrina.”

BARACK OBAMA, IN HIS SPEECH: “This administration was color blind in its incompetence. But everyone here knows that the disaster and the poverty happened long before the hurricane hit. All the hurricane did was make bare what we ignore each and every day, which is that there are whole sets of communities that are impoverished, whole sets of communities that don't have meaningful opportunity and don't have hope and are forgotten.”

WILLIAMS: “Senator Obama's message on race came a day after an unusual forum that found the Democrats talking about another sometimes touchy subject, faith, and they spoke with what some saw as surprising candor. With that, NBC's Ron Allen...”

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Where was Barack Hussein Obam

Where was Barack Hussein Obama when all those poor blacks were dying in the heat-wave in Chicago back when Clinton was in office?

Funny, William Billy-Joe-Bob Clinton couldn't seem to get himself off the golf course for that one.

Never heard so much as a peep from the MSM, either.

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

Does Obama realize that the

Does Obama realize that the "disaster and poverty" in New Orleans was sustained and deepened by a Democrat city government, and a Democrat state government, and at best wasn't helped any under Democrat federal government? All of which George Bush is to be blamed for, of course, somehow.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Vancouver, Washington

The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain

Strangely enough, the MSM ove

Strangely enough, the MSM overlooks this poignant fact every time the story is told. Of course, revealing this fact in every story has an adverse effect on the Bush-bashing quality of it.

The only disaster is all the social programs.

The real disaster and disgrace was the birth of "welfare" and the culture that has been pushed by the socialists and "progressives" in the democratic party. All it does is create an underclass of people who buy into the idea that the Government should take care of them and give them whatever they need/want. It's those people who are poor and destitute and hopless because Government always underdelivers on it''s promises and disappoints people.

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic

Get Over it and make it on your own

After a generation of preferences, these Blacks had better start doing it on their own.  They don't know what anger is until they see the real anger in Amaerica at this continuing welfare society. 

Chasvs,Wait 'till the dems ki

Chasvs,

Wait 'till the dems kick them to the curb in order to appeal to their new "favorite minority."

That ought to be fun to watch.

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

hispanics will displace the blacks

The hispanic birth rate, if sustained, will quickly propel them past blacks as the largest minority (if not already). And if you want to see racism, watch how the mexicans treat the black community. It is raw and it is ugly.

Dr. Martin Luther King (Republican) must be rolling in his grave to think that all these decades since his assassination have been squandered and wasted by failed black leadership and the democraps.

Pragmatic,Aside from the robu

Pragmatic,

Aside from the robust birth-rate of hispanics already here, you also have to take into account what could very well happen near-term in the event the scamnesty bill actually finds its way into law.

If each illegal is allowed to bring in five more, then years hence, things could get really, really ugly for the black community. Particularly if you believe, as I do, that the actual number if illegals in this country is far higher than the government's WAG, if not out-right deception.

I do not see the hispanic and black communities coexisting peacefully.

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

gangs as leading indicators

Ditto, Dave. I am not a native of California, but spent the better part of last year in East Hollywood, Rampart Precinct District. Although I only saw one murdered person on the sidewalk, I listened to the police helicopters sometimes every night. And the news in LA regarding the gang violence is not good. One thing I noticed, was that while the black gangs were "ruthless", the hispanic gangs were "brutal". Not to split hairs, but the distinction was evident repeatedly.

For instance, a black gang would be prone to rob, commit drive-by shootings, and other seemingly random acts of violence. But the hispanic gangs were more methodical, and much more brutally thorough. They would wipe out enemies quickly, along with the other family members. And their communities supported them, whereas the black neighborhoods seemed to "tolerate" their gangs. Also, the hispanic gangs were multi-national, with well defined structure. I heard of one business school studying the organizational structure of the MS-13 gang for its efficiency (morose).

Just observations from reading and hearing the local LA news for a while. But if these behavior patterns are indicative of violence to come, God help us.

pragmatic,Are you in Law enfo

pragmatic,

Are you in Law enforcement?  Are you familiar with the stated goals of MEChA?

"...The Democrats love chaos. The Republicans love order and discipline and waiting your turn."  Chris Matthews on "Gregory Live"  as reported by Scott Whitlock 16MAY2007 blog "Matthews Rips..."<

Google &quot;Ethnic cleansing

 

 

"...The Democrats love chaos. The Republicans love order and discipline and waiting your turn."  Chris Matthews on "Gregory Live"  as reported by Scott Whitlock 16MAY2007 blog "Matthews Rips..."<

You are about as right as you

You are about as right as you can be.  Hussein O might want to look at his two friends Al S, and Jesse J and ask why they try to keep their people down, never mind Hussein I'll tell you.......their pockets keep full by their race bateing.  Step up Hussein tell your people about family responsibility, speaking the english language correctly, education, etc. etc. oh and tell him the brim of a hat goes in front. If I were as employer I wouldn't hire any one based on anything but a willingness to do a good job and get along with every one else.

Black dispair?  That's what

Black dispair?  That's what happens when you keep voting Democrat for 40 plus years. 

Insane Despair

Definition

Insane Despair:  Voting the same for 40 years and expecting to get different results.

When you do what you always done, you get what you always got.l

Jack Kevorkian - America's Economist

Hmmm...I wonder if Barrack

Hmmm...I wonder if Barrack Obama knows that Democrats started the KKK and that it was in fact the REPUBLICANS who created the civil rights bills. Also wouldn't that mean Democrats are the reason that african-americans have suffered so much since it was DEMOCRATS who opposed the Civil Rights Act. He should check up on the Democrats history =P

"Mass genocide is the most exhausting activity one can engage in, outside of
soccer." (Dogma)

Everett Dircksen

Yeah, LBJ gets the credit for the bill Everett Dircksen stuffed down the Democraps' throats.

While Robert Byrd was trying to save the Armed Forces from the pollution of the "mongrels" (Blacks), Republicans were busy pushing the agenda of another Republican, Abraham Lincoln.

Jack Kevorkian - America's Economist

That's 'white nigger' talk!

That's 'white nigger' talk!

Silly me i thought Obama was

Silly me i thought Obama was a lib, and all libs know;

Enabling is bad  

Does Obama Seek to Incite Blacks to Riot?

Does Obama Seek to Incite Blacks to Riot?

And, what's with "1991?"

 Obama does protect himself a bit by noting that his view of the rising discontent and despair amongst blacks by saying, ''but the poverty and the hopelessness was there long before the hurricane." However, as the AP piece makes noted of, Obama repeatedly pointed the finger at President Bush as the underlying cause of this discontent.

It is true, the "poverty and the hopelessness was there [New Orleans] long before the hurricane [Katrina] hit. In 1965, just before Hurricane Betsy (a slightly stronger hurricane than, and which hit New Orleans more directly than Katrina), the population of New Orleans was growing by leaps and bounds and stood at 702,108. Just five years prior, in 1960, it stood at 627,525. That was one booming town.

Then Betsy hit. Fortunately for the folks of the lower 9th ward, which was completely inundated by the flood waters, the evacuation was much more orderly than in 2005, when Mayor Nagin, a black man, ignored the President's personal request, and neglected to order (as well, as he had not planned for the disaster and the care of his people) the evacuation, until it was too late. Betsy resulted in about 75 deaths - Katrina, well over 1,000.

Yes, we've seen pictures of President Johnson flying over flooded New Orleans, and yes he went and visited, and yes he called for great improvements and reconstruction. The Corps responded and - some, of which, the City of New Orleans (and levee boards) opposed. One of these projects were building flood gates across the canals into the city from the lake. Had they been constructed as the Federal government wanted done, they would have been closed prior to Katrina's storm surge (unless Nagin nixed that also),the water would have been kept out of these canals. The Superdome and the Convention Center would not have become the island, in a sea of despair that it was to be. Under president Bush's administration, these locks have now been ordered constructed, and the work, I believe (don't look to the news to find out) is almost completed.

Similar relatively straightforward projects have also been on the drawing board for years, including closing MRGO, the intercoastal canal which parallels the north edge of the lower 9th ward. Gov. Blanco has now signed off of going ahead with the closure. Combined with a few other improvements, a reasonable chance exists that the flooding would have been minimized. Back to Hurricane Betsy. The Media, in little tid-bits from time to time has led us to believe that under LBJ's leadership, we all joined together, and New Orleans came right back to life.

Remember now. Pop. was 702,108 in 1965, before Betsy. 1980 - By 1980, it stood at 557,515; by 2000, at 484,674; and by 2003, it had dwindled down to 469,032. 233,000 people had fled New Orleans from the time of the Great Society, the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act.

Sen. Obama, something was going on in New Orleans long before President Bush's days, and long before 1991.

Back in 1992, Homestead Florida was devastated by Hurricane Andrew. Now, Homestead finds itself next to a US Air Force Base. It's on flat ground - easy to get to during the recovery effort (you don't need boats and helicopters - you can drive right up to it). Other than 18 wheelers loaded with FEMA Ice getting trucked back and forth all over the country, Homestead had a bit of a problem.

You see, by 2002, covering 8 years of the Clinton administration, and the last and first year of the Bush 1 and 2 administrations, Homestead was not rebuilt in 2, 3, or 4 years. In fact, at the 10 year anniversary - hey you folks can search - but, well the leads go like this:

For the hard-hit city of Homestead, it's been a tough 10 years. Ten 10 years later, the effects can still be felt.

August 19: Building Andrew did more than devastate South Florida: It exposed dangerous shortcomings in ...

Time and time again, we have heard - we have read, that "nothing is being done to help people rebuild in New Orleans; that Bush does not like Black people; that other than trailers parked somewhere in a field in Arkansas, there is no federal aid to help. Oh, yea? The Federal government passed and Bush signed a historic amount of money to help folks rebuild in New Orleans, and along the Gulf Coast. It has been funded, and turned over to the state of Louisiana and to Mississippi to manage and to distribute. This is not in the form of low interest federal loans - rather, it is in the form of grants. Tax-free. It is to cover uninsured losses.

How much money? The maximum grant per home is $150,000. But there is enough money there that target an estimated 200,000 households, for each to receive an average payout of $85,000 each.

Maybe Obama should do his job as Senator, and in his speeches spread the good word about what is available to help instead of inciting people to riot.

Same ole fear and smear

When will black race hustlers and politicos stop thinking its 1964?
When? Always the fear, the smear, the pandering. Its 2007, the Civil
Rights Bill was 1964, there is a Civil Rights Comission, there are
signs in every workplace. Its time for him to help solve the 70%+ black
fornication (fake) families, the dropout rate, kids exposure to ugly
rap-hip hop thugism, the teaching of personal responsibility and so on…
but what does Mr. Fantasy do? Same ole, same ole. I knew Bill Cosby and
you are no Bill Cosby.

(theconservativecrawfish Blog)

“This administration was co

“This administration was color blind in its incompetence. But everyone here knows that the disaster and the poverty happened long before the hurricane hit."

Color-blind in its incompentence?  What does that even mean, Obama?  And just I hint for the rest of us, whenever a lib usues the prefix "everybody knows" oh man, that's code for, I really don't have a clue, so I'll just assume that everyone in the whole world agrees with me.

Obama is just trying to estab

Obama is just trying to establish his street creds with the black community, which is still largely reluctant to flock to his banner.  By tryinbg to sound like a civil rights leader, he hopes to woo votes away from Hillary Clinton, whose weak attempts to strike solidarity by forcing a drawl in her speech, has alarmed some black voters.

&quot;Brian Williams on Tue

"Brian Williams on Tuesday decided to showcase a clip of Obama
delivering a standard liberal critique of President Bush for not
spending enough federal money on social programs."

HOW MUCH FREAKIN' MONEY DO YOU NEED? He has already spent more on entitlement programs than any other President. And it still isn't enough. And newsflash, Mr. Osama Obama, it never will be enough.

B. Hussein Obama

Seems Louisiana Democrats were too busy lining their pockets with graft rather than caring for their constituency before Katrina.

Wrong stump, Obama.

Jack Kevorkian - America's Economist

That is true. Too bad that yo

That is true. Too bad that you have to do all of the research yourself on a story like this, Well, with the MSM being the propaganda arm of the DNC and all.

Btw.. OBAMA Bin Laden is an idiot.

For liberals, when it comes

For liberals, when it comes to the question of how much to spend on social programs, or how much the "rich" should pay in taxes, the answer is always "More."

The middle man

The "cut" the middle man gets can almost buy a $3500 hammer.

Jack Kevorkian - America's Economist

If only they'd empty William

If only they'd empty William Jefferson's refrigerator completely, they'd have enough money to feed the poor for a month in Louisiana.

The people of New Orleans were very wealthy until George Bush took office. - A logical conclusion based on MSM reporting

tv or not tv

In these mondern times when you can't tell you AC's from your DC's, I find no relevency in  the broadcast news shows.  I once watched the evening news and even some of the morning shows (I called them the meaningless and pointless morning drivel).  Over time I quit watching all these shows because they became so ridiculously biased in their coverage.  Couric and Williams and Lauer reeked of liberalism to the point of becoming unwatchable.  Now I'm in my third year of ignoring all broadcast news.  Have never seen Couric in her new 'dim talking points' slot, have never seen Charles Gibson?, and saw Brian Williams once while sitting in an airport bar.  To call these news titans 'comic' would be to credit them with some merit.  I choose to think of them as oracles of the modern liberal times which confuse everybody and make the world seem not what it is.  I think they're all Bozos on that bus.