As opposed to the fabulous discussion that occurred on Sunday’s “Meet the Press” as a result of the presence of a balanced panel, “The Chris Matthews Show” was the epitome of what transpires when a program is stocked with exclusively liberals.
Though “Matthews” also focused on the 2008 presidential candidates, without the existence of even one conservative guest, the 30-minute segment was practically a love-fest for Bill and Hillary Clinton, with a dash of grossly grotesque Gore gushing on the side.
In fact, host Chris Matthews, after introducing guests Cynthia Tucker of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Patrick Healy of the New York Times, Kelly O’Donnell of NBC News, and Joe Klein of Time magazine, actually began the discussion with this sycophantic praise of the Clintons:
First up, the Clintons might be the most storied political duo in history.
What? More storied than Franklin and Eleanor, Jack and Jackie, Harry and Bess, or Ron and Nancy?
See what happens when there aren’t any conservatives on the panel?
Alas, the sycophancy was going to get much worse, for next up on the praise parade was Joe Klein:
At a certain point, you’ve got to give her [Hillary] credit for being one of the very few people running for president right now who actually knows what she’s talking about.
What? She’s one of the very few people running for president who knows what they’re talking about? Could you be more specific, Joe, and tell us which of the candidates on both sides are really stuffed-shirt ignoramuses? Please? Pretty please?
Unfortunately, such an elaboration never occurred. Instead, as the conversation moved to former Vice President Al Gore, Klein said the following with a straight face:
This guy has been right about every issue for the last twenty or thirty years.
What? Al Gore has been right about every issue for the last twenty or thirty years, Joe? Including about how he created the Internet?
Without a conservative nearby to challenge this idiocy, as this segment moved toward a commercial break, Matthews said the following:
Joe, I have this strange suspicion sometimes when I watch the difficulties our presidents face now and we as a country now are in this horror in Iraq, and just this sort of malaise out there and everything, that maybe they’d like to just throw it over to the Clintons and say, “You handle this hot potato for the next eight years.”
Malaise out there, Chris? Are you kidding? The stock market is at all-time highs, unemployment is near historic lows, the economy is humming all across the globe, and this is what you characterize as a malaise?
Think Matthews would have uttered such nonsense if there had been even one conservative on the panel? I doubt it.
Regardless, here was Klein’s answer:
Well, I, he’s so good, though, I mean, he’s pretty amazing when you watch him…Listen, he’s the best I’ve ever seen.
Amazing. Makes you want to run to the lavatory, doesn’t it?
Yet, they weren’t done, for when the show continued after the break, Matthews began:
The Republican Party is all about the South these days, and the South was supposed to have a couple of heavyweight Senators running for it. Supposed to.
Video clips of Bill Frist’s statement about Terry Schiavo and George Allen’s “macaca” faux pas were then shown. After the clips, Matthews continued:
That left a field of three irregular Republicans: Rudy Giuliani, John McCain, and Mitt Romney.
Three irregular Republicans? Nice way to refer to America’s Mayor, a well-regarded senator, and a former governor, wouldn’t you agree?
Regardless, this moved the discussion towards Fred Thompson. Matthews asked Tucker, “Can he beat Hillary, in the general, Fred Thompson?” Tucker responded:
He’s got that baggage of the war. But, for a lot of folks who will never be comfortable with a woman, he’s not a scary, right-wing conservative. Solidly conservative, but avuncular, good stage presence, not frightening.
Imagine that. He’s not a “scary, right-wing conservative.” If there was a conservative on the panel, do you think she would have said that? Not a chance, right?
Yet, moments later, Klein said the following:
As things now stand, and they’re going to be different, November 2008, but as things now stand, there isn’t a Republican in the field, or out of the field, who can beat any Democrat in Ohio. And that decides this I think.
*****Update: NBer Gary Hall posted the following in the comments section concerning the above statement by Klein that is just too delicious not to share:
"As things stand now?" - isn't a single one, 'eh?
Mmm. Let's go to the May 16, 2007 Quinnipiac University Poll - head to head competition.
Giuliani 47% to Clinton 43%
Giuliani 43% to Obama 42%
McCain 45% to Clinton 44%
Giuliani 48% to Gore 40%
And the "most favorable" rating amongst all voters went to Rudy Giuliani@ 54% with Hillary tied with Gore for 2nd at 46%, and 3rd to John McCain at 45%.
How spectacular. I guess neither Klein nor anyone on the panel was aware of this poll taken from May 8 - 13 by Quinnipiac University of 939 Ohio voters. Thanks, Gary!
Think that if there had been a conservative on the panel, Klein would have been challenged for making this factually inaccurate statement?
Regardless, after the second commercial break, Healy predicted the following:
Here’s something that Hillary, Rudy, and Romney all have in common. Their campaigns think that Thompson is going to bleed McCain dry of money so quickly in June that July, early July, it’ll be all McCain obit stories. That he’ll be broke, he would have spent so much money on consultants and not raised enough…
Matthews responded with a huge smile on his face:
That’s what I like to hear. Hard prediction. It’s all over in a month.
Any questions about which panel discussion – Russert’s or Matthews’ – was better on Sunday morning, and why?
—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Debate
June 3, 2007 - 16:50 ET by Jerry MackMsnbc should change its' name to Praise Democrats Network. (PDN)
I saw this leftist lovefest t
June 3, 2007 - 17:04 ET by bigtimerI saw this leftist lovefest too...it usually is preempted by basketball here....
I wished it had been again...lol!
I wasn't furious knowing the other leftists he had on....so I expected as much. Fair and balanced goes against Matthews brains....you know that one brain cell that works occasionally upstairs in that vast empty space between his ears.
...but Mr. Anonymous was infuriating to me more than the others with his B.S. all the way around, especially about MisterSunshine himself Algore.
They had better start practicing saying President Thompson......
ROFL!
Which show was more balanced this Sunday...hands down Russert's...for a change.
Rudy wins in Ohio, Joe Klein
June 3, 2007 - 17:20 ET by Gary HallRudy wins in Ohio, Joe Klein.
Noel, you noted:
"As things stand now?" - isn't a single one, 'eh?
Mmm. Let's go to the May 16, 2007 Quinnipiac University Poll - head to head competition.
Giuliani 47% to Clinton 43%
Giuliani 43% to Obama 42%
McCain 45% to Clinton 44%
Giuliani 48% to Gore 40%
And the "most favorable" rating amongst all voters went to Rudy Giuliani@ 54% with Hillary tied with Gore for 2nd at 46%, and 3rd to John McCain at 45%.
My other favorite line (there were so many) was Matthew's opening teaser:
A conservative participant (or any journalist in the the know) might have countered by reminding us as to how old Clilnton supporter and friend, Hollywood mogul David Geffen, described the Clinton's several weeks back:
We all know that if an old financial backer, friend and/or supporter of any of the leading Republican candidates came out and vomited on them, as Geffen did with the Clintons, that the MSM would henceforth keep the quote alive. It would find it's way into almost every public MSM discussion of the candidate, right up until election day. Here's how Mattthews would do it:
Journalists who can't read - can't conduct research - can't tell the truth.
Gary
June 3, 2007 - 18:44 ET by Noel SheppardGary,
Spectacular catch on the Ohio poll. Great job. I'm going to move this into the body as an update if you don't mind. This is really too delicious to keep in the comments section!
Thanks. ns
Pinocchio
June 3, 2007 - 17:45 ET by Pragmatic-ManBy the end of the first commercial break, their noses were getting so long that the cameras were having trouble focusing on their faces.
panel
June 3, 2007 - 17:55 ET by iveseenitallIn high schools they have the advanced and honors classes, the average classes, and the slow learners. Then there are those in Special Education. Where do you suppose this group belongs?
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
Yup, no propaganda here, Chri
June 3, 2007 - 18:25 ET by dahliatraversYup, no propaganda here, Chris Matthews.
Where
June 4, 2007 - 08:17 ET by cvgbuckeyeBy the way; where in the world would you go to get three members of the MSM that weren't left wingers anyway? There are 2 kinds of MSMers: 1. Left wingers that know they are left wingers and are unashamed. 2. Left wingers that know they are left wingers and lie about it.
Well, there is a third classification of MSM: Those that have passed on.
How can you tell when the MSM is lieing? They are breathing!
WCVB in Boston actually has r
June 3, 2007 - 18:03 ET by Del DolemonteWCVB in Boston actually has relegated Chrissie's show to the graveyard hours-it's on at something like 12:30 on Sunday morning! Considering that he used to work for Tip O'Neill, that's pretty sad.
Del...What's the connection b
June 3, 2007 - 18:08 ET by Clear thinkerDel...
What's the connection between Tip and the TV station?
The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.
No connection, the point I wa
June 3, 2007 - 19:03 ET by Del DolemonteNo connection, the point I was trying to make is that WCVB is one of the most widely watched stations in Tip's old House district (the People's Republic of Cambridge)
What? More storied than Fra
June 3, 2007 - 18:41 ET by Wildcatter1980ROFLMAO
Just my $0.02
Chris Matthews long ago gav
June 3, 2007 - 19:12 ET by motherbeltChris Matthews long ago gave up any pretense of being a serious, unbiased journalist.
I wish there were one key on the keyboard that I could program to type that entire sentence with one stroke. I could save myself a lot of time. It is the all-purpose comment for any post about Matthews and/or his show.
Many times, he is as emotiona
June 3, 2007 - 19:25 ET by dahliatraversMany times, he is as emotional, impulsive and non-objective as Rosie O'D.
Bill Maher could learn a th
June 3, 2007 - 20:13 ET by Conrad5Bill Maher could learn a thing or two from this post. His WORST shows are the ones where a bunch of like-minded Hollywood liberals sit around a table and agree with each other about how mendacious the Bush administration is.
The funniest thing about Matt
June 3, 2007 - 20:28 ET by TEThe funniest thing about Matthews and his panels is that he actually "thinks" that his guests are "objective" without any biases and are merely dispensing with objective truth. That's how stupid Matthews truly is. Never forget that Matthews seriously speculated on his unwatched Loveball for Leftists show that Paul Wolfowitz cooked up a conspiracy in the bowels of the Pentagon to funnel a dog collar to American service members in Iraq, so that they could place the dog collar around the neck of an Iraqi prisoner.
Paul Wolfowitz cooked up a co
June 3, 2007 - 20:36 ET by dahliatraversPaul Wolfowitz cooked up a conspiracy in the bowels of the Pentagon to funnel a dog collar to American service members in Iraq
... you mean, he didn't??
Patrick Healy got one thing almost right about McCain
June 3, 2007 - 20:46 ET by Dave RPatrick Healy did make one statement I totally agree with:
....early July, it’ll be all McCain obit stories.
McCain's campaign is about to go in the tank, alright, but it will have little to do with Fred causing him to spend all of his money. It will be due to the mcsenator's unbelievable support for the scamnesty bill.
This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz
The stock market is at all-
June 3, 2007 - 21:01 ET by Tom1969caTwo possible answers:
~~~
"The current tax code is harder to understand than Bob Dylan reading Finnegan's Wake in a wind tunnel."-- Dennis Miller
Speaking of unbalanced "
June 3, 2007 - 21:07 ET by Del DolemonteSpeaking of unbalanced "journalists"....here's the side story from tonight's debate. CNN had pulled it, but it's now back up
June 3, 2007
Columnist/author arrested in spin room
MANCHESTER, New Hampshire (CNN ) – Columnist and author Eric Alterman was arrested Sunday night inside the debate spin room and charged with criminal trespass after police say he refused repeated orders to leave.
Goffstown, N.H. police say Alterman was in the spin room as a guest of the Creative Coalition and went to an area reserved for a private reception for WMUR-TV. Police say he was asked by an executive at the party if he was invited to the private area and was asked to leave. A police officer was called after a verbal altercation ensued. He was asked by police seven times to leave, and police say he became increasingly loud as he refused. After ignoring a final request, police say he was handcuffed and taken from the building. He is charged with criminal trespass, and a bail commissioner will determine if he will be released.
Alterman writes a column for “The Nation” and writes the “Altercation” blog for Media Matters. He also has authored several books, including “Why Presidents Lie.”
– CNN Political Desk Managing Editor Steve Brusk
http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2007/06/03/columnistauthor-arrested-in-spin-room/
I think I'll print all of the
June 3, 2007 - 21:27 ET by Sonny LykosI think I'll print all of these pages here and mail them to Chris. He must be made realize what an azzhlel he really is. At 65, but remembereing what it was like growing up in Chicago and being at the home of a teenage friend and listening to the "adults" all taking about the blacks. One wanted to walk away thinking: "These people really believe what they are saying."
Scary back then and still true today. Same people, different subject. The disease called a "elitist superiority complex" has survived over these decade, from the 50s and 60's factory workers homes, to TV stations The names have changed, but the disease spans everything and everyone.
Progressives? They should refer to themselves as "regressives. Mental illness have obviously not been successful cured in their case. I remeber back then as a kid, and my Ma saying about blacks; "If they did not even exist, some people would still find some other group to hate. These people live and die in their own subculture. For those pathetic types, they create their own hell on earth and are incapable of reaching the that plane we call being 'civilized."
A few years ago I had a bumper sticker that said: "Hire a tennager. They already know everything." Think I'll have a few new ones made up that say: "Hire a liberal. They already know everything."
Will Bill Maher say that Demo
June 4, 2007 - 08:01 ET by RedGuyBlueStateWill Bill Maher say that Democrats have such a love of the Clintons it's almost gay? I'm sure Slick Willy would be all too happy to drop trow for Matthews and Co. to kiss his butt. C'mon, Maher. Step up to the plate as you've done so many times before. (yeah... right)
Side note - I remember when Maher was a 'comic' on Rodney Dangerfield's HBO special (circa 1980-ish), "Young Comedians". He sucked then, too.
"This business will get out of control. It will get out of control and we'll be lucky to live through it."
Fred Thompson as Admiral Josh Painter (Hunt for Red October)