Bill Clinton’s first Surgeon General, Joycelyn Elders, was an outspoken opponent of the religious right, and was pressed to resign in December 1994 for suggesting that masturbation should be taught in schools as part of sex education, as a "safe sex" option for teenagers. She resigned, but never felt she was wrong to say it. That’s obvious because National Public Radio put her on Wednesday still spreading the message that the best thing about autoeroticism is "you know you're having sex with somebody you love." On former ABC reporter Michel Martin’s new talk show "Tell Me More," Elders was brought on as part of a segment called "Wisdom Watch."
Martin explained: "Every so often, you want to talk over an issue with people who aren't just smart, but wise. So we came up with Wisdom Watch, where we ask some of our most-respected elders to guide us through some of today's most challenging and important issues. Today, we're joined by Doctor Joycelyn Elders."
Clearly, NPR finds "wisdom" in the notion that conservatives are repressed yahoos who never teach their children anything about sex. They offered no time to the Abstinence Clearinghouse or any other advocate opposing Elders’ radical vision. To Martin, the problem in our society wasn’t the viewpoint of Elders, but the general backwardness of our culture:
MARTIN: During your time as surgeon general, you were known for talking about, you know, taboo issues like masturbation and abortion, and, you know, since then you've been continuing to talk about these issues. Do you think that anything's changed since you left in the willingness of the public at large to have these difficult conversations about sex and sexuality?
Dr. ELDERS: You know, we've come a very long way from when I first started talking about it. And I tell people all the time, you know, we have known about masturbation forever. We didn't talk about it because we were silent. We've been silent about sexuality issues and the fact that we could talk about masturbation as a form of sexual pleasure. You know, sex is for pleasure, 99.9 percent. I said that to a group the other day, and they said no, Dr. Elders, you didn't add enough nines onto that. It's for the pleasure, but, you know, very little of sex is really just for procreation only.
MARTIN: What were you taught about sex and sexuality as a young girl or a woman, and what do you wish you'd been taught?
Dr. ELDERS: I can say that I was thought not nearly enough. You have to remember I was born back in the '30s, when everybody was silent. And my mom probably taught me what she knew, but she didn't know anything. You know, we as parents haven't been thought, so we can't teach - the reason we don't teach our children more is because we don't know anymore, and we're fearful. You know, they taught you, ‘Don't do it.’
You know, we act like abstinence is something that just came up. We've been teaching abstinence for a thousand years, and what do we have? The highest teenage pregnancy rate in the industrialized world. We have a lot of adolescents -- 50 percent of the HIV and sexually transmitted disease are in our adolescents -- these children that we swear do not have sex. And the fact that we would act like we've never heard of masturbation, when 90 percent of men masturbate, 70-plus percent of women masturbate, and it's felt that the rest lie. [Martin laughs] You know, masturbation has never gotten anybody pregnant, never made anybody go blind, never caused anybody to have a sexually transmitted disease, never caused anybody to go crazy. And I always say, you know you're having sex with somebody you love.
Martin asked if you could have conservative moral values, that sex should be saved for within a marriage, and still teach your children about sex. Elders said yes, but that most parents, if they teach, they teach "abstinence only." Still a radical, Elders cast her conservative opponents as the forces of blissful ignorance (instead of educated restraint) and advocated starting sex education in kindergarten:
MARTIN: Dr. Elders, in our last couple of minutes, we've talked today about how you feel about Americans have become more open about discussing important issues of sexual health over the years. But is there one thing that you think most Americans are still ignorant about, that you feel -- that you would wish that we'd become more educated about in the sexual health realm?
Dr. ELDERS: I think that we need to look at health -- sexual health -- as a part of our overall health, and I don't feel that you can really be healthy unless you are sexually healthy. And I truly feel that we need to start educating our children about sex from kindergarten through 12th grade and so that they could respect their sexually and protect their sexuality so that they can be - have sexual health throughout their lives. Other countries do it. Why do we have to have the highest teenage pregnancy, highest rates of STDs, the highest rates of HIV in our adolescents? It's because we feel that ignorance is bliss, and it's not bliss. We got to educate our young people.
It’s quite clear that social conservatives need to explain to liberal reporters that conservatism is not automatically associated with ignorance and silence. As the movement for abstinence education in schools show, traditionalists have their own vision of sexual morality and health for America’s children – even if our taxpayer-funded radio network doesn’t want to give it air time.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
BLIND
June 1, 2007 - 07:51 ET by PawpawNGuess there was truth to what our parents told us about going BLIND if you do that!!
Do as I say, not as I do!
June 1, 2007 - 08:01 ET by goldenthroatIf my memory serves me correctly, isn't this the same woman whose son was busted for dealing drugs while she was in office? And doesn't this speak volumes for what happened during the administration of Slick Willy?
So teaching abstinence doesn't work, huh? Teaching is one thing - putting it into practice is a whole new ballgame and that is something the left-coast, bleeding-heart, 'do as we say, not as we do' liberals will never understand!
Never dance on an empty stomach unless it's a liberal.
"I don't feel that you c
June 1, 2007 - 08:18 ET by SouthJersey1953"I don't feel that you can really be healthy unless you are sexually healthy." And she was surgeon general? Wonder what medical school she went to.
I haven't seen a picture of her....maybe there is a reason she advocates masterbation.
No RINOs in '08 - Thompson/Hunter would be a good ticket
No wonder Elder's teachings h
June 1, 2007 - 08:29 ET by Senior ChiefNo wonder Elder's teachings have been embraced by public schools as in Boulder, CO's case, where proponents are telling students to use drugs and have sex, for it is good. Sex or sexual health, Ms Elders is not good if people are having sex outside of your wife/husband. Where did you get your education from? You're promoting transmission of STDs, promiscuity and abortion. Teen pregnancies, welfare recipients, drug addicts and criminal abortionists will be plenteous. I don't have a Dr. infront of my name (and names of every conservative folks in this country), but I do understand the consequencies of what you're promoting.
You need to go back to grade school...
I remember when a teacher in
June 1, 2007 - 09:28 ET by nnptcgradI remember when a teacher in 12th grade overheard a couple of the girls talking about sex and asked them if they met someone who loved, honored , rspected, and worshiped the ground they walked on but wasn't quite as good at sex as they wanted what would they do? Drop him was their immediate response. Nowadays sex is the be all end all of a lot of relationships that I see now. As soon as they're bored with the other for sex, they leave and look for new partners. We're trained from middle school on to enjoy sex, not the partnership it's supposed to bring, and there's people still wonering why we have such a huge divorce rate?
Mother nature is a bitch - Ninth Corollary of Murphy's Law
You know?
June 1, 2007 - 09:42 ET by imokYou know?
Many years ago I read a book,
June 1, 2007 - 10:30 ET by iveseenitallMany years ago I read a book, written in the 50's, about the coming sexual revolution. The author predicted the harm that was going to be inflicted on this nation through an obsession with sex. Sadly, his predictions have come to pass. We have now ruined a generation and the situation isn't going to improve any time soon.
NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal
What do you suppose the schoo
June 1, 2007 - 10:21 ET by BeanManWhat do you suppose the schools would do if a student flunked the masturbation class.
Do you think they'd have a remedial class? Would you still be able to graduate high school? Would it be a seminar with demonstrations and a class activity. What would the field trips be like?
"What would the field
June 1, 2007 - 10:27 ET by MightyMouth"What would the field trips be like?"
Undoubtedly more interesting then any field trips I can remember....:-)
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
community service
June 1, 2007 - 10:57 ET by LionKingIf they failed, they would have to "perform" community service at a sperm bank.
Might students flunk the cl
June 1, 2007 - 11:27 ET by balboaMight students flunk the class on purpose? So, you know, they'd have to take the class again?
Kind of like a trial run? Y
June 1, 2007 - 11:33 ET by MightyMouthKind of like a trial run?
Yes, I think some might. After all nearly 50% fail the first time in some states. That sounds like a possibility. I think it's the lazy way to do it though. And I think you get a better lawyer when they study and pass rather then flunk once and take it again, knowing what to expect.
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
discrimination lawsuits
June 1, 2007 - 11:35 ET by LionKingNext there will be discrimination lawsuits because of low sperm counts.
shh, trying to mess with ba
June 1, 2007 - 11:39 ET by MightyMouthshh, trying to mess with balboa's mind over this... :-)
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Remedial classes are going on
June 1, 2007 - 13:04 ET by Senior ChiefRemedial classes are going on across the country. Have you heard of teachers having sex with middle/high school students; middle schoolers having sex in classroom infront of classmates. Some got caught and in jail, but many got away- even principals and teachers...These are Elders' students of yesterday continuing her message to today's generation.
I don't think what Elders w
June 1, 2007 - 13:49 ET by balboaI don't think what Elders was saying can be responsible for adults taking advantage of minors, or for young people having sex.
Bal, she is a public figure a
June 1, 2007 - 16:54 ET by Senior ChiefBal, she is a public figure and whatever she says in public could be construed as truth...Just like the priest on yesterday's posts. There are people out there -young and adults- are not capable to discern right from wrong. What they hear from TV, or internet, causes them to react...
Huh ... I had heard that Joyc
June 1, 2007 - 10:54 ET by Michael ChapmanHuh ... I had heard that Joycelyn Elders was diagnosed as going blind....
She also has----
June 1, 2007 - 11:31 ET by misterbillShe also has---- carpal tunnel syndrome.
I thought she had hairy palms
June 1, 2007 - 12:06 ET by TexasOptimistI thought she had hairy palms.
George W. Bush is not a full-fledged conservative, but I still support his presidency. I'd rather have him as president than ANY of the Democrats.
Merry Christmas 2007.
teaxs optimist---Did you mean???
June 1, 2007 - 12:12 ET by misterbillteaxs optimist---Did you mean??? Mary Palm's brother Harry???
This is not a joke... my moth
June 2, 2007 - 06:21 ET by TexasOptimistThis is not a joke... my mother was a classmate of a student named Harold Butts. Some parents are just not that bright. (Or on the other hand, maybe his parents WERE smart, in an "A Boy Named Sue" kind of way LOL!).
George W. Bush is not a full-fledged conservative, but I still support his presidency. I'd rather have him as president than ANY of the Democrats. (Although I am rethinking this position daily!)
Merry Christmas 2007.
And one of her children has
June 1, 2007 - 13:09 ET by Senior ChiefAnd one of her children has mulitiple skin colors of white, brown, black and red, I heard!
Now THAT is a Rainbow Coaliti
June 2, 2007 - 06:22 ET by TexasOptimistNow THAT is a Rainbow Coalition!
George W. Bush is not a full-fledged conservative, but I still support his presidency. I'd rather have him as president than ANY of the Democrats. (Although I am rethinking this position daily!)
Merry Christmas 2007.
Notify Reps
June 1, 2007 - 11:38 ET by NortoBeliever
When I get off this I am going to call my reps to see if $$ can be withheld from npr. Why do my tax $$ have to go for this rubbish?
While I agree with Dr. Elder'
June 1, 2007 - 12:01 ET by stratmanWhile I agree with Dr. Elder's trite saying "... you know you're having sex with someone you love", would the corallary for suicide be "you know you're killing someone you hate"?
As far as I can tell, since the inculcation of children with relaxed views towards sexuality, in school and media and even by our president (oral sex is not sex), children are having sex at earlier ages and that progression to sex is occuring more rapidly than in past eras, more sexual partners in a shorter time span, more group sexual encounters, higher prevalence of sexually transmitted diseases, higher prevalence of teen and unwed pregnancies, and progression of occurrence and increased prevalence of younger age of pregnancy.
While sexual education in our school systems is probably here to stay, abstinence teaching should be taught as a guiding principle, not one to be shortshifted and paid lip service (no pun intended) so that a teacher's personal agenda can then be fullfilled. I shudder to think that kindergarteners are being taught sexual education. Specific questions, if they arise at these young ages, should be handled in complete alignment with the parent's desires, not the agenda driven teacher or school board or the ethically challenged politician.
Dr. Elder helps make the case for school vouchers, private schools and home schooling.
stratman-- don't you just love--
June 1, 2007 - 12:11 ET by misterbillstratman-- don't you just love--the recent "educational event" in Boulder CO?? Someone needs to fire everyone involved in that disgusting incident.
Starting with the principal.
I am not aware of events in B
June 1, 2007 - 13:18 ET by stratmanI am not aware of events in Boulder, Colorado.
Can someone provide a link, please.
Rubbing one out is fine if th
June 1, 2007 - 14:01 ET by RESTLESS 1Rubbing one out is fine if that's what one wants to do. However, I don't think it should be foisted upon schoolchildren. They will stumble upon this by themselves and don't need encouraging from anyone. Why do so many poeple have nothing better to discuss than sex and masturbation? With the obsession with sex in our music, television, and movies, it is hard enough to keep kids away from it's influence. We certainly don't need teachers having classes on masturbation when they can't even to teach them to read, write, do arithmetic, think independently......
stratman - here's a linkthefi
June 1, 2007 - 15:48 ET by thefightinggopstratman - here's a link
thefightinggop.org
Thank you for the link thefig
June 1, 2007 - 23:24 ET by stratmanThank you for the link thefightinggop. I am thoroughly disgusted.
I honestly didn't think that adults at a public school would behave so irresponsibly. Were these adults employed at the school or were they part of a group brought in to do an "outreach" program by the school? And this was mandatory for attendence?
I find it hard to believe that adults encouraging illicit and dangerous activities to minors would not trip an investigation of illegal and corrupting activity. There should be no shield from prosecution using the guise of an "educational" activity.
If this is what's happening in Boulder, I wonder what more is going on in Berkeley, California? Frightening.
stratman - Were these adults
June 3, 2007 - 03:01 ET by thefightinggopstratman - Were these adults employed at the school or were they part of a group brought in to do an "outreach" program by the school?
According to one of the articles on this story at the Boulder Daily Camera (check link), this was a group of people that were brought in to do the seminar. (Some of the comments made following the article are unreal!)
thefightinggop.org
"Dr" Elder's is s
June 1, 2007 - 17:01 ET by charlietexas"Dr" Elder's is so funny. Shes one I really miss from the Clintoon admin. Well I guess when she wants to switch things up, she uses her left hand. It makes her feel like shes on a blind date. With both hands, thats her threesome.
OK, now I'm sick......
"My mom taught me everyt
June 2, 2007 - 00:19 ET by SnowWhite"My mom taught me everything she knew, but she didn't know anything". Boy! There's a statement and a half. This reminds me of a stupid poem I heard in high school.
"I love myself, I think I'm grand
I go to the show, I hold my hand
I put my arms around my waist
I get so fresh, I slap my face."
Sweet dreams all! Snow
Dr. Elders' is quoted as sayi
June 2, 2007 - 02:48 ET by jdhawkDr. Elders' is quoted as saying, "Why do we have to have the highest teenage pregnancy, highest rates of STDs, the highest rates of HIV in our adolescents?" Well, this may be true - if you are African American.
Dr. Elders advocated:
legalization of drugs
distribution of condoms in our schools
teaching masturbation as part of sex education in our schools - as early as 3d graders!
nationalization of our health care
No wonder she advocated legalization of illegal drugs, while still the Surgeon General, her son was arrested for cocaine possession. She couldn't handle raising her own son properly, let alone being the nation's spokesman for public health.
And, then there was that little matter concerning the Clinton's running off the nation's vacine providers. By 9/11, we had so little capacity that we had to go to the Europeans to manufacture bioterrorism vacines.