'Was It Fair?' ABC Attempts to Justify Anti-American Booing of Miss USA

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
By Scott Whitlock | May 30, 2007 - 11:35 ET

Updated with video (14:35 EDT).

On Wednesday’s "Good Morning America," the ABC program attempted to justify and explain away the booing that Miss USA, Rachel Smith, received in Mexico City during Monday night’s Miss Universe pageant. In a tease for the segment, GMA anchor Diane Sawyer even wondered aloud, "Was it fair?"

Video (1:21): Real (2.19 MB) or Windows Media (2.49 MB), plus MP3 (376 kB)

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Reporter Dan Harris insisted that the rude heckling and yelling must be understood in a broader context. He explained, "By all accounts, the booing was actually not personal. It’s actually a sign of the increasingly intense relationship between the U.S. and Mexico at a time when the immigration debate is very hot." Harris later elaborated, saying that "many Mexicans feel that U.S. uses its power to get its way in world politics and also in competitions such as this one..."

At no time did time during the segment did Harris feature anyone who disagreed with this so-called political statement from the crowd or even anyone who simply called them rude for booing a beauty pageant contestant.

He did, however, interview a left-wing Green Party activist who attempted to validate the boorish behavior:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Dan Harris: "The tensions were evident back in 2004 and 05 when Mexicans booed during soccer games against the United States. Some even chanted Osama. The resentment has only grown since then as the U.S. has sent the National Guard to help beef up border security and build a wall to keep out the immigrants. Many Mexicans are also anxious about the new immigration bill in Congress supported by President Bush that many fear would split Mexican parents from their American born children."

Nativo Lopez (President, Mexican American Political Association): "People in Mexico get a flavor of that debate and it’s irking them. And I think what occurred is an expression of their disfavor with the debate and the manner and the tone in Congress currently."

For a taste of Mr. Lopez’s politics, see his interview in Socialist Worker magazine. Notice that Harris used the phrase "keep out the immigrants" and doesn’t include the world illegal? The ABC reporter also never seemed to wonder why, if America is so hated, millions still flock across the border.

At the very end of the piece, host Diane Sawyer did utter a mild rebuke for the booing, but clearly Dan Harris felt that berating a young woman who did educational work in South Africa is a legitimate way to make a political statement.

A transcript of the segment, which aired at 7:17am on May 30, follows:

7am tease

Diane Sawyer: "Was it fair? Miss USA loudly booed at the Miss Universe pageant. Who had the breach of manners in Mexico and how much did it sting on top of that fall?"

7:17am

Robin Roberts: "We're going to switch subjects now because it's the fall heard around the world. Yes, you're going to see it again, Miss USA taking a tumble during the Miss Universe pageant in Mexico City. But if you thought that was tough, wait until you hear what Miss USA had to endure from the audience there in Mexico. You hear that? Boos, even heckling? A lot of people wondering why that type of reception. We asked Dan Harris to find out."

ABC Graphic: "Why Was America Booed? Cat Calls For Miss America"

Dan Harris: "Robin, good morning. By all accounts, the booing was actually not personal. It’s actually a sign of the increasingly intense relationship between the U.S. and Mexico at a time when the immigration debate is very hot. The boos started as soon as Miss USA., Rachel Smith from Tennessee, stepped forward for the interview round in the Miss Universe pageant in Mexico City, Monday night, which aired on NBC. But the booing and the chants of Mexico did not stop."

Rachel Smith: "When I traveled to South Africa to volunteer at the Oprah Winfrey Leadership Academy For Girls in South Africa. I'm very passionate about education."

Donald Trump (pageant co-owner): "I don't think they were booing Rachel, Perhaps they were booing some policies of the United States."

Harris: "The tensions were evident back in 2004 and 05 when Mexicans booed during soccer games against the United States. Some even chanted Osama. The resentment has only grown since then as the U.S. has sent the National Guard to help beef up border security and build a wall to keep out the immigrants. Many Mexicans are also anxious about the new immigration bill in Congress supported by President Bush that many fear would split Mexican parents from their American born children."

Nativo Lopez (President, Mexican American Political Association): "People in Mexico get a flavor of that debate and it’s irking them. And I think what occurred is an expression of their disfavor with the debate and the manner and the tone in Congress currently."

Harris: "Rachel Smith herself has not commented. It was a tough night overall for her. She failed to capture the crown after slipping during the evening gown competition. However, she's being credited with grace under fire, during the boos which she managed to partly turn into cheers by address the crowd in Spanish."

Rachel Smith: [Briefly speaking in Spanish]

Harris: "Many Mexicans feel that U.S. uses its power to get its way in world politics and also in competitions such as this one, and they were upset that Miss Mexico did not make it to the final five, and Miss USA did, even though, Robin and Diane, she slipped and fell as we’ve seen."

Roberts: "But she showed a lot of composure."

Harris: "Yes, she did."

Diane Sawyer: "And who boos someone at a pageant like that? Really? How do you say boo back in Spanish? Really? To do that to her–"

Roberts: "Didn't the producers there try to tell the audience–"

Harris: "In the commercials, yes. They said you’re making Mexico look bad, during the commercial break."

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

"many Mexicans feel that

"many Mexicans feel that U.S. uses its power to get its way in world politics and also in competition such as this one..."

the mexicans have been having their way with us for the past 25 years.

Y Boo Miss U?

Mexico sends us an excess of 12 million Illegals and just one American tries to take a job a Mexican wants and see what happens?

Gore lied. Nobody fried

And had Americans booed Miss

And had Americans booed Miss Mexico, we would all be immediately denounced as racist imperial nativists.

Maybe at next year's pageant a Mexican contestant can be Miss USA since no American will want the job.

They hate us, but they want t

They hate us, but they want to come here... Ay carumba! Yo soy muy enfurecido!

These leftist apologists for

These leftist apologists for anti-American behavior are nothing short of traitors. The boorish behavior by these ungrateful swine should have been roundly condemned, as per Chris Matthews.

ABC

ABC anti Anti American Company, gives away country secrets.  Pro illegal immagration, Anti War, Anti Millitary,

Anti Bush, etc. of course thats only one Partiots opinion

I agree. They are my countrie

I agree. They are my countries enemies and should be treated as such.

"Was it fair?" --

"Was it fair?" --Diane Sawyer

The fact that she would even pose the question speaks  volumes.

Mexico's immigration laws are

Mexico's immigration laws are WAY worse than our own. All those fools have to do is walk across our border and there are few to stop them, so why are they booing? We have a right to defend our border. They should have booed Ms. Mexico for the conditions they live under.

Booing of Miss Universe

These people claim they want to come to America because they can't survive in Mexico. If they would

use some of this energy in Mexico to change conditions

in their own country, they wouldn't need to come to this

country.   If they do come to this country, they need to

abide by our laws, our constitution, our customs, etc.etc.

This is the United States of America, not Mexico.   IF its

so bad here, stay in Mexico.

So utterly typical of liberal

So utterly typical of liberal bias toward anything remotely resembling a right-leaning event or item:

"Many Mexicans feel..."

Just what the heck does this mean?  Did they talk to "Many Mexicans"?  How many does "many" mean?  Did they even talk to one single solitary Mexican?

No, they just throw in the statement "Many Mexicans feel..."  just like they do when they say "Some people are saying..." to Mitt Romney etc.

it's obvious that one doesn't need to be smart to work for ABC.  Isn't Diane Sawyer a former Miss USA? or Miss America or something?

I was thinking

I was thinking smart should be changed to honest.

When the newsheads and democrats claim millions of Mexicans come here in order to feed their families, it seems to me that 108 million Mexicans might get pissed off.

 But, the news never notices that. I mean, let's face it, the news practically declares Mexicans are starving to death every day. I guess 108 million people without food is a crisis.

 When the talking heads keep declaring we should allow mass illegals flooding our southern border because they have to "feed their people", I suppose somewhere down the line they might take a second to consider what that sounds like to Mexicans.

 I don't hear about the massive food supplies crossing the border going south. In fact, I have no idea if it even happens.

 I certainly don't think it's GWB or Iraq that has them pissed off.

you want to think the worst

Here's another example of the lies, perpetuated and spread daily; of our extremist right --

And no one questions them. When I've contradicted this lunatic fringe, they called me "resident apologist," Troll, demented, etc.,

Mexico is NOT teeming with poor people. It has a low-level stratus of peones and hard-up folks just like every country on earth has. With mexico the main difference is, those poor all watch American TV; they SEE all the advantages, the riches just across the border. So, it's a fact; they cross over illegally in hopes of taking a piece of that Pie in the Sky. It has NOTHING to do with their leaders or millions being "without food." We say these things and then ask, why do they boo Miss America ?

Every time one of these stupid lies is repeated, it demeans the whole Mexican people. Just as it would demean us; if Mexicans were to declare every day, "Americans are a nation of drug addicts and racists."

Why not treat others with respect, instead of fomenting hatred and repeating lies ? Aren't we good people ? Isn't it so, that Americans are strictly for Fair Play, and call the foul ?

No sh*t, tumbler

Mexico is NOT teeming with poor people.

Because the dregs of Mexican society are all in this country, waiting, for GWB, Teddy K, McCain the Mcsenator and the rest of the political class to put them on the government dole.

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

Mejico has hills filled wit

Mejico has hills filled with people living under tents.

Open sewage.

Red light streets.

Children standing at the crossing with rags waiting to wipe windshields for coins.

No education.

Another toke in front of the line?

JDW

News media: Scoreboard for terrorists

What "lies, perpetuated

What "lies, perpetuated and spread daily; of our extremist right --" are you referring to? Open borders and free citizenship is a lefty pet position. The MSM is predominently left. So what extreme right lies are being touted?

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

Open borders is not a lefty p

Open borders is not a lefty position.  What a ridiculous statement you've just made.

Open borders (in case you haven't noticed) is a big business position.  And we all know Bush supports Big Business above all else, which is why he's pushing the amnesty program.  That's what the big money makers in America want/need.

Sorry, nice try politicizing an issue that cuts across party lines.

So, Leon....

OK, how about describing YOUR position on 1) illegal aliens, and 2) the border 3) the proposed amnesty plan?

To tell you the truth RJ, I'm

To tell you the truth RJ, I'm really not concerned about Immigration.

The way I see it, it's inevitable.  What do you expect when you have the greatest/free-est country in the world?  People will do whatever it takes to get here.  Build a fence, build a wall, arrest every immigrant, i imagine you could even go so far as to kill illegal immigrants, and it would do nothing to deter future immigrants.

Basically, their lives in Mexico can be no worse.  What do they have to lose by coming to America?  They might get arrested?  So what?  They get returned home so they can try again.

Right now, I think Bush actually has a plan that might work or at least give us a chance to document these workers more accurately.  I don't see anything better on the table.  And to think we can simply stop immigration is nothing short of willful ignorance.

Why what's your plan?  What would you like to see happen? 

Leon's amnesty program...border control is pointless

And there is the liberal position.  Let 'em come.  Fences are pointless.    Amnesty.   Hardly a position similar to conservatives.

And, of course, that puts the lie to your earlier statement that open borders are a cross-party position.

And there is the liberal po

And there is the liberal position. Let 'em come. Fences are pointless.

True. What bothers me (about both parties, oops, I'm not a robot) is that there are already laws that, if enacted, would force the illegals to leave and they aren't being enforced. Think the new law will be enforced?

Sickening.

D


A day without NewsBusters is like a day without sunshine.

Laws already on the books

Funny you should mention that.  Seems we wouldn't have hate crime laws if our government would enforce existing laws.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

Do you not see that positions

Do you not see that positions on issues are what defines political philosophy?  George Bush is NOT a consevative.  His position of illegal immigration is only one of many issues where he departs from conservative ideology.

Where do you stand on illegal immigration?  If you take any position that seeks to legalize these invaders the you are not a conservative.  It is a litmus test issue.  There are many others.  Abortion on demand is another.  If you support that, you're not a conservative.  Spending is another.  If you support deficit spending, you are not a conservative.  [G. W. Bush again is not conservative on this issue.]

I'd call Bush a moderate on his issue positions.  Nobody sees this because the MSM is so left that no can see what the center of the country really is.  Bush was elected twice.  Were he permitted to run again, against any leading Democrat currently on the scene, I'd bet he'd win again, because these Dems don't represent mainstream [moderate] America.  They are all flaming lefties like the MSM.

I believe my fellow NBers hav

I believe my fellow NBers have sufficiently answered your statement. Open borders is most indeed a liberal position. It always has been and always will be. The more conservative (the opposite of liberal) one is, the more isolationist one is. So if isolationism is the opposite of the liberal philosophy, then the liberal philosophy is clearly open borders. 

This is an exercise in reasoning, but it was totally unnecessary, as the lefties haven't made any secret of their position on "immigration".

And if you don't see immigration as being political, then you need to lift up that rock you're hiding under a little higher.

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

"many Mexicans feel th

"many Mexicans feel that U.S. uses its power to get its way in world politics and also in competitions such as this one..."

Who cares what a bunch of people who hate us think about anything?

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

Many Mexicans

Many Mexicans feel they can't change their own government and have a much better chance of overthrowing ours.

Many Muslicrats feel this country should surrender to lies, fables and the wisdom of fools.

When will these idiots quit harping on how they 'feel'.  'Feel' is nonsense.  Let your yea be yea, and your nay be nay.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

I agree, they are like spoile

I agree, they are like spoiled, disrespectful children who need a whoopin' and a mouth full of soap.

Mexicans feel? Perhaps. I wou

Mexicans feel? Perhaps. I would rather have people that have the ability to think and reason and know the diffrence between right and wrong. Mexicans feel? I dont think they do. If they did, they would understand the pain inflicted on an already embarassed young lady. Mexicans dont feel, evidently dont think and havent the ability to reason out their actions. They demonstrated this lack of courtsey with a caloused display on international TV. Was I president I would impose a tariff on their imports untill Miss America was duly compensated.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

'Feel' is a buzzword

'Feel' is a buzzword of the Muslicrat party used to impart victim status on some potential voter.

Right and Wrong don't seem to apply when referring to these victims of conservative hate.  They can thumb their noses at the law because it is their culture.  Muslim, Illegal alien, the poor... take your pick.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

My apologies to all for the c

My apologies to all for the covered language, but what the F*#K is with these people? Why is it that every time I turn around, there's a so-called American making excuses for people from other country's behavior, statements, or actions? And many times placing the blame squarely on America? No, we're not lily-white all the time. No one is. But so often, this blatant anti-Americanism is not only condoned by the MSM, it is encouraged.

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

If there's an occasion where

If there's an occasion where ABC could be booed by its audience, say if GMA has one of their shows from a remote location, and I booed Diane Sawyer, do you think they would be so interested in understanding the reasons why I feel justified in using such a derogatory and rude form of expression?  Didn't think so.

Anyone who says they support the troops but not the mission is a liar. 

All I can say to you Mr. Harr

All I can say to you Mr. Harris, is. "Booooo! You're a jerk!' And it is personal.

That intellectual BS. To brush aside bad manners. They want our money. But sc--- us.

And same to you Mr. Trump. I though you had a "little" more dignity to tell the truth.

I may decide against my trip to Baja. Belize is more appreciative.

"The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule.”   H.L. Mencken

"Nativo Lopez (Presid

"Nativo
Lopez (President, Mexican American Political Association): "People in
Mexico get a flavor of that debate and it’s irking them. "

And this is what irks me: Mexicans(and others) feeling as if they are entitled to come here at will, and feel any debate about or attempts to secure our borders somehow infringes upon THEIR rights. The one thing that bothers me more is Americans who feel the same way.

I agree.I dont care what coun

I agree.I dont care what country your from.You come here you need to be legal.You have to follow our laws.Starting with legally immigrating.