Sicko: GMA Uses Moore Movie, Liberal Group to Push Universal Health Care

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

Based on its own ABC poll, "Good Morning America" could have run a segment this morning on the theme "support for universal coverage slipping as Americans express increased concern for keeping taxes down." But that wouldn't have fit ABC's big-government paradigm. So instead, GMA used this prescription for pushing universal health care:
  • Cherry-pick results from a poll you've conducted; ignoring inconvenient findings.
  • Bring in a spokesman from a left-wing group that pushes universal care.
  • Uncritically rely on a clip from, yes, Michael Moore's latest propa-mentary, "Sicko."
Today's "Good Morning America" took Barack Obama's announcement yesterday of his health care proposal as a jumping-off point for a segment on the broader issue. Co-host Diane Sawyer flashed a graphic showing that according to an ABC News poll, 56% of Americans favor Universal health coverage. What Diane didn't tell you: the number of people backing universal coverage has dipped since ABC last conducted such a poll, when support was at 62%.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓


Sawyer handed things over to ABC correspondent Claire Shipman, who promptly cited the poll finding that most people are more interested in universal coverage than in keeping taxes down. But again, she didn't disclose that the margin of people preferring coverage over lower taxes has fallen significantly since the last time ABC polled. Other inconvenient poll findings we didn't hear about: by a 2-1 margin, people think universal coverage would make the quality of their own care worse, and by better than 2-1 think it would worsen their choice of doctors or hospitals.

Shipman emphasized how times have changed since the Hillarycare disaster of 1993:
Clinton's effort to promote universal health care roiled her husband's presidency. But these days a healthcare plan is a must-have for candidates and for Democrats the buzz word is "universal."
We then heard from Ron Pollack, Executive Director of Families USA, who put in a brief plug for coverage. Pollack is a former Clinton appointee. Families USA is a liberal advocacy group that promotes universal coverage. Phillipe Villers, its founder and president, also serves on the ACLU President's Committee and the Amnesty International USA's Executive Directors Council. ABC predictably didn't bother to give us any background on the benignly-named organization.

Shipman then shifted to Michael Moore's upcoming documentary, Sicko. Said Shipman:
The issue could soon get hotter with this: [cut to a clip from movie] "He sawed off the top of two of his fingers," the upcoming release of Michael Moore's new film, Sicko, his scathing look at the healthcare system. [Back to movie clip] "The hospital gave him a choice: re-attach the middle finger for $60,000, or do the ring finger, for $12,000."

As she spoke, GMA helpfully ran a clip from Sicko showing drawings [displayed here] of the detached fingers.

ABC found it unnecessary to invite any guests to balance with a free-market perspective Pollack or Moore's weighty, big government views. To the contrary, she closed by again suggesting that the tide was moving in the direction of support for universal coverage:

Who would have thought, candidates fighting over ownership of the phrase "universal health care"?

Co-host Robin Roberts was happy to agree: "Who would have thunk it?"
Shipman & Co. didn't let ABC's own poll, showing support for universal coverage dropping, rain on their big government parade.

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net



—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Claire Shipman, who promptl

Claire Shipman, who promptly cited the poll finding that most people
are more interested in universal coverage than in keeping taxes down.

That's because the people that the dems and their liberal MSM dog-washers are pandering to have pretty much been removed from the tax rolls. They pay no taxes, or very little, so it stands to reason they will enthusiastically support the idea of "the rich" (anyone who has a job) paying for their healthcare.

After all, they have no problem forcing us to pay for their food and housing.

Socialized healthcare is coming. Don't get sick.

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

I think you're right, but I

I think you're right, but I think it goes beyond that, to a 'corporate welfare for wealthy executives' aspect of "universal healthcare" that few people bring-up on the MSM for some mysterious reason. Consider: ABC = Disney, NBC = GE, etc. etc., but all of them are giant corporations which already pay for the medical expenses of literally-1000s of employees. "Universal Healthcare" to these overpaid-already fatcats means "the taxpayers taking-over all those payments their companies otherwise be contractually forced to make anyway," which effectively-means "a bunch of sweet executive bonuses that year it takes full-socialistic-effect" if you ask me. Because of the ironies involved, the left is less likely to bitch about this particular piece of media/corporate welfare, but if I haven't just pointed it out, I'm not sarcasmo.

Socialized healthcare

Yeah, we really need to subsidize with free healthcare all those prostitutes, Illegals aliens, Smokers, Drunks, buttocks invaders, even the no seat belt wearers and no helmet wearers.

I don't give much of a flip what these people do, but I don't want to pay for their lifestyles.  And there's the problem.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

You're also right. This for

You're also right. This form of socialism is designed to turn nice people like you into control freaks, via a sneak attack on your wallets every tax day (and via even more inflation, no-doubt). That's why it's so dangerous, not just the corporate-welfare argument. But if you like, I'll probably be able to come up with OTHER arguments against it, it's so-wrong...
JMR

Tough enough in a few years

Can you say Social Security?  Sure you can.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

sarc,You mean companies lik

sarc,

You mean companies like the NYT who benefit from tax breaks as well as flagrantly abusing eminent domain for their own selfish purposes, then turn right around and publish articles criticizing others for doing the same thing?

Talk about do as I say, not as I do.......

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

"Do as I say, and not as

"Do as I say, and not as I do"

The motto of elite liberals everywhere.

Anyone who says they support the troops but not the mission is a liar.

kathleen,The libs need to p

kathleen,

The libs need to put that on a bumper-sticker, then affix it to the rear-end of their clapped-out old Volvo 240s (the ones that belch thick, blue smoke) right between the stickers admonishing us to "Save the Planet" and to "Visualize World Peace."

If they don't have room, they can always put it on top of the KERRY-EDWARDS stickers I still see from time to time. :-)

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-Neal Boortz

Michael Moore fears "THE

Michael Moore fears "THE TRUTH" about the healthcare in Cuba...

TheRealCuba.com

These same bumbling media idi

These same bumbling media idiots that blasted Bush for the "horrible conditions at Walter Reed" don't get the fact that this is an exact snapshot of what the dem. healthcare plan would in fact look like.  Apparently they were so quick to degrade anything associated with the military that they forgot that this is the friggin' same government that would be in charge of healthcare for everyone.

Bumbling media?

Why give MSM the benefit of being concerned for human beings.  Especially American human beings.

Consider also the cash flow Washington would enjoy with the new taxes.  It's because of that cash flow we have nothing but career politicians.  The admin costs are a Big Government lover's dream.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

Bumbling media?

Why give MSM the benefit of being concerned for human beings.  Especially American human beings.

Consider also the cash flow Washington would enjoy with the new taxes.  It's because of that cash flow we have nothing but career politicians.  The admin costs are a Big Government lover's dream.

Gore lied. Nobody fried

Big coverup -- Michael Moore's surgery in Cuba

Big coverup -- Michael Moore's surgery in Cuba

I found this in a little read weekly paper in Nepal. I guess even the best can't censor the news 100%. The truth does leak out.

Dateline: May 12th Havana, Cuba
Michael Moore, while visiting Cuba, was stricken with an illness of unknown type and origin. He was rushed by emergency donkey cart to the world-class hospital reserved for foreigners (actual beds and sheets on alternate Wednesdays). The highly trained universal health care doctors were summoned from their day jobs as pimps at the foreigner beach hotels to attend to Mr. Moore.

After much discussion, the diagnosis by consensus was either late term pregnancy or over indulgence during his meal the night before hosted by the El Supremo leader. After removal of many foreign objects (foot in mouth was the most difficult the doctors reported as it was lodged so firmly), the problem was apparent. Mr. Moore is now resting comfortably after the discovery and removal of Danny Glover from his GI tract. Mr. Moore could only remember swallowing large portions without chewing.    Mr. Glover, after being hosed down, was toasted and welcomed back by El Supremo but a note was made not to invite both he and Mr. Moore to the same El Supremo dinner party in the future.

Twins?

Does anyone recall ever seeing Michael Moore, Rosie or Lou Costello in the same place at the same time? HMMMMMM!

"Mr. Moore is now rest

"Mr. Moore is now resting comfortably after the discovery and removal of Danny Glover from his GI tract."

That Glover dude gets around. I heard he had to have his lips surgically removed from Hugo Chavez's ass not too long ago, which might explain why Hugo agreed to finance Glover's next propaganda piece.

ckc....LOL!Glover's lips must

ckc....

LOL!

Glover's lips must of took the place of Sheehan's....

Now that she stomped her feet..... packer 'er up and went home in a snit.