A television program came out strongly against the war on terror and the war in Iraq Thursday evening, but Katie, Charlie, Brian, and Wolf weren’t involved.
Video (1:42): Real (1.23 MB) or Windows (1.04 MB), plus MP3 (1.12 MB).
In this instance, it was NBC’s hit series “ER,” and the show – about doctors, nurses, and patients in a hospital emergency room if you couldn’t guess – didn’t wait very long to take a jab at the White House (h/t NBer SpinyNorman).
In fact, the episode began with the staff being informed by desk clerk Frank Martin: “Homeland Security raised our threat level to orange this morning.”
Leading character Dr. Neela Rasgotra asked, “Well what does that mean exactly?”
Dr. Gregory Pratt quipped as he was walking by:
“It means it’s an election year.”
Hmmm. What elections are happening this year?
Regardless of the political science gaffe, the lead patient of this episode, Kyle, was introduced after the credits rolled. He’s a young man that put his arm through a glass coffee table, and now has serious wounds. As he was being examined, we learned that he was in the military, and had done a tour in Iraq. One of his friends with him explained that Kyle never saw action over there, just “drove a desk.”
Kyle explained that he was “with intelligence. Worked as a translator.” The other friend in the room said, “He taught us how to swear in Arabic.” We found out that Kyle did “some missionary work over in Jordan for two years out of high school.”
As the episode continued, we found out that Kyle was addicted to codeine, and he actually steals a nurse’s keys to get into a medicine cabinet where he quickly swallowed a bottle of pills. After he’s restrained, Dr. Archie Morris asked, “What’s going on with this guy?”
The assisting nurse Samantha Taggart said, “It looks like textbook PTSD [post-traumatic stress disorder] to me.”
Morris responded: “No, he never saw combat. That’s what his buddy said. He was an interpreter.”
Dr. Tony Gates asked with an obvious message: “Who do you think translates during those interrogations?” I guess the actor playing the part, John Stamos, had read the script, and knew where the episode was heading, and the statement it was going to eventually make on this subject.
With that in mind, after Kyle had his stomach pumped, Morris asked him what was going on, and what the words meant that he was shouting in Arabic as they were trying to restrain him. Kyle responded in Arabic, and then translated:
‘Please don’t hurt me. I’ve done nothing wrong. God have mercy.’ I must have translated a million times in Iraq, man. It didn’t matter. They didn’t listen to me any more than they listened to prisoners.
Morris asked, “Who didn’t listen to you?”
Kyle replied, “The interrogators. The interrogators, they didn’t…” At this point, Kyle broke down crying and shaking.
Nurse Taggart, with a shocked look on her face asked, “You saw them beat the prisoners?”
Kyle replied through his tears: “Beat, burn, other things.”
The camera moved to Morris, who said with a thoroughly shocked and disgusted expression on his face, “You mean torture?”
Kyle replied:
Most of them that we questioned didn’t even know anything. They were innocent. I tried to convince the interrogators, but they didn’t believe me.
Somber music had been in the background the entire scene. But, at this point, the choir came in almost with a death mass. Kyle continued: “So, they kept hurting them. Everybody just kept translating their cries.”
Morris said soothingly: “It’s not your fault. We’re going to get you some help.”
Kyle replied: “I don’t want to go back to see VA, man.”
Morris answered:
You’re not. Not right now. You’re going to stay with us for a while. Okay?
Kyle responded: “Okay.”
And folks wonder why so many Americans respond to polls saying that they’re against the war. As if they don’t get enough of this posturing from the news media, now it seems such sentiments need to be forced down folks’ throats even when they’re trying to be entertained. In this instance, the viewer must have wondered whether this was an NBC drama or a Michael Moore schlockumentary.
Sadly, there was more political posturing left in this episode, for in the very next scene, Dr. Rasgotra was shown walking to and through an antiwar rally as Jeff Buckley’s song “Hallelujah” played in the background:
And I've seen your flag on the marble arch
And Love is not a victory march
It's a cold and it's a broken HallelujahHallelujah
Hallelujah
Hallelujah
Hallelujah
As the scene moved from the antiwar rally, back to the hospital, we were treated to a dressing down by the new ER chief of staff Dr. Kevin Moretti, who has been actively observing the goings-on throughout the episode. In this scene, Moretti was angrily tearing the staff apart for errors they made with a patient who almost died despite “all the attempts that we made to kill her.”
Moretti then went through each division of the ER, and what mistakes they made concerning this patient. He said to a protesting Dr. Pratt: “See, again, you’re arguing that incompetence and sloppiness are the norm, and that’s no way to impress me.”
At that point, Moretti was making the case that the doctors and nurses involved with this patient did an inadequate history and physical (H and P) to determine a diagnosis and course of action.
Coming just after a scene wherein a member of the army was discussing torture in Iraq, and another doctor walked through an antiwar march, one got the feeling that Moretti wasn’t scolding his staff, but, instead, making a statement about intelligence before the war began and the Bush administration:
Based on the incomplete H and P, which he took, and you accepted at face value. Your intern led you down the primrose path. You sold that to the attending Dr. Pratt, and then the three of you blindly walked Mrs. Calder right along with you to death’s door.
Sound like claims made by the left and the media concerning the White House and Iraq? Coming right after the antiwar scenes previously described?
Consider this. After Pratt defended his actions stating “sepsis was a viable diagnosis,” Moretti went almost ballistic banging his clipboard on the desk: “Nobody took a decent history.” Moretti then went into a monologue about the value of looking at a patient’s history:
What I want is for us to live in mortal fear of doing something wrong, of missing something, and having somebody else pay the price for that. And I want us to use that fear to make us better. I am not here because I need the work. I’m here because I want to save the world. And the way we’re going to do it is we’re going to reinvent the way we practice medicine every day right now, right here on the front.
After a brief, private discussion between Moretti and nurse Abby Lockhart, the scene immediately shifted back to Rasgotra at the antiwar rally, and a speaker saying at the podium:
It’s not political. It’s not Republican or Democrat. It’s about young lives lost every day. Every day. And knowing when to say we’ve done what we could, and maybe it’s time for us to go home.
At that point, Dr. Gates was also shown at the rally, approaching Rasgotra, when a bomb or grenade went off in the crowd. Role credits.
Still think Moretti was speaking to the staff about problems in the ER? Or, in the middle of this episode chock full of antiwar messages, was his rant at the end more to the Bush administration?
I vote the latter; how ‘bout you?
—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Bet ya it was a pro war activist....
May 18, 2007 - 11:48 ET by Gary HallBet ya it was a pro war activist.... I watched it. I believe at the end, with the explosions, etc. there was automatic fire spraying the crowd. Just before that, the commotion in the back of the crowd was coming from pro-war ("conservative right-wing" radicals, I would bet). I suspect the set-up is well established on this one. The left does not have the right to protest (they are traitors in the view of the right) - the radicals are the white conservatives - and they are the terrorists. I love mainstream TV.
And the vote? Oh, ya think so? (;~> g
I loved the set-up for the fi
May 18, 2007 - 14:52 ET by Tom PaineI loved the set-up for the final scene. They show the park with a sea of thousands of people, not seen since the Viet Nam era, all there to protest the “unjust” war in Iraq. The anti-war protesters were all calm and measured in their tones and the pro-war Nazis were abrasive and disruptive shouting moronic canned slogans like “traitors” and “stay the course”. Of course, Tony was able to immediately find Neela in this sea of humanity in just the right spot to be close to the bomb.
I would love to see a television series in which the conservative characters were all glib, witty, and got the last word in every exchange. The liberals would all be slow witted, speak in liberal talking points and unintentionally make fools of themselves to the knowing nods of the superior conservatives, whose views obviously reflect all of America – fade to black.
If he were someone who had do
May 18, 2007 - 20:43 ET by BDIf he were someone who had done translations during interrogations in Iraq he would not be screaming about how the detainee was being tortured.
In fact, what he would likely be screaming as he came to would be "Oh dear GOD I AM SOOOO BORED" in Arabic.
But that would not make for good liberal TV melodrama.
Just a word from one who has been there.....
Political indoctrination
May 18, 2007 - 11:49 ET by RJThe libreral media has perfected the stilted political indoctrination "morality plays" communist governments like the USSR and China used to require their citizens to view.
At the same time, they are intent on creating a new victim class - our military....who they call our "children."
propaganda
May 18, 2007 - 11:57 ET by bulbasaur"It is the absolute right of the state to supervise the formation of public opinion"
Joseph Goebbels
"Dr. Tony Gates asked
May 18, 2007 - 11:52 ET by dabal"Dr. Tony Gates asked with an obvious message: “Who do you think translates during those interrogation?”
I guess the actor playing the part, John Stamos, had read the script,
and knew where the episode was heading, and the statement it was going
to eventually make on this subject."
Sorry. Had to stop reading here and throw up.
democrat disgrace
May 18, 2007 - 12:05 ET by bulbasaurThis is the mob that, when they realized they had no grounds to impeach President Bush, had to suffer the humiliation of getting caught holding a pretend-impeachment in the dank basement of congress.
This band of pseudo-intellectuals was raised on a curriculum of leftist clap trap that denies objective reality, and therefore emboldens them to construct their own reality.
I was furious about this asin
May 18, 2007 - 12:26 ET by Hero SquadI was furious about this asinine "powerful new" episode "that comes along once in a lifetime," or whatever ridiculous hyperbole they used for the promos.
Quite possibly the last "ER" I'll ever watch... even if that means not finding out if Neela was crushed to death in the protester stampede.
Calling our troops torturers, and giving the words to a soldier in order to give them more credibility was just despicable. And then to have counterprotesters open fire and cause the stampede? Pure trash.
My vote is also with you, Noel.
*****
"Was it a millionaire who said 'Imagine no possessions?'" - Elvis Costello
I thought this show was can
May 18, 2007 - 12:28 ET by charlietexasI thought this show was cancelled years ago?? Oh well.....
I watched that episode last
May 18, 2007 - 12:29 ET by balboaI watched that episode last night, and when the torture story emerged, I was disappointed. If there were well-documented stories of torture instead of the administration's vague policies and posturing, that would be one thing. Just thought it could have been concluded better.
And the whole Halleluiah song montage was awkward, jumbled. The tone was off. I didn't think Moretti's speech was about the war in general at first, but I think Noel's right. Moretti might have a point.
But the whole last 5 minutes was just badly done, and I'm an ER fan (Maura Tierney, and Morris is funnier now).
Shut Up And Sing
May 18, 2007 - 12:33 ET by RJAnd I'm sure you understand, balboa, that this is what we get when morality plays become the focus, rather than entertainment.
Like Laura says "Shut Up And Sing" ;^>
I was actually digging
May 18, 2007 - 12:34 ET by Hero SquadI was actually digging the arrival of Stanley Tucci to the ER until this episode went south. I'm done now. Shark, thy body hath been jumped.
At least now we know with clarity that the writers of "ER" think our soldiers are horrible, horrible people doing terrible things to innocent people, presumably for nefarious purposes. That should not be soon forgotten by any of us.
*****
"Was it a millionaire who said 'Imagine no possessions?'" - Elvis Costello
I think it's a little broad
May 18, 2007 - 12:37 ET by balboaI think it's a little broad to say the writers think that about our soldiers. They've had military characters before who were not projected that way, such as Gallant.
Yeah, the new template for soldiers
May 18, 2007 - 12:40 ET by RJYeah, haven't you been listening to Hillary and the Democrats? (sounds like a garage band)
The new template for soldiers is "victim"
Right and they blew him up to
May 18, 2007 - 12:41 ET by MassConservativeRight and they blew him up to allow Neela and the rest of the cast to take another round of pot shots at Bush and Iraq.
Well, it's hard for everyon
May 18, 2007 - 12:45 ET by balboaWell, it's hard for everyone to be cheerleaders for war.
It's a show about a hospital
May 18, 2007 - 12:48 ET by Hero SquadIt's a show about a hospital in Chicago. It doesn't need to be for or against the war. The writers and producers have decided to wear its bias on its sleeve anyway.
*****
"Was it a millionaire who said 'Imagine no possessions?'" - Elvis Costello
Good point. Not everything
May 18, 2007 - 12:57 ET by balboaGood point. Not everything has to be a statement, and I generally don't like heavy-handed shows (Aaron Sorkin's weakness). That was one reason I thought the final 5 minutes just fell flat. The whole war thing came out of nowhere.
Ain't fiction grand???
May 18, 2007 - 12:36 ET by c5thenAny competent script writter can come up with any number of scenarios that make a case for any number of points of view. The fact that the entertainment industry is heavily left-wing and usually very vocal about it means that is the type of fiction that we will see.
Ain't it interesting that a young nurse in a metropolitan hospital can recognize PTSD that quickly?
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic
c5...Not really, she's been t
May 18, 2007 - 12:40 ET by Clear thinkerc5...
Not really, she's been trained by the liberal media since the beginning of the war.
The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.
Ain't it interesting that a y
May 18, 2007 - 15:08 ET by rimskyAin't it interesting that a young nurse in a metropolitan hospital can recognize PTSD that quickly?
Yes, this is a pet peeve of mine - the writers create these characters that just freekin' know everything! Self righteousness abounds! They are empowered individuals, and they have 18 epiphanies every day, and they WILL NOT be victimized, althought they have suffered bad victimazation at some point in the recent past and it has given them such wisdom that you'd think they've lived 1,000 years! And besides all that, they are usually gorgeous to look at.
I can't believe this show is
May 18, 2007 - 12:38 ET by MassConservativeI can't believe this show is still on the air. I was a big fan when it first came on and still watch it occasionally.
Since they first sent Dr. Gallant to Iraq this show has become more and more preachy and I am now forced to watch it with clicker in hand. It drives my wife nuts but it is better than listening to me rant about the stupidity of it after the fact. In last night's episode as as soon as the mentioned that the patient was a translator you could see where it was headed.
ER
May 18, 2007 - 12:52 ET by connmanSo let me get this straight. They can't drum up any public sentiment towards the administration with regards to torturing prisoners during interrogations, so.....they have to make it up and show it on their prime time TV shows. Too sad! Was this ER's season Finale?
er
May 18, 2007 - 12:55 ET by connmanIt's like trying to watch Boston Legal. The characters can be pretty funny, but the political commentary is just too much to take!
This is how ER has developed into agit-prop
May 18, 2007 - 12:55 ET by Jack BauerThis is how this show has always worked...
The character Dr. Kerry Weaver started out as a heartless cold, one-legged bitch probably a conservative, then one morning the writers had her wake up as a LESBIAN.
(But at least they didn't have her wake up in a shower after a dream sequence.)
At that point she become a sympathetic, complex character deserving of our love.
But to keep things the same the writers introduced another cold heartless bitch, only this time he was a MAN: Dr. Robert Romano.
And, naturally a persecutor of the now lesbian Kerry. But there was no happy transgenedered ending for Robert.
No siree Bob. First of all they chopped off his arm with a helicopter blade. Then they went one further and dropped a helicopter on him. Happens all the time, honest.
Then just in case you didn't "get" their immense subtlety, they named a Gay, Lesbian, Transvestite wing of the hospital after him.
Talk about hitting you over the head with a hammer.
That's two examples from a HU
May 18, 2007 - 13:06 ET by balboaThat's two examples from a HUGE cast of characters. Not really indicative of much. Nothing that horrible has happened to Frank, Morris, Kovac (Catholic), Benton, but Ray, a most likely liberal character, just got his legs amputated.
Carter had a liberal transfor
May 18, 2007 - 13:51 ET by Hero SquadCarter had a liberal transformation before he left the show, becoming almost embarrassed by his wealth and at odds with his more materialistic father, played without a shred of ironic awareness by Michael Gross.
Frank is probably the most arch conservative of the characters, and he's played as a brash, insensitive curmudgeon. He did have a massive heart attack.
I gotta add that this has to be one of the worst places on the planet to work. During the course of its run, it's employees have been shot, stabbed, chopped up by a helicopter (twice!), exposed to deadly viruses or benzine, beaten senseless in the bathroom, taken hostage, driven into the river, hit by vehicles, assaulted by unruly patients, and when all else fails, succumbed to a natural illness. Any one of those things would have me dusting off my resume pronto. For a show that prides itself on realism, it's laughable how unrealistic it's become.
*****
"Was it a millionaire who said 'Imagine no possessions?'" - Elvis Costello
They've definitley seen the
May 18, 2007 - 13:58 ET by balboaThey've definitley seen their share of disaster, but then that's why it's a TV show.
Carter never really was comfortable with his wealth. It was revealed accidentally that he was uber-wealthy.
Well, I go on about the absur
May 18, 2007 - 15:12 ET by Hero SquadWell, I go on about the absurdity of these hospital disasters, and then this happens at a hospital in my area.
*****
"Was it a millionaire who said 'Imagine no possessions?'" - Elvis Costello
LOL! I've always thought t
May 18, 2007 - 14:14 ET by StogieGuyLOL! I've always thought the same thing. What a grim, horrible, dangerous place to work. I used to watch the show every week, but have fallen away.
On the whole, Hollywood is out of control and 'entertainment' programming has become just as stilted as Soviet-era movies were. Although we here know better (well, most of us), the sad thing is that this propaganda works well. If you can't get 'em through the news - win 'em over while they watch TV. Scary.
Did I hear someone say "
May 18, 2007 - 21:08 ET by ArchConservativeDid I hear someone say "arch conservative"?
Balboa,It's one thing to have
May 18, 2007 - 13:53 ET by jpatchBalboa,
It's one thing to have a different set of ideals and beliefs. It's another to try and play devil's advocate at every turn for the sake of trying to sound different and intelligent. The writers of this show blatently injected their own political views into the script, and denegraded our soldiers at the same time.
At the very least, can we have an episode next time where we get some of our GI's back from war that have been tortured by our enemy? I mean, that is if they don't come back decapitated, castrated, dismembered and boobytrapped, like our boys were when we found them in Iraq.
If you read most of the newspapers in this country, and listened to most of the TV and radio broadcasts, you would never know the the Japanese, the Koreans, the Nazi's and now the radical Muslims are responsible for the most heinous acts of torture and humans rights violations that the modern world has ever known.
Can you please stop being such an ignorantly stubborn liberal for two seconds, and be an American like the rest of us?
Can you please stop being s
May 18, 2007 - 14:00 ET by balboaCan you please stop being such an ignorantly stubborn liberal for two seconds, and be an American like the rest of us?
You had me until that sentence. I think that the show definitely leans toward liberal, not disputing that. But I don't think the writers "hate" any one faction, though, or are "against" conservatives or are "out to get" conservatives.
Well, as much as I didn't wa
May 18, 2007 - 14:07 ET by jpatchWell, as much as I didn't want to do any name-calling, I sometimes get overwhelmed by the reality of whats happening in this world. I really can't even begin to quantify the fear and pain that those two American soldiers went through, and when I hear Rosie O'Donnell spouting off about the troops being dumb and poor, or Bill Maher making jokes about the war, it enrages me...especially when our troops are being accused by OUR OWN MEDIA of torture, hate, malice and incompetence. I really just want people like you to not be against everything we say, but instead understand that we feel like America is being demonized not only by millions around the world, but by many here within our borders. We need everyone to come together, so we can be strong and find solutions to problems that are bigger and more complex that any of us would like to admit.
And please believe me when
May 18, 2007 - 14:13 ET by balboaAnd please believe me when I say I'm not against everything conservative. The world just doesn't fall completely along party lines. I don't think all conservatives are evil, I don't think all liberals are perfect.
I thought this story was a dumb idea on this show and didn't have to be done. I just don't think it's a symptom of something deeper from the writers.
I couldn't care less about th
May 18, 2007 - 14:38 ET by jpatchI couldn't care less about these writers, other than the fact that they are adding to the lies and denegration of our armed forces.
At this point, do the terms "liberal" and "conservative" even have any substantive meaning anymore? Why can't we all approach an issue with a blank slate, instead of having all of these predispositions and emotions before a word is even spoken? Like you just said, the world doesn't fall along party lines, so why even have them? All they do is act to seperate, to divide, to cause discord and chaos amongst people who are trying, or should be trying, to make our country and our world a better place. We are our own worst enemy, while our real worst enemy is beating down our door. We're all so caught up in fighting each other than we have nothing left to defeat those that wish us death and destruction.
United we stand, divided we fall. I prefer to unite and stand as one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
May God bless and keep Pfc. K
May 18, 2007 - 14:01 ET by jpatchMay God bless and keep Pfc. Kristian Menchaca and Pfc. Thomas Tucker. You endured unimaginable pain and torture, and made the ultimate sacrifice in the defense of your country and countrymen. Your honor, sacrifice and courage will never be forgotten.
Your comment about how the
May 18, 2007 - 14:23 ET by StogieGuyYour comment about how the (WWII era) Japanese and (present day) Muslims did no wrong as far as the MSM is concerned is right on! Add the North Vietnamese to the list. All are victims.
When it looked like islamists were the bad guys on '24', there were protests. It was "controversial" (Ooooooo!). Just imagine a guy coming into the ER with PTSD from having been tortured by Iraqi insurgents. Can you? Frankly, I can't.
The only point where you are mistaken is that the Nazis are still reviled in the media. Hollywood hates nazis. In fact, they are treated as if there can never be any equal to their evil. And that would be ok, if it were true. BUT, many other regimes have been just as murderous - yet they somehow get a pass.
Apparently, all of the world's real evil rests in the hands of white, Christian men.
Well, it depends on who you t
May 18, 2007 - 14:54 ET by jpatchWell, it depends on who you talk to about the Nazi's. Lord knows there are enough people in this world (some of them LEADERS OF COUNTRIES!!!) that will swear that the Holocaust did not happen. Not to mention, how many times on a daily basis is George Bush compared to Adolf Hitler, or at least portrayed as a Nazi? One time is one time too many. The problem is, every time we see something that compares Bush to a Nazi, we lose sight of just how evil and destructive the Nazi regime was, which is why we hear more and more that George Bush is the worst terrorist in the world. Stuff like that is unacceptable, and in my opinion, should be considered treason.
ROFLMAO! OMG! Jack, you're
May 18, 2007 - 14:00 ET by MightyMouthROFLMAO! OMG! Jack, you're one in a million!
Then Without missing a lick, balboa's dead pan response!: "That's two examples from a HUGE cast of characters"
LOL! What a friggin friday! :-)
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Crap crap and more crap. Wh
May 18, 2007 - 13:38 ET by buddycCrap crap and more crap.
Why subject yourself to political indoctrination and liberal brainwashing? The channel blocker has a purpose.
USE IT!
ER
May 18, 2007 - 17:12 ET by a12iggymomHave you let NBC know you didn't like the message this show sent? I let them know DURING the airing, how disgusting the message was.
I personally worked with inte
May 18, 2007 - 21:05 ET by ArchConservativeI personally worked with interogators and this is just the most blantant piece of crap I've heard...even for a NewsBusters item. They should beat and burn the writers and actors of ER for inflicting and humiliation, perjury, and libel on our troops...BASTARDS!
"Every nation, in every region, now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists."
- President George W Bush September 2001 speech to a joint session of Congress.
ER use to be our favorite sho
May 19, 2007 - 10:46 ET by msh1973ER use to be our favorite show, but a few seasons ago we stopped watching. They introduced a character (name escapes me) that went to Iraq and was killed, the show took a deep left turn. Way to alienate an entire conservative audience, NBC.