In another sad example of self flagellation by western elitists, the Guardian Newspaper in England published a column on how we Americans (and our English cousins) should not celebrate the founding of Jamestown, the first Virginia colony, 400 years ago because of... you guessed it... slavery.
Here we have another elitist congratulating himself that he is "informed" enough to know that slavery makes the founding of the USA a blight on humanity instead of the great event it truly is. Another leftist who cannot bring himself to be proud of anything the west has been responsible for because there were some bad things mixed in with the good. In fact, the bad things make us such hypocrites, goes this type of thinking, that all the good should be discounted over it. (It is always in fashion for Europeans to look down on the US, isn't it?)
In the Guardian, Historian, Benjamin Woolley, is wooly headed enough to say that the Queen not being around to celebrate the doomed Virginia colony is "understandable" because of how evil the USA is.
The Queen took a tour of Jamestown, Virginia, on Friday as part of the commemorations of its 400th anniversary. The site of England's first permanent colony in North America, recently uncovered in a series of spectacular archaeological excavations, is of huge historical importance. It is the reason the US is an English-speaking nation, with Anglo-Saxon legal, commercial and political institutions. However, the Queen will be not be present for the anniversary itself, which falls this weekend. The reason is a prior commitment that necessitated her presence in the US a week early: the Kentucky Derby, held last Saturday.
The Queen's desire to escape to the safety of the world of horse racing is understandable. Compared to a punt even on a rank outsider, commemorating the arrival of a motley crew of 100 or so English renegades and outcasts on the shores of the Chesapeake Bay in 1607 has proved to be fraught with risk. Not only is there the solemn complication of the campus shootings at nearby Virginia Tech, but there is the small matter of Jamestown being the birthplace of African slavery, Native American genocide and the global tobacco trade, as well as of North American democracy and free enterprise.
Give me a break.
Here's a question: how can the USA be the "birthplace" of African slavery? There weren't any Africans here before the English BROUGHT them here. This means that African slavery existed BEFORE they came here.
And what is with this classifying of tobacco as just as bad as slavery? Is this more smoking naziness?
Apparently it is. And were I an American of African descent, I'd be quite upset at a guy who claims that smoking a cigarette is just as bad as my ancestors being held in bondage.
And, naturally, this guy makes it Bush's fault, too.
Meanwhile, the darker, more complex dimensions of the Jamestown story have if anything flourished. The way the colonists treated Native Americans, the importing of Angolans pirated from Portuguese slave ships, the exploitation of the land to grow tobacco, the chronic infighting that nearly destroyed the settlement in its first months - these have become potent elements in attempts to make sense of the combination of high principles and base motives that are such a feature of American history - no more so than the country's recent history of engagement with the Middle East.
It always amazes me how the slavery perpetrated by the Spanish and the French in Central and South America is ignored while leftist, elitists take after that in the USA. It seems never to be recalled that we sacrificed over 600,000 American lives to pay for the slavery that Europeans imposed on the fledgling American colonies, as well.
In any case, here we have another Brit elitist tsk tsking the evil Americans.
But, shouldn't we point out that the Jamestown colonists were British in the first place?
I'd say Woolley knows this and imagines his "guilt" for his countrymen is just as bad. Of course, this type of thinking also ignores the fact that the Brits were one of the most courageous anti-slavery proponents in their day as they used all their diplomatic and military might to rid the world of the African slave trade. I'd bet Woolley doesn't tout that accomplishment very often.
Woolley also ignores the fact that slavery was so common as to be entirely pervasive in the world during the founding of the Jamestown colony. Nearly every country then and nearly all before that time had slavery, so for it to have arrived on the shores of the New World with French, Spanish and English colonists is unremarkable.
And for intellectuals like Woolley to constantly castigate only the west for the institution of slavery is absurd to say the least. Especially when it continued in other countries for over 100 years after the end of it in the USA. And, in some instances, is still around today.
So, I say don't be ashamed to celebrate the founding of Jamestown despite the left looking down their noses at us knuckle dragging patriots. Be proud of what we have become despite the rocky road we took to arrive at this day. Because, in the end, shame is useless if used to condemn even the good because it makes the bad commonplace and normal.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Well obviously the guy is rig
May 16, 2007 - 01:51 ET by EcstasyOfGoldWell obviously the guy is right, I mean look at his gentlemanly haircut! And by the way, nothing says "I know about Evil American Slavery" like a fancy cane.
"American Slavery" ain't got nothing on the horrors British Colonialism.
He must know what he's talk
May 16, 2007 - 09:44 ET by MightyMouthHe must know what he's talking about, he has a really cool clock-ema-jigg in the background. Obvioulsy asstute about history and... umm...clock-ema-jiggs.
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Wait till anniversary 500.
May 16, 2007 - 02:13 ET by securityWait till anniversary 500. Technology and Science will be so advanced, they will probably reconstruct & recreate the entire landing
I especially love how he ig
May 16, 2007 - 03:33 ET by motherbeltI especially love how he ignores the fact that the Jamestown settlers were British, for heaven's sake! He makes it sound like 100 English renegades magically morphed into evil "Americans" and started "growing" African slaves. Oh, and how dare we celebrate anything in the same state where the recent VT shootings occurred?
Is every anniversary of every event in the history of this country to be an occasion for heaping scorn upon us? Apparently so.
This guy is such an effete cr
May 16, 2007 - 03:42 ET by Warner Todd HustonThis guy is such an effete creep, isn't he? I'll bet he's really french!
What's wrong with historians lying?
May 16, 2007 - 05:38 ET by SportPoliticsWhat's wrong with historians lying?
Aren't they supposed to nowadays ?
I guess I'm supposed to overlook the massive historical error.
History question
May 16, 2007 - 04:26 ET by UnsaneLet's try naming a civilization or culture that HASN'T indulged in slavery or profited from it...
"HAV3 TH3 BRIDG3S OF INSANITY B33N CROSS3D AND FOR3V3R R3TRACT3D???." - Meshuggah, "3ntrapm3nt", from Catch Thirty Thr33 (2005)
Yo, Benny boy, ummmm, who b
May 16, 2007 - 06:08 ET by DontFeedTheTrollsYo, Benny boy, ummmm, who built the pyramids?
Where were they built?
When were they built?
Was there an America then?
D
A day without NewsBusters is like a day without sunshine.
The British caliphate
May 16, 2007 - 06:34 ET by reelman46Amen, many cultures have had slavery but none now has the most spoiled (and successful) black people on the planet. Britain is always jealous but they will soon be cultural slaves under the moslem heel because they are so weak.
Maybe these gifted liberal writers will be spared beheading and have jobs writing hate manuals for the young jihadists. Maybe not.
slavery
May 16, 2007 - 07:31 ET by AgnosticI could be wrong but in the wonderful world of 'Islamic Extremism' isn't one of the opportunities for the infedels to live an agreement to convert and serve as slaves to their Islamic masters, that is unless they just need to set an example by removing your head to keep the sheep in line.
Pyramids builders
May 16, 2007 - 07:02 ET by dagdaIf you are implying that the pyramids were built with slave labor you are wrong. It was built by citizens who owed a certain amount of time each year to the state. Current scholarship has found no evidence of slaves being used in the construction of the pyramids.
Really the Portuguese are responsible for African slaves in the New World. However, when the British took over, they should how a good business model could really make slavery big business.
Our real problem, then, is not our strength today; it is rather the vital necessity of action today to ensure our strength tomorrow. Dwight Eisenhower
Wilberforce
May 16, 2007 - 07:18 ET by NortoBeliever
Google the name Wilberforce and you will find out about real Christian courage. His entire career was spent in the abolition of slavery in England. BTW weren't the people who became slaves delivered to the boats bringing them here to the English colony at Jamestown, of their own color?
Re: the pyramids. Do we discount the entire Biblical narrative as to who were the slaves in Egypt at the time those were built? Or have I been watching too many Hollywood flicks.
According to current scholars
May 16, 2007 - 07:43 ET by ahusserAccording to current scholarship, Dagda is correct. The term I heard used is Corvee labor. Kind of like being drafted into the Army (it aint slavery but you don't have much choice). Back to the thread, this idiot historian is again using modern sensibilities to customs and mores of the past. Seems to be a common mistake among the elite liberal "intelligentsia". I imagine our customs etc. 400 years from now will probably be abhorrent or laughed at.
"A mind is a terrible thing." - A comic I forgot the name of.
Actually, the there is no con
May 16, 2007 - 08:31 ET by Roger the ShrubberActually, the there is no concrete proof that either slaves, indentured servants, really poor, downtrodden farmers without jobs during the flood season, or an Amish-like "barn-raising" mentality of the Egyptian people has been completely proven true or false as of yet. They are all theories, and I would hazard to guess are all a part of the truth. In other words, it was a mixture of the four, or more categories.
"Current scholarship"?
Roger is right. NO ONE kno
May 16, 2007 - 09:39 ET by Warner Todd HustonRoger is right.
NO ONE knows how the pyramids were built and by what conventions the labor was organized. The Bible could easily be correct in that slavery was used in the era in question during the Bible's narrative, but the pyramids were built for a long, long time and it is foolish to think the same systems were in place the entire thousands of years they were in the process of building all the pyramids.
In short, they really are all nothing but theories. We have NO proof of ANY of them!
pyramids
May 16, 2007 - 10:51 ET by tejanodiabloeverbody knows they were built during visits by the mother ship when it could levitate the large blocks in ..
never look a gift skunk in the tail ..
I disagree. I and I should kn
May 16, 2007 - 11:01 ET by Roger the ShrubberI disagree. I and I should know: I've seen "Stargate" three times.
Maybe it would do him good
May 16, 2007 - 08:33 ET by kgMaybe it would do him good to realise that Jamestown (the father of slavery) WAS founded by the Brits. So in fact, the Brits are the father of slavery.
Here in the People's Republic
May 16, 2007 - 08:36 ET by ahusserHere in the People's Republic of Maryland the wonderful state government and of course the Annapolis city council just issued an apology for slavery. Reparations are sure to follow. I am of slavic descent the root word for slave. I want my reparations too because I am sure some Viking (Rus, Norseman et al) enslaved my ancestors. I think the UK government should apologise to us for inflicting us with slavery. Again modern sensibilities are used to judge the past. It don't work folks.
"A mind is a terrible thing." - A comic I forgot the name of.
Oh stick a fork in it Woolley
May 16, 2007 - 09:58 ET by bigtimerOh stick a fork in it Woolley...
My great great great great great grandfather, and I may be missing a great there, helped fight and found Jamestown.
I am proud of that fact....I hope to visit there someday.
Slavery
May 16, 2007 - 10:14 ET by pocomocoLest we forget, it was the Africans themselves who put their brethren into slavery as one village would raid another for some kind of remuneration from the slave traders. A small point the so called black leadership in this country and elitists such as Whoolley conveniently ignore.
Secondly, the Africans brought to America by the slave traders were miniscule compared to those brought to Europe, the Caribbean, and South America. It was noted in National Geographic magazine (with charts) a few years ago that the total number of Africans brought to the colonies was around 3,000,000, while the Africans sent around the world totaled in the several millions.
It is also of interest to note that every white nation in the world has long ago done away with slavery, however, it still remains on the African continent itself.
This tells me, then, that its ok for blacks to ‘own’ slaves, but all others need not apply. The hypocrisy is so thick you have to cut it with a chain saw.
Portuguese & African Slavery - Not Jamestown
May 16, 2007 - 10:35 ET by Gary HallPortuguese & African Slavery - Not Jamestown
And 600 years prior to the arrival of the Europeans in Africa - oh righto, that Islamic thing:
These little historical fact
May 16, 2007 - 10:41 ET by bigtimerThese little historical facts always get omitted Gary and poco....
Doesn't fit the agenda of the leftists to use for votes anymore.
Truth seems to hurt them always...we can't have that now can we?
Pog ma thoin, Europa! Bo mo
May 16, 2007 - 21:42 ET by kathleenirishPog ma thoin, Europa! Bo mor.
" 'Fred's Slacks' is a winner!!"
Sorry my universal translator
May 16, 2007 - 21:48 ET bySorry my universal translator is on the blink
Supreme Court, National Security, Borders, Fiscal Restraint, my litmus test for President.