CNN Reveals Truth About Sebelius’s Iraq-Ruined-Kansas Line, But Still Spins It Her Way

Photo of Matthew Balan.

Apparently, CNN can't get enough of Kathleen Sebelius, the Democrat governor of Kansas. She made two appearances on CNN on Monday, once on "American Morning," and the other time on "The Situation Room." Both times, she tried to blame the Iraq war for any hampered reactions to the devastation caused by a tornado in Greensburg, Kansas. The same evening, the "Paula Zahn Now" program featured another segment on the supposed equipment shortages Governor Sibelius has highlighted in her media appearances. Even though the segment's sound bytes supported the governor's line, CNN Pentagon correspondent Jamie McIntyre and Major General Tod Bunting of the Kansas National Guard made several points that reveal the truth of the situation.

One thing that was missing from all 3 CNN programs were any Republican responses to the governor's line. Both the White House and Kansas Senator Sam Brownback (who is also a Republican candidate for president) both disputed Sebelius's claims that there was a shortage of National Guard resources

.

In the first part of the "Paula Zahn Now" segment, McIntyre investigated if the Kansas governor's line was valid. Though sound bytes from Governor Sebelius and National Guard chief Lt. General Steven Blum highlighted the equipment shortages, McIntyre admitted:

But, as bad as it is, the Army insists the devastation in Kansas isn't overly straining the Guard's admittedly limited resources. There are still thousands of troops and hundreds of vehicles available. In fact, of the state's more than 7,600 Guard troops, only around 10 percent are deployed in Iraq or Afghanistan. And Kansas has not asked for any reinforcements or extra equipment from neighboring states.... The Army says it has enough equipment for both a simulated drill and the real-life disaster, and argues, if the governor of Kansas has an urgent need for more bulldozers, backhoes, or Black Hawk helicopters, she only has to ask.

In the second part of the segment, host Paula Zahn interviewed the adjutant general of the Kansas National Guard, Major General Tod Bunting. He mentioned the Emergency Management Assistance process, in which 400,000 National Guardsmen and the necessary equipment from across the country can be made available to assist in federally-declared disaster areas (a Defense Department press release on Monday mentioned this, as well as the Sebelius's government not requesting any assistance as of that date). Zahn also asked Bunting about his experiences in Louisiana with damage from Hurricane Katrina, and how that compares to the damage in Greensburg.

A full transcript of the segment:

(CNN Caption: "Not Ready for Disaster? War Has Natl. Guard Spread Thin")

PAULA ZAHN: Now, I want to bring the Kansas governor's complaint out into the open tonight. Governor Kathleen Sebelius says that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan has siphoned off so much of her state's National Guard resources, it's slowing down the recovery effort. We asked senior Pentagon correspondent Jamie McIntyre to look into that situation.

UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "Oh, no! The structures! Oh, no!

JAMIE MCINTYRE, CNN SENIOR PENTAGON CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): When a major disaster like the Kansas tornado strikes, state officials are often quick to blame the Iraq war for any delays in emergency response.

GOV. KATHLEEN SEBELIUS (D), KANSAS: With regard to our first- responders, they don't have the equipment they need to come in, and it will just make it that much slower.

MCINTYRE: It's no secret the war in Iraq has left the National Guard under-equipped and badly strained. The Guard's top general admitted as much to Congress last month.

LIEUTENANT GENERAL STEVEN BLUM, NATIONAL GUARD CHIEF: The National Guard today, I'm sad to say, is not a fully ready force.

MCINTYRE: A January Government Accountability Office report found shortages of trucks, generators, radios, chemical protective gear, and engineering equipment. Before the war, National Guard units typically had 65 to 75 percent of their needed equipment on hand. Now it's between 30 and 40 percent, a shortfall that will take some $40 billion to make up.

BLUM: Can we do the job? Yes, we can. But the lack of equipment makes it take longer to do that job. And lost time translates into lost lives. And those lost lives are American lives.

SEBELIUS: Here in Kansas, about 50 percent of our trucks are gone. We need trucks. We're missing Humvees. We're missing all kinds of equipment that could help us respond to this kind of emergency.

MCINTYRE: But, as bad as it is, the Army insists the devastation in Kansas isn't overly straining the Guard's admittedly limited resources. There are still thousands of troops and hundreds of vehicles available. In fact, of the state's more than 7,600 Guard troops, only around 10 percent are deployed in Iraq or Afghanistan. And Kansas has not asked for any reinforcements or extra equipment from neighboring states.

MAJOR GENERAL TOD BUNTING, ADJUTANT GENERAL, KANSAS NATIONAL GUARD: I think we got here in good shape. But we have limited resources. So, if we had another big storm right now, we would be hard-pressed to cover that.

MCINTYRE: In another sign that the Guard is not yet overtaxed, there's been no talk of canceling exercises, under way this week, in which thousands of Guard troops are practicing how to handle an even larger disaster, such as a massive storm, or even the detonation of a nuclear device by terrorists."

The Army says it has enough equipment for both the simulated drill and the real-life disaster, and argues, if the governor of Kansas has an urgent need for more bulldozers, backhoes, or Black Hawk helicopters, she only has to ask. Jamie McIntyre, CNN, the Pentagon.

ZAHN: And with me now is someone we saw in Jamie McIntyre's report, Major General Tod Bunting of the Kansas National Guard. Thanks so much for joining us.

We know your governor is very concerned about the shortage of equipment, National Guard equipment, in your state to handle this disaster. How will that compromise the efforts to get the job done?

BUNTING: Well, at this point in time, we're fine with this job. What the governor is saying is, with the shortage of equipment, if we had another storm anywhere near this magnitude, we wouldn't have enough equipment to handle it. We have got plenty of soldiers and airmen here, but we would be short on equipment. And we would be forced to go to other states, through the Emergency Management Assistance Process, to get the equipment in here.

ZAHN: General, I know you saw a lot of the damage that came out of Hurricane Katrina. And, in many ways, you have described what you have seen there today as even worse than what you saw in New Orleans. How so?

BUNTING: Well, here -- I saw Bay Saint Louis and New Orleans. I would say the damage is equal. The difference is that this entire community was hit. The way we have described it is, it looks just like Bay Saint Louis without the Gulf of Mexico. So, that's the -- the difference, total devastation, just everything moved off of the earth. So, it's -- the fact that this entire community, too, got hit, with virtually nothing spared, it makes it a tough one-two punch.

ZAHN: When you look at the pictures, it seems miraculous that anybody was ever pulled out of this wreckage alive. But is there really still hope tonight that you still might find more survivors?

BUNTING: Oh, absolutely. It's -- it has been amazing. And we did find one today. This rubble, though, in some cases, is 20, 30 feet deep. So, that's a challenge. But we have searched every area at least twice, and have extra crews coming in to spare the ones that are exhausted or going back -- back home to rest. So, we always keep that hope present. And we just keep working, too. We just go over it and over it and over it, to try to find everyone we can.

ZAHN: We wish you well. General Tod Bunting, thank you very much for your time tonight.

BUNTING: Thank you.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

We can't have the truth repor

We can't have the truth reported.

That is an 'owie' to the leftists everywhere.

Doesn't fit their template.

You know...agenda and all. 

Dems are SUCH hypocrits

Much like the Katrina debacle where Nagan blamed the Fed Gov for not getting the "poor" out in time while hundreds of city school busses were left in the parking lot to get flooded.

Now the gov of Kansas blames too many troops being deployed to Iraq with their equipment (10%) with hampering the relief effort, meanwhile she has never asked Nebrask, Missouri, Iowa, Colorado or the Fed Gov for the equipment that is supposedly lacking.

They constantly exploit people in terrible situations in order to try and score political points. It's disgusting!

Govenor Sebelius is STUCK ON STUPID!

Govenor Sebelius is STUCK ON STUPID!

RJ,Well, Charlie Gibson whine

RJ,

Well, Charlie Gibson whined on the news this evening that FEMA was unable to park their trailers......because there was debris in the way!

Oh the HORROR!

FEMA is there, two days after the disaster, with living accomodations, but it's the fault of GWB and the feds that there is no reasonable place to park the trailers.  (Oops, NG is deployed....hmmm, why is it called the "National Guard"?)

Okay, I'll fess up, mum just loves Charlie....I try to ignore it, but sometimes I actually hear the stupid stuff he says.

Finally, every interview I've seen with the wonderful midwesterners who got hammered....had each and every one in a bit of shock at the devastation, but in even more shock over how they're being reached out to by the rest of us.  Hmmm.

More tag-team lies, Blonde

Of course, Blonde. It's yet another trumped up scandal, with the DemocRATS and the media throwing out their usual tag-team lies.

RJ,Well, if Ms. Governor-stuc

RJ,

Well, if Ms. Governor-stuck-on-stupid cared to pay me the appropriate consulting fee, I'd fly up there tomorrow and fix it all in a week.  I know how to do that.

The media response to this has been so typically overblown.

Oh...did you see this one?  An arctic seal was rescued in Fort Lauderdale...hmmm...it died.  Wonder why?  It must be GWB's fault, or maybe it's global warming that caused the seal to swim to South Florida.

The seal was on vacation tr

The seal was on vacation trying to see Miami Beach that it had heard was set to disapear soon as the ocean levels were rising so fast. It was doing just fine until some enviro-PETA activists tried to "save" it and in the process fataly injured it.

Thanks, C5, for clearing that

Thanks, C5, for clearing that up.

I was truly having a blonde moment over it all.

After all, it was an Arctic seal, not an Antarctic seal.  And it was swimming south.  Do you think it was trying to get away from Global Warming?  Maybe it was trying to reach its southern brethren in the antarcitc? 

Or maybe it was just confused by Al Gore?

Poor seal.  They should have just left him in the Tarpon River (in Fort Lauderdale) until he was dead and stinky on the beach, at which point it would have looked like another manatee run over by hyper-rich evil leeches in a power boat.

Nah...it most likely was a ma

Nah...it most likely was a male seal that refused to stop and ask for directions....

Just taking one of those short-cuts dontcha' know...

Oh well...

The nappy headed 'ho of Kansa

The nappy headed 'ho of Kansas, Kathleen Sebelius, has to make this a BDS issue instead of taking care of the citizens in the disaster and celebrating the planning, hard work, and sacrifice that the National Guard in general and the Kansas National Guard in particular do in order be there when disaster strikes.

Instead, she puts the Guard's leadership in the awkward position of having to contradict her.  She ends up of looking like an ignorant fool.  She is neither aware of the status of her own state Guard in terms of men and equipment nor is she aware of the larger National Guard system.  Gee, who would have thought?

Meanwhile, the drive by media is aiding and abetting another case of BDS.   

Yeah, I said she was a nappy headed 'ho.  Hey, I am a hip hop "artist."  What, you don't like "art?" 

Truth About Sebelius’s Iraq-Ruined-Kansas Line

No dump trucks and bulldozers? Does Kansas have a Dept. of Transportation? Don't they have these things?

Mobilize your state's resources Governor ! Look around. There is plenty you can do on your own to help those people hit by those storms and tornados.

For someone SO concerned abou

For someone SO concerned about the recovery effort you wuld think she would not have so much time to be doing political interviews for every broadcast station dumb enough to listen to this incompetent idiot.

The governor flat out lied an

The governor flat out lied and knows it.  CNN is attempting to lie to cover her.

Supreme Court,  National Security,  Borders,  Fiscal Restraint, my litmus test for President.   

Ask the neighbors

Did Kansas suddenly become an island?  No?  Then they should be able to get help from neighboring states.  When we had a huge ice storm in Iowa late in the winter, utility crews from many other states came flooding in with equipment and supplies to get our power grid back up in a very short time, given the extent of the damage. And that was the private sector.  If Kansas requests outside help from the governors of neighboring states, I'm certain they'd get Guardsmen and women and equipment in short order.

Maybe this is a pre-emptive CYA in case things don't go smoothly for another Democrat governor.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

So when you request the Natio

So when you request the National Guard after a natural disaster that is all your going to get is the guard.  Is this government staffed with total morons?  Why wouldn't you automatically think "We need to move debris we're going to need backhoes to repair water lines or gas mains,  we need bucket trucks to work on restoring electrical..." No, we'll just send them the bareass National Guard with a few shovels and call it good!  Who do they think they're kidding?  Sam Brownback might as well kiss what little hope he had at the White House goodbye because his comments prove he's just another Bush apologist.

You forgot to slam Tony Sno

You forgot to slam Tony Snow, he said the same thing as Brownback. And your comments prove once again that you are a Bush antagonist

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

fender - he's really going

fender - he's really going to miss your vote since you would have voted for him before that. Poor guy.

And fender - you have no id

And fender - you have no idea how the National Guard works. The Governor has to make requests. They can't act on their own because it's not a police state. It's her job to survey the situation and tell them what she wants. So if anyone is stupid - it's her. Like they said - all she has to do is ask.

Here's the real story: Seb

Here's the real story:

Sebelius' staff said she had informed the Department of Defense of equipment needed - in Dec. 30, 2005.

The governor, a Democrat, wrote then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, concerned about "significant equipment shortages" because of machinery the Guard was required to leave behind in Iraq and Afghanistan.

In January 2007, Sebelius wrote Rumsfeld's successor, Secretary Robert Gates, about the extension of Guard tours, and in February, she repeated her concern about the Guard equipment shortage at a press conference in Washington, D.C.

When the Guard responds to a natural disaster, Montano said, the soldiers bring security, drinking water, mobile medical care and skilled help, transportation, food and heavy equipment.

Info from WHERE

Could you please link your info source?

So sorry AGAIN, fendertele. Governor stuck-on-stupid is backtrac

So sorry again, fendertele.  Governor stuck-on-stupid is backtracking:

"Snow recounted a phone conversation on Tuesday between Sebelius and Bush's White House-based homeland security adviser, Fran Townsend, in which the governor said she was pleased with the federal performance on the tornado and had everything she needed.

"Her spokeswoman, Nicole Corcoran, said the governor didn't mean to imply that the state was ill-equipped to deal with this storm. Sebelius' comments about National Guard equipment were, instead, meant as a warning about the state's inability to handle additional disasters, such as another tornado or severe flooding, she said.

"We are doing absolutely fine right now," Corcoran said. "What the governor is talking about is down the road."

http://apnews.myway.com/article/20070509/D8P0H7DG0.html

Busted/Bent Fender

Busted/Bent Fender.  No comeback?

another =====

another =====clintoon appointee given ink and paper and air space to say something nasty bout the Prez. Gee, what a surprise.

Old news, fendertele, and doesn't answer my post

 A statement by a Clinton administration loyalist?   Old news, fendertele.  

It does nothing to answer the backtracking of the stuck-on-stupid governor.  

Wow! A FOB statement

Wow!  You never cease to amaze.  It was a FOB-Bullock who worked in FEMA in Clinton admin for FOB James Witt.  Also commented about Lawrence Korb, who happens to be at The CENTER for AMERICAN PROGRESS ACTION FUND, a Dem senator from Wichita, and everyone involved was Dems, FOBs, etc.  & the statement on staff saying something was not QUOTED, probably because made up!  

One More Thing

I left out the PRESS CONFERENCE meeting of THE AMERICANS AGAINST ESCALATION in IRAQ were also part of the story(guess that why now they are called news stories instead of fact, because most are made up stories!!).

I did not realize that the Na

I did not realize that the National Guard had dispatched all of its "Backhoes, Bucket Trucks" to Iraq.  Please itemize each item that has been dispatched to Iraq and list its usefuless based on your previous comment.

(Up-armored HMMWV's are not eactly needed in Kansas this week....)

Only States With Dem(Dumb) Govs

Ever notice that the only ones that complain about things after disaster are states with Dem Govs.  Guess the Pres only sends the good stuff to states with Rep Govs.  Maybe we'll get everyone to move!! 

 pawpaw -Chicago has Dem M

 pawpaw -Chicago has Dem Mayor and IL a Dem Governor. There was a story in our local news a few weeks ago about the Feds giving us failing grades on communications upgrades since 9/11 despite all of the federal funding. I don't remember the details, but it was clear that much money had been wasted. The Mayor and Gov blamed it on media not giving up radio frequencies, but the story showed that therer were plenty available, they just needed to pay for them. The national media would never cover this story.

Of course if we have a problem in Chicago - it will be President Bush's fault.

BD

Your indiscriminate use of the word "backhoes" Has been found to be bigoted.

We prefer that you call them "pleasure girls to the rear" from now on.

Roger THAT!!!!

Roger THAT!!!!

As soon as I hear the story o

As soon as I hear the story of this terrible catastrophe I knew some Bozo would find some excuse to slam Pres. Bush and make it political.  Turned out to be Gov. Bozette.  The poor victims of this calamity must be so proud of her!  What a loser!