CNN Illegal-Alien Rally Coverage Includes Soledad Interviewing (Unlabeled) Leninist

Photo of Tim Graham.

Surely, CNN doesn’t stand for Communist News Network. But CNN’s Soledad O’Brien went looking for the "grass roots" of the pro-illegal immigration movement in Chicago during Tuesday’s Your World Today at mid-day. She interviewed a man she described as "Shaun Harkin of the March 10th Movement." She did not describe him with ideological precision: he’s a fervent Leninist.

An instant Googling of "Shaun Harkin" quickly brought up an article from Socialist Worker Online, where "SHAUN HARKIN explains why the Russian revolutionary Lenin and the theory that Lenin developed about the rise of imperialism remains so relevant today." Harkin concluded: "The dynamics of imperialism that Lenin analyzed are still present. His approach continues to offer the best framework to understand imperialism -- and is an essential tool for revolutionaries today."

On CNN, anchor Jim Clancy asked: "Soledad, what are they really expecting to see there today?" O’Brien noted from Chicago’s Union Park "There are organizers here who’ve told us that they expect to see twice the numbers of marchers that they saw last year. Now on the other side of the spectrum, we've also heard people say you could just see under 10,000....What's interesting to me is to see how quickly it has really filled up in the last hour or so."

Then she turned to the protesters and touted their usual palette of diversity:

O’BRIEN: "Now, because it's a grass roots organization, lots of people with lots of different agendas taking part in the march, also, lots of different groups. We’ve seen Muslims and Puerto Ricans, we’ve seen Filipinos, we’ve seen Koreans, you know, you name it, we've seen it here. In addition, of course, a large Mexican [presence], illegal and legal, by the way, turning out. When you ask people why they march, there are a couple of things in which they all see eye to eye. Here’s Shaun Harkin. He is one of the organizers with the March 10th Movement.

HARKIN (with heavy Irish brogue): There's a united message today. We’re here to say that the raids and the deportations that have been escalated over the last year are wrong and unjust. And that immigrants are here to work and they’re not criminals. And that we think that the best solution to this problem is legalization with full rights for all the undocumented.

O’BRIEN: He talked a little bit about these raids, immigrant raids, criminal raids that have been taking place over the last year. Some people were concerned about the most recent one, a criminal raid, they were concerned that might scare people, clamp down on people turning out for this march. Other people predicted exactly the opposite, that the furor your over that raid would actually make more people turn out."

It’s odd that the March 10th Movement would complain on its website that "The undocumented worker is situated on a most flexible and precarious edge, giving rise to extreme forms of labor exploitation." It would have been interesting for O’Brien to ask Harkin if the "undocumented worker" is so extremely exploited, why are they streaming in to capitalist America illegally?

Clancy also raised the prospect of the march being ruined by conservatives (although he granted them some momentum), and O’Brien agreed and then did another publicity turn for the protesters, noticing the relative absence of foreign flags:

CLANCY: Soledad, what could really rain on these people's parades is very strong, very vocal opposition to any kind of amnesty, opposition that seems to be growing in a lot of quarters. This is really quite a debate in the U.S., isn't it?

O’BRIEN: No question about it. That is going to, as you say, metaphorically, rain on the parade. Also what's interesting to me is the visual, and concern to the visual message, as well. Last year, you have a lot of people marching with Mexican flags, and that visual made a lot of people around the country concerned about illegal immigration. They felt that they couldn't support it because of the visual message, and now you’re seeing here today, look behind me, the number of American flags. I've seen maybe four Mexican flags the whole time we've been here.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

So, nobody got a job they got

So, nobody got a job they gotta go to?

Many illegals, socialists,

Many illegals, socialists, and communists took today off.

Do not patronize any business that is closed today. Ever.

Good point, Rackie.  Were th

Good point, Rackie.  Were there any Amway recruiters milling about the crowds?  :-) 

And why should we not be surprised that this event, once again, was scheduled for May Day, and that one of O'Brien's interviews was with a confirmed Leninist?  Hmmmm . . .

My theory on why conservative

My theory on why conservative protests never draw as many people as liberal demonstrations: we're all too busy working to pay the taxes for the "causes" the liberals advocate at those demonstrations. Plus, we have a life and other responsibilties...

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

"The undocumented

"The undocumented worker is situated on a most flexible and precarious
edge, giving rise to extreme forms of labor exploitation."

Labor exploitation? What about American citizens who lose there jobs to these illegal aliens? What about the flagrant exploitation by these illegal invaders of our tax dollars? What about the hideous burden these people are putting on our health care system? Our legal system?

Just exactly who is being exploited here?

It would have been interesting for O’Brien to ask Harkin if the
"undocumented worker" is so extremely exploited, why are they streaming
in to capitalist America illegally?

It would have been most interesting to watch Mr. Harkin tap-dance his way around that one, as the lefties cannot seem to bring themselves to criticize the corruption of the Mexican government.

This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-
Neal Boortz.

It's not just the Mexican gov

It's not just the Mexican government Dave. The reason these illegals are more than willing to come here and get "exploited" is very simple. The extremely low wages paid to illegals are still several hundred percent more than they could make at home.

The math is simple. It's so easy, even an uneducated Mexican illegal can do it...

The Closed Mind Builds Strong Barriers

Another good example of the m

Another good example of the media passing off fire-breathing radicals as just plain ol' everyday folks. Like this guy is your insurance agent or something...

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

Hey, Soledad!  Viva la revol

Hey, Soledad!  Viva la revolucion!  ... What idiocy.  CNN interviews a die-hard Leninist.  Earth to Soledad: The Lenin-Trotsky-Stalin experiment did not work, and it killed more than 100 million people worldwide, tens of millions of them killed by insipid agricultural and "economic" policies crafted by Lenin and clearly close to the heart of the man you interviewed.  Here's another note: Leninism and communism did not work in Russia, Eastern Europe, China, North Korea, Vietnam, Cuba, Angola, Mozambique, Nicaragua, and the People's Republic of Cambridge, Massachusetts. 

What do you expect from a per

What do you expect from a person named "Soledad". Her parents must have been flower children (slash) radical activists extrordinaire. 

The new 'immigrant' song

The new 'immigrant' song

Ah, ah,
We come from the lands Fox (Vicente) and Co.
From the broken fence where the Rio flows
The floating wood, will carry our kin.
To fight the citizens, singing and crying: El Presidente (Bush), I am coming!

On we sweep through the widening door, Our only goal will be to make you poor..

Ah, ah,
We come from the land of Fox of Fox and Co.
From the broke fence where the Rio flows.
How fast we steal your green, your laws that we ignore
Of how we started the alien war. We are your overlords.

On we sweep through the widening door, Our only goal will be the to make you poor.

So now if you're a cop, your job you will be losing
Pull us over and sensitivity trainin' is all you'll be doin..

Copyright (C) 2007 Six String Spiff

Thats awesome.  Immigrant So

Thats awesome.  Immigrant Song 2007.

Texas has a population of nearly 21 million people, all of whom are ashamed to be from the same state as the Dixie Chicks. (IMAO.com)

Aww darn it! There are typ

Aww darn it! There are typos in it.. oh well enjoy none the less

Islam should have it's religious status revoked until it can prove it's not a hate group.

I wonder if Shaun is a relati

I wonder if Shaun is a relative of a prominent politician from Iowa.