Newsweek's Howard Fineman's first instinct when he heard about the Virgina Tech shootings was to call up Capitol Hill and ask members for gun control legislation. On this weekend's syndicated Chris Matthews Show, the Newsweek reporter admitted "the first thing he did" was call the Democrats to demand: "Okay, you gonna do something now?!"
The following conversation occurred on the April 22nd edition of The Chris Matthews Show:
Chris Matthews: "Let's go to a more familiar terrain for us all: policy and politics. Just a week ago, the NRA held its national convention. Executive Vice President Wayne LaPierre warned the members of the NRA that the Democratic Congress will threaten gun freedoms. Quote, this is Wayne LaPierre: 'Today, there is not one firearm owner whose freedom is secure.' Polls do show a majority of Americans now want gun access restricted. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi this week is working on a bill that would prevent gun access by the mentally ill. Congressman John Dingell of Michigan is negotiating with the NRA right now on this, to try to tighten up the laws, give states enough money so they can find people like Cho, who've been through this system, been identified, and make sure they don't buy guns. Is that gonna work?"
Howard Fineman: "I think it might. As a political reporter, of course, the first thing I did was call the Hill and find out from the Democratic leadership, 'Okay, you gonna do something now?!' And the answer I was told, bluntly by Democratic leaders on the Hill, is ‘We are not going to touch it in the macro sense, but this question-"
Matthews: "What do they mean by that? They're not going to address the Second Amendment issue?"
Fineman: "They're not, they're not going to go straight at the Second Amendment issue. If you look at the Electoral College map, you see Ohio, you see West Virginia, you see Pennsylvania, you see Wisconsin, they're not going to do it. Their whole modern mentality is built on avoiding that issue. But John Dingell, who is smart, as a Democrat and an NRA guy, is trying to draw the NRA into at least this one small incremental thing about making sure that mental health records and other state police records-"
Matthews: "Yeah."
Fineman: "-get into the Insta-Check system. What happened in Virginia is, they have Insta-Check, this guy had no criminal record. He had a mental record, which they knew nothing about. By law, they should've known about that. They should've known about it."
Matthews: "Will the Democrats pay a price for the, and I've heard this, that Hillary Clinton has made it, has assured that Dingell's, especially, John Dingell, that there's not going to be any Second Amendment issue in this upcoming campaign. They do not want this to be the fight."
Fineman: "Now, there was a dignified conversation."
—Geoffrey Dickens is the senior news analyst at the Media Research Center.















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
I'm hopeful that the left wil
April 23, 2007 - 16:40 ET by Mean Gene Dr. LoveI'm hopeful that the left will avoid opposing/restricting the 2nd Amendment like the plague because it tends to be an election killer. They'll definitely jump on the bandwagon when they don't stand to lose the presidency and the house over gun rights.
"When life gives you lemons, make lemonade, and then toss it in the face of the person who gave you the lemons until they give you the oranges you asked for in the first place!" --Bill McNeal, NewsRadio episode 3.17
Fineman say he is going to ca
April 23, 2007 - 16:45 ET by bigtimerFineman say he is going to call congress and ask are you going to do anything about this now?
Hillary says not to touch this issue...
Just who in the hell do these people think they are?
I say try it...make my day!
Btw...I saw this all yesterday...and was really trying to forget about how mad I was then...
These leftists are enough to make you want to wring their scrawny little necks at times....they would have all our guns confiscated if they knew they could.
Howard is a political reporte
April 23, 2007 - 17:13 ET by bassndudeHoward is a political reporter. He should know that the second amendment attack by the dems would result in massive democratic defeat or a massive democratic desertion of the party. It is a losing issue. My idea is, you either support the constitution, all of it. Or you dont. If you dont, then in my opinion, you are a traitor, or at the very least, unamerican. I sometimes take issue with the MSM, but I do not want to restrict the first amendment. Even if I could. And that is the diffrence between a conservative and a democrat. A democrat will restrict all amendments that they do not agree with, and extend the ones they like.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
bass,Howard should know bette
April 23, 2007 - 17:30 ET by bigtimerbass,
Howard should know better, but he's a dim-witted dem and doesn't have Imus's show to spout off on anymore first thing in the morning...chalk that up for one less show...for now that is.
BT - he sounds to me like a l
April 23, 2007 - 19:03 ET by Gat New YorkBT - he sounds to me like a lobbyist or the head of the Dem party, but definately not a reporter.
Rush had a good point on hi
April 23, 2007 - 17:14 ET by motherbeltRush had a good point on his show today...how the heck are you going to restrict gun ownership by the "mentally ill" when you can't even call someone "mentally ill"?
Not only that Mom, but you ca
April 23, 2007 - 17:17 ET by bassndudeNot only that Mom, but you cant tell anyone that they were in a mentally ill hospital.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
Hell with PC, let's go back t
April 23, 2007 - 17:23 ET by Clear thinkerHell with PC, let's go back to using the word 'crazy'.
The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.
Howie,You spineless, ly
April 23, 2007 - 17:26 ET by Dave RHowie,
You spineless, lying totalitarian-supporting weasel.
If you want my guns, then come and get them.
This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.-
Neal Boortz.
Regarding the idea of not l
April 23, 2007 - 17:56 ET by radiofitz34Regarding the idea of not letting mentally ill people buy a gun sounds good. The problem is the term "mentally ill". Obviously Cho was that way. But where do authorities and lawmakers draw the line?
What if christian conservatives are concidered mentally ill? Pretty soon it could result with there being "thought police". I understand Mr. Fineman wants something done. We all want something done.
My guess is the Virginia legislature will refine their gun laws. Hopefully without violating the constitution.
Exactly! Who gets to declar
April 23, 2007 - 18:22 ET by RoverExactly! Who gets to declare someone "mentally ill"?
As a Second Amendment right, I say that someone can't be denied gun access without due course of law, specifically a finding in a court by a judge. A criminal history counts toward that, a mental illness diagnoses does not.
Pretty soon we'll have people proposing that anyone who thinks they'd want to own a gun is mentally ill. (I grew up in New York City, I can imagine the thought process of the NYC liberals at work now.)
Rover
The location of the line woul
April 24, 2007 - 07:01 ET by Dave RThe location of the line would be wherever the government wants it to be, which is why I do not trust them.
I honestly believe they would abuse this to no end, with the enthusiastic support of the libs. After all, Finemen (who I cannot stand) and others like him consider gun owners to be mentally ill, anyway.
Hows that for a standard?
This republic will not survive the continued neglect of its people.- Neal Boortz.
Ok how bout this
April 23, 2007 - 18:26 ET by Cool ArrowIn addition to the unborn and the terminally ill, can't we also put down the mentally ill.
Goose stepping. Google it.
Does this post make me mentally ill?
Don't ban the guns
April 24, 2007 - 09:39 ET by Pasco ConservativeForget banning the guns. We need to find a way to ban Dangerous Ham Sandwiches. "Ham is Not A Toy."
Any man who is under 30, and is not a liberal, has not heart; and any
man who is over 30, and is not a conservative, has no brains.
-Unknown
Yes -- lets make guns illegal
April 24, 2007 - 10:00 ET by paperheadYes -- lets make guns illegal in this country. Thats going to really make criminals stop getting them? Are liberals that stupid to think that by making something illegal, it will stop crime and mass shootings like this? I guess so. Cho was mentally ill. He was going to do what ever he needed to accomplish this. If that meant buying guns off the street, he would have done it. My question is, why is no one in the media focusing on his worthless parents? If your child is mentally ill, you have a responsibility to seek help. If more parents were more involved in their child's lives in this country, it would be a much better and safer place. I have to believe that if Eric and Dylan's parents gave half of a rat's ass about them and sought help, they wouldn't have committed their act of violence either.
He proudly demonstrates his t
April 24, 2007 - 15:38 ET by BeowulfHe proudly demonstrates his total ignorance of the issue with one sentence:
Fineman: "-get into the Insta-Check system. What happened in Virginia is, they have Insta-Check, this guy had no criminal record. He had a mental record, which they knew nothing about. By law, they should've known about that. They should've known about it."
Hate to break the news, but the NATIONAL INSTANT CHECK SYSTEM (not "insta-check), BY LAW, does not include mental records. The NICS is specifically for criminal records checks. The instant government tries to include medical information, in which mental conditions fall, the ACLU, the AMA, and dozens of other groups will protest and begin lawsuits based on patient confidentiality and right to privacy.
The Closed Mind Builds Strong Barriers